High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/5747/2018disposed of

Hdfc Bank Limited v. Heera Lal

2019-09-05Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary8 pages

!" #

$ %&'( )* ++ ,"

- %"*+ "# $% %%% ."

" /0#1 " -"23 #1 "/" 41" %%% & 6/ +/ ! " ""!7/++ 4+

%&'! )/++ 2 29-2 " :

!7 /+"

'1+3-23- "1 #. 9-2 "

!7/+"

"3-2#. / ; /- "+ /" ! " ("

"7 "/9- / "// ++ 4 +

+ - " "1"7 $

8< + 20/ + --"" " =>++ "+ ?

+//+

4( ) " + 82"

: /" "! /+ 0 !7 / 6/ +

) / " + " / # "" $7"

- $

8<0 / " - !+ -"7 6/ + @;.%01"#/+

) :

: - / ;"

2// / " 7+ 2" -2/1/ "! "

- -"7 - 0 -2/.

/ 1"# /01"# / -"7 - 0 " - !-"

;

-+7 !7 / +

) !7/ "A- +2+

#/ - 0 " - !7/ % #/ - +0" ) 21"-

"+ "7!9

- "+ 0 +!7/ #+ /-+/7 +

/" / 1"/ +

<! )

: "/! )!-+ " +

1+0") /!-+ 2/ ) /+

) 6/+

# #"

-""7- : :

? // -

8<#0//// -"" /0")""- /!-+ "/ /+

"1"#B

8<+ !/" # !- " /+

0" / 6/- "

+ "

8<0 - + /0" "+7/ - "+ 0 + &++0 2

- 0" " !7/+"

"+'-" ! /+ /"

< C//"/+

+" ""1"7

8< "7 "D..

C//"/ +" "/ -

8< "1" " /+

-8"-+B< '.' "7 /- "+ D. : C//" - !+ /" " D.

C//"/+

/ - "+-

+/" -D. C//"/+

/ -"0/+ /

/ + / "- "+ " / % E!+'-"D. B + @1 0 +!7!//" *"

"+'-"

" 2/1 ""1 9-2 " :

"/ - /+

/ +$

8<0/ " /" >"

- " / + -++"+ '- "+ + !7/ 4" 0 + "/

+ - :#

8</" >"

- " / + /- "+ ++ "+ + 0 + !7 / ++ < +

!7/ 4" *"

"3-2#. 1 -2 9-2 "

!// + +!7/+

+!7/ 22"1/" " #" +/ ! + !7/+

<! )/++ 2 2/" 1-" /- "

+ *"

1/ +7"2- / "

:#/+

4 ! )0 0++0/ "2/ /1" /+ 7 0/-

2 7" #! "/;"7 / -" #!7 21 2/" / "" 0" 2#/+

+ "

'+- ???!

:*"

+ + " "

'+- () -! //+

"/- ")

+++ /1+0") / "

/-+ / -++

/"77 // 21"

/ "

+ 20///+

0 +""7-/ /"-2/ /""

9- / -""# " /" !/ +

"6/1+ 0")# -! #"" - /"

A- 0 " / "

/ + 2" 6/" "#/" A- /" ++ /1 2 / "/"1+

6/ /+"

!+0# # "1"

/- "+ +!7/ /-+!

? -"/" -! /!// +"

-" !+0/12"

+7"" "+7 2- 0" " @;C 8 " !/+ / ""

; -" -"" 1+0")*"

-"/""2-

/ / 2 +)2 /" #/+

7 0 +!+)" #"" 1 0//+

7!? // 0")0 ""- ++ ? #/- #"7//" +!++0 / - "+ +!7/ 4" !

"/1"<" 0/+" - 2/ "2- !1 -! //+

)/) /"

+ "" $7"

6/"A- 1+0")0 ""- / /+

#0// "" /-+??

/+ ? -! //+

)/ 1

/ /-+ / + 2" / + + 2" 0/ / /-+ 0 + "" @; !7 /

? "2-/ - ) /" /! )

+ //" /!16/!" / /! )/ ! "-"+"!-/" A- 0") +

/-"! "-/ 2+2 /" /

+ /! ) 6/!-+ 20 ) "" $7"

"70")

0"""-/ /+

/-2;

-""!7/" 6/"+1

" "--"0 "1 +7 !- /" 0 2- !-/ - "

" $7"

%01"# / "

! )

+ //!" /0 ! "/F" 8"-"+"#

"" 0

/ - #!//+"

-" !+0 /1 "2/+7 /+ / " + / ;

-"" !7 / " "1 2 / + 1+ 0") " /

/! )? #/- #"7// +!

?/1/"+"

"/" /1"- / + /7 /""#0//0 -"

/!7 +"

+ '-"7 6/A- "1"7 $

8< " /" #

""!7/+"

-" !+0# - /"

/++ 2/ 6/ "1"

7"1+1 "- /A- 0//"/" + - :#

8<#

""!7/+"

-" !+0# - /;

-""!7 /" 1+0") "1 "/ +

)/ 2# "+1 //" -!+

+7 +- //+

+" / + 7 ! "/;"7 -" + 0/-

" !7 21 2 /" / "" 0" 2 / +

" %01"#/ # " //" +- 7"1 + #0//"

- "

< ' @/."7/G?

7 2."7H/"!7 ) //""72

# - " ++ #/"2 #;

#+ # +

" 2#0// 7! -""" -

"!7//"

."7 !7 "

7 !"/# -+# 2+2 # "1 # <!

# 2" ""

# 1 "1

* /" / 7 2."7!!

"1 "

" *"

- !+ 7// ) //!" / A- !) + "/F" 8"-"+" -/ 2+2 /" /

+ //" " 0") / " +2/#/ "" 0

-? " ""//" + / +

/" /" 71 "1/ *"

"/ ++ - !+ - 7 -/ 1 "" "

/-+ /0//+

:#/" + /1+0") ! +!7/+

" "/ +

6/"+1 +- " - "

< '%( )"

6/*

" /++/ +++/1+0")

" *+,-+./-,0123-4-++-- /

++0

"1 "0" ) " 0/1+!+7 0""1

/"0" -+7 2# 7#0++!"

6"1 ""/ B E ++ + 0")"A-" + 2 6"1"""++ 2 /-"

2"++ "++

/-"

""7 +"7# 0" -+7 +

+ -" 2( )

"- 6 " / +"+1+ "A-"!7! ) +1++ " 8( )" "( ) " "! )

" " !-+ 2 " " /!-+ 2 C"" 2" 6/" ; ?

" (!-C "1/;

-""@;C 8 /+ /;

-"" "/1+0") + ! !7/+

8<0" " /+1+ +"8 "+ 8+ "80++ "#

8< " /-"

8< "+-22 2+)2 0"" /" ? 7 " /"2- " !7+"

/@;C 8 +7/ 0" #/" "#

!"+- C / ""0/ / ""-/0")/ ++7 / /

-+7"1@;C 8%01"#/ # ! / " /0"" +-22 2 /"

#/ 0-+/1!""-!7/+

7 # "" 1 0//+

6/" !21 - 0-+ /1! " " +)26/0") "2" 2

/ /-"

" /+1+ +" "1/1 ! ""-/

" // 0")0-+ /1! ""- / !-+ 20 + -/+

)#0/+0"" +-22 /+)28 2 " /" " " + -) /!-+ 26/" "#/" 8- "

+ /+ + - #:

8< /""2- ! "

C//!1 / - 0/// 8- "+ +"1"#/ + %.+*.44!

!" #

$ 5,6- "

C//" ) 28"

I 8 C//"""!+

I 8