High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6033/2017dismissed

Gurdev Singh v. Mohinder Singh & ORS

2018-11-12Mr. Justice Amit Rawal3 pages

!"##$%&%'()#*+#,-.

/,0#)%'12 33#44!'"

5#,&/& 2%'0#,%'12 "2#,& #&3'0#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

,#&#'"( ,5%6!&/3"!-0)$!"#- ,"2#!33#44!'" 77777 *)+%,' 8.9

, "2# ,#!&'& *#'"%'#0 %' "2# !334%$!"%'- :2%$2 %& &/33,"#0+;!'!%0!)%"-0#4!;0!;&%',#9%4%'1"2#!33#!4%& $'0'#0 &"!'0&0%&3&#0

33#44!'"90##'0!'"2!&'"+##'!+4#"0##'0"2#&/%" ,&3#$%%$3#,,*!'$#-:2%$2+##'$'%'#0",#/'0#!,'#&"*'#; 4!$&#'"!%4%'1%'"#,#&"<=,*"2#0!"#",!'&!$"%'"%44 0!"#&/%"!'0=3#,!''/*,*"2#0!"#0#$,#"!4"2#&/%""%44 ,#!4%>!"%'

#&3'0#'"934!%'"%$4!%*#0"2#&3#$%%$3#,,*!'$#"2# !1,##*#'""&#440!"#0:%"2!'!4"#,'!"%)#3,!;#,,,#$)#,; 4!$&-:2%$2:!&!1,##0"+#3!%0+;0##'0!'"&%',#&3#$"4!'0

*#!&/,%'1 6!'4&*!,4!,$'&%0#,!"%' 84!$&3#,6%44! 1!%'&"3!;*#'"#!,'#&"*'#;4!$&8:!&6#3"!&! &"%3/4!"#00!"#,#?#$/"%'!'0,#1%&",!"%'"2#&!4#0##0%'$#"2# 0##'0!'"&0%0'""/,'/30#&3%"#"2#!$""2!""2#34!%'"%*!,6#02%& 3,#&#'$#+#,#"2# #1%&",!,-%4#0"2#&/%"'@ 33#44!'"90##'0!'"33&#0"2#&/%"+;0#';%'1"2##?#$/"%' "2#!1,##*#'""&#44-*/$24#&&,#$#%3"#!,'#&"*'#;!'0#?34!%'#0 3&&%+%4%"; "2#"2/*+ %*3,#&&%'& ' !$$/'" &!4#!1,%$/4"/,# 3,0/$###'0!'"%4#0&#3!,!"#:,%""#'&"!"#*#'"!'0!&&#,"#0"2!" "2#,#:!&!'!33!,#'"$44/&%'+#":##'"2#34!%'"%!'00##'0!'" '"2#3,#3'0#,!'$#"2##)%0#'$#-"2#",%!4/,"!"#, %'0%'1 "2# !1,##*#'" " &#44 " +# !

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

#1%&",!,0%0'"!,%&# '$#%"2!&+##'/'0"2!"'!1,##*#'""&#44:!& #?#$/"#0- "2# B/#&"%' ,#$#%3" #!,'#&" *'#; :!& ! %1*#'" %*!1%'!"%' !*!,!%0-"2#!,#*#'"%'#0!,1/*#'"%&'"&/&"!%'!+4#!&

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

.12 '(34& +252167 81

918

+252 5/!

918