Dharam Pal v. State Of Punjab And ORS
!
" !
!#$% (%)*+*&,
-- !.#/#0 #1
------ %$*$*&,%/
+
2%/+3+ 4$#$% 3,5#6 &$.%/+
------
%+7&,(%,$
+
8 9
4 4
/%+%,$ /- /+.*$ &%1:
(;&)#$% 7%$*$*&,%/-
/- #;,%%$ 4*,<.:
4%,*&/ ! 3,5#6-
- - 4
9
%$*$*&,%/
!.#/#0 #1 /$*)1%+ &,+$*$3$*&, ,(*#:
*,$%/ #1*#:
+%%>*,< # ,#$3/% )%/$*&/#/* +%$$*,< #+*(%
:
7#++%( !*;*+*&,#1 #<*+$/#$%)30&11%)$&/:
#1#,(.#/:
=.%/%6@ 3,*)*7#1 &/7&/#$*&,:
/%+7&,(%,$ &- 7%$*$*&,%/:
4%)$*&,+ 3,5#6 361*) /%0*+%+ 9#,(
;*)$*&,
%,$
%)&;%/@ )$:
+.&/$ 8 )$8 #11&=%(-
-
'3/$.%/ 7/#@%/ 0#(% +%$$*,< #+*(%
:
7#++%( &00*++*&,%/:
#1#,(.#/:
=.%/%6@
(*+0*++%(-
- /*%'1@:
/%+7&,(%,$ &- 3,*)*7#1 &/7&/#$*&, 4%)$*&,+ )$:
+%%>*,< %5%)$0%,$ '/&0 +.&7 0%#+3/*,< A +B- '$-:
+*$3#$%( #$ 3/1$&, #/>:
/%)&;%/@
+- ::AA 6%*,< #//%#/+ (#0#<%+ 3+% &))37#$*&, ).#/<%+ #'&/%+#*( 7/%0*+%+ 37$& -- #1&,<=*$.
'3$3/% (#0#<%+ =-%-'- - - $*11 (#$% #)$3#1 %;*)$*&, 7%$*$*&,%/- - .% #77%#/%( #'&/%+#*( %;*)$*&, 7/&)%%(*,<+ )&,$%+$%( *,$%/ #1*# 71%# .% .#( #1/%#(@ ;#)#$%( +.&7 3,*)*7#1 &/7&/#$*&, @%#/ A +.&7 7&++%++*&,
#0%+.
.#,(%/ +&, .#<=#, !#++ #=#, C30#/ +&, !*=#, .#,(-
%$*$*&,%/ #1+& 6%'&/% &11%)$&/ +%%>*,< *071%#(0%,$ #6&;% /%'%//%(
#0%+.
.#,(%/ #=#, C30#/-
$ $/#,+7*/%+ &11%)$&/:
;*(% *$+
:
#11&=%( %;*)$*&, 3,*)*7#1 &/7&/#$*&, (*/%)$%( ;#)#$% 7/%0*+%+-
.% 3,*)*7#1 &/7&/#$*&, '3/$.%/ </#,$%( 1*6%/$@ *,*$*#$% 7/&)%%(*,<+ /%,$ /%)&;%/@ 4%)$*&, )$-
-
%%1*,< #<</*%;%( #'&/%+#*(
:
7/%'%//%( 6%'&/% &00*++*&,%/)30&11%)$&/:
%?%/)*+*,< 7&=%/+ &00*++*&,%/ )$:
.&=%;%/:
(*+0*++%(:
;*(%
- - #'&/%0%,$*&,%( )*/)30+$#,)%+:
/%1*%'
+:
,&$*)%( #6&;%-
77#/%,$1@:
*073<,%(
7#++%( &00*++*&,%/:
-- :
=.*).
)&0% .%#/*,< $&(#@ *-%- -- -
;*(%,$1@:
6%@&,( # 7%/*&( $./%% @%#/+ '/&0 (#$% 7#++*,<
- - !3/*,< )&3/+% .%#/*,<:
# 7&*,$%( B3%/@ /#*+%( )&3,+%1 #77%#/*,< /%<#/(+ /%#+&, '*1*,< .&=%;%/:
,& %?71#,#$*&, *+ '&/$.)&0*,< ,%*$.%/ #,@ /%#+&,*,< <*;%, %,$*/% 6&(@ 7%$*$*&,-
.% (*( ,&$ *,;&>% #,@ 1%<#1 /%0%(@ $./%% @%#/+ #'$%/ )#3+% #)$*&, #/&+% 37&, (*+0*++#1 .*+ #77%#1:
;*(%
-
.% *,#)$*&, 7#/$ 0&/% $.#, $./%% @%#/+ 6% #((/%++%( '*/+$ 6%'&/% .*+ )1#*0 )#, 6% )&,+*(%/%(-
-
!*;*+*&, %,).
$.*+
.%1( %;%, '*1*,< # +3*$:
7%/*&( 1*0*$#$*&, *+ $./%% @%#/+ 7%/*&( /%#( *,$& 0#?*030 7%/*&( '*1*,< 7%$*$*&,-
-
!"#$%& !' (
) "*+ :
9&/(+.*7+ .%1( #'$%/ '&3/ @%#/+ /%5%)$*&, #11&$0%,$ # 71&$ )#,,&$ 6% %,$%/$#*,%( &6+%/;%(
!
"
#$ " %
" ## # "
"
# &' ! "%
" #
! ( $ )
! *$ !
#$ ) + !
'
' !
#!
"
" "
$ ! , $ ! # #* !!
! $
$ -
../ 0 " 0
# !
"# -&&%&.!!./"*+01
1& -
- ,! 2 ,,!' #
3
.#%& & &- !. &,861% )1%#/1@ .%1( 0#@ .#;% *07#)$ &$.%/+ /*7%,%( /*<.$+ 0#@ 3,,%)%++#/*1@ (/#< &$.%/+ *,$& 1*$*<#$*&,:
%?7/%++%( &7*,*&,
/' $ # "$#
0
* "
#$ !' 0
# ! - " -
$ * #)
0
$
" 1# !
$
!
""
*
0
0
# " #"
# " #
2 $! $ * $ ! $ ! $# # ! !
$ $
" 0
3 $
$
" 4 " " # ! !$
"
! ! - 3 $ # " 1
)
$ 5 " #
$
$
"
$ 0
!
$ 0
! $#" $ ) '
#
" ! " 4 !
$#" # $
$
"
#$ !
$ #
- ! ! "
$# $ ) 6
$# ") $
$! $ !
" ! $ $
" " # !
# #$! $ # $ 0
"
" 4 !
+ !# ! ! 7
$
$
" "
0
#
$ - %#/*,< 0*,(:
7/*,)*71%+ 1#= 1#*( (&=, 9&/(+.*7+ #6&;%+$#$%( (%)*+*&,+
!
"#$ "*+ ,:
,!2 ,,!'# 3
.#"*+
,:
*'
'#)$+ #/% %?#0*,%(:
*$ =&31( #77%#/ %;*)$*&,
(*+0*++%( #77%11#$% #3$.&/*$@
:
=.%/%#+ -- ,&$ /%,(%/%( #,@ %?71#,#$*&, '*1*,<
=.*).
*+ +3''*)*%,$ (%,@ /%1*%'
)1#*0%( 7%$*$*&,- A-
;*%= #6&;% (*+)3++*&,:
(& ,&$ '*,( #,@ 0%/*$ /%+31$#,$1@:
*+ (*+0*++%(-
-
%,(*,<
+:
*'
#,@:
+.#11 #1+& +$#,( )1&+%(-
4
!
--
+5>+ .%$.%/ +7%#>*,< /%#+&,%(
"%+
& .%$.%/ /%7&/$#61% "%+
&