Union Of India And ANR. v. Tarlochan Singh And ANR.
! " # $#%&' ( '
"
')* '*+,-
- .&/!%#0 !% 1
!" #!
#
$ #!
# #!
#
#!
#
%
& # !
# '
( #!
#
'
)*+,-./- -0
12 3
4 0
5 12 % 1 2% -
' %6+-7,%6/- 8*9 :
; )*+.
/- 8*9 :#%6+-77%6/- 8*9 :
; )*+,./-#%6+-7<%6/- 8*9 :; )*+,,/-9)*+,-./- 4 =0
0
6
<
0
9 6 #-77.
0=
5
& #&
'
0
& / #/-/ &=-7#/-/
'
&= -7#/-/ ' 0=
0
>644
5!
?
'
+ @ ' = #-7., 4 A0=
' '
& / #/-/ 4 = 0
4
#B +-/, . -/, ,// '
6
#+ @ ' =
=
6 '
'
B
4 ' =4 '
''
0
=
' '
@ 6 '0 '
' *
4
6 #
' 0=
+ @ ' =
= >+@A
'
& =/C# /- ) = /# /- )* +,. /-
0
=
'
'
0
3
= -C< =
'
.
B4
#-7,
6 +/C,-%6/-
=' '
+@
6
'
6 4
/ #/-
'
!
/#/- !
=
' !
<#/- '
!
0=+@
/#/-
' '
/<# /-
=-C< =0
4
0
='
0
0=
'
4
'
=
=
=
'
4 =
; *4*5667+), . +
' '
% !
* 0
/7#/- +
= ?
'
4 '
'
D?
6 '
0 =
?
0=
6 ,
& #
4 =0
4 0 =
'
0 #
=
4
E40 =@
6 '
8:+-,,-C/-/ 0
+.//C ,840)9:+):97!;**9;/)! 8* 89,8)9 0))*'*4*76<*)969) /<)* '
=
&
E40 =@
6
0
96 #-77,> 0
= F %
! =
=
'# 4
' 0 4
' ! '
0 ?
# =
'0
!
'
<
&
4 0
4 =0
8-:=7>89)4*9),;
! *<)1<7)89+8)8*9,#8/-/:766 <G8:
=9<67)8*9,41?8289<)8*9,#-77<8-: 4B&.G8: 0<+89/<)*2%789!@(A
!H0<)0:9,8869)8*9, !1?B=:<9869 )8*9,#//8 :64B&-G//8 :6B./-G8 :0:6*9)*;
!;**9 ! &0:>>*B#8-777: 66 G8.: 9)8*9 )*9*9, /)!/)"4*99 '*78#8-7C/:66-,< 8,:
=<7*,81*9<!B5))8*9,#8/-:C66/ C
> G %-:A
6
'
0=
6
$
40 0='
44
?
0=
% !
4 = 0
4!
'
0
6
I
' 0
= ! '
'
I
'
40 - - ' %
!
"
#
!
$
%
!"# $"%& & #
'#
' ()
!!#!$ * ' ) +) ()#
#
' )
'
%,# -%.& / 0 #
'123 ()
%4# 4 $& # )5 6/ ' 2&
/ # 6 73*()
4% #- 4!& #2( ))() )) 21
8) # 8() 7 4*%# !-& #
9
() -,,4 7 * 7
* "$:-,,47 * "!.:7-,,4*- #%," (
"
# "
" "
"
"
)
*
"
"
"
" " + ,
"
"
7 )8 :
&
6
'
'
4
6
!
5!E
0 @ 6
0))*!&7*4?#-77 4 B '& -.- 4 #
'
6
4 6 #-7<-4
#
4 0
0
4 0
!
@'
#
#
@ 6
'
=
=4 (
3
'
'
' !
=
4
4 #
'
@ 6
'4
4 0
!( -/ - . /
> G %:A
0
4 0=
5!E
6 .
#'
% 0 /
"
3
1211 3
"
(
405
"
"
(" / 3
.
16 (
405 ,
"
445 #
"
.
2
445 7
" 8 --
='
0= 4
!
4
4
0
6
6 ?
! '
0
# -77,# ?!
# ?
!
4
!
'
=
!
' -
?
3. )
" > G % :A '
6 '
!
0
# -7 /0
'
I
- 9 ( $ : / > G %.A
6 '
!
0
#-7 /0
!
0= &
4 0 =
6 '
''
'
-< *
< -
6 6# 4
!
6 #-7,, *
/ -6 0
!
0
0
0
'4 0
!
' 0
6
0
44
?
'
'
!
? 4
0
- ;
> G %,:
6 =
'
''0 4 0 '
'
44 H -,
'
' % # 2
6): 5 ,
" % $ : <
%!
$: =
"
#
>
" & $: ?>
& $:
"
,
@"
@
-- -
" ( / / 0)) ) 8)/) / ) ) )() 7 ""* # "-, @
@ ,
3
2
# / ' ) () 1 () -, .7.*
8 6; ' )7 *$.!:+-, .74* #-%" $3: <
%!
$:
$: ? > $: )
$ : )
$ :
"
"
!
"
$ : , "
$ : ,
$ : ,
"
$#: )
8 -. *
0!
4 &
'
0 4 44 =
'
0 I
'
-, *
# ! " #
+@
;
8 :0
= ' ' = !
6 - 9-.
4
'
0
6 # I
F)
, ( #
' # 3
2
A421 . .(( 05
% $.(( 055 :
-
.
"
"
3
#9 #&
A$4B0 .(( 5B+C (
% $.(( 5B0 :
D E
"
> >
" " E ,
"F8 0
"
"
" ( #
"
"
"
8> 4 A -< )
4 4
6 0
4
8*
< -6 6:4 0
'
'
0
4 0
!
'
' 0 ?
4 4 ( 0 0
! '
4
0 = '! '
0
'
'0=4 '
0=
%
=
-<
6 0
% <B
(
(
>
, ( . G
" 3
-
G
H -"
/ H 7 $110:5 .(( 50
% @1
( !
/
3
#
" ( <
,
"
>
"
,
@ -C
"
0
4 /89 =:<9!# )8*9,#-77<6--.
4 4
4 0 = '
'0 4
'
'
@ 6
,
6 '
0
? 0= 6 4 4 &
'
4
G
' !
#
'
' 4
!
"
6 ?
'
'
, <
6
0 =
0
@
8<,!0))* =*97#///8-:6 4
"
" I
-
. 6 ,
.
2( J
( # "
. 6 ,
#
"
.
2(
'
6 , - (
- (
.
2($:
K
. (
'0 (
"
- ( = - (
- (
L + - ( ( )
0 (
( )
" ( )
" (
, - ( ( )
" >
"
-
"
" - (
"
" - ( "
"
, - (M
" )# #2 /) 7 !!*.# %$$ *
(
- ( ( " ( )
0 -"M / G $+ G ; 1 B':
% @,
(
K
" ( # "
(
# "
N
(
(
( >
# " (
" , - ( # (
"
"
" (
@ $,
G (
" " ( :
5 )
"
( 9 . ? > $:
* ( /=> ) 9
) +
'1 44' . $: .(( +''
% @, - ( (
, "
, "
"
J # "
"
" . ( - (
@ B
- (
- (
,
" > "
- (
8 -7 @ 0
6 E 084*0;8)8*9,!0))* $:?>)8*9,#-7,6 -7/7
C
4
' % <2 , ? I .
*
/
5
(
"
- (
*
"
5 (
- ( #
"
"
" -
*
M *
"
"
"
"
"
"
"
- (
" *8 / @
4 ):7B4,0BC )8*9#-7CC6-.-'
'
'
'
6
0= -
"
'*78 ;8 :9))7 ;85B,:)89)B 4, '*<*))
/<)*#//<8 : 0B...85 :85E:0
'0
? 4
4
3
4
0
= 4 0 =
4 0 =
' 0
? 4 '
'
0= 0
) (=#
!
'
96*
> =
96A
!(
4
0
0
.
. 8 :
=
0=6 E '
'
'' 0
'
?? ,8 :
?
'
'
6
@ 6 = '
'
0 =
@ 6 J'
=
'
-<?? ,
'
'
@ 6 #'
I
@ 6
'' '
# =
(
= '
@ 6 '
'
'
'
(
' 0
' 4 0 = =
'??, " '
'
!4
'
44 = 4
4 =0 (
0 # 4
4
4
'
0
4
'
0
4 '
I 4= '
= '
4
' !
'
& E
!5 4
-+28-C <:
2-C % F
0 ' ('
0 #
=
4
'
'
4 = ('
K3
' '
'
& =/C#/- ) =/#/- ? 4 '
' I
#
'
4
# =
4
0 0
4
0 0
' 44
= '
4 =
4
0
'
=
0
3
'
#
(#0 !
4
#
#
' (
=
0 ('
'
' @
'
' '4 =
'#'
I
# 0 0
' 0
44
4
#
4 0
=
#4
= 3
! '
'#
0 0 !
0 >'
?
=
4A'
?
#I
= (#' '
;'
44 = 4
#'
' !
8*+), . B 4 - 0
E ' I
!
# // 0=
+ @ ' =
=
?
@ ' =
I = ' 6
' L-/#//#///;%
= 4 -##/./;% ' '
0
'
644
#&
5!' '
'
4 ,
I
' I
%
+ @ ' = '
' 0
5
# //
5 # &
%4%4
=
4 4 0 '
I
(
!
0
#//
!
644
#&
5!
' 6
' -/
' ? 0 ='
I
+-% =# 4
-##/./;%' 4 - ! E # I
?
@ ' = < 0=4 '
#
+-
4 0
0
'
+@ '
644
# &
5!# &
64 ' - ! '
/ #//7 C )
'
4 +@
0
5
& #&
'
!
/7#/-/
4
'
0 (
0
4 (
'
(
8$:8<:
8 : 8:
+@
5&'
4
4
96
!
' % .
"
"
"
"
>
> >
" .
'$I: $B: $: $ : 9 - "
405
"
11+
"
"
#
11+11 >
' 3
#
)
8 7
0
4
'
& / #/-/
'
'
! ! ' '
0 0=
'
& 4 0 #
=
6
'
4 4 .
0
4 4
;5"
4'
' ./= ' = 4 + @ ' = @ 4
4 4 0 ='
0
(
0
;5"
4 =
D?0 %-,9 %-<
0
! $8<:
+ @ ' = #-7., '
=
'
=
0 =' '
' 4
//
%'
' 4 0
!
0=
=
' ?
4 0=
'
L7M' '
4 4
'
,/ = 4
4 '
-.M
0
#
,/ =#
'
-CM
4
//
4 ' '
?4
4
'
&
/ #/-/4
4
' 0
!
;5"
4 4
4 '
4' 4 (
! '
4' 44
0
'
0=
'
(
'
0 =' 4 =0
4
=
I
' - 0 /
B '
4 0 0 4
I
=
'
'
0
'
4 =0 (
' 0
0
4
'
& / #/-/
4
L-./
I 0 !
0=
=# ?
4 0=
'
H '
/ 0
'
'
# =# 0
'
=
0
'
'
4 .
(
4
0 '
' '
' 4 &=-7#/-/E
'
& / #/-/ &=-7# /-/'
0=0
'
4
4 4
&=/,#/-'
= +@
H
I
' - '
44
0 ='
/
5
& # &
4
#+@
<
'
' 4 0=
6
& = /C# /- 6 (
! '
= ?
=
<
?
=
' 4 = 0 4
*4
#
!
&
# !" # (
! '
'
' I
.
'
8 ;5"
4:#
'0 -.
0= =
=* '
0=+@#
6 (
! '
0
?
''
#
#
0
''
8 :'
4 0
4 ( 0
'
0
4
0
0 '
' =
0
'
4 0=+@
'
I = =
4
4
4
0
0
4 0=
=' ! '
6 4
0
?
0
0
0='
4 ( 4 )
#
'
4 - 0=
# +@
B
+-/, .%-/, ,/-
0=+@
6
'
- #/-
% = "
K
>
( .
"
" - (
"
" - (
8
0 (
+@
6
'
!" #
+@
4 04
'
'
@
0
'
' '
; '
0
6 4
0
4 ( '
8 :
='
0
'
' '
'
# ? '
4 4 ! '
4 0=
0
'
4
4 '
0=
B I 6 # '
'
4
=
4
'
= I
0
'
;5"
4 4 4
'
' 0=+@
4 '
0=
6 &
4
0
4
0
4 0
'
0
" 04
0
'
'
0
4
; '
0
'
' '
=
4
;5"
4
'
0=+@0
6 '
0!
' !+@ =
'
0=
6
0= 0
;5"
4
= ,
4 ;
' '
0
4 4 ;5"
4 #
#
= =
4
@
'
! '
'
4 ! =
4
&=/,# /- 0=
5&#&
0
0
4 4 0
.
=+@ 0=
<
'
? '
4
)*+,-./- 4
, 0=
5
& #&
#
L '
44 L//;%
%'
0 =' @
0
3 (
'
(
"
(
# 5
@ '
' L.
@
0= 0
'
& / #/-/
'
0= + 0
E '
' =4
I
'
'
4
6# E '
0 4 44
=@ 0= I
4 '
0 @ 04
5
6
!
L /
//7%-/ 0
0
5&#&
!
(
! @ 0=
0
; 5"
4 0
44
I
'
E 0
;5 = @ 04
0
!
(
I
$ (
4 I
4 0
;4
0 0= 4 '
(
!
(
4
%4%
0=#
0
@ ' =
'
0
I
?
?% '
' 0
4 0=
0
6
8
5 4 : #-7,
4
#
0
4
0
I
= 4
0 5
!!
'
@ ' =
# 0 ' 0 =
' ('
4 0=
//C%/7
0=+@
I
'
0
# ' 0
=
E ('
4
)
D =
# //
0
!
( '
'
4 4 4
4 0
'
0=0
0
5
& #&
< 4 =0
0
6
<
0
96 #-77.
0=
5
& #&
'
0
&
/ #/-/ &=-7#/-/
'
&=-7#/-/' 0=
0
0=
'
'
& / #/-/ # ' 4
40 ' 4 =0
B +-/, . -/, ,// '
6
#+ @ ' =
=
6 '
'
B
4 ' =
4 '
' C
4 #0
I
=
7 44 H " J 4 '
0=+@
'
;5"
4
4
0
6 + <;/-/
C# /-/# .
? J #
5&#&
8 ?%,:
/ #/- -,#-C 0
% 5 K
> >
9 - " #" K> ,
* K> 9 - "
-
" " K>
9 "
"
" 9-
2114
-M . ( >
-
" "
>
11+!110
>
,
#"
)0 ,
.
?
!
#
" J K
=
,
"
9
2
"
K K "
,
J
K
=
+
"
B11
>
,
"
"
"
>
("
( 9 11112411
MJ H
.
? 7 M 6
)
)8
/ 4 =0
( =
;5"
40
'
-
4 '
0
4 0 !
0=
' 4
?
0=#
' ! 0
0
4 4 (
'
4 ( '
4 (
'
0
0
0
#
! 4
= '
0
'
'
4 '
4 (
!
4
4
'
0=
4404 " '
0
0!
'
0=
6
4
0
4
0
4
;
4!
=
' 0
;
E #
4
#
4 0= "
8 :
96
!
4
! 0% 8 :
' % ..8
6 29? 9 < "
"
" !
$: "
" "
"
"
" "
& $:
" "
" "
!
$:
>
"
"
' , "
"
"
$: !
$:
"
"
+ J
" "
" " "
"
>
0
!
$+:
>
#"
"
5 , "
#
"
>
>
!
$: !
$0: B .
' "
8
I
=
'
0 I 0
0=
0
4'
0
4 0=
=
0
'
!
'
4
I 0
='
0 0%
@
"
+ 8 : - % 9 "
"
,
"
"
" "
"
"
" "
. ,
" .
"
=
"
,
" ,
" " "
"
" "
> , > "
"
> "
> < "
"
"
" 8 8 4 H :
4
5E
5 6 + 0
0=
6 6! + 7<77/-/'
0=
= # /-.
'
. @ 04
6
(
?
0
?
'
0
0
'
4 '
0
!
'
0 '
'
0
?
0 '
0 4
0
' :
I
4
'
0
4
0=
0
'
0= 0 ?
4
! =
0
#
'
'
'
0=
0
'
' 4
?
8 :
964 ( !
%!
'
0=
0
=#
='
=4 =
I #'
/ = 4
'
4 ( '
4
0
0 4
4
'
0
0 ' ? 4
I
8.:
96 4 =
4 ( '
'
,/ =
I 3
0 8 : 4
0
'
8 : ! % 7
!
$: ( " 5
" "
"
"
>
8
,
0
04 "
4
0
4
0
'
H
4
;5"
4
0
! 0 0 4 = =
'
'
I
I I
4
'
'
(
'
44 = 4
=#
4
4
0
!
!!
0=
0=0
@
;#
#
0
'
0=4
? 4
I ='
%
'
0 4 0
=! '
(
'
0
0=
44 = 4
#
# =+@ 0
4 #0
0=
4 '
' =
< 6 I =#
'
'
#
( 0 0= G
4
0
4
4
8 :
96#-77.
& =/C#/- ) =/#/-
0
0
;5"
4
'
!
4
4
0
0
0
0
/ # /-,
C @'
# ! '
4
8 :
96#
* 0
.#/-, '
4
0
0=
!
' ;
0 0= 0
'
!4
4 # =
= ' 0
?
@'
#
4
'
4
0
6 ?
=
='
? 4 = 4 '
3
''
7
0
4 # )* +,-./- !
0=
4
=#
* 0
.#/-,
# =
I
% 1
%#'"!
4