High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5361/2018dismissed

Amarjit Kaur v. Devinder Singh And ORS

2018-09-26Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary10 pages

!" # "$%&" '' ("

) " +"

"# $% %%% ,"

" +-&" #)

"+'' ...

%%% & '' / '

**") &"" *

" " *

+ !0 + '"

1)' 2&* 2& " ) # 1+ *"+)$&* "

3'' !0+ '"

' "2&*#1+ *"+)$&* " 4

5& '

' +" & '' 6'

' & "'" +

+ 7'' "9,:;<=, =&!0$ " *+

2 ' *+ " &' "# "#" #& &

& + +

>#+" "# ! * +"*+

3+ +33 +" $ " *+

'0%&'!" *++ &"+"' ! ' ;

+ +" +& 5& ?3 '+$ " + 3 , $!

%&"++"

&" " *+#) " *+#%&'!" &"

&*+"

,"'%&"#1+" $%&"#&9+$%&" $%&" &" " *+ 8> @ 3 &")) !0 + 33 @"!+$ %&"6" >A+'' B +& ! %&'!" *+

') *!+ + 33+" '' +' 3 !"

& + 3'9 , $! %&" + "'"

8 $ " *+

? &"+"'++ '' " ""0 !030 '0"" * "")

+0" #+'' 6'

3 ') * 3" 9+ +*"& '" ++& 5& >6 @"!+$ %&"' *3++"+"&*+"

3 '

" * ++"

3" 9+ +*"& '" ' *3++

3 * + " "

'" ++& A+

'"3 '& #3++"'"& !9 !0$ " "+ +!0@"!+$ %&"<'"0

& ++& 3

+"3+@"!+$ %&"!0+'

8 " + <

"# DA# 1+ *"+ 3 ") !0 + ''

" *+"+ 4 &*+"

" +& & +! 3'' A+'' 3

9 &! 0& "0) &" +"' !0+ <

"#DA1+ *"+C*' 3

&!0+'' 9 *+<

"#DA1+ *"+ "3+"

++& +! 7'' + 3 =&& "&"

"" ? 3 ' !0 + '' + '"

&!0+<

" 9 *+" &! & "0 ) ")' ="" "0 " ! * +3 + "!0

"A+7'' 5& 3 +*+'0 &

/?+"

+! & & 5&!'

"A+''

&"+" +' +='& + ""&*+"

&'! '* !&+" " "='& *+'' 6'

+" +" ++& 3+&) "*+ +" ?3

+ 0 & 3 !0$ " *+++& ! '' "!&0 *" '+& 1+ *"+ +0" 3+ B +& ! +!& 0"

-)"

") + " $ " *++ "+

@"!+$ %&"

33 + '" ' *3++"+"&*+"

3 *) 3"

9+ +' + " +*"& '"3+"

+"*++ 3" "& 9+ 3"*) + '

3++ +'" +" ) "3 *) + "

'"" $ " *+#3 #& 3++

'0 + +< " '"0 B +& ! 3 *) $ " *+? '0+"! =

3++3"" !0+ E= & 3 $ " *+!0+'' B +& ! ''+

+ +0" ?3 ++'' ")$ "

*+ + '*''++* !&++ +"

" '+& 1+ *"+" 0+"'7'' ''+"3''

0*" * 5&!' +" ++& )&"

3 ''*'+"

"''*'# "&&' " &' & &

" # "!0" >A+ ! '" &''#)

)5&+"*+ " + &("& "' "0 !$

3"" ?3 ++" &3 ' '03+ &'"" )*"!+""0 5& 3++ +&' 9 &" *+' +3 " " +7'' '0$ "

*+" ++& 5& #3 '#

$ " *+#3 ' # 3 +'

" +

> )!' )!'""0)'" 4 4 4&'0&!' + + 3 "

7'' + ! "*+'0=&!0$ " "+ 3 3 +

& * #3+& 09 & &

"" ? 3 &"+"'++'

"+"+& ! )" *'

0 " 0 "!& "+3'

" + '0"+"& "

$ " *+A+'' )"+*"'

3++"

+"/ /'3 ? + +

" + " 3 )"+ )"+'

'0 ' $ "

*+ + 7'' + '" " #

"& + '!+)&" 3" +

" !5&+ * 0" +""0& + ! '"'0 + 7''7'' "* "& A3"'"3''

#3++3"=&!0$ " *+3" ''0 '' ")9 + ' 3''

*)+" +

+ + ,"'+ " + 1+" " $+ !$ 3'' ' $ "+3" 3 ' E''3 *

& 3" " !0+'"

"'1&" ! +' * / 7++" + '

' " + '" " $& "0 "F,, 7++"+ & ")'& F,, 7++" & ! "3 & " 1,1F, )7++"+ & )F, ) '

<) 3 '!0!++" C"

"'1&"

+ & '!0+'

6 '' 3+'+' *+7'' 3 )'+) *!

") " 3+'3 +'

6'' '") +3 =&& "& &

#" " "" ' '!0+'' 3 '

!0+'"

"2&*#1+ *"+ ) $&* 4 **") +" " #" '+ ! ' C"

' "+'' )+ '0"*& +3''

+"& & "& + !

") ""#+" "#!++'"

&" !'3+)*"

'0 ""

*+ & '!0+'

6'' C"

'3+'" "" *+ 7 7

&! ++"" "' $" "

+ 0

+ "'3

#) +37'' <= +9 3'* +! " <= ")! " &' "# " & &

>? ) "& '0"*&++"3 " )

" *+"*+ ++& 5& + ''0 ! +"'"7'' > >B"9GB? &"+"

&! ++'

6''

+" +& 5& "

7'' > > + ' " +"

+ ' ;

+ +" + " ? #+& #"0++ '!''3# &* $&* "

!0+'"

1)'2&*2& "

) #1+ *"+ $&* " 4

!0+'"

' "2&*#1+ *"+! &

'!0+'' !"+"&*+& ?+)+"'"

' "+'' +)"& +0 +""#3++3 &"

+!0'"

' 1&" 0 ," &3 '!0+'' 6'

9 * '" +

+7'' =&!0$ "

*+ " &' "# "#" #& &

"!0 +

6" >?3 # +& # & ! & ")++ 7''3 " &' "# "#" #& &

#+" "# ! *& '' + *# "') ""&+"') ="

7'' /

"#$%

#$$

( )

+ ( , -

/0 0 -

1 20

*" -

2////3"

4////3"+ -

5 / 6 -

4 / 0

2 /

7/ /

.///3" #

06 -

;

17/2 71"

* :

; 17/2 "71"

* <

1/ 1==.

<00> 7//4

<00 6

<00 * <00 %

(

* *

15 7//2 ?

?+)'

* +"&*++"'"7''

8 > >3+++) ! =+!!&")'!' "9 & "9H "9G+

7''

88# ''0 ++ "B %&'!"

*+++& ! " 3 0"

!'0

+&*+"

++" # '0&" " *+ +

+ 3 ? &"+" +!+)&" + %&')"

*++

+ 3 + ! "&' & !"!'&!

& +! *) +'' B +& ! "&"+ " ''!&%&')" *+&' + & "&"+ *"&'&"'' +)''* + /'3 ? + &+ "+! *) %&')" + ") 0+ * " A+&*+"

#3 #" 3''' +" " '

+ ?

" +*"& '"#3 +%&')"

+ 3 3&'+)"*+" +" !&3'' +) 0"*+ '# "**"" & 0" ++& +"3&' + + 0 ?

#+0+ '" *#+ +'3&'! '+3 "

+ +""0!& +' 3&' +) 0 +" +" ?

+ &!

5& 3'' > ># * +++& ! 6%&')"

*+# 3+

30 8

# + " +" "

!'01"&'" +"+ '

'" ++& 3 !*) +'' / "$%&"

"" &" *+"' # +3&' +) 0"*+ '# "**""

" +""0 +3&' +) 0"*+ ''3 0"

""')')3++"?

+) +""/ ""* "+#") " 2* *+*"

$ " *+ 3&'!+3 " + '" +""0&!

5& '0#7''

<= 3 =&!0$ " *+3+' ''0")9 *+"'"

3''

88 > >''++"7''

""* " 3''

7'' 3 &'0")!07>/,%"

+ *3

+ 3''7> + 3''3

=&!0 $ " *+ + " +" +"

* 3

7> 3 + *+!&" $ " *+ @

''0 +$ " *+=&+3'' & * ?

+ "

= # + * )&"!'3&'!'!0+ '' +" )&"10 + &!' + 3 "

"9 I+) ! A+" ) "" +7'' " &' 09 "&#"

"& &

="& $ " *+A+" + * "" +$ " *+3 & * +

=& 3'' "*& !+'

* &" & "'"3''

+' 3'' +"

''& &!

!0 0) ""#+ #"$ ?

+ # "*+'0!

")!0+'"

"'1&"+ &+ "*& !0 +' * A+"'"3''

) ") ""# ="3 = &!

+ '

E"+ 9 "*& ) +7''

B"9G HB"# +" '"& ++ '!+)&" +"+& ! 3" $ " + 3 ")"#!++ 3''

''0")9)' 3'' A+" ! &+ "& " 1'

'*'+"

!0 '

" 0 & 3''

A+" &++""0 5& 3 + '

5&"""0 $ " +3 3''3+ + "*+ 9 +

+ ""0 " " I+ + '"

&" !'3 +) " " &""

* *

+ '' 3+' ""

" ) ""3++3"" "

" ?

" # 5& '3 &+'

'5&

'3 )') + ' +""*& 3 "

' "+'' & !' & ''*'0

" 0 &* $&* "

!0+'"

1)'2&*2& ") #1+ *"+ 3''

$&* " 4

!0+'"

"2&*#1+ *"+3++''

" "

" !0+ 1&" " *'0#+ '

3+ "" %'()'**!

!" # +,-.

7++" 9 *;"

H ; 7++"""!'

H ;