High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/45842/2025allowed

Naveen Alias Minu v. State Of Haryana

2025-09-17Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

#$ 4 3(# #$ 4 3(# #$ 4 3(# #$ 4 3(# ' !

% 6

% 6 - . - . - . - . "

%( ( & #$ %& B< (2#

"' :) < !

! :) < !

! ) ) ) ) %< > (* - 4#3"

$#% "

%< %<

2, ? 5% % =0- %& < @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ ) ) ) )- < 8);

- < 8);

! ! ! ! %

" ( 4 2 *( 1

$0 % !

3"# / #$ *%"& +%, ! %,(* ! *"- ./ 8$#% (*#%" 9 !!:; $#% +% " #$ + 0% 10 "

"# "*

+ #<6 4"

4 67<6.<./- +("

4 $#% % #$$

( 2 (*10

% !

( 6.- .6- 6A- /7- 6.- / #$ "*

0 #4 - 6A. 8$#% (*#%"

" 9 :; 4 !

3"# 86;8;

;

#$ "* %5( 3"- 677 8$#% (*#%" 9%5( 3":;- " #03 !""# %=0- ("%3" (% %- %& < <

+%5

+"# ( + (" "*

% ( "*" "*

3#520 "- 5 0&- - *4 (""

4 "*"

" * - 0# + ="*

%- =(

520#& 4 ( !0 (5 " 0 "%#0 52- %=0- 4 1#"* =

4 "& # 67<6.<./ $%#5 '.. 2<5< "#

'.. <5< "* + 4&< "

1# "

' 2< <5<- "*%

&# + 1#&(- ="* "* % $3 ( 3# 4 ="* =*"

30#"*-

%% 5#"#%3&30 ="*# " % 20"

4 5 4+ %4< =# #$ "* +#" 4#= - 2# 4 2("#0( " "* 3#520 " 4 *( 3#00 + - "*%

4 "# ,00 "* 5 $ "* & 44 #" * 4 # % "* % 1 0# +(<

3#520 " 00 4 "*" * =( 3%%& + ₹//- .C 3(* 4 05

5#10 2*#

- =*3* "* 33 ( 4 $#%310& "##, $%#5 *5 " + " 1 $#%

+ $%#5 "* (2#"< 6A<66<./- 3#33 ( 4 D>

%- 5% ((- D%

% = %% ("

4- 4 "* 5#"#%3&30 3#55((#

#$$

=( % 3# 4< ! 1(

"0&- # 6<66<./- % 3#33 ( ?%5>

!"&=

!"" =( %% ("

4- 4 4 % %%#+"# - *

45""

4 *( %#0

" 3( < %"* %- # 6/<./<.-

% *

; =( 22%

4- =*#- *( 4(30#( % - 45""

*( #0

#33 %%

4 3# 4 "# * + 4 ("%#& 4 "*

5#"#%3&30 :( % 20"

< $ %"* % 4(30#( 4 "*" * *4 3# (2% 4 ="* D%

*#2- 5% ((- 4 #"* %( 3#55""

+ "* #$$

< %#5 00+#""

5# "- ( 5 #$ ₹-...C $00 + "# *( (*% =( % 3# $%#5 *( % (4

/< )

0 $#% "*

% *( "

4 "*" "*

3 ("#4& ( 6/<./<.< )

4 3# 0 *( %+ 4 "*" "*

% *( 1

$0( 0& 5203"

"# "* ("# < )

0 *( "

4 "*" (( 5 + %+

4#- "* 2%#( %(# ( ",

"# 1 3#%% 3"- # = 2#

3# 4 $%#5 "*

% 4 " ( 0& -...C- =*3* = 40& % 3# 4 $%#5 *5< )

*( $ %"* % "

4 "*" "*

% *( 1

5203"

"# "*

("# - 2%5%0&- # 4(30#( % (""

" #$ 3#33 ( 4- 5 0&- 5% ((< )

0 *( %+ 4 "*" "* E ("

"$3"#

/ %4

; =( #" 3# 4 3"

4 1& "* 2#03 4 "* (- "* 2%#(

%(# ( $$ %( $%#5 4 3"(< )

4 3# 0 *( 0("0& "

4 "*" "*

% *( ( $$ 3%3 %"# #$ 5#% "* .6F & %(< * (- % + 0% 10 ( 2%& 4 $#%< < )

4 !""

0 *( #22#( 4 "*

" 2 1& %+ + "*" "* +"# ( %( 4 + (" "*

% % %# (

" %

4- *

- * # +*"

#" "# 1

+ 0% 10< )

0 (

,( "# 203 3#%4 "* 3 ("#4& 3 %"$3"

6A<.7<. # %" "#4&- =*3* ( ",

3#%4< <

* %4 3# 0 $#% "* %0 2%"

4 * +#

"*%# +* 010 3#%4( #$ "* A<

% =( %% ("

4 # 6/<./<.- =*

("+"# =( 3%% 4 # " 4 "* 3*00 *( 1

4 #

67<.<.< #"0 2%#( ="

( *

4- # " #$ =*3*- 0& .A *

$ 00& G5

4 "00 4"

" ( "* (- 4 1"10 "*"

30 (# "%0 =00 ", 0# + "5 %0 3#

( %( 4 " % + %( "# 4 1"10 (- =*3* (*00 1 %"#3 4 2# 4 % + "*

3# %( #$ "%0< *( # %" 4# #" 4

5 " 22%#2%"

"# 4 0

"# %0 3#

(- " "*( ("+ - 0 (" " 5& 2% > 43 " +10

1%# +*" $#%=%4 "# 43"

0, 0*##4 #$ "*

1(3# + $%#5 "* 2%#3 (( #$ > ("3 %$ + ="* "* 2%#(

A<6<

4 1"10&- "*

" 2 ( "* 4 ""

52" 1& "*

% "# ( 3 % + 0% 10< 0(" 10 20 2% %%

=( 4(5(( %"( # A<./<.< #= %- ,

= G"

3%3 %"#

% $#% 2 %#4 #$ 5#% "* .A 5# "*( 8=*3* ( $0 4 $%#5 "* H5 #%4 %( 1%# +*" $#%"*; # ( 1(" "0 2%#+%

"%0- "*( # %" (

4 "# $$%5" 0& 3# (4 % "*

(" " 20 $#% 10< 2%#$"10

"*( % +%4- 3 54 "# > 4+5

" #$ "*( # %" 2(( !// // // //./ ./ ./ ./ ""0 4 ( $E ?* %( ( !""

$E ?* %( ( !""

%& 4 %& 4 %& 4 %& 4 %I % " =* 4( ( %'

J6.< (

20#+ "# "* 1# 4(3 ((# - "* 320 %+ 4C( 33 ((

+ 0% 10 8(;

$0 " 10

0= K *

( 3* 2 # +*"

#" "# 1 > (#0 0& # +%# 4 #$ 5 " 10"& "* #$<

! 3* 4C( 33 ((

+ 0% 10 8(;

" 10

=( 4(5(( ( ="*4%= C4(5(( 4 ( #" 2% 4C4(5(( 4 $#% 2%#(

%0 % 2 =( 4(5(( %"(< #% "* 4C( 33 (( + 0% 10 2 8(; "# ( 33

4- "*

%C2203 " (*00 1

"00&C2 %"

"0& E % 4 "# (*#= ( 1(" "0 3*

3%3 5(" 4 (*#= #$ 5 ( 2 %$30 #% #("

(10 3* =# 04 #" ( $$3

"2*#%3 G2% #$ (

, + ( 4C( 33 (( 10 20 8(;

# +*"

#" 1 1("%3"

"# 0"

%0 "

%"# ( #$ 2 8(; ="*# "

( 1(" "0- $$ 3"

"0 3*

3%3 5(" (<

G* (" + 4

( 3 2#((10& 1 04 4#= ( "# =*" =# 04 3# ("" "

( 1(" "0 3*

3%3 5(" ( ( %& *( "( #=

$3"(C3%3 5(" < , + ( 3*

52" ( + 1 " "#2

# %< %+#- "*( (( (" 0 $" "# "* > 430 =(4#5 4 4(3% # %" 4 0 ="* ( 3* ( 4C( 33 (( + 0% 10 2 8(;<

# %" 3*##( ( "# +% " ( 4C( 33 (( + 0% 10 2 8(;- 3#+

" 4 0 34 % (# ( % %"

"0& % E % 4 "# 3#%4 4 $#% +% + ( 3* 20 4 (2"

( 3* 20 1

4C( 33 (( 8(;<

% =#%4(- "* 3 ( $#% # %"

* ( 33 (($ 00&

( 3* 4C( 33 (( 8(; # +*" "# 1 40& 4 30 %0& 32* %10 $%#5 "* (4 #%4 % 2(( 4<L A<< ( 2 % 3 ("#4& 3 %"$3"

4 6A<.7<. $0

0- "*

% *( 0% 4& ( $$ 3%3 %"# $#% 2 %#4 #$ .6 & %- .A 5# "*( 4 . 4&(< %"* %- ( 2 % "* (4 3 ("#4& %"$3"

% ( (""

4 "# 1

#0 % 8(;< #= %-

"*( $3" 5 3

#" 1 +%# 4 ( $$3

" 1& "( 0$- "# 4

+ 0% 10 "# "*

("# =*

3( ( 54

# " $#% +% " #$ % + 0% 10 E "* ("# 1& %"#3 + 2#

$3"(C3%3 5(" ( #$ "* (4 < 0

"*( % +%4 3 203 > 4+5

" #$ "* # :10 ! 2% # %"

0 #*4< 5% 0 #*4< 5% 0 #*4< 5% 0 #*4< 5% (*4 < !""

#$ << 4 %- .6 86; 8%5 0; A (*4 < !""

#$ << 4 %- .6 86; 8%5 0; AI (#

3* > 4+5

" #$ "* # :10 03 "" +* # %"

!%4*% ( < !""

- 677 8; 8%5 0;

!%4*% ( < !""

- 677 8; 8%5 0;

!%4*% ( < !""

- 677 8; 8%5 0;

!%4*% ( < !""

- 677 8; 8%5 0;

K > 4+5

"( #$ "*( # %"

#</. ""0 4 ( ,*0 (* !

+* < !""

,*0 (* !

+* < !""

,*0 (* !

+* < !""

,*0 (* !

+* < !""

%& %& %& %& - 4 34 7<66<.6- 4 0%> < 0%> < 0%> < 0%> < !""

#$ %& - 677 8/;

8%5 0; 676< 8%5 0; 676< 8%5 0; 676< 8%5 0; 676< ! $$3 "# (&- $ %"* % 4

#$ "*

% (

%"%0 ( #" =%% $3"( 4 3%3 5(" ( #$ "*

= #$ 1# - "*

" 2 ( 00#= 4<

% ( #%4 4 "# 1 ( + 0% 10 # *( $ % (* + 10C( % "& 1# 4( "# ("($3"# #$ "* )4< #

4 C "& +("%"

< #= %-

44"# "# 3# 4"# ( "*" 5& 1 52#( 4 1& "*

4 C "& +("%"

- "*

% (*00 % 1# + 3# 4"# ('

% (*00 #" 5( ( 01 %"& +% 4< 8;

% (*00 #" "52 % ="* & 4

- #%0 #% 4#3 5

"%&- 4 % + "* 8;

% (*00 #" 1(

" *5( 0$ # & 4"

$#%

% (*00 #" 3#55" & #$$

=*0

10< 8;

% (*00 4 2#(" *( 2((2#%"- $ &- ="* "*

"%0 # %"< 8;

% (*00 + *( 3 002*#

% "# "*

("+"

+ $$3 %C! #$ 3#

4 #03 !""#

4 (*00 #" 3* *( 3 002*#

% ="*# " 2%#% %5((# C "& +("%"

% (*00 #"

& 5

% "%& "# 4 0& "*

#$ 1% 3* #$ & #$ "* $#% (4 3# 4"# 4 "*#(

=*3* 5& 1 52#( 4 1& 3#

4 C "& +("%"

( 4%

(*#= & ( $$3

3 (

C3#520 " (*00 1 " 01 %"& "# 5# 3 00"# #$ 10 #$ "*

%< 7< %4 4 33#%4 +0&< 6.<

+ (4 *

1# (*00 1 ("% 4 (

G2% #2 %"( #$ "* 66<

34 4- 2

+ 5(3 00

# ( 2203"# - $ &- (*00 0(# (" 4( 4(2#( 4 #$$< 8! ) ! ) ! ) ! );

% 6

% 6 - . - . - . - . 5*% M* % (2 , +C% (#

(C M* % % 2#%"10 (C