High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/601/2018dismissed

Gurcharan Singh v. Jasbir Singh And Others

2018-02-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan8 pages

!"#$%& ""'

&%%! !"#$%&" #"'!#$%# #( ")!#$% (( ***** "'

&%%!(# + , " ( (( - #"%# ," %% "#", %## - + - & &- " " # - % ", / (( "% #%# (# - ' )&"# !"&"

&#"'"#- " + $"# #,' ##%## 0

0#(( ( #- %%

( ""

#"# "# &"##"" 1""%2 #,!3 #" %", ,#% "#('" %" - % "'","' -4% "$&"(" 56 7869:

##567880; &' ",:;

< ##("%#" " ( ! " # 2" #! 3 #" -" ,' 4%, ##

= &" $' # # $ ",! " " " "# (( > % ,# #% (#"%"$" "

## ; :" # # = -", " , ! # $"# # # # '"("! ! -"#", ( ", ( ""

% ,-#"%#," ####

;;

4% # - #%# 3%' &"

", " # # #9-",$")

# :0 "(% ( ",9: < #% 8 " $#

=! ' 3%' 4%,#(( ",:;

< #" - # &" ( ""

" " # ' 0 < #%'("#")=9 ;@

!=9; @

!>#-

" #$" ,A "#!&"$2",3 #"$"# ,' 4%,##

=" #'

#&,"$- ( ""

'3%' & " 4%, & ! ( "% % (" (" ",= < # :;

< # & ,"$- '3%' ( ""

&A( ""

& # "#",""#("&"" '"

#'"",(" (&"%% (" 8&

,#' 3%' # -#& #-" # "B ( " " "

"' ", # ' 3%' #"#

0 0 ;;

# ;

;;

!(%"$ # '3%'

!( ""

&#'"#- " # # (&"% "%% (" # #: A -'""'#- % (( " + - &

# ( ,' 4%, ('" ' " ,"# #% '! ! " #'""- "$"#%8", #&"$'%" "#", + " ($ # " "

((%" %"

A ( %!

!"(( "%- "

-! ! " < "' " & ((" " #" --4%,#- & ,"##% ' 8##""!"", #" -! 4%, &#- # "$ (" "

"%" &"( 4%,# ((" 8 (( " %"! # #,' (# - " +

"# # $"

% &'()*(+ *,+-)'! ##./"

#"" #.%&''0*&+ *,+10&%2

$3#,

#4 #."5%&''6*(+ *,+-'1% #7#

## 3#, # #$"

% (881*6+ )'% #7#2##$"

#/" ##$"

%(88'*(+ &8'% #

#/" %&'((*&+ *,+&0)## ##"

$ 3

#$"

##$"

% $&'(6 $9(8-:%5$')'&&'(0 A%- #"( - #(""" & " -!%"

A ( %!

"(( "%- C< "( #,'## - " + -%) ' ;:9! 4%, % ( # &" # "$ (" 4%,#(( "$ "# - & 4%, 8 % #! (( ( ## 4%, % ( # &" # "$ (" ,# 4%,# ((" % ! "# ( ,' 4%, ##

=4% #-&'3%' #.

% ",(( " 5 #$", -'""'#- % (( !""% 4'",' 4%, "# (- (( #-" "% "'"," #

= " " %"- ","##% + #& ## 4% #- '3%' " # # = ,' 4%, - ')# C4 A #% '"" -"- " ""C, "# &6 DA 8! 3%' &"

", 1 ",! "# 56

69:

! 2" #! 3 #"! ' 4% ",' 4%,A8'& "(" > 56

69:

!2" #!3 #"! &"%":;

< ##- #" #6 C ,# % % E ' # .

"",% 2" #A# 8!&" &" # "

! $ 4% # " ,' 4%, " " (( ' 0 < # " # A "#! & "$" ,! #"%'("#" =9 ;@

#=9; @

! >#- #&!.

%", ", 1 ", $ ) (" -$'"#(( ,. & $"#$"): ## ; 9 ;:0#&$( ' ",'8 " -$'"# % %# 9:

!' ",:;

< #!'( &"% " $% # ( % %#! & ' -%$# ' 0 < #A("% -((""' ,8#' -# ", "$!&&" "##%" %"$ "# ( 5 ! ' # &#! % ", ", -%' & " (" " (( .

% ", " # " (" = < ##"#",A !" 4%, ## - %"-# # 8 $ ((## ' ", ",##'"",'%%

"( 1#

@ ;@ = C4%

#@63%' "( -" #@6.

%", E" #@65 -"","" '",""!@ :;0@;! #( "!3 #"8C, " E" #@6 )

' > ! 5"' # 8 C, "F A + " (( " (

#,' #! < # 6

8& #- ( %'" , ,'C4 "-",% "'#4%,##!- "

% " " ##! -% %"#" # 0 < #-)"%% ("%

A"("" % " "

"# ' % ,' C4 " ! &" " - %## #' 0 < #- ## %"#"- #- 3%' #

-# ",$!"%'"$"#% % ", E6 ("# ' 0 @6 ,"(( !&"%'$ "' @6A !#% '%"#",- ##!&< "#-,"#F ( " # %

#", "# 4% ' ,' 4%,')"$"#(" #'

#" #A "#! &"$2", #"%'("#")=9 ;@

!=9; @

!>#- &) ,. & $"#$"): ##

; 9 ;:0# ",'!' -(- '8" % &#(' ",((

#C$""% &#- &'((

#& #8" % 'C4 " & ". & $"#$")## ; 9 ;:0 & 4% # >&$! " % " (%#", " ,#(( #!& & 4% # " ", 1 ",! ( ""

@(( .

% ", $ ! " -%' - "# ("" % .

% ", & & (( ##,' 4%, &4% #

=8"' %'')& #,"

%",&& # " = (( # # #! & ("-" " #-",4%,#&" ! #'"# ! &# - ' 3%' A #% 'C4 %" #%# (%" 4%, -& (( # ' 3%' ! ! " % - '#'' 4%,%#",(%"A" % "

"%" , ( (( , ,' 4%, C4 ! (( # ' 3%' 4%,# &"( ((" " (%"$ &"( % ( # &" # "$ (" (( (( !(& "(% (( #&,"$ ",! (( # ",-" "#(& # (( ' 0 < # 8#"( - ! ", " ("$ ,' 4%, ",& # # #(( - (( -"," !& & " &"'3%' ",'

4%,< " "

# # # - ", -" & 4% #- (( 8%% #", " ,'!" , &'3%' # -# ", "$! &" "##%" %"$ (",- '3%' %" #-"(" -" ,#"% (" (" #% &"", %"$ (A" % ,( (( -" ,' 4%,! (" & # "$#- '3%' .

%",8& # ##"#% 'C4 !" %.

%", " # "(" = < ##"#",?" ! % = < # " < "

"# - &# D " (( F%# !"

" !&"# "$ (""

%",& # "("A-",! ( (( (" ( & # "$# "' # ,' 4%, " '"%%"$# # "- -%# A (( + # (( " # ## % $"#% ($ " (" A " $ %%(# (( - " # #'

% ( ' "'% ! $ ((#% # #&",#%"( - ' B# ' , !(( '"- " #($ & $ "# 4%, -& "' # ' 3%' ! &" & G# %"% '%!

(( % #"$ #$, #% ' C4 % "' "' -& 8(( #' 3%' ( (# " "B#

#-"# #! ,# (( # (%# #& "##- # %"#" "

%",A#% '"< "!-!%-"# -,' ##-,(%"

"% %#" %%#%&" &- )",% ((("(%#",A (( & # %'( &, "'(" -"# &"( - & 4%, -" ,'##

=(( %% "'"' - & - & 4%,-" ,' C4 !"+ #,"< "&"#% ' < "#,""&#'""- "$"#%%A" " & #-%"##- "+ "((("(%#", "%#% '%@4", "",""''$- (( $ ' @6! & " < " ,"" &" " $"& ($"" %" : # =; ,""%! ("-"# ? ,",!(( " #"%%#", #"'"#" "'"#%

()%&'(- * 2 3+ H1.

"I E()",@#

@ E(-