Ram Chand v. Mangat Pal
!"# #$%&''
& () ' *
!
" # $ %
&&&&& * '
+,- '
% #%
(
)* +, )+'-+. ') )+'/ (%(
(
# # (% (%#%
0
)
%
( #
% 1 2
3 4 $ $ 3 5 0
#
6
#
(
%# ('7% ( 6 )++20
# # *++20
# # (
5 (
)++,
1 0
8 #
# 1 (%
0
% (
( % 8#
(% 0
(%6 #
1 #09
: #
-
',-*
#
# # ## 4 0
+- +* )+'* 3
'+- 4
%
'..) ;',.)
<! #
#
2 %(
% :
* =
# #
(
3
'+- '..)
#
8#
#( > )
):
#
0
%:# # ###
6
#
#
% 1 ( 0
#6 % % 8#
%
# (% 0
?
%
(% 0
# #
( @ > (
# 0
!"" #$%&% '(' &
"*# (%&
)$*%& #"+% +"
'# ,-./012 # $'(% *3#
4(%# 5$ 6
!"" $% #$$& '%7 $#%
#* &* "# +% (%&
%&* 6
5 !"" #* $% )(%(%('6
5 !"" % % *3#
45 #& *$%
#$%&%6 5 !"" $#% $% (& *3 *'
-5-6
5 ' 4
)* +, )+'-
0
(
# # (%
$ "
35 !
+. ') )+'/ - 8
(%
(
#
(
0
#(
8
'+- '..)
% #
(
:
%1 ( # #
% %
%
(
(
6 #
3
'+- '..)
# #
%
% # % # (
# (
( B
+- +* )+'*#
# #(
1
% #
## #(%> )
) / >
0
(
%
# %
#
( #
6
0
(
% # :
# #
# (%
# % 1 C
(
# #
1
( (
% %
(% # %
(% (
#
#
(
(
.
8
0(6 ,
# (
#
%(
(%
0
%1 (
0% 6
( # 0
(
% # (% (
##
( # 0(
#
(% 0
1
# # %
0
B
% # # #( (%
#
$D)
#
%#
: 0% 6 ( #
4
%
%0
# # #
0 E(%
#
( % 1
% ( # '+
( ( (
3
'+- '..)
#
(
1 (
'+- '..)
6
(
# ( (
%
1 (
(%
# (
(
(
4
+- +* )+'* (% 2
2
'+-
'..)
# # #
#
# %
?E '
)
# (
2
%
?E '
(% 1
( %
2
# # #(% AF(
E ;
!
(
%
%
1 % # :
2
#
%
7/7,(
E 0 9
:% * + #$%&% *7" "( $'& % ( # (('(' $$*% +" "
" ('& & # : ()*%# +( % " $(
"(''%7 %('& %) ;* % '*&%7 +%#"$ ##* (#& "%
:%
(# 5(+( ,( # (&"<(
-
% 9= :
-
;*#% (# (# +"" %(% )%(&
&(% +"
$#%#
4" &%&(% &#$ %7 % $'(% && $'
4"# -* "'& &%&(% &# (# (% > ('& ;* % (
9 # (('(' $$*% > +''
&)& "( % +(& 4" ''+%7 5(( & #% ($$# +" "
(&# (# *%&=
4" #%7*'( ;*#% ?()%& $#%
(# +"" %(% )%(&
&(% +"
$#%#
4(%# 5$ 4" $ % &%&(% (&)& +% #()% 4" &%&(% "(# (#& (% #$
> (# ('& % % > (# %('& %) % *%&
#"*'& (#& #$ ('' (%& ( ('#@ '# +''
&)& "( % +(& % " ?## % :
(%% " #(& % $#%
(# #*& (% %)
$ % ?"& (%& $& $'(% (# /? 58 ''
(
#
( %
( ( > )
) % #
3
- ',-*
6
% 1 # E
(%
#(
:#
(
(% 2
#
( # 2
: 3
7 ',-*
%
( (
: # (%> )
)
%(
E
7G- ',-*
# E 0
"# $%"%"# & $ A $#% %'& $####% #$
))(' $$ )( )(%% $&& -& -'
5 &*
'( &$ % # & $A
: (% $#% &#$####& +"* "#
%#% ))(' $$ "+# "(% &*
*# '(+ " (% $#% B"*7"
+") " "(# % $####% (% $#%C
'()%7 "*7"
") )( #* $####% " %+"#(%&%7 (% " ' )( # *$ #* "
#*
D #* *%& "# # #"(''
*7"A
( ( ?$ #?
)%"# &( &#$####%@
(7(%# 1%)%
D ($$('
#"(''
' (% & & $(##& (% #* %#*& *%& "# # % % #"(''
(% + (% #* "
& & (''+&
8
) * )" ) &
$
% ( * &))(") $
"# ) % =
- @! ',-*
#
( %
%
3
- ',-*
#
%(%
% (
% 4
2
1
%1 #
63
- ',-*
# %( (
% (
1
% ') B
(
(
> )
)#
%
#
# (
#
2
% ( (
3
- ',-*
(%
2
#
( %6 %( #
#
( # #(% AF(
E ;' + ) ' ,
-%.$
/
'/!B
,G :'*(
0
D+ +
) )
%%% ($$''(% $#% #* "
& ::
*' -& + ( $'(% )&
'() ' (#& % )7(7 (' #*
D
8
*#' *&% #('#"
"# $'( % ($$''(% 4" ($$''(% "(# %
(& $&* $'(% (' #* #"+ +"( ?( '
(*# $* #* ,(%< #* 4"( $&* $'(&%7# )*#
'( & #%# "# -* 1**?
%7"
E# ,"('('
8 -
(%& 3# ,%7('
!($ F)& E# 3# ,)( !($ (%*( *%7 - ()$@ %
*$$ - C 0) $#% $'(% #$ ('' $((7($"#
" #% ,(%< "(& (' #*& '(% +"
%# "% (# )% #* D '
'()& )% % ;*(' )7(7 :% #* ,(%< ($$(# "( ()$& ? *% %7 )7(7&
$$# #(' 4" ($$''(% "(& > & #* %7 % )7(7 )7(7& $$#
*'& #'& ? *% +"* (% (( ")% 4"( > *$"'& 4" ,(%< " #*%7 % )% )7(7 &$# ' &&# ($$''(%GG
HHH HHH HHH HHH HHH HHH HHH HHH HHH HHH HHH HHH
-%#*% ,% "
"# -* "(# ?$'(%& # $ $'( (#& %
& ::
*' -& 1**?
%7"
E# ,"('('
#*$( : +''
*#*'
;* 2(& % & #%= 2'&=
$'( *%&
& *' -& (#& % ?#% ) $'(&%7
(%% %(%& +"% $'(&%7 % +" "
## "(# % $&* & : "# (#% $'( ( *%&
-&
(% #('#"& %' &%&(% '# &% $'(&%7# $*# #* (%& " $#
* &%
(*# + #*# :% " +&# $'( *%&
-&
(%% )(& * ?
$ % $ $'(% $*# #* '%7 +" "
#(&
( ( !"* $'( %7
* $'(% +" "
"# ( # + (''7& &%&(%
(%% %
* #$ *'( % $ ## &&* +"( "# ( # )7" +"
% '# +" "
+ "%
'()&
% ( # "#
(# "(# "'& $'( ( *%&
-& #"*'& "( % %(%& ( (''
('
* (*# $'(&%7#
'
#* D
+ '& ($$''(% #*$$ "# $'(
:% & $'( ( *%&
-& #"*'& #*
& &%&(% +" (##
$'( )*# )(< *
# %& #* #$ #()
(*# (# % +" "
$*# #* (#&@
#$
(*# $'(% %'& ) "(% % '
%7 "*# %'& ) "(% % ' $'(% +"* '( (%& -* )& #* ' +" "
# %& #* "(& % '&
: % ##( )*'$' (*"# ?
$ % & #%# &()($$( E# (>(#" ()$@
#
9
-
C .( () ()$@ % E# :#"+( -"(%& (%& %
*$$ -
(%& ( ("((#"( (%&@ % E# 3# D(%('
-%#* -)$(% ,)( (%& %
-
"( (& (%& )$"(#I& "# $% $' '* % # 0(
%
% #
(% (
#: (
( '@
%
+7 +@ )+)7 * 6
D
62 25 D
(
25