Somnath v. Jagdish Lal Chopra
!
"
""
#$% &'
%(")"&* + ,, + - . ,
/0 1.
!
"
# ! , /0 1.
. 44
"* &, &'
$
!"
!%&%"
" !
"!"
$"'($ )" !! $
* +
!,! $
#$""
,
$"'($ ) " !! $
! &, &'
This judgment shall dispose of the aforesaid two appeals, for, the issue arising in both the appeal is the same. The facts are being derived from RSA No.6065 of 2018.
These are plaintiff's second appeals. The suit for permanent injunction filed by the plaintiff was dismissed and the counter claim filed by the defendant was allowed by the the Court of learned Civil Judge (Junior Division), Jalandhar vide judgment and decree dated 08.05.2017. The plaintiff then filed two appeals, one against the dismissal of the suit and the other against the counter claim having been allowed which were also dismissed by the Court of learned Additional District Judge, Jalandhar vide judgment and decree dated 17.10.2017 leading to the filing of the afore-titled two regular second appeals.
- + .
"! !
!
$
# "
'
""01"
"
2! "
0 1 " ,
.
3 4
,!
""!!
"
"
,!,!
#
5!
"
"" !
,
""
!$
6( 67 %88& ! #$
"" ,!), ,
!
5
$. .
,!! #$
"" ! ! * :
,!! " %& 0 ,! ,
1 /, "
, ! #$
"
6( 67 %88& / ,
,!,,
,!
""," 5!
"
"";, ,!! . .
5 ,"
" "
, !
" "
,
6( 67 %88& $ ! ! "
, #
<
/
""!! ,
"
"
,!
"" "
, ",! ,"
& ,
#$ "
= , !
$#2 ! < # # # #" )2 " !
$ ! "! ! , >
!"!,.
, !
"
%& ! ,
6( 67 %88& =,
#
$ "
5!
"
"" , " .
=
! ,
,
, ! !
,
.$2! !
""
,
$!! #$ / ! !
, #$
""#$"
$ ?
+
" "
, ,
" #$ )
!
"
# #
$
%
&
'
(
)
* +
(
! !
suit filed by the plaintiff and decreed/allowed the counter claim filed by the defendant. Two
"
#$
""# !,
" " !
!
"#$ "#%&
'
'
&
(
) *
'
+
,(!
"#$
'
,(!
%-., / ', *
$
'0
"#%&
"#%&
"#%& "#$
.
'
1
' '
' '
'
,,
/0 1.
@
.; ; Whether Reportable Yes/No