M/S Kanav Rice Mills v. State Of Punjab And Others


 
 

   
  

  



 

 

   





! "  #


 !"

# 


 $

 $" % &  '"  ' %&    "#

 # %& &(%

! () *"% &  '" + *"(%&    "#

 " # *"%&     ,-(&.-



 $   /"# '#

"!   &

0

1 " $



.

2 * " *    3

4
35 

 4
5 #  !6 "  &  $ ))  &## &"

6 #6%   * "   # 6  #


)

 .

!%"" ) !67,8%

'""& "/"#


) **  " !  ) *# 6 " ##  "

!$ )

6 "2 

4 "

$

5   # 6/"& ))

  "  "#


)    ""#


)  

!

  ))    # 6 ) *  *





""& %! * "7,8

*" #


)%

*'"9 ")" !

)  !6"

!

* : 8.-   09

*  

 ;3% ;

% ;09% ;1%  
: .

$  

 1% 9%  %  4 5  "

 

$ #

&%399* *2!

*! # 6  # 

%!

 * 

*   &**  *  "   

 "  & $ ))%")'2 # ##!6"#


)

'" ")/"&##&"

6

2  " )  " 



 " 

 "  &  $ ))   *" # 6'  %"

  6 "## 4#

" 5  

) ! )  "  # * 6 ") "   " .'  " ""#


)  

!   /" 

*'* ##

$1%945 "$

<#

"* '  *"%'"

* #

   ")      



%"&##&"

6  "  # !6"& )) ; .  " "

 

%   *)  '     !' ,- , "#


 &   "    *) % " #


) '   # 6 '*" * ;/!6 ,- ,  "##  ) *& '  

 

 

 " % "  & $ )) " # 6 )  #

 " *   /" #


) #    "    )) 

 


 ## "  " &$ *  "  

  /"  & $ ))     3

 )6  " # 6 "## * "  

'  %

= '"""  '#

"!    /")'2 # " *!6"$ 

9

  " 

   " #

 !)  "   "  #

6% #)  8

   $% ##   $

) &

! ' >   " )% " #


) "

  ## !  ") &   *6% " # ##     " !  # 



*   *"#6 "#


)  "

    

 /"    #  !6 "  # 6 " ! 2

   0  $"  %     $

   !6    ' % &   ## *   " #


) '

  

  " 6'" 8.-   09

'* !6"#)

*  *  &  ) +   " )% "  & ))  

 )) *)  !   !' "#


) "# * 6& ##'  !  "  % 8

% $ ##   $

) &%

!% '"

!   * #

    

  *     $ ) "



""##  ! ' %

 " ## % " '

 )     6  "  # * .* ""'

* #

$9 " $

'"# *")#*    %")"! # '"

2 * 

""#


)# 7,8 # # & %! *%"  6?  #

;


'  &  6 4

&5  '  "  *    "

>

     "'%'"

  # /" 

&%'"""!    ) *  ) # * " 

")%

!*

  

 # 6 " #


) /"   !    * "    " &  )+   



"

&    #+ 

## #%" %" "

 !   1 @   $

## * "#


)'

 6 #

"

&? !6& %'"" 6"

># +        ) * " #


)  " 

 !       #



7* ""'

* #

 $9 45 $

.* ""6 %'" " &  $ )) "     % " &## &"

6 "  *

   "     '"" "      # 6 '   

 ")#*     "& )) ' ."* ") & '

 

  "#


) ) # 6%#6'" " #


)  #!  # ) *  #  " 

   *# 6

) 9



%() *"%   $

 !6 + *"(%&  ## * "#

") 6

##  "'#

!6

 *"")"! 

     "



"!  "$945 $

 

#) 6  6"

   )%'"



# ""

 " .* "" #

' &  6    #+ 

 



'"$


 945 "$

 ## '   6 !*

6 ""

  # )

 6 "#

. * "")"!  !6&  "   #6

 7,8   

" # %'" !) *" #+ 

# ""

    %"# '   6  

"!   "  ) *"#


)."* "$ 45 "  # 6  A* #B   6 #" %" " ) '

  !        # 6  8"%  # " *    

 

    !
 45  $ 0  #     * 6%"& ))  ) 



"" ) # 6    )%  !)  &$ 

 

.

"# % " !  !6 ,- , *  * & ) + " %     #   " % "* * ")   3 . " "     

   " #   " #  " ##!

2  @   $

 "#

"2  *" ) $0  $

   * "

 " 7,8   %"  !   # 6 !  

" )   ""# 6)  )    "  #

 8

$ # 

.

/"  '  !) !6# *  &$ 

 

    ) # 6 "  )!=  "  8 "2 #

%" '

'2

'

0
 "" "7,8

*"#


)"!

)     8..

6 %& %" "   # 6 "!       " # '    6   !6"

#!  

$945 " $

  /"$ )

6 

 )#" 

) '" %)


 
  "! #6    $ 45% 45 4'5#6$0 "  # 6#"#     * 6 $ 9  !

 '"

         *)  !' #  * 6   " )  /"      #



## * "##   
 




      

 

 

  

  

   

     





  

  

    !"    

 

 

    

  

 

        !#$%    

 

          

  

   

&

 
' 

  



  







     

 

        



 

   

 



 

  





  

    

 & 

  

 

     

 

1


              

!#$%&


(

      

 )  





 



*  !   (  +  ' 

'   

   

  

     

       

 
 

     

 

     

 

  ,&

-. / 

 

      

 

    

 ,   

   



 

0   





#%  

   1

"0 &  &

+ #%      )  

   

 

  0   &

/





#%  

         

  

       $2 

1

"0 && /

  

  

      #%





0     

 $2&

/

  #%         



   



     $2 

.        &

3 /

      



    

   

 * !   &

/

 

!    

% 

+ 

2    

9
  

  !       

 

  (   

  +   2 

 



 

  



 4



!       (   + &

5 

 

(  

   

       

    



   

&

+  







     

!       (   +   



 

  

      

 0



   (&

+

   (     

      

       

 0 &

3 /



  

 # 



  

 













      &

+ ! 

# 

  



  

 

      

    



 &

+   !  # 

 

  

            

      &

+ (  

  



     &

6 !#   

     &7

  /"

  # "? ""#

)'    # 6    *)    

 )   ! ?  !'  " #


)   " #  * 6  /" *) )     " &## &"

6    "    "

3
 & ))%'""   # 6 "#


)

 " *

 "   8. -    09

 ' *  *  " )  /" &## &"

6  " !   *

#

 "  " #   *      " 8. '

  "

!

"     *6 "   " & ))."""*) '   !" # 6

' *" !  

 &  )+ & ##" *"%#

6 )%"  ?   #

'  &  6      "' # +      )     "



    " #6    7,8  &#$

% )

    

6# 6/")
      $ 45%'""  "  )% '"

 "      "   ) ))  



# 6     "#)  )) *!6" #   "# 6  '"

 "

 '" 6 "# *  &8$ "# 6      " "  "# 6.

" ! * %$1'

 # "! 

# 6 ; @  

##

!" "#


"

! ! # "" 

 6!
 $1 "

6 "#


)   )#6'") 





 6*)     "# 6  %"

* # # * !'       6 " # * 6  &

 %

 * #   * "!     # " !

) #   * "  '%/!

 


 6 "  ) !'  " #

  #  * 6        





 "   6 " #  )) *# 6/" % "#


)"

!    %)*

8.* " 7,8  #  

 !  *

      

 # 6  /" *

 "8."& 

*'" ")'      2!

* !  # 6    # 

% !

  *%'""

!"  !#   *  6$ ) 

6/"

 # #   *%     6  '" $ ) 

6   #  6% " % " *)  *" ! "

"* #!' " ) # * 6 % # 6 !  % '"

6  /")''2 !6"&##&"

6% '" * "  # !6"& ))  *  )) *) ! *   !' ") "# * 6&" % '

"'"

 "   "&##&"

6  



 !  

" *  "##  @   $

## * "#

" * )#"

 " 

    

% "

 "  " !  % " 

 )#  #

    "#


)   "*  '

 !  C?"= # 6" !)        #

  8$. .  *  " " # # '   6 

  #! ) $945 $

  &    $ 9 45  " $

 6 #" ) !6   6"

 %" *  '


 " !#

!  !*

! "*)  /"# '   6 "##  

*) !*

6 """

  # )

 

   /  # '   6 6#

"" """

   # " )

   " # 

/" #

' &  6? !6&    "'# + ##" *"%"



# '"""

 

   0 /" #"   !   " *)    !6     $

## * "#

"#+ 

     " #


) "   #

'  &  6    $ # /"# $945 "# 6 * >")  ! !6   6."

# "%'""6" # '    6      )   ! *

6   " ""

   # )

 6 "#

/" #

' &  6"! ? !6&   #  ")% '"" 7,8%   "'%'"

 """

 

 # "#


) " %" #

' &  6     "   '

 

  " " '"  6 #6    #


) "$

&!"! )#   $945 $

"# '   6  ) !*

6 """

  # )

 6 " #

  & ) 6% # +   "  ""

 

  # #


) " %"# '   6?  "  

!  ! 

 )6'"$945 $

%


 '"" *""

6  ") "!  & ) +  1/""

>

%'"""! 2

   )2   ADB% '"" '   ! !  " &## &"

6 

 # 6%'

 "#+  #  " ! "

>   * *) %##

 )   "    "!    ""

'

 !!

/" "

>

" !  !6& .

" #

" %" "

>

 %'

 "#+   # '""#


) 7,8#+    # 7,8% '""& .  # 

'"'

! #  7,8 " %"

*=

 # ""

   ")"

 " !  "

>

 % '"" " !      "  #6  # %'""

'

 '/"

# 

 $

" '

# #  "

> 6#

  ")

6!6 * "

>

 9/" 

 "!

2# * '" *#  *"# 6'"" 

/""

 

  )

""" !   '   6 8.-   09

"'

  )

 #

 ! * !   ) *

  " )   * " ##6 $- 

 " ) *  '""'2 !6 ""




 3 .

 '  "     *% "    #

   ) %! *    )<   3

%



#"  

 $

 %&%'(%) *+ 

2 E F""#2 *

  G- F""# ! G-