High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6029/2017dismissed

Sumer Singh v. Mahender (Since Deceased) And ORS.

2018-10-11Mr. Justice Fateh Deep Singh3 pages

"#$ %$&'(' )*

! +

,$($)#* ,!-'(./"0$$#')1.2%3 &"#$

,#.$"44$55")#

.$ 4,$($)# "44$"5 %',$&#( &."55$)1$ "1"')(# & )&6,,$)#

')%')1( ,$& ,%$% 78 #.$ 6,#( /.$,$78 (6'# , %$&5","#' ) /'#.

& )($96$)#'"5,$5'$ ')06)&#' ) '5$%78#.$"44$55")#:45"')#'

#."#.$'( /)$,")%')4 (($((' ) "1,'&65#6,"55")%# #.$$;#$)# <(.",$ =$"(6,')1

>")"5 ?=",5"2%$#"'5$%')4"," #.$06%1=$)# #.$#,'"5 6,#/"(%'(='(($%78#.$#,'"5 6,# )@!! A")%"44$"54,$ $,,$% 786)(6&&$(( 6545"')#'

:"44$55")#%'%) # ')% "3 6,/'#.#.$ 6,#

%%'#' )"5 '(#,'&# 6%1$2",'%"7"%!

.$&"($($#6478#.$45"')#'

:"44$55")#'(#."#4,$3' 6(58

"#.$, #.$45"')#'

")%1,")% "#.$, %$ $)%")#( ! # ?/$,$ /)$, ')4 (($((' ) (6'#5")%! #$,.'(%$"#.25")%/"(').$,'#$%78#.$ 45"')#'

")% "#.$, %$ $)%")#( ! # ?! .,' 655'2 "#.$, #.$ 45"')#'

."%#">$)(="55"1,'&65#6,"55 ") , =$/ )%'"22 ",'%"7"%/.'&./"() ## .'(>) /5$%1$!5"')#'

( 5%

>")"5=",5"

5")%# =#!",48",'3'%$("5$%$$%%"#$% ?!@!

+@")% >")"5=",5"( # .,' $$>""=3'%$("5$ %$$% %"#$% A!! +@ ")% .")%$% 3$,

4 (($((' ) # #.$ 46,&."($,(! 67($96$)#582 %$ $)%")#( ! # ?

,"6%65$)#582'55$1"558")%6)5"/ 655846,&."($%#.$# #"55")%')"6&#' ) & )%6&#$%')46,(6")&$ #.$%$&,$$') "3 6, $/ )%'"

"1"')(#5 ") (!

@2@!?@/'#. 6#>) /5$%1$")%) #'&$ #.$45"')#'

=#!",48",'")%.,'$$>""= '5$%&'3'5(6'# !?@?%"#$%! + &."55$)1')1#.$"6&#' )("5$/.'&./"(%$&,$$% )!! ")%("5$/"( .$5% # 7$ ) # 7')%')1 64 ) ,'1.# ")% ')#$,$(# =#! ",48",' $#&!

5"')#'

&"=$# >) /"7 6##.$ ,"6%45"8$%78%$ $)%")#( ! # ?

/.$).$,$&$'3$%) #'&$')#.$&"($#'#5$%=#! ! 5"')#'

"(>$%#.$%$ $)%")#("7 6##.'( ,"6%")%#.,$"#$)$%# #">$5$1"5"&#' )76#%$ $)%")#( ! # ?4, ='($%#."##.$8/'55$;$&6#$ ("5$%$$% #.$%'(46#$%5")%')#.$)"=$ #.$45"')#'

!)A!!2 %$ $)%")#(,$ 6($%# $;$&6#$#.$("5$%$$%') "3 6, #.$45"')#'

$ $)%")#( ! # ? '5$%#.$/,'##$)(#"#$=$)#2($,' 6(58 & )#$(#$%&5"'= #.$45"')#'

:"44$55")#!.$8&."55$)1$%#."##.$(6'#'( ) #="')#"')"75$"(,$165",($& )%"44$"5'(4$)%')17$ ,$#.'( 6,#'!$!

!@ + A")%#.$"44$55")#(. 65%."3$ '5$%")"44, 4,'"#$ "445'&"#' )')#.$"

,$("'%'

.$."%")81,'$3")&$# $;4,$((!55 #.$,="#$,'"5"3$,=$)#( #.$45"')#."3$7$$)%$)'$%/'#.4,"8$, , %'(='(("5 #.$(6'# 6)($5 ,#.$"44$55")#/ 65%6,1$#."#"(#.$("5$96"(.",$

=#!",48",'$#&!."(7$$)($#"('%$')#.$(6'##'#5$%

#.$4,$($)#"44$"5="87$.$",%/'#. !@ +

A!) #.$,(67='((' )="%$78& 6)($5'(#."#"(,$(4 )%$)#( ! # ?4, ='($%# $;$&6#$#.$("5$%$$%') "3 6, #.$45"')#'

96".'((.",$

5")%2.$%'%) #')'#'"#$&'3'5 ,&,'=')"54, &$$%')1("1"')(#,$(4 )%$)#(

? ! # ? ,#.$ ,"6%& =='##$%78#.$=!$/ 65% 6,#.$,"44,'($#.$ 6,##."#.,'".$)%$,%$ $)%")# ! "44$",$%')#.$/'#)$((7 ;")% ').'(&, (($;"=')$"%='##$%#."##.$5 ") , =#.$ ")>."%7$$)#">$)78 .'( "#.$, .","=')1.!

)%'(46#"7582#.$45"')#'

:"44$55")##'55%"#$."() # '5$%#.$ (6'## &."55$)1$"6&#' )& )%6&#$%78#.$ 6,# ,("5$ 5")%')96$(#' )

,("#'( "&#' ) %$&,$$4"(($%') "3 6, #.$$/)%'" )%'"2 ",'%"7"%!.$4,$($)#"44$55")#/"("4",#8')#.$(6'# '5$%78=#!

",48",'# &."55$)1$#.$"6&#' )96"5")%( 5%').$, "3 6,")%.,'$$>"

"=2# #.$$;#$)# A>")"5

=",5"!)#. ($4, &$$%')1(2#.$("5$."( 7$$)($#"('%$ )58# #.$$;#$)# 5")%46,&."($%78=#!",48",'")% .,'$$>""=")%,$165",($& )%"44$"5'(4$)%')17$ ,$#.'( 6,#') /.'&. 4$,"#' ) #.$06%1=$)# ")%%$&,$$4"(($%') "3 6, =#!

",48",'$#&!."(7$$)(#"8$%!

(#.$4,$($)#"44$55")#:45"')#'

)$3$,&."55$)1$%#.$("5$

(6'#5")%')"6&#' )& )%6&#$%78#.$ 6,# ,,$"5'B"#' ) %$&,$#"5 "= 6)# 7")>2#."#."("##"')$% ')"5'#82#.$"44$55")#&")) #7$.$",%# ("8#."#.$'( /)$,")%')4 (($((' ) ."5 (.",$')(6'#5")%=$"(6,')1

>")"5 ?=",5"!."#7$')1( 2% ) # ')%")$,, ,=6&.5$(('55$1"5'#8 ')& )&6,,$)# ')%')1(,$& ,%$%78#.$ 6,#(2/",,")#')1')#$,3$)#' )! ,#.$ ,$1 ')1,$"( )(2#.$"44$"5 "'5(")%'("&& ,%')158 %'(='(($%')5'=')$! ,%$,"(# & (#(! $>."'##"5 6%1$

! + = .")7'=7,"