← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6043/2018dismissed

M/S H.S. Oberoi Buildtech P Ltd v. M/S Enessco Enterprises

2018-12-07Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

  



      

 

  !"# $%   & !'(#()*+*",   -+ $.(/*0*1#'()23'# 455(11!"' 6(/+0+ -+ "(++) "'(/5/*+(+ 4(+5"#("'   , 73 $ 

$83 /(+("', /!1/!9/!+2!/:#;)!'(/'2(!55(11!"' <<<   

  11=(#!+5/!>(#/(*)*(")>*" 0/'((*+!11=(#'.( 9!#(?#

 @A (?01!/$()"#55(!12!+.(("*1(#!?!*"+''2(B0#?9("'!"# #()/(( #!'(#   5!++(# .> '2( 1(!/"(# *;*1 0#?( / *;:

2!"#*?!/2!+052(1#.>'2(1(!/"(###*'*"!1*+'/*)'0#?(: 2!"#*?!/2 ;*#(B0#?9("'!"##()/((#!'(#     @ A /*(!)'+'2()!+(1(!#*"?''2(*1*"?'2(*"+'!"'!55(!1 !/('2!''2(!55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">0"#(/'C)"'/!)'0!1B.!'+*'( 

: !/C:D*+2!"?!/2!"#("?!?(#'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9/ (E()0'*"+9(B.++0)2!+=/C!"#'2(/B.+!"#9!#(!#;!")(

 5!>9("'  +::-  '2/0?2 )2(F0(  2(/(!'(/: '2( !55(11!"'- #(("#!"'

95!">C(5'"9!C*"?5!/'5!>9("'+"*'+/0""*"?!))0"' =*'2 '2( /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 .0' #*# "' 9!C( 5!>9("'  + :G:% -  #(+5*'( /(5(!'(# /(F0(+'+  '2( /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9: =2(/(05" /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 +("' ! 1(?!1 "'*)( '2/0?2 5+' " %  .0''2(+!9(=!+0"#(1*;(/(#=*'2'2(/(5/'20+(1)C(# +' )5>  1(?!1 "'*)( #!'(#  %   =!+ !1+ +("' .> '2( */9'2/0?2(9!*1''2(!55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!"> .0' #(+5*'( 9!"> ;*+*'+ ' '2( *)(  '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">: '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!"> #*# "' .'2(/ ' +(''1( '2( !))0"' !"# !*1(#')1(!/'2(0'+'!"#*"?5!>9("'+1(!#*"?''2(*"+'*'0'*"'2(+0*' .>'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 @ A 2(+0*'*1(#.>'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9=!+#()/((#!"# '2( /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 =!+ 2(1# ("'*'1(# ' /();(/ + :G:% - !1"? =*'2 *"'(/(+' H I 5(/ !""09 =*'2 (()' /9 G%  05'

   !"#0/'2(/0'0/(*"'(/(+'HI5(/!""09/9 '2( #!'(  B0#?9("' '*11 /(!1*J!'*"  '2( 5/*")*5!1 !90"' *( +

:G:% -  @%A 55(!1 *1(# .> '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!"> =!+ #*+9*++(# .> '2( 1(!/"(# ##*'*"!1 *+'/*)' 0#?(: 2!"#*?!/2 ;*#( B0#?9("'!"##()/((#!'(#     @KA 3(!/"(# )0"+(1 / '2(

95!"> )"'("#(#'2!''2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */92!#"'.(("!.1('5/;('2!' =/C=!+)!//*(#0'!''2(+*'(:'2(/(/(:'2(!55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!"> =!+0"#(/"1*!.*1*'>'9!C(5!>9("''2(!90"')1!*9(# @A #9*''(#1>: '2( /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 (E()0'(# '2( =/C !++*?"(#'*'!"#/!*+(#.*11+/!+09+ : K:% - 11'2(.*11+/!*+(#

 .>'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9=(/(#01>+*?"(#.>'2(/B()'!"!?(/ '2(!55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">"!9(1>$2/!;((" */'((!'(/'!C*"? 9(!+0/(9("'!'+*'('2/0?2$220'':!=/C(/=2(E()0'(#B./ '2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9(+*#(+:!55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">9!#( 5!/' 5!>9("' ' '2( '0"(  +%:

K:-  '*11  %  =2(/(05" !" !90"'  + :G:% -  /(9!*"(# 0'+'!"#*"? !?!*"+' '2( !55(11!"'- #(("#!"'

95!">

=(;(/: #(+5*'( /(5(!'(# /(F0(+'+  '2( */9: '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!"> #*# "' 9!C( 5!>9("'  '2( .!1!")( !90"' =2(/(05" '2( /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 =!+ )"+'/!*"(# ' *++0( ! 1(?!1 "'*)( #!'(# %    ' '2(

95!">.0''2(+!9(=!+/()(*;(#.!)C0"#(1*;(/(#: '2(/(05"'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9=!+/)(#'+("#!+')5> 1(?!1 "'*)( #!'(#  %   '2/0?2 (9!*1 ' '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!"> .0' '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!"> #*# "' 9!C( 5!>9("'  '2(0'+'!"#*"?!90"' @A 1'20?2 '2( +'!/ !/?09("'  '2( 1(!/"(# )0"+(1 / '2(

95!"> *+ '2!' '2( /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 2!# "' .(("!.1('5/;('2((E()0'*"'2(=/C!'+*'(:>(''2(!)'/(9!*"+'2!' '2(.*11+/!*+(#.>'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9"'2(!55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">=(/(#01>!)C"=1(#?(#!''2(+*'(.>*'+/B()'!"!?(/"!9(1> $2 /!;((" */'(( !'(/ '!C*"? 9(!+0/(9("' !' +*'( '2/0?2 $2  20'':!=/C(/=2(E()0'(#B./'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 20+: '2(.*11+/!*+(#.>'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9''2(!55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">=(/(!)C"=1(#?(#.>'2(/B()'!"!?(/""((1+('2!"'2(

95!">  " '2( )"'/!/>: '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">2!+"'.(("!.1('/((/'!">(;*#(")(=2!'+(;(/'+2='2!' '2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9)01#"')951('('2(=/C)!//*(#0'!''2(

+*'(: 2=(;(/: '2( !)' /(9!*"+: * '2( /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 2!# "' )!//*(# 0' '2( =/C !' '2( +*'( '2(" '2(/( *+ " /(!+" / '2( /B()' !"!?(/  '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!"> ' 2!;( !)C"=1(#?(# '2( .*11+/!*+(#.>'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9(+*#(+:"'2*"?=!+=/*''(" "'2(.*11+'2!''2(+!9(=!++0.B()'';(/**)!'*""/=!+'2(/()(*5' '2( .*11+ !)C"=1(#?(# .> '2( /B()' !"!?(/ 0"#(/ +9( /(+(/;!'*" /(;(/: " (;*#(")( 2!+ .((" /((//(# ' .> 1(!/"(# )0"+(1 / '2(

95!"> ' +2= '2!' !"> (/' =!+ 9!#( .> '2(

95!"> ' )"'!)' '2( /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 ' /(+1;('2(#*+50'(/(?!/#*"?0"5!*#.*11+#(+5*'(:*'.(*"?!#9*''(#5+*'*" '2!' 1(?!1 "'*)( =!+ +(/;(# .> '2( /(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9 " '2(

95!"> '2/0?2 (9!*1 )!11*"? 05" *' ' 5!> '2( 0'+'!"#*"? !90"'  '2( .*11+  =(;(/: '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!"> 9!*"'!*"(# ! +'*) +*1(")( *" '2( 9!''(/ !"# #*# "' ?*;( !"> /(+5"+(=2!'+(;(/''2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9"/+("'!">/(51>' '2( "'*)(L "/ 2!+ !"> (;*#(")( =2!'+(;(/ .((" /((//(# ' .> 1(!/"(# )0"+(1 / '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"' ' +2= '2!' '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">(;(/!55/!)2(#'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9/;(/**)!'*" '2(.*11+/!*+(#.>'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9"'2()*/)09+'!")(+:'2( (E()0'*"=/C.>'2(/(+5"#("'-51!*"'* */9!'+*'(/=2*)2*'2!# *++0(#.*11+''2(!55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">=2*)2=(/(!)C"=1(#?(# .> *'+ /B()' !"!?(/ !' +*'( +'!"#+ 5/;(# !+ !1+ '2!' =2(" '2(

95!"> !*1(# ' 5!> '2( 0'+'!"#*"? !90"': '2( */9 *++0(# 1(?!1 "'*)( .0' '2( !55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">#*#"'/(51>''2(+!9( 2(!55(11!"'-#(("#!"'

95!">2!+ !*1(# ' /((/ ' !"> (;*#(")( ' +2= '2!' '2( )1!*9  '2(

*/9 *+ !1+( / '2!' '2( =/C !11''(# ' '2( */9=!+"'(E()0'(#'*'++!'*+!)'*" @ A "'2()*/)09+'!")(+:*"#"*"*/9*'>=*'2'2(=(11 /(!+"(# B0#?9("'+  '2( 0/'+ .(1=   +0.+'!"'*!1 F0(+'*"  1!= !/*+(+ 55(!1*+.(/('9(/*'!"#*+:!))/#*"?1>:#*+9*++(#*"1*9*"( $8!1*! 0#?(    !9*'  82('2(/+5(!C*"?-/(!+"(# , (+-  82('2(//(5/'!.1( , (+-