High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-CR/73/2015dismissed

Oriental Insurance Company Ltd v. Bachni Devi And ORS

2023-12-21Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary4 pages

! "

#$%"

&'()"*+",)-./.*01"#232#3#4#5"

67.)0('8"90/:7'0-)";*<='0>"?(,3"

3333@==)88'0("

ABCDED "

F'-G0."&)H."'0,"67/"

333I)/=*0,)0(/"

J KLM

N ! OOOOO "

P7)/)0("1" "

Q73"F3I3"I'0'R"@,H*-'()"+*7"(G)"'==8.-'0(S7)/=*0,)0("T*3U" "

Q73"&3P3"V:=('R"@,H*-'()"+*7"(G)"0*0S'==8.-'0(W'==)88'0(" OOOOO ! M M "

23"

XG)""

=7)/)0(""

'==8.-'(.*0""

G'/""

Y))0""

+.8),""

:0,)7""

Z)-(.*0""

22$""

;P;""

+*7"

7)H.)[.0\"(G)"*7,)7W]:,\<)0(",'(),"#234#3#42%"='//),"Y>"(G./";*:7(3" "

#3"

?)'70),""

-*:0/)8""

+*7""

7)H.)[""

'==8.-'0(W7)/=*0,)0(""

T*3U""

/:Y<.(/""

(G'("

(G)""

7)\./()7""

Y7*:\G(""

Y>""

(G)""

[.(0)//""

.0""

=:7/:'0(""

(*""

(G)""

'==8.-'(.*0""

+.8),""

Y>""

(G)"

'==8.-'0(S-*<='0>""

+*7""

8)',.0\""

',,.(.*0'8""

)H.,)0-)""

*+""

,7.H.0\""

8.-)0-)""

*+""

(G)""

>)'7"

2^__R""

7)8'(),""

(*""

([*S[G))8)7/""

'0,""

8)'70)7/""

8.-)0-)/R""

[G)7)'/""

(G)""

*0)""

.0""

`:)/(.*0"

=)7('.0/""

(*""

'""

G)'H>""

<*(*7""

H)G.-8)3""

XG)7)+*7)R""

.(""

./""

)//)0(.'8""

(G'(""

(G)""

I)\./()7.0\""

'0,"

?.-)0/.0\""

@:(G*7.(>R""

a'8='""

'(""

I)-b*0\""

P)*R""

&./(7.-(""

a.00':7R""

cP""

Y)""

.<=8)',),""

'/"

='7(>S7)/=*0,)0(R""

+*7""

[G.-G""

(G)""

'==8.-'(.*0""

:0,)7""

67,)7""

9""

I:8)""

24""

;P;""

G'/""

Y))0"

+.8),3""

d:7(G)7""

(G'(""

(G)""

]:,\<)0(""

Y)""

7)H.)[),""

'/""

(G)""

/'<)""

/:++)7),""

+7*<""

.0+.7<.(>"

Y>"G*8,.0\"(G)"/'.,"7)/=*0,)0("8.'Y8)".0/()',"*+"(G)"90/:7'0-)";*<='0>3"

!"# $ ! " %&'

$ (

)!**$+%! ,!** $$! **'

* !- .

+$ *$!%+/

$+!%

0&"/1 ( 234$

5&* 6& + 789:; <=> ?<@ A8:B C7B >7B DE9E= F; GBHB 9I FE8=:7 JKLM NOP Q56R SJ#

T+ . +' 1!+ !+!4$

/ &"' !' '&/

& / " U&

4 &/

% "

T * +1! (!%+ .

1&$ +*$

/+'

' .

+/ 1!+ !+ " 4-

/+'

+/ V W+% '+/ N&

+ -# X!$*! !

%Y/ Z # [+'

+% X+!& Q2ZR#

* "&% " !" ! '* %+(+%

+% .!' 1!"

# +

!((+"!T+ (

((+%+!$ .

!** !

" !' ! .+ '' "

' (

+' 6& #

1 !$' '&% \& + /! "+/

'!1 .!'*& ] ! "$ ! "%&'

$ +

'+"

!"(+$ * &'

" ^ _- (!

$!. !'

/! "'

'%* !" !14+ ( +

% +

T+ . +' %% + +'

$ "

$+1+

" !" %! ! !** !$ + "+'/&+'

234$

5&* 6& + D9`9a bcd9: e9:f9g >7B DE9E= A9h ;;i=: @j JKJ 566 W+ 56 L]Kk# !(

%'+"

+/ ! +/ ( 0&"/1 ' %&$$ "& !/+'

(

%+'+'.

+% !"

&'l mQ+R N 0&"/1 +'

T+ .n opqrsnn tuotn +(

+' ! 1+'

!Y ! !**!

(!% (

% " Q++R N 0&"/1 * &% " 4-

6& +' (+!$# !" "

& ( 1

* +%+*$ +' 0&'

+(+ " $- .

%+ %&1'

!% ' ( ! '&4'

! +!$ !" %1* $$+/ % ! !%

1!Y + % ''! -

"' Q+++R N

+% +' $() T+"

" 4- ! * % '' (

!'+/# %!

! "$- '!+"

!**!

(!% (

% " 0&'

+(-+/

v %+'

+ '*.

( T+ . Q+TR O

v %+'

(

0& +'"+% + &"

]w P&$ L 6Z6 # + +' 1+''+4$ ( !

&' "

%+'+

! " !"% %

$%& % !

) *+,*"& %#) -%##"! .

%''"

)!".

/%#%** %' #) &0+ & 12 3#) , !$ 0+ & "4 ,

5 !$ !

"# , -%##"! .

,( !!

) !" , %0 !%!

%#) , %,0+ !$ 6+ &!

"#& $ -$ $% %', %)7.

#%)), && )%#)) - ) )1

,,", !$ 4%- "4 , -",) (+&! .

&+-$ %#

,,", $ -$5 , '""8 #0 %! !$ , -",) &$"+') &!, %#)

! &$"+') #"! , 6+ , %#7 '"#09),%# *,"- && "4 , %&"# #0 "# !$ *"

#!&$ , !$ , (%7-"#-

%.'7.

!""* # "#&1

: # !$ -$%#0

# '% ", &+.& 6+ #! ) - & "#;<+)0( #! "4 % -"9",) #%!

", '%,0 , = #-$ .7

!& '4 -%##"! .

, 0%,) ) %&%0,"+#)4",,

12 >1 %# #0 !" ) %'

!$ !$ &+.( && "4 !$ %,# ) -"+#& ' 4", !$ ,

9%**'

-%#! %#) !" *+! !$ (%!!

, %! , &!5

& )

) %**"& !

!" , , !" !$ %44 )% ! )%!

) @A1@B1C@AD5 "4 ?,1 E1F1 &;" H%' #0$ 5 F+* , #!

#) #! E,%) 9II5 !$ "44 - %' &+(("# ) .7 !$ & J"+,! 4,"( !$

, #0 K - #& #0 +!$", !75L%'*%5$ -$, %)&!$+&M /A1 N$%! !$ ) *"# #! $%& .,"+0$! !$ , &!

!$ , 0%,) !"

&&+%#- "4 ), #0 - #- & .7

, #0 %#) - #& #0 +!$", !7 ?1O15 L%'*% %!

-8"#0

"5 &!, -! L ##+%, Q1 14",!$ 7 %,ARBB1 C1 N$%! %& , !$ &% ) , -",) .,"+0$! .7 5 #" ), #0 - #- G"1 SSCTU )%!

) AU1A@1ARBB %&

&&+ )

# !$ #%( "4 (%,< ! #0$F;"P%,&$%#F #0$1 D1 N$%!

# !$ &% ) %, "#'7 DT ), #0 - #- & &!%,!

#0 4,"( G"1 FPL9A;BB !" FPL9DT;BB

&&+ ) 4,"( !$ - #& #0 +!$", !7 %& , !$ , -",) .,"+0$! .7 1 I# !$ &% ) %,5 #" ), #0'

- #- %& &&+ ) #!$ #%( "4(%,< !F #0$1 U1 N$%!

# ), #0 - #- &

&&+ ) .7 !$ &% ) - #& #0 +!$", !7%, !$!$ &+44 VFPL12 S1 ,+&%' "4 *%,% A %4", &% )

!& '4 (%8 &

! (", !$%#

) #! !$%! !$ "44 - %' $%) .,"+0$! !$ , &!

, , 0%,) #0 !$

&&+%#- "4 ), #0 - #- & .7 !$ &% ) %+!$", !7 4", !$ %, ARBB5 %& , $ -$5 #" ), #0 - #- .

%, #0 G"1SSCTU )%!

) AU1A@1ARBB %&

&&+ )

# !$ #%( "4 (%,< ! #0$ &"# "4 P%,&$%# #0$1 ?", &"5 ) &* !

-"(*'

"**",!+# !7 $% #0 .

# 0,%#!

) "4 $ &

!"#!"$ " %& #!" ' (&# # #) '!#"

$ # *! *!# )! # #! "+ #

,!!# (" # "+ %& +- ." '/ 0 #) 12 # 3! #"*$ #) &1 !!" 1+ , "

* &" , 0 2!

((,!"# ("* 4-5$ #)# #) #)" "

3!# $ * "# ),* "+ '# - 6)! 7&#$ #)&$ , 0!"* " " 8&#!0!#!" # ,, 0 "+ **!#!", * 0 #) 9! "!"3 :&#)!#+#(1 #) ## "+0&#) - ;- 6) , "

* 7&" , 0 #) 2!

((,!"# )2!"3 , "#

" 1, # 1!"3 )! '!#)!" #) 0& "

0 #) ( # ,!* *'" !" #) 8&*3 0

*$ &,* "# &* #)! 7&# # 3"# !"*&,3 " !" #) (

*!"3- <- ." 2 ,, ( ! "* 0,, &# 0 #) 12 $ #) 2!

' ((,!#!" , #) ((,!#!" 0 ! (, 2 # "* ) 1+ *! ! *- =>- "*!"3((,!#!"$!0"+$ *!"3,+ *!( *0- @ABCDBEF GCDHI

J J K-L M) #) ( /!"3N "

* O N4 M) #) (#1, O N4