High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6309/2017dismissed

Sarwan And Others v. Babu (Now Since Deceased) And Others

2019-02-13Mr. Justice Amit Rawal4 pages

"#$$%&'&() $*+,"+- . "+/"(#0$+'

11$22"(# 3$+','

"*, (/4$%$"'$4!#0+,506 '#0$+'

$'1(4$(#'

! "

#$%&' () *+!' +*,&

+$'$(#) +"(4$$170"+8".49%"#$.

+#0$"11$22"(#' ::::: +*,&-(

+ #0$ +$"'(' 8$(#&($4 &( #0$ "112&%"#&(. /0&%0 &' ',11+#$4 *- "( "&4"9&#. 4$2"- = 4"-' &( +$<&2&(5 #0$ "11$"2 &' %(4($4 '#"(4'4&'1'$4

0$1+$'$(# $5,2"+$%(411$"2 &'4&+$%#$4"5"&('##0$ %(%,++$(#&(4&(5'"%#"(42"/./0$+$*-#0$',&##0$"11$22"(#< 12"&(#&'+1''$''&("(41$+8"($(#&(>,(%#&(&2$4&(.0"'*$$( 4&'8&''$4*-#0$%,+#'*$2/ # &' " %2"''&%"2 %"'$ /0$+$ #0$ 12"&(#&' 0"9&(5 2'# ,1# (?*2$#0$,1+$8$,+#&("1+$9&,'+,(42&#&5"#&(.&$.&(&9&2 ,&#= @@/0$+$#0$A,$'#&(#&#2$&(&(>,(%#&(',&#/"'4$%&4$4 "5"&('##0$8.%0'$#&2$#0$',&#.*,##0$%,+#'*$2/./0&2$4&'8&''&(5

#0$',&#.4&4(#&81'$#0$%'#' 1$+'( %"((# *$ 1$+8&##$4 # +$1$"#$42- &(9B$ #0$ >,+&'4&%#&(,(4$+$%#&(#0$ #+$<&5(&#$#0$2&#&5"#&((%$ 0"9&(5*$$($C#&(5,&'0$4&(&9&2,&#= @@0$&(>,(%#&(/"'

',50# "5"&('# #0$ 4$$(4"(#' 0$+$&( +8 &(#$+$+&(5 &(# 1$"%$,2 1''$''&(9$+2"(48$"',+&(5;B"("2'

8"+2"'.%81+&'$4&(70"'+"

' @DD D < !.D <@!. @DDD

< !.'&#,"#$4&(3&22"5$"+0".

$0'&2"(4&'#+&%#"2"(40"+./0$+$&(#0$4$$(4"(#'0$+$&("(4#0$+$&(2"&4 +$2&"(%$#0$+4$+4"#$4 @*-/0&%0#0$8,#"#&(&(0$+&#"(%$ "#$+#0$4$"#0 "B&+"/"'&("22-'$##2$4&(#0$&+"9,+ 0$#+&"2,+#.(#0$*"'&'#0$"+$8$(#&($412$"4&(5'&( #0$1+$9&,'',&#.+"8$4#0$22/&(5&'',$')< E

" #

$ !

% &

0$22/&(5"44&#&("2&'',$'/$+$+"8$4(= )< $ (

'$ )

! $ *

' )

#&'"8"##$++$%+4#0"##0$'"&4',&#/"'4&'8&''$4(

;

9&4$>,458$(#C"(44$%+$$<'0$$#CF"(4,2#&8"#$2- #0$"+$8$(#&($4>,458$(#/"',10$24*-#0&',+#&( $5,2"+$%(4 11$"2;

@9&4$+4$+4"#$4= C;!"(4&("22- &( 1$%&"2 6$"9$ $#&#&( *- (?*2$ #0$ ,1+$8$ ,+# (%$ #0$ 4$$(4"(#'0"4"2+$"4-'$#,1#0$#&#2$*-9&+#,$#0$8,#"#&(/0&%0 #0,504$'(#%($+#&#2$.*,##0$+$&'"4>,4&%"#&(/($+'0&1&("',&# +&(>,(%#&(1$+'(%"((#*$*$1$+8&##$4#+$<"5&#"#$#0$&'',$,(4$+ C12"("#&(' "(4@$%#&(

#0$&9&2 +%$4,+$4$%,%0&(5 #0$',&#%2"&8&(51''$''&("(4&(>,(%#&(/&#0,#"(-4$%2"+"#&(./0&%0 &(4&+$%#2-./"'',50#0$#+&"2,+#"(46/$+11$22"#$,+#.*- +$2-&(5,1(#0$>,458$(#'.4&'8&''$4#0$',&#"(4#0$"11$"2 +"(4$$170"+8".2$"+($4%,('$2"11$"+&(5(*$0"2 #0$"11$22"(#<12"&(#&'8"4$"("##$81##"11+&'$#0&',+##0"#"($+# /"' 8"4$ *$+$#0$ %,+#' *$2/ # ',112- %1-#0$+4$+4"#$4

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

. &(>,(%#&( *,# #0$ /($+'0&1 /"' "2+$"4- 4$#$+8&($4 &( #0$ 1+$9&,' 2&#&5"#&(+$"%0$4,1#(?*2$#0$,1+$8$,+#C12"("#&(' "(4@ $%#&(

"(4"'/$22"'$%#&(#0$(4&"(9&4$(%$%#$("*2$#0$ ,+##2B&(##0$1+$9&,'1+%$$4&(5'"(4#"B$&(#$9&4$(%$"(4 *"++&(51"+#-#%2"&8'"8$+$2&$ (9&$//0"#0"'*$$(*'$+9$4"*9$."8#0$9&$/#0"# #0$12"&(#&4&4(#0(,+#0$1+$9&,'2&#&5"#&("'(#&%$4"*9$*- '$$B&(5 4$%2"+"#&( 8,#"#&( /0&%0 0"' "2+$"4-*$$( ,10$24 &( #0$ 1+$9&,'+,(42&#&5"#&(#/"'"'$%(4"##$81##9$++$"%0#0$%,+#

+#0$+$"'('8$(#&($4"*9$.#0$>,458$(#'"(44$%+$$' #0$%,+#'*$2/%"((#*$'"&4#*$',$+&(5+8&22$5"2&#-+1$+9$+'&#- 5+,(4+&(#$+$+$(%$&'8"4$,#.8,%02$''&(929$8$(#"(- ',*'#"(#&"2A,$'#&(2"/ $',2#"(#2-.#0$"11$"2&'4&'8&''$4/&#0%'#' .D<#*$1"&4##0$%(#$'#&(54$$(4"(#'(%"'$((< %812&"(%$.2&*$+#-&'5+"(#$4##0$4$$(4"(#'#89$"("11+1+&"#$ "112&%"#&( 6$# #0&' +4$+ *$ %88,(&%"#$4 # #0$ #+&"2 %,+# + &812$8$(#"#&(#0$+4$+ /01- +*,&

234 ()56'

,474389 :3

;3:

,474 70"

;3: