High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5662/2018dismissed

Joginder Singh v. Gurpreet Singh

2023-01-09Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan11 pages

!"!#

$$%% &"' ('"$"!#

$ )"

* +, "#$$%%

'%(-%+, "#"$

....

*"%-+#"#$%('"$" !# # % ' " ","- +/0+/1 ! !" !# # ,"2 # # %" "$"!##33"%2'"!"4' 4!# ' # " ,%%! )#"'"+ 5#% 6+ "7'#+#!"%%#2%!3#1"#" 4"+$!+6#% 3##$%8 ++1$"

" +",!'2 %6##"

2-9#3"!"2%%34-)"2!# *##"!#+:#!#;"%!# <"="!#>"!#+",%%!*#%;#'"+ 5#%5$9"2#!"2+##!" ?'!"!"#%,'"#$%'$ "$#4%%"2'+ #3,"+#"?'"!"%3 ?0 #2# ",'2 ++1"2#$%93"!# "!"32#"!%!"2%%9#3,"+ 0 +#2$"#'4 !""+6"#$'"$?'!#%,'" #$%+#'!

##$%"2$"#"%!3# '2'$-#4%"4"# #"?$"2$%#%9#$%# ?',#"!"'%-4-'4"!"" '2 @?'! !"+ 69 #"" # $% $$"##6!#2?'!"!" #%4'$'#2"$"?"# #"9#$%",%!

'$# %%!'$#22"3""2$%# "

9#%!%

3 ",4-#4'#2#'4

!""+6

$""2#$"#"+ #'!##$%"2$"#"#,!'2- $-#4%"2'4"#?$" ?'"!"#%9 #$"# $% 3 '%- 2"6 $$%

,#,9#""#$%""%' "$$""2!#4$-# =24"2<%A)3"

4'#3#6 63#33"#%2'"!" 4!#92"#'%"2!##" 3%##+#""+#!"2%% 3 , $% '% % ' " $ $""2#4#!"2 <#$%# %'"","-!# "'# 2-$#$%%!3#"8 B$"2#

# $$" % 3" 2!#'#'!#2!#,!" !"2%%3##$%!##!"2 3"#4##$"9#"3$ "21#!"2##$'"#""% "2#!"2+#"2-3'%4"4-# %%"92"#$%3"-3%%!! #%?'#,$'!$$"4"

0 '4!""60 9##"## "2 $" #" #"'!#' # -9 '%2%- '42$$%'4!""+6"!!# $"""""3$4-'4!""+6 '#$$%9#$%3$"#"#-9 #3%3-"-3%%!$""2#$" "#,!#%%""2'24"" #$'"$9#$%3$'' $-#4%"2'#4" #%%"-?$"2$%#%+#""+# "2-$4-#$%#" #!"2!

%%+#""+#$%% "%"'#2-$4-#22'#%3#"9 #2"#"6#"C 032# !"20;%2"%6% 02"% A'4'#32""""'%4" $"4%!$",%3 '!#"2!

#$%!#$"+%%3!'3" "2

! "

! $ %

5#$"3""A'$$"'% ,'$$"#""$,%2

'"!#'",#$%+#!# 32"")D "$## !,#$% <'"#"?2)D:#!#)D <"="!#+3#""4"#,"

D###,#$%3%

E"4'% !"!#!#2 ""D ""##," !,#3"24''4A'%-#$$" "?2 5#,#3%4- ""#:'" /

"#"!"!'2+#"%:'"' C ,'"#$%!#+'

C 03#,!42"'4!$" 'C 3!#,'"# $% "'%!'+#'#$%3 "3#""' %6#$ %!3#"8 B$"2#"2 %% "9 ++1 $ %! 3# " 8 B$"2#"2 %%#"''" "8 B$"'23!"'#2'"2# "%%'%"%F 5#3,='!2 " /

G%!!!",4-#='!2"+# # % $$% # :'" " '!+ 7'#+3##3!%"%" '!+ 7'#+ 3# , ='!2 "

$"%- %%3#$$%'$#%!#='!2"$4-# "% :'" 3# "!" "! # ' " ","- ++1%!3#$%"8 B$"'2 "2#%!#'%%"''"" 8B$"'2"2#"%%'%"%F

<3,"+#"%!"4-#"%:'"3#"!"$-2 "#2'$""%!#'33#"3

%% %! + # # % # $""!'%"$$%4"#:'" 5#'!#

/ 23'#4'#"$#$$"# 3#"'!#'%

E#,#"%"'%"#$"4!! #"'!##""

*##:'"4%3"!#$%! ,4"'!#%4-#$"#,"'"#!# $%%","#2'$4-#2 #4!"2%% ##$% #%3-4"-3%%!$""2#$""+ 3#"33#"!"+3#2 "3"?'#%,'"#$% E# '"#" 4 4", # # !"2 %% 3 , 2'##33"#%%"3## ##"!"2%%3##$%# 3"#$3%##"!"4-#24%# $% 5#""+ # $% 3 =' '!

# "$$""2!"2%%4'# 3'%#,4$?'% ,'"#$%"#"!"4-#24%# $%##2%%6%#?#%3 "%#" <3,"+#$%''%%-$",## #"2"-3%%!!#%?'# ,'"4-##4!"

E2-42#"## -##$%#,!"!"2%% 3##$% +",! %6#" 2-"!4!? ##% '%4?'#3? 0 # # ", '"#"2' ++1"2#$% 5## %26'###"!#"#2' ", 4- #2 "2 # $% ' - '% 224-#$%+"#"$%#''%%-$", #"3%%!!#%?'# ,'"#"'!#'?

$3#$"'%$-=24+# 263#33"%%+3### # !" %% 3# # $% # 3"#$ 3 '4%%-%## 2$"#!4## !#!+,!"%4%,4#"%3%% '2"-'4-#$%+##$$ # 3 4? D ! # ?2# "" 4' $$" # :'" ! " ?2+#3-+#22$%4 %6 '##,'4-#$%#!

'"4'#"%:'"3='""!"'# 2-",4-#"2#$%'"!"2 %% #,"-3%% %!3#"2$#$%"#$"3## 3$",#2'4-#

%#'!#%"'%"#$$%%#" '%3##2$'!='!2"!# #$%3"A'"%'"$$""2 #'!##'%","%+#'%#,'!# """'"2-3#"4'## +#""#'#'%#,42+4'33"!%- " 4-#"%:'"$$%!#='!2 "$4-#"%:'"3#'!#$"%-%%34-# G"$$%%:'"4'#'4%"%!"" 2-3%%3#'!#3#$"8 B''" "8B$"'2

<3,"+ E 2-% , 4- '# 4%##""#3 3"#2$%""!"!3####" !"23##$%+#$%3='%! '"$$""2#!"2%%"#" '!""'2-$4-#2#'"# !"2 %! 3# " # ='!2

"$4-#:'"4%34'%"#"

G'"#"2"+#$%#%#'!#4%#""## #%3-4"-3%%!$""2#$"" #'!#'##33"# %%+3####!"%%3##$%+## %'"$$""2!"2%%+"#"% '"","-2'3#"

5# ='!2 """ 4- %" '% " # $$%%

$$%4% ' " "'2#?3##'#4",#4 2

*##='!2""A'% 3%%"$"'%$"$"$$"%$$" ,"""$"%3 5#"%%!%-"

"2-#" C'4%A'%3""# $$% 5#'!##"%:'"#!""#2' "2-"#$"$""%!#'+#3,"+ %" % " '!+ 7'# # " 2#='!2"-!""#$" $""%!#'#$%"#"!"" $%8 B$"'2''""8B$"'2

G! 2" # $$%+ # 2

2"!%-

# 2 $$% 2+ # 2%%'$$% +-+$"!%-

*"=

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#