M/S Ashian Ply Palace And Another v. M/S Chaman Lal Gurdev Sharan And Another





    
 



  

 !" !#

$$!! %#&

'()!*&#+##

$     
 #

#
, ,--#.+ #$$!!

////  0#!".#$!

 '()!*&#+#.1 !!1#.2#3$&#'" $#$## #456#&5&5

  !" !. !7 8.9&#!#.2#3$&#'"   #$##    45  ,&(#  : 
;&  -5  $   &#!&6#5$!7 8+5#&#&!!"

!$!1$! #1  &     9&#!  #.  2#3$&#  '"  6 !(5($#:
 <.

$#(#( !5&!!!+#"$

 $#+#$!.$!7  $&#    &  $#$#"  #(      &;6    # #&#=$!#(##6& &$#$#"!! <##15+# 7 

 !" !.2#3$&#'"#&5 #$##45,&(#:
;&>7 $"( #
 <.

$#(=!$"# &$#$#"# ". ?.$!!;( $51#$$#! 1##$!""5#!$!!# !(5&$#$#"6!#!!"6"$!7 7 "#

#&(
  #!#$6"++#= 7 6(1#&$#$#"6"1" +#$=&5$#1#!.1+# !#$!1#1#$!& #$ #5$!.#5!+" &$#$#"$!! 7 #($#($!= $!651#&$#$#"#!#+# $#(=#!!6! $"($#$!

  .      $$#    !  1#

8 (  5    &.  #5  +#&  !5!  6; !&5&1(6!=&1( 6##=(##1##!#!61 $!7 7 $!1!! &$#$#".##."51 5#$&#&$#$#""6" $"5&(
 $!=$! 5#@&!+&#7 # 65$#(#($#(9&#= 7 1$&$&$#$#"+#"( !#        -$    #A&5    $!    5 $#(#($#(@&!# +&#6&=7 #5(!6 1#&$#$#"B&#".

6( 1#&$#$#"6"1"+#$= $!1!1"#5##&$#$#"

&5#(5#$!.$#" #(!&

C  $!    !  #$!  #+#5   !!51#(1###5+#( $!

$!5$#.!!15&1# #(

< D#$!#!##$ &!E

D#&$!$!!"(6##E



D#7 6(1#&$#$#"

6"1"+#$E  D#&$!(6! $##(E 

< D#    &      $!    !.  #+!&   +@&E 

 D#$!&!$# &E 

!

C$#1##A&$$#&! #+

##5!#&!#$#.#! '&#+;&5(# <  ?#& $!1(#$!1#! !6$&$&$#$#"11 ($5;&5(#1"&!- $&&#!1

2!555#+6";&5(#. !  $$! 6##B&5.2#3$&#.

 115!#B&5.2#3$&#.1 +;&5(#< <  ($$! &$!($&5;&5(#$6"#!'&#

!!!51;&5(# $6"'&#6!1.+!$# #5&!#$$!6#'&#

9+#!#&!#$$!!6 55#&5##9"(#$$!

9        $!  65  1#      & $#$#"$& $#. $!  7     !    &  $#$#"      7    B&#".

#&(
 .$&57  $          7    6 #5 (!61#&$#$#"$!#+5 "#5##.&$!-$ &$#$#"#( C 6#;6"'&#6!1#5#5# &(+5!!5!&$#$#"6"$! 7 7 1# 9#(?
5# .  . ((+6! $#$#"  +!& 
 (#6!!"#&5#5#&( 9 65.$!#!!&$6"6 $    1  #5!"  #;  6"    '&#  6!1  C

F #&##!(5"+6(1#6" 1"+#$ G1+#.'&#6!1!5 &!    !5!  $  +  !&      ! 5##5##(5 
#.1# &    6    $#(+  $      &  $#$#"  C $!+56&61#&$#$#" $A&$#$#"65$#(+. $!&!+#"1!!#+#$&$#$#" #(651##&!6"$!1 #5!"#6"'&#6!1

C&##5&## &##("##5&!#"#!!5!"

C5##(

7&!&1;&5(#$6" '&#6!1 C#&$!  7&6!A&!1#$$!

9  65        +1      &##  5 #&#6"'&#6!1119"# 5#.9!&$$!1&(#( #5!"

  

  0#;

 

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*  "&#

 '# !+,

  "&#