High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6450/2017dismissed

Shimla Devi @ Simla Devi v. Ramesh Devi And Others

2018-08-14Mr. Justice Satpal6 pages

"#$ %$&'(')*

+ ,'-." $/'".'"('-." $/' 00$..")# 1$2(3( "-$(, $/'")%#,$2( $(0)%$)#(

2$($)#* (4"#'5%/&"#$")% 2 ")$#"5%/&"#$ 2#,$"00$..")# 66666

,$0."')#'

7"00$..")#'("882'$/$% #,$93%8-$)#")% %$&2$$ %"#$%

0"(($%:;.$"2)$%'/'. 3%8$ 3)'2 '/'(')5<"2)"."( 4$.. "( #,$ 93%8-$)# ")% %$&2$$ %"#$%

0"(($% :; .$"2)$% %%'#')". '(#2'&# 3%8$5<"2)". ,$ "00$..")# ,"% '.$% " (3'# 2 %$&."2"#') # #,$ $

$&# #,"# (".$ %$$% %"#$% =

= $>$&3#$% :; ,$2 ,3(:")% "#0". ') 2$(0)%$)#(")% '('..$8".5)3..5/'%")%)#:')%')8)#,$2'8,#( #,$ 02$($)# "00$..")# ")% ,$2 ,3(:")% ")%"#2; ')93)&#') %'2$&#')8 #,$ 2$(0)%$)#(")% #,")%/$2#,$/"&")#0(($((')##,$"00$..")# ")%,$2,3(:")%"(4$.."(0$2-")$)#')93)&#')2$(#2"')')8#,$2$(0)%$)#( ")% 2-".'$)"#')8#,$020$2#;')%'(03#$4"((38,# #4"(0.$"%$%#,"#02 2-"%$ $)%")#72$(0)%$)#=?"#0".5 ,3(:")% #,$ 02$($)# "00$..")#5 4"( ") "..##$$ #,$ 0.# -$"(32')8 =

-"2." &-02'($% ') @,"(2" A7 7 ('#3"#$% ') #,$ 2$/$)3$ $(#"#$ 1'.."8$"@,")"5$,('.'.@,$2'5 '(#2'&#<"2)"...#-$)#4"(-"%$##,$ "00$..")#B( ,3(:")% ) A+ :; #,$ 2"- ")&,";"# 1'.."8$ "@,")"5 '(#2'&# <"2)". 3)%$2 #,$

')# 282"--$ /$2)-$)# "2;")")"(0$&'

'&&)%'#')#,"##,$("'%0.#(,"..)#:$".'$)"#$%#"); #,$2 0$2() :; #,$ "..##$$ )2 #,$ ("-$ &") :$ 8' #$% # ");)$ ,$ 4)$2(,'02'8,#(4'..2$-"')4'#,#,$"..##$$'$%$ $)%")#=24'#,,'( .$8".,$'2(')&$A+ #,$"00$..")#")%,$2,3(:")%4$2$')0(($((') #,$ 0.# $(0)%$)# 2$C3$(#$% #,$ "00$..")#B( ,3(:")% # 8'/$ #,$ ":/$("'%0.#)";$"2.;.$"($,$"00$..")#B(,3(:")%"82$$%#$>$&3#$ " 2$8'(#$2$% .$"($ ') %$ $)%")# D (

7? 0$2 -)#, 4$/$25 2$(0)%$)#7%$ $)%")# ') &..3(') 4'#, #,$2 4'#)$(($( ')#>'&"#$%,$2,3(:")%")%3)%$2#,$') .3$)&$ .'C325(".$%$$%%"#$% =

=4"($>$&3#$%:;#,$"00$..")#B(,3(:")%') "/32 2$(0)%$)# ?"-$(, $/'4'

$ 2$(0)%$)# E,$)#,$"00$..")#")%,$2 ,3(:")%%$-")%$%"22$"2( 2$)#"-3)#')8#( =5

7? 2-%$ $)%")# ) A

5,$2$ 3($%)#,$02$#$>##,"#,$,"(:$&-$4)$2 #,$0.#')C3$(#'):;4"; (".$%$$%%"#$%=

=#4"(0.$"%$% #,"# 2"3%4"(&--'##$%30)#,$"00$..")#")%,$2,3(:")%)0."&$ 2$(0)%$)# 5 0,#82"0, ")#,$2 0$2() ,"( :$$) "

'>$% "( 032&,"($2 ) #,$ :"&@('%$ #,$ (".$ %$$% ,$ "00$..")# "( 4$.. "( ,$2 ,3(:")%2$C3$(#$%2$(0)%$)#(")% #8$#&")&$..$%#,$(".$%$$% %"#$%=

=")%,")%/$2#,$/"&")#0(($((') #,$0.#')C3$(#') ##,$0."')#'

:3#2$(0)%$)#(")% 2$ 3($%#%($)&$5#,$(3'# 4"( '.$%

= $(0)%$)#(")% 2$('(#$%#,$(3'#E2'##$)(#"#$-$)#4"(

'.$%#"@')8/"2'3(02$.'-')"2;:9$&#')(/$2-$)#()-$2'#(4$2$%$)'$% # '( (0$&'

'&"..; &)#$)%$% #,"# (".$ %$$% #,$ 020$2#; ') C3$(#') 4"( $>$&3#$% :; "00$..")#B( ,3(:")% ') 2$(0)%$)# 2 &)('%$2"#') ,$ ("'% 020$2#; 4"( 8'/$) :; 2$(0)%$)#( ")% # )$ #,$'2 &.($ 2$."#'/$ )"-$.; 8')%$2 ')8,5 4, 4"( 23))')8 " 3)'# 3)%$2#,$)"-$")%(#;.$ ,2$$"-#$$.E2@(".)84'#,":2#,$2 2$(0)%$)# .$&#2'&'#;&))$&#')4"(".(8#')(#"..$%')#,$)"-$ 2$(0)%$)# #'((0$&'

'&"..;%$)'$%#,"##,$020$2#;')C3$(#')4"( $/$2.$"($%3#"##,$2"#$ (

7?0$2-)#,#4"(&)#$)%$%#,"##,$ "00$..")#B(,3(:")%"#0".4"('))$$% -)$; 2,'(%-$(#'&0320($(5 #,$2$ 2$5#,$020$2#;')C3$(#')4"((.%#%$ $)%")# 2"/".3":.$ &)('%$2"#') (+5

7? '(-'((". #,$ (3'# 4"( 02";$% 2 :; 2$(0)%$)#(")%

2-#,$0.$"%')8( #,$0"2#'$(5 ..4')8'((3$(4$2$ 2"-$%*? E,$#,$2#,$0."')#'

'($)#'#.$% 2"%$&2$$ 2%$&."2"#')")% -")%"#2; ')93)&#') 4'#, &)($C3$)#'". 2$.'$ 0$2-")$)# ')93)&#')"(02";$% 2F

E,$#,$2#,$(3'# #,$0."')#'

'()#-"')#"')":.$F = E,$#,$2#,$0."')#'

,"(8#).&3(?(#")%'"(4$.."(&"3($ "&#')# '.$")%-"')#"')#,$02$($)#(3'#F E,$#,$2#,$0."')#'

'((#00$% 2- '.')8#,$02$($)#(3'#:;,$2 4)"&#")%&)%3&#F

E,$#,$2#,$(3'# #,$0."')#'

'(:"% 2-'(?9')%$2")%))?

9')%$2 )$&$(("2;")%020$20"2#'$(F

E,$#,$2#,$0."')#'

,"((3002$(($%#,$#23$")%-"#$2'". "&#(

2-#,$&32#F $.'$ G$"2)$% #2'". 32# ) &)('%$2"#') #,$ "&#( ")% &'2&3-(#")&$(5%$&'%$%'((3$') "/32 %$ $)%")#(72$(0)%$)#( ")% ")%"8"')(##,$"00$..")#((3$( #4$2$".(%$&'%$%') "/32 2$(0)%$)#( ")% "( 4$.. 3'# '.$% :; #,$ "00$..")#70."')#'

4"( "&&2%')8.;%'(-'(($% 00$".02$ $22$%:;#,$"00$..")#4"(".(%'(-'(($%:;.$"2)$% %%'#')". '(#2'&# 3%8$5 <"2)".5 /'%$ 93%8-$)# ")% %$&2$$ %"#$%

882'$/$%#,$2$?

2-502$($)#"00$".,"(:$$) '.$% G$"2)$% &3)($. 2 #,$ "00$..")# /$,$-$)#.; "283$( #,"# #,$ (".$ %$$% %"#$% =

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

($# 30 :; #,$ "00$..")#70."')#'

'( #,"# #,$ (".$ %$$% 4"( $>$&3#$% ') "

2"3%3.$)#-"))$24,$),$2,3(:")%4"(')")')#>'&"#$%(#"#$,$2$'( ')%$$%)#")'#" $/'%$)&$#(3:(#")#'"#$(3&,"0.$",$(".$%$$%') C3$(#') 4"( $>$&3#$% ) =

= ,$ 02$($)# (3'# 4"( '.$% )

:; #,$ "00$..")#5 4, '( #,$ 4'

$ #,$ /$)%2 ,$2$ '( ) $>0.")"#') 4,"#($/$2 "( # 4,; ) "&#') 4"( #"@$) %32')8 #,$ ')#$22$8)3- .$" #,$ "00$..")# #,"# #,$ 0.# ') C3$(#') 4"( 8'/$) ) .$"($ # 2$(0)%$)#( ")% ')

=5 #,$; (#00$% 0";')8 #,$ 2$)# ')

")% #,$ 02$($)# "00$..")# ")% ,$2 ,3(:")% "(@$% 2 #,$ "22$"2( ')

5 ) 4,'&, #,$; &"-$ # @)4 #,$ (".$ %$$% %"#$% =

= '( 0".0":.;')&22$&#")%3)(3:(#")#'"#$%#'(#:$)#'&$%"##,'((#"8$#,"# 42'##$)(#"#$-$)#4"()# '.$%:;2$(0)%$)#=?"#0".")%)$'#,$2%'%,$ "00$"2:$ 2$#,$.$"2)$%#2'".32#$4"(02&$$%$%"8"')(#$>0"2#$:3# ,$ "00$"2$% "( # (3002# #,$ &"($ #,$ "00$..")#70."')#'

'( "

'%"/'# 4"( 0."&$% ) 2$&2% "( > 7 $(#'-); #,'( 4'#)$(( '( $>#2$-$.;2$.$/")# (0$&'

'&"..;"%-'##$%#,$2$&$'0# (+5

7? 2- 2$(0)%$)#$ 32#,$2"%-'##$%#,$$>$&3#') #,$(".$%$$%') "/32 2$(0)%$)#"

#$22$&$'/')8/".'%(".$&)('%$2"#')#'((0$&' '&"..; :($2/$%:;#,$.$"2)$%#2'".32##,"# ,"()#3##$2$%"42%')2$8"2% # #,$ 2"3% "..$8$%.; &--'##$% :; 2$(0)%$)#( ")% %$)'$% #,"#,$3($%##"@$.'C32 # '( )# %$)'$% #,"# 2$(0)%$)#( ")% ,"% 2"'($% &)(#23&#')/$2#,$0.#')C3$(#').$&#2'&'#;&))$&#') 2#,$0320($ &"22;')8#,$'2 '2-7(,2'"-#$$.E2@(4"(:#"')$%,$"00$..")# ")% ,$2 ,3(:")% 4$2$5 )$$%.$(( # (";5 "4"2$ #,$ "&#3". 0('#') 283-$)#):$,".

#,$"00$..")##,"#')/'$4 #,$(0$&'

'&&)%'#')

#,$"..#-$)#5(".$%$$%&3.%)#,"/$:$$)$>$&3#$%'("823)%4,'&,'( )#"/"'.":.$#,$2')");('#3"#') "#"..5'#'( 2#,$&)&$2)$%"3#,2'#'$( # #"@$ )$&$(("2; "&#') "8"')(# #,$ "00$..")#B( ,3(:")% ")% &)&$2)$% 0$2()(4$/$25)2'8,#4,"#($/$2"&&23$(##,$"00$..")##&,"..$)8$ #,$ (".$ %$$% %"#$% =

= ,$2$ 2$5 % )# ')% "); -$2'# ') #,$ "283-$)#(2"'($%):$,".

#,$"00$..")# #,$2"283-$)#,"(:$$)2"'($% G$"2)$%&3)($. 2#,$"00$..")#?0."')#'

'(3)":.$#0')#3# "); C3$(#') ."4 -3&, .$(( (3:(#")#'". C3$(#') ."4 4,'&, -"; :$ ')/./$% 2&)('%$2"#')')#,'(2$83."2($&)%"00$".#,#,$'-038)$% 93%8$-$)#("2$4$..2$"()$%93%8$-$)#(2$)%$2$%" #$2020$2"002$&'"#') ")%&)('%$2"#') #,$$/'%$)&$)2$&2% <$$0')8 ') /'$4 #,$ "&#( ")% &'2&3-(#")&$( "( %'(&3(($% ":/$5 % )# ')% "); ') '2-'#;5 '..$8".'#; 2 0$2/$2('#; ') #,$ '-038)$% 93%8-$)#( ")% %$&2$$( %"#$%

")%

0"(($% :; #,$ .$"2)$% '/'. 3%8$ 2 '/'(')5 <"2)". ")% .$"2)$% %%'#')". '(#2'&#

3%8$5<"2)".52$(0$&#'/$.;54,'&,4"22")#");')#$2 $2$)&$:;#,'(32#

2$($)#"00$".'(5&)($C3$)#.;5%'(-'(($%4'#,)2%$2"(# &(#(

! (,4"2 "#$ #$%&$'()*+%$',*$-./$+ , "#$ #$%%$&,% '01$./$+ ,