High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6291/2017dismissed

Suresh Kumar v. Kanta Rani

2023-05-05Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

!"# $$ !%&!# ''((

)! &

* '

+*,!'

''(( ! .%/ + +-"

%' /*(1

- %"

'( *&

* .!2% !* * !%&!# 3*2 " '*.14 1'"**"'# " ((

5* *

" *22 '# *+!"

* ' %"

*- % *

4* * (%*%! . *26-"

- 78 & ( !# -$-$ 9 - "**2:( 3% #1- %* (

;"!

* (4 *; -%4* 4 ;

$ -.!

* "#4 ;"!

( * ! * %

*;5 %!2% 2 %*"!.2* -& ( # *' % 2

*2%'"# 35 (2 ( *"!'

((*2!'%*# "#4 ;"!

( * # ((

!"%-

*( %!* *<! *

*"- % *( 4*

# " *2 %!* **2 *!(2 (.+"

*-#*

*2% *2 * ((4* %2 %!* !* 4* * "**2:( 3%

#1*;*2

-4%*"%4 ;

$ ""*2 - ** "%*"!.

2* -& (

-4% %# *' %

2 %* '" # 3 .1 4 1 * * !

*2 # **2 *- ' 1*#* ( %!* =% '( * % *( '(*"

* " *2

((2

** %4*

# 4% *

*2 # *

% '( *2 % '

*- ((4*2 *! 4 # >% % ((**'!

4 ;"!

.1 !

%*>*(( (*

"**2 % #1 ((2? >% % *4 * *(( 1 4*((*2 '#

((**'!

? @. .*! '* *#

*-4% % '( ** ( %(*'"**"'# "

((**'!

? >% % ** ( ( %(*'#

*+!"

* %.1 **2 % # (*

*2 %4*"!#.*2 %!* ( ? $ >% % ("!

* "

! *(

* %' !* ?

>% % ** ''#*(*2 %' !* .1% 4 "!"

(* =%'

*4 '' !* * ( *"* !'' %*'"

*"( *#

!*2 %"!%**"- *-%;

#* !&!# -*"A(3-=%*(& ( >-4%'

;"!

* * 8; $ ( *&

* *2 >*% * * 8; >9'

%% 2* * % '( > %*( &!# % # - "

%% (2 ( *"8; >9A ' 2* ' >)*+ 1 %!(('!"'* ""! '( *4 >$B '*2%-/ -B CA / 3 **

- #! - - 9 4 4* % 4 # ""! 9D!*+*C*# B' "'1

# ""! 8; >$9 >%3&!# -2* 1A(3-

=%*( *"- & ( '!" "'1 ( 6 9

3 E;"!

.1 ** ! %!.

( %* * > '

%!-A(3-B CA/ 3'!" '% *2

! !(

%* - '

""! 9D!*+*C*# >: %* *2%- *

= ! **

- &

*% '!"

#''

' - 9 $ &

*% <! # 3!

#''

' > * &!# - .

* 1 *"-/@-, * 3 / "%-& ('!"

# ""! '( *&

*-"'18; >9 > 8BA #.* *2% '!" "'1 ''(*"

* 8; > 9 !.#*

.1 *

'(*"

* -'% "'1 "#'#* .*2 8; > 9/ '"*2 ' 8; > 9A >% F (*%* * * 8; >9' .!

;"!

* 8; > + 1 - 6/-,= -& (

*% 4* % 4-$ - 9#% ""! B '

# ""! &

* 8; >9 > #

3 %-6

1 !.(*"'

-%%

((# 3*2 1*%*2*

* (6 -"'1 4%*"% .*2 8; >9 =%

*2 "

* "!# "!( "(%*" : @.!

(- !%&!# > *%* * * 8; >9-%' '

3.1%*#*

%4*

# >*

%*" "( % *2 %( "!( %'

*- * (

$ A! (A**(G!2 *-& (2 *!4***2 *+!2# "

!* *4 " '( *4 %( ( "'*.14 1 '"**"'# " ((

1# .

( " ("*

=% 4 *"

;"!

("**2 %.

( " ("*

*-4%

*4 *"

# 3'

1# .

( " ("*

* 4* %* '*# % *"

% *(!- % #1 % ((

* @ 4 ! %*"

* *( ;"!

(* ! *- *4!(.

(*. 1 2 (;"!

%!2%'"( 4 C(*2 22* .1 % * +!2# "- % *( (* %A! * *"

G!2-& (- 4%*"% 4 *2 * * ( * *"

G!2- & (- 4% * +!2# "

$ *#* (!'%(*2 +!2# "'

.1 * (A! /*2*

**4* %+!2# "'

%A! .(4- % *( %' 2!( "

(. %*A! 6 *" (4 2* %' -4%'!

" %!2%"!( @% % ( "!( %'

*.*2*2

%!2% %" @*

%* .(!

(1#* *

( @ %* "

% #* % *2 *

(( %%!*<! *4* * !#-$-$ 9 "**2:( 3% #1 64 %<! * 4%1 (4 ;"!

.1 * ! *""*2 *-%% . 1 4*((*2 2 (;"!

*% ! % 2 *"!.2* -& ($ - %

*; ;"!

* (

'!'.!

* "#

%- !"%%2 * *

"3 >% ""*2 %%* % %(2*"

-%% 2 %*"!.2* -& ( *'!(

$ 4 %.!

'( * *( !!' B;"!

* * %(

'( " $ =%A! .(4*2 "*"!#

" *".!2% ".1 %"

% 2* **2

'( *4 * *(( 1 4*((*2 '#%'

" *"!( ."#'( ""! "#*24 '#%*'

6 4 ! . % 1 %(*'"**"'# " ((

% '( * =%- % !* '* .1 4 1 '"**"

'# " ((4 ".1 * (A! -4%*"% +!2# "4 *#.1 %C* ''((

A! -*

1. %A! .(44 #'

2@ * *'!

* * *.!

# %" (

(2 "#'( 2 *2 %*1#

4* %'(*" * -4% "#'#*%

3'( "* #

% 2 ! -$ - 9 % '( * .1 : .!

*( '

#! * F "!( *2 ''(( 9 %

* .!*(!' 2!#

" %#

% ."#'#* . 4 %'

'(*"

** #4%*"%

2 "* % #! #1 '

* .1 % (24* %#* 9"#'

*- % .*22 '"#* 4* %2 %4*((*2 2 (;"!

. A! .(4((**%(*2

'( . * *(( 1 4*((*2 '#%'

% % % - ( "!( *2 ' 9'( * % "

%!2% % #

% . "#'#*. 4 %'

'(*"

*.!

*"3

"#'#* '

1*2 -$ - 9 *.1 : - !"%- (2 ( *"8; >9A!'

%*( %!* * %*#:$ @ "

. *

%4 1( "3 * 4*((*2 %'

* 2 (;"!

: % *2 %* (" *-@*

% * %*2 * .*

(* 1 *''''"

*@ !.#*

"#'( *

%'(*"

"#*24 ;"!

(*% !

% *2 *

((4* %% "**2 !.

(

#! : ( 3% #1 % #

% . "#'#* %- %!2% % .

"3!

"#'#*

'( *%4 1*"(*

2 (;"!

*% ! * '

! #181# ('4 *% ((* *2

*=% %*2 .# (*"!"

* .*!(1% * .!1 ' " 3*2 ! % #1 '

* .1 % (24* % .(* 9"#'

** 2

*2 ("3*(* *2

*4* @ 4 %4 1!

**"!( * !

**4%*"% *!%(( */!

%% 2*!''

*2 ( ;"!

*% !=%1

4% *( '

#! -$ - 9 % .1 : * #

'(*"

*- % 2 (2 ( *" !' "

((*2 !' %*# ;"!

% ( * % ! =%

-%*( !* '"**"'# " *;*2 (# % '!! %#

''(1%4*2

%% (4 1 .4*((*2 '#%'

" %!2%!

>* %2 % *** "* ("

"* 1 '

1 .

( " "*

* #! - % % .!2% !*"* ( "!#

1*""*

. %A! .(4 !

% % * "* ( "

"* 1 '

1 % .

( " "*

#! @ 1 * 24* %A! .(4

'* 6 * % 1 %(*'"**"

'# " % '( * % % % - % "!"

4 !"%-4%*"%'!

%*#!!'*"* >* %""! **2% *2.".1

A! .(4 * % ''(( 9 - 4%*"% .

'' '' * (*" ""

* '

*( 4 % .*2*((2 (* 1**#* 14* %*#'!2+!2# " '

.1 %A! .(4- %*2! * 4* %!"% *#'!2+!2# "*2!( " ( 6!.

(<! *( 4 ** %* ( C**2#* * (- #

*#* =%* *#

: :'

.1 %*A!

1*2

%;"!

* (- %!"# *" % # * ( * *#*- % #*"(( !

''(*"

* -* 1

*' ""*2(1 $$ /*+

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#