Executive Engineer, National Highways, (Pwd/ B And R), Nabha Road Patiala v. Mukhtiar Singh And Others

2023:PHHC:141549



    
  CR-6904-2019         

 !"#$$#%!%& Executive Engineer, National Highways, (PWD/B & R), Nabha Road, Patiala.

 



 
 








    '( # )
 *)    



 




 




  
! 



" 


 
# 




$ %

&


$


 
 ' 
 
( )
 #*
+


$ ,-
...
  *) +#,- % /0
"0


 


  

*
'


%%11%,
+

2 
3%%-

*0

42 3 '3  


( 


!
  

42



$ &6&

1%7
  

8  
 
9


 #*


:
" *0

 

3#' 
*


* 


 

* 






3 

 '

" 

61161%

*0





"





%111%

*0
 



 
;


$ 7%

1%





  

8)  
 
9


 #*
 :
 /  0
 


 
&

 
#

 0

*0


3  
 

5 
( 


  

'

*
 

$



1,111%
 1111






 



=

< 


%&,
+  




8%&,

:-

"
*0

" 
%%%%11
" *0

' 
 


 
"


>




/ 
 
 


3 








%&

%&,


" 
'

*


#' 

61161%
 

' 
 

"




'
>


1111?3



* 
"

?*  


2 
>





6 / 
   
" 

" 

*0




* 

 
 

 
;

 
" 
'

*

*0
 
5

%111%
" *0

' 
 

"




%11?3

< 
0 

77111?3



* 


'




2 
61


'
>
 

' 
 
@
   

#' 

%111%
*



A

B* 
2
5 
 " 
 
 
'

*
 ' 



61%1%7
/







 

#' 

%111%


3  
 
42




"



 

*  





 



 

0' ?
 * ' 
*  
 " 




3  
@
42 
5 



%%11%,
 

 

  

*  
 " 





3  
 C'





%%11%,

*0

42 
5 







 

*' 


42 
5 
 


 ' 

 







 


*  


 
 
  






 





*0

 
" 
'
*0

 



 
*0


3  
" 
"


<  



 

 
C
 
 

*' 


'




?*  


*

 
 " 

 

 
*0




 
 



*
 
*0
 0
  
'


'


 
A

*' 


42 
5 
 
 "

 

 
" 
*0




?" 


3  

>


 





5 
  

3   


 
 
5 


6+%-

%&,



*' 


'
 




 

*
 
 



'


" 
"



'
 <  


A
   







*0




" 

61161%


"

 
  


*
'

 
$ 7
%%
 
%




 
*' 



*



*


 0
" 

3  
 '


 



 " 

 



A
 
*' 



 

 

3 '


  

"
 
0
 


*0





'
"
< 

*
' 
*0
"0



0
 
" 
 
" 
 
*

 
 
"
  
 
 /


2'





 

'0
*
  




 


6

%&,


  3 

 

 

!

!" #
$


%
!

!

&
'

!" 
 
 
'


(
 )&
& 

* +

 &
((
,


 




!,-(&
'

(



'

"& (  '

.

'  
& 
  
+
&  

/0

+

!
&
1

"  +
1
 '

,
'
1
 
 "

 
!1



(


!
'

 ((  2
,
"

 
 '0



!
'
1
&
1

"  +


!
'

 ((  2
,
 '

( +
1
 '
-
& 
(
' !


( 0

 +

!
'
1
&
1

"  +


!
'

 ((  2
,
 '

( +
1
 '

 )&

3
4& &(1
'' 


" "1+
!

- (

!!

- (+

1

!+


0

+


)& 
'

 )& '

(
1

 ((  +

" 



!"((




  

"( 
'
&+

 (
5"
'
1
  (

& +


 +

!
'
1


' 
&(
' !
!& '

" '
'

(


!
'

"& (  '

 ( 
& 
  



!
'

 ((  2
,
"

 '

( #


%
  


!,
-(&
'

( +


-
" -  +

 &
((

-1



!

&
( &(



'
(-
"
&!
"
&!

& 
!,
-(&
'



"

!! 



' !


'

"& (  '


'  
& 
  
+
&  

+

" 

'
& 
(



'


'

 ((  



'
,
"

 '

( +
 -

(#

  

#

%

!"&

"
'



&   +
1
" 
" 
&
 

"

 
'



 )& '

(

(
&"

&
'
1
1

4&  1

 
'
1
 &
((

5 (&  #/

%
  


!,
-(&
'

(



-
" -  +

 &
((

-1



&!
'
.1
"
&!/

& 
!,
-(&+


  '


!"&( 1
&
'

)& #6


7#

* 
 

 
 
5 
'

 


*




' 
  
5 
 "
 

'


5 
" 
  
 

' 





*0




" 
 
#

 0
 

'
 <  


D " 
  

  

=   
*0
 

' 

*

  

 '

' 


 
 " 



*  
 
 



5 
'



6+%-

%&,


 

*


#

 0



 

 0

#

 

 
 


5 
 0
 "






=   
"




*  


  # 0



 
8 :
" 
 #

 0
 

<  







' 



*

 
*0


 


 


<  


 

 





8#

 



 


'




 


 




  * 






5



   


 
" 




 
 


*03 "0
"


"



  0
  

'

* 
 
 

"

 
*

 
   
  






*
   

* 


E
>
 
' 
 


 
 
; 

   
"
 


*0



3  

0
" 
   

>
 

' 
 


 
 


' 




" 
"



 
 


*0
* 






C

'


 


" 
>
 
' 

 


 
 
"
 


'   


7
* 



 

 "0
 


 


<  

* 
 

 
 


*03 "0
*






5    *


'
*0



  
$ %


" 
 

 
  3

5555
9
" 
!(1
:


 +
;,
!+
&,
<+
:&
<
+
=&"
<+
( 
<+
:


 +
=&"(
<
>
(
<+
=&!
<
>
<&
<+
?&( 
<

<( 
<+
( -
<

(
(

'-
" 

'

!,
-(&
'

(
 )&


!" '


- 


(
'

" 
 


('


 
'

1"

(

 #6
@


"  
  *
*0
 
5

*0

A

:* 
2
5 
 

* '



*"   

,




 

* 




'

"
'

*0
 
5 
" 
 

#' 

%111%






 
 
" 




*  
 




2 
61


'
>
 

" 
*0





  


'




%111%

*0
 
5 



 
  3
5555
 !


- 
+

(
' 
 &


(1
3@


 +
 






-1
( 
 #



" &(
' 
& (& 

(

 

"

(1
'

 )&
( +

 &

'

-


 &(

4&

 (


8

 @
'

!,
-(&


(






&
'
- 
#
   

     

  !   " 

 

   " 

   "



  

! 

#
=
1
(

 @



&
'
- 

 &(

 ((1
 )&

 &(

!

 
'
4& #
 


 (1#
5555
6
%1
 
 


*


*' 

'

* 


 



"


" 
 
 
"

 
 

 


' 


 




5 

"

 
5 
" 
" 

*


" 
 0








*
 
 0
 
 






  

 
*






" 


"



 
 


*0
0


42 
5 


 


"


# 



  
" 

*  
" 
*0



 
5 




*
 
*0

A

:* 

2
5 
"  
 
* 
 0




 




 


*  
 



 
2 




%% 4< 0
'

 



 

" 

*0





"

#' 

*0
 
5 


'

 


42 
5 
"
 0




'




 0


*

' 

"
" 


<

 
 

 
 
"





42 
5 
 



 


*' 












/3' 
 

0
'


'
 


 0


 
 
# 
* 
 
*

 # 
 
 




 

"
 0



*0

 




  

" 

*0




% "


 
  

'

*



 

 


.

/

.
%6  


+-

 0

 
 +-
  

  !"#$$#%!%&       *)  (
<          F
 
?




G
$ F


* 

G
$