High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4922/2022dismissed

Gurpreet Singh v. Anju And ORS.

2025-11-28Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal11 pages

!"#$ %% & "#"'#( !"#$)%% &

$ *+ %,-. /+

!"#

$ % 000 -. /+1% & ' '%

( * +",-."/0123*

4 ) 1516616,'%

$ & ' 7 ( 823 43 )

' %%

) '

6 + % ) '% ) ) )

,!!

,255( 823 -(243 )

)

* 6-1,61,5 - ))*

$ $ '

7"-2+"21/1 9 661,61,5 $

) ' )'

'* :

. 9 6-1,61,5 '1,11(

661,61,5 ;6-1,61,53 *'

+",-."/012( <"55 #!6#7 =3 )

'% %

* $ " / #)

'% ># ,0 6-1,61,5 ) 602;-1/#$ +: ? #) )62% )*

$ * %

) ,?

111@" # )

) % ?1 * )

! & )'% &

* ># ' ) ) ) 0 &

$ %(& )#

$ . 3

) &

) #)

% 5 >

)

) "

:% /3 ;((6!

#26# <'

26"#"(('

! !'

;

3;#!# #2!6 6#7"523 "55 #!6#72'(="% 9+>? @A

B"#!

#2"%C % /3 23 B 2626"#

;

#2628 ! 2" ("

("DB ;26"#;D"'#25"D23

B"#!

#2 165 "12"E3;2

(2C 9% /3

B"#!

#2"%E;

#"23"8!6#7; ;86!

;#! (26 !6 6#786(

2"!6 ;@"

;223

;#226D C9 % /3 B 2626"#3;

#568 !6#("#2;

#26"# "5B" 6 6"# "5 "2"- (2C9 &% 5%4 2

,1 #) '% $&

'% A

) 62%7

)5 ?11@" /1B) ) ,@/

) ) 4 & ) ,5 011@" ,1, ' %%

)

) %

' % ) 7% % # ' %% ) '

7) )

$ %)%

) '

' ,, . ' ,6 .

% ' %% )

)% # ) '

% ' ) C% ' 7%

) %

,- !"#

$ %' ) ))"

' %% )' @)

'% 7 ='$ .%;7 #!; % 3 E#!6;# ';#( "%+2!%;#!"23

6 68BB ;8"

%9 FF 9 F?"5 &1!

(6!

!"#% % & G "3; "3;DD !1 % 22;

3,2;2 ";!;# B"2"B";26"# "23

1 9 ,9)D ;#6 % %;26"#;8# ';#( "DB;#A+2!% % 6 68BB ;8 "

% ?) ? "5 ?

-,1061,5D

$ 3 E#!6; '

;#( "DB;#A +2!% %;H#6,3;D; % &F&9 )1!

(6!

!"#&% % & % ,/ # ' '%

& ,? & >

A & %

' %% )

,! $

* )

7% ( 3>

)

% ' %# % 7% '

) %

& ))''%* '% +

)7) '% 7 ='4 $# '

' %%

)' @)

$ )%

) ' @) ,0 .%;7 #!;* (;

(3 10,161,/

)

) '%

)'% *

?1* & $&) ,5 5!

111@"

) E!B& )*

$ F * +

'% #

$ %

$&=)

'% # )

,0, & 7

$ F * ) '

G '%

$ ) )

* '% ' ) '% ') C $

$ % % +

% & )

)

) ' A %

%& 7 ='4$ )

A "

:F% 3 <'

26"#23;2("D

'B5"("# 6!

;26"# @ 5"

236 "'26# 23

;BB ;8 6 E3 ;#A !

6;26"#5"D23 B

(6@ !"'2 ;

B B D62 7;#2 !@A23 2;2 2;# B"2;26"#;'23"62A1E"'8!

6DB;(2"#23 86;@6862A"523 # ';#( "DB;#A5"

;#A;((6!

#2E36(3D;A2;= B8;( E368 6

"# '(3;!

6;2 !"'2 %#;# 2"236 <'

26"# E"'8!@A62

85H'

265A23 ("

(2#

"8;(=23

"51 "523 "!

"523 673"'2E36(3 DB8"A IB;A ;#! ("

JB6#(6B8 %4 ,06 4

) ' 7 ='4 $

)' '

)' ' "

:)% "E1 8 2 '

("# 6!

23 6# 2;#2 (;

% 3

("!

;8 23;223 "55 #!6#7 !6!#"23;

B D62 2" #2 3;##;B;2#; 62A1 E3

;((6!

#22""=B8;( %36 B"

626"#6 #"26#!6 B'2 #<'

26"#;@8A123

123 2 "523 B D62 3;

6;2 !% % 3 B'B"

"5 ;# 6# ';#( B"86(A 6# 23

#2("#2 K26 2" 8!23 "E# >"B ;2"5"D !6 (286;@6862AE3 # '(3;#'#5"

#>'#5"2'#;2

6#(6!

#22;=

B8;( %"!

#A23 6(26D>!

#2 "5 6(26D("DB ;26"# 6DB8A@ (;'

;((6!

#2 2""= B8;( "'2 6!

23 @"'#!

"5 23 B D62 ;#!1

1 6 "'2 6!

23 B' 6 E "5 23 6# ';#(

B"86(A1E"'8!@ "55 2"23

"5H'

26( 15"

;((6!

#262

856 5"#"5;'82"536 %3 #123

# ';#( "DB;#AD"

2( 2;6#8A"'7322"B;A% % 223 ;D 26D 23"'731E3 #;## ';#(

"DB;#A2;=

"#;B"86(A;#!;(( B2 B;AD #2 "5 D6'D 6# B'

';#( 23

2"1 62 ;7

2" !" "

E6236#( 2;6#@"'#!

%3 ("#2;(28;A !"E#23

5"'("#

E6236#E36(3 '(3;#6# ';#( B"86(A E"'8!"B ;2 %523;26 (;

12" KB (223 6# '

2"B;A("DB ;26"#2";236!B;2A1E36(36 (8 ;8A "'2 6!

@"'#!

"523 ;6!;7

#2E"'8!@

'#5;6% ;8;#(6#7 23 #

! 5" B;AD #2 "5 ("DB ;26"#2"23 6(26D 6 ; 6 6#2

"5 6# '

123 "!

"523 673"'2;BB8A6#723

B;A;#! ("

B6#(6B8 16#"'("# 6!

! 6 E16

#26 8AH'

!;#! <'6

#"6#2

#( %4 ,5 ))* '% 7 ='4$ "3;

"3;DD !* (;

(3"

:)% ; 6#73 ;!8 ;# !("'#

85"23 B;26

;#!"#B '

;8"523 D;2 6;8; ;68;@8 "# ("!162

) (8 ;8A

;8 23;2 "# 23 !;2 "5 ;((6!

#21 23

;BB 88;#2!6!#"23;

; ;86!;#! (26 B D622"

B8A23 "55 #!6#7 "#23 "'2 E3

;((6!

#2 2""=B8;( %; 6#7 K2 8A7"# 23"'7323 5;(2 56#!6#7 K (6

1626 (;2 7"6(;88A ("!

!@A 23;223 ;BB 88;#2E;

# ;@8 2"B"!'( >B"

"676#;8 B D62 #" E;

;@8 2" B"

6#5"D;26"# ( ! '#!

(2% #65 6#5"D;26"#6 ("# 6!

!@AE36(3626 #"2(8 ;;

E3 #23 !6 B'2 !B D62E;

!;#!@AE3"D% 3 ;88 !B D62E;

!"#)% ?% 16% %"# ,;2'!;A;#!#" KB8;#;26"#6 "# ("!;

2"E3A !

62"55

;

= !"#23 # K2!;A6% %,'#!;A%

1 ;

'D6#7 23;2 B D62 E;

;86! ;

"5;# B"2'23"62A1@'262!"

#"2"5;#A 8B2"23 ;BB 88;#2 6#( E;

@ 6#7B86 !

"#;"'2 !655

#223;# (656 !6#B D62%3

;BB 88;#23;

5;68 !2"76 ;#A KB8;#;26"#2" 5'2

;26"# D;!

@A 2"B8A23 "# ""=

@AB;

2";6!E; 6;

'2E36(3!6!

#"25;88E6236#23 "'2 "5B D626

!@A;# B"2 '23"62A% 3 ;6! 56#!6#7 "5 5;(2 3;

;556D !@A23 673"'2@A23 6DB'7# !"!

% 52 7"6#723"'7323 ("!123 ("#('

#2 56#!6#7 "55;(2!"#"2E;;#2;#A6#2

#( 6#(

A!"#"2"'2;7 "'

8A!

5A23 8"76(;

2" '55

5"D23 6( "56;26"#;862A;#!# 6#('23

@8;D "5 @ 6#7 B

% # 6 E "5 5"

7"6#7 !6 ('

6"#1E ;

"523 ("# 6!

!"B6#6"#23;223

;7'D #2 ;6

!@A;BB 88;#2;

52"5;#AD #( 236 ;BB ;86 3

@A!6 D6

!%4

,2 "H +

7 ='4$ )

;#6* (;

(3"

:%/ ;

"523 6 E23;223 673"'23;

;8 ;!A 7;#2 ! D"

23;# H'

2 ("DB ;26"# ;D"'#22"23 8 7;8

#2;26

"523 !

( ;

,;26 %#23;21

#6523 (8;6D"523 ;BB 88;#2

7;!6#7 5'2'

(2 1 ;!!626"#;8 D !6(;8

;#!;!!626"#;86#2

2;D"'#2E;

2"@

;(( B2 !1 "# 23 @;

"5 23 #"26"#;8 6#("D "5 %& > 'B

56 23"'

;#!

B D"#231 23

26"# "5 ;E;!6#7 ;!!626"#;8 " 5'23

("DB ;26"# ;D"'#2 2" 23 ;BB 88;#2 6# %%% "%&)?"5 !"

#"2;6

%3 ;BB ;813"E

E"'8! '((

!2"23 86D62 ! K2 #223;223 ;D"'#2 "5("DB ;26"#!

D6# !@A23 673"'2 3;88 @ 56 2 B;6! @A 23

B"#!

#2 "% # ';#(

"DB;#AE62386@ 2A2" ("

;D 5"D23

"E# "5 23 "55 #!6#7

B"#!

#2 "%

6# %/ ;

6#(86# !2";88"E23 ;BB ;82"236

86D62 ! K2 #21 =

B6#7 6# D6#! 23 KB"

626"# 6# ,6#73;D- %6D;8;;#! %;#!;BB';#!

%- %-6#"!.'D;+;D@;;#!#% &%

26#7 2" 23 ;BB ;8 B

! @A

B"#!

#2"%# ';#( "DB;#A;7;6# 2#;#!

%%% "%&)?F "5 1 ;

#"2 ! 6# B;;7;B3 "

%;#!"523 6DB'7# !H'!7D #2 B"!'( !

;@"

123 673"'2!6 B"

!"523 ;6!;BB ;8@A ;@ "8 6#7 23 6# '

5"D 23 86;@6862A 2" B;A ("DB ;26"# ;D"'#2% #"26( ! ;86 1 23

;BB 88;#2 #;#!

!6!#"2568 ;#A;BB ;8;7;6# 223

;E;!B;

!@A23 6@'#;85" #3;#( #2"5 ("DB ;26"#;D"'#2;#!23 ("

"@H (26"#568 !@A

36D6#23 ;BB ;8568 !@A23 # ';#( "DB;#A (;D 2"@ !6 D6

!5"#"#B"

('26"#% #6#

(2"5236 ;BB ;8123 6@'#;83;!5"'#!23;23

5;68 !2"B"!'( ;#A 6!

#( 7;!6#736 D"#238A 6#("D ;#!23 B D;# #2!6 ;@6862A '55

!@A36D 3;!@

D6# !;

#"2 K(

!6#7 L2"23

E3"8 @"!A;#!("DB ;26"#3;!@

#;E;!

!2"

36D"#23;2@;

'82;#28A1E 6#2 #!2"!6 B"

"5 ;BB ;8 "# 23 ;D @;

@A !6 (26#7 23

B"#!

#2 "% # ';#( "DB;#A 2" B;A 23

("DB ;26"# ;D"'#2 ;E;!

! 2" 23 (8;6D;#2

#;#!

6#23 56 2B8;( 1E62386@ 2A2" ("

;D 5"D 23 "E# "5 23 "55 #!6#7

B"#!

#2"% %4 61 +

$ ) %

"3; "3;DD !* (;

(3 * )

3 E#!6;

';#( "DB;#A+2!% %;H#6,3;D;

;#!"23

:% %%%# 23 B

#2 (;

;!D622 !8A 23 "'2

D62 K%& E;

;86!"#8A5"3;#!67;3;#!23

;((6!

#2 2""= B8;( 6# .;#;8% 3"'73 ; 5;6#2 ;7'D #23;

#;6

!@A23 8 ;# !("'#

85"

"E# ;#!23 !6 23;223 "55 #!6#7

;8 "6

!#;26"#;8B D6213"E

1 #" '(3 D62 E;

@"'732 "# 23 ("!% # 6

"51236 ;7'D #2"523 8 ;# !("'#

85"23

# ';#( "DB;#A6 ;(( B2 !%,6#( "55 #!6#7

3;! 23 "'2 B D62 2" B8A "#8A 6# 3;#!67;3;#!23 ;((6!

#22""=B8;( 6#.;#;81 # ';#( "DB;#A6 3 8! #2628 !2" ("

6, & '

' )

'% $& ' %% )'

$ %)

)% )

66 ) ''

% 6- (3

-. /+ "

D@ )1 &

I *

@ J ' J