High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5305/2018dismissed

Raj Kumar v. Rajinder Kumar And ORS

2018-09-20Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa5 pages

!!

"

$% !

!"#$ %&'( $ '$%( $ ( ) (

& '(()( "*#+$,

...

'$%( $ ( ) (

*+

"-- "! "

!

,$ # / -$ %"! $ %+"

0 "

# !,, !!- /$%%

$1( "

--,! %!"-$# "$ 1!"

!" #0"

#3(45(6557

, #/8)()

"

-+$$-

$(4 "

( "$ 1! !$ !$0% 0"

"$ *"- 8*"

! ,$-%$!

!" 2#$(:*#"'$%

* / "8($ ;

"

-$-

1! !$!$0% !"

0#

$(4-$

"

0*!

0*$00"

0$, "

8<"

#$-,%0 $+ % !"$ 8(1!+

*1%$1!$% "--! !$#

!1!% $1

$!!

!!"$ %$!

#"! $%

$-% !% 1%",%!%

%#"

#-$% %!/ #)%(,% = (!!,%* "--

!1

#$!,,

#$% $+/

#"$+/

$ 8 $-)()

( $1 *#

$(4"

"+ 1"%%

!!

- #-/",

%"!-+$# 3(45(6557 $--", $-)/

0"!*/ 1"%% $/ ";

$"+ $0/% $ 8(1!!

%#

, 82"

#"

"- $ 8"

#"! $%

$-!% $-)()

1! ! !1

!"

#$"

"

$ 8( )"1!,$

!$--"

0$-1"

!

/8

$(4<"

0!

%# ,

#>(4(6554 #!$,

$(67?("

"-

!% +$< #!,%1"

! "--@

1! $/ %+"

1"%% #!!,%* , #- !%2"

#3(45(6557 !$,

$(6:5( !

0%$-!,%2"

%! "

# % !" $ 8( 1! -% !/"

# /8

!% $ 8$1

#/8-% )%( ,% = %! #8# +$ #$

0 % "!/8+" $-2"

, #/8)%(,% = (1!-% !

1!"

!$ ##"!$!"

0"

#% $- ,"$

(

)%('$% = %#!,"/

#

!

$,

- 2"

$--", $- )/

0"!*/ (+

)%($ *#

$(4*1%$"!%

/$% $-/$% "--! !$#

%## 8

- % "

0,$

"

! #$ ,""$ $-

##, ,$#*!"1!#"!"!!

#/8% " $$

65(6(6547(

%+"

0 #,"+"

* ! %!/

#"!"!!

#+"# #0

#64(3(654A!!

#/8

###""$ "!",#0 */ ( =

# ,$

0 %

%! 0 # % 1 $!!!","$!,",! !!$

1%",%%+ /

#"!,# #/8%

$1( 0 #%$

24%

)"

0%=/ #'$% =

*261

$#, # /8 % #

# $ $% 1"

!! %# /

9"

#$$+ ,"$

( 0 #%%

,

1! $$-!$ #"

#1!!-- 0-$ "

#"!

!

%

+ (3(45(6557 #1%",%! , !$ %!/

$+ $$< #("!,$

1! $$

$% "--/ !$$-%

! #!!,%*% 1!

$$,,!"$ -$% $%+

#$%

%"!!%

!"$ 8( +"

#,$

0%*%"!$"!

$-% !"# #+"

1%% "! $ ""

! !$/ #"!"!!

" $ $ # ,""$ $-

%!

,$# #-"

0%% $-) 7B$-% #" ),, !!"$

,! !$) 7>$-% #" +"#

,*4>A6%!/

!

0#!%

#3(45(6557( %"! 0#"%!/

$", #%-$$+"

0 ,"$ $- 2"

# # 3(45(6557 9( 4* #

%# 9"

%

)"

0%=/*1%$1!%

!!$%

!24 #1%$"

,

8! #%%

1!0$ 8 #-$'$% *

$ !<"

0$-)()

( - % 1"

1!!,"/ ! #$+ $)()

""!$

8% - %!%

#% %/" !!"$ !"

%"!

! !$

$% 1$

! #'$%

2"

(

'$% 1! !$ 9"

#!26 #1%$ $!

#%% %#8

#3(45(6557$ !<"

0$-)( )

"

$-%

)"

0%=/ #$ (

,

!$$#

)($(BB?

#3(45(6557(% !00 !"$ -$%/8% ,$

; !"$ %! $/

$+ ,,$# 1"% 1*!!,%*"!1"%$ "( ! 0#!% !!","$!,",! !$

* ,$

%!%"0% "0% -$

$1"

0,",! !& C"D 24 %

)"

0% =/ 0 1"

!! $ %

"0

#"

%"!,$!! 9"

"$ %% #"# $0$$%

%!"

#%# ,% - ?A"

!( C""D $ !$ %#/

!!"0

#!$1%8%

0 % "!

$-)()

%#/

9, # #/8% -$$!

!$-"

""

C"""D )()

1!$9"

8>58 !$-0 #1!

!-- 0-$ "

#"!

!

(, #1%",%%#

#%

-, !!"

"

#!!,%*!% 1! $"

!$ ##"!$!"

"

$1%+ #"!,# -$ !"#,",! ,"

/ % -$-%

/8!!"0 0,$0

#+ "# !$ 0(%!/

$/!

#%% "! $ ;"

1%

!!$2"

%!$/

/ -$ %$"8(%* 9, !"$ $-

0 % ",

$/8"!

-"

"!$ "$ * / !"# #!!!","$!,",! ! 0#!0

"

!!$-

( $ *

%$0%*%

%#!!

, $ / -"

%/ $

%#/

##, ,$#! 0#!

#"!

!

% -- ", # % # 1% !,% #"!

!

* "-*

%# #+ !

-- #%

% %(

"!,!

1%

%!!" 8

#-#%

% #!$-%

!$-!!

0$--< -$0 # 2"

( % $ ! 1! $ %

$ %+

!/! "

$--#($

%"! 0#1!##, 1$ #/ $!"

$< $ %"#

8$ "! $

$% % /$% "-- #1!

8 !"!8@#

$(B($1 *!,%1"

!!#"# $

0, % 1"

!! /$9 $ !$ % + !"$ $- %"! /$% "(

)--", "$$/!

#3(45(6557 1! ##$,

( !"$ 1$ #/ -+$$-!,%2"

) 44:$-% #" +"#

,( %"! $ #$ ! $ -"

# 8 "

-""8 "

% "0

#0

! !!

# /8 % ,$! /

$1 #

8"

0 $ %

%

"$ !$0%-$( "!,,$ #/8 ","$ (' 4:755654> ) ?$-% ="""$ ,!

<"

0,$ #$ "$

$-#

8$-656#8!"

-"

"

", ;" #$ 9 ,%#8$-#

8%%!

$,, #($!,%!"-","$ "!-$%,$"

0(% ","$ %!/

-"

#/8,""

0$"

0$ #!( 8 -$,$ #$ "$ *!!,%*"!#

+"

1$-% /$+ *% "!#"!"!!

"!

!1

!$ 0$ #$-#

8(

'$%( $ ( ) (

%&)$

,<8 2% ! <"

0@ !$

#& !@$ 2%

$/

& !@$