← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-AD/114/2015dismissed

Isha Gupta v. State Of Haryana & ANR

2016-03-15Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice T.P.S. Mann5 pages

   

                !"#$ %"&'( )''*++,( -* %&%

((* .,,/,("*  ) *%',/*,(%  

 01



   21



   

*%*,( 3 ,#/-!(* ("*''*++,(

  # " &4" ("* ' *%*,( ''*+# ("* ''*++,( "% %%5+*/("*6&/47*,(!8&5((+/(*/9'%%*/:. ("*//5(5,+ *%%5,%&/4*#3 ,+ "*: 5*!(%;"5!" * *+*-,((/5%'%*("5% ''*+ * *!'5(&+(*/%&,/* "* ''*++,( ;% ; <5,4 ;5("   *;*++* %# *" & +!*# 3 ,+  "* * %"* 7*( ;5(" ,* =5<% ,%+# ;",>$(<"* (("* *%5/*,!*75(";,#, %( +4* #%5(&(*/5, *!( ?# "5,5#*+"5@ *%',/*,(A (<,;"* &(& *' %'*!(&%7 54* "*7*("57("* *

*%',/*,(  ' 5%*/ "*  ,/ %";*/ "5% ;5++5,4,*%% ( 7 . "*   "* *(* #  ("*. %( (*/  *8&*,(+. -5%5(5,4 *!" ("* 0% "&%* ,/ *%(:+5%"*/ *+(5,%  "&%:,/ ,/ ;5* ;*-* #%,/;"*,("*''*++,(%<*/"57 %+*7,5B5,4 ("*7 54*#"*&%*/('&(("*7((* ,,*' *(*C(  ("*("*  *%',/*,(<*'(,*C'+5(5,4"* '".%5!++.

  ("*+%(,*.* ,("*%%& ,!*%+*7,5B5,47 54* ;5(""* 1(* ,#%"*!7*(<,;("( *%',/*,("/ *C'+5(*/ D 45 +% %*C&++. ,/ '".%5!++. :. 45-5,4 %575+  +%*%%& ,!*7 54*;5("("*7

"* 7-*/ , ''+5!(5, /(*/ $ C  ;"5!"+*/( *45%( (5, "*'+5!*7!"5,* .;%%*( 5,(7(5, *%',/*,(;% *%(*/ ,!7'+*(5, 5,-*%(54(5,#5,+ *' (;%' *%*,(*/:* *("*& (

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

' 75%5,4 ( 7 . ("* ''*++,( *%(:+5%"*/ %*C&+ *+(5,% ;5(""* ,/#("* * *#"*5%+5:+*(:*!,-5!(*/ ("*%5/ *,!* E* "-* 45-*, &  ("&4"(&+ !,%5/* (5, ( ("*  4&7*,(%/-,!*/:.+* ,*/!&,%*+ ("*''*++,( /75((*/+.#("*''*++,(,/,*=5<%,%+;* * ; <5,4;5(" F%  *;*++* %#*" & +!*#3 ,+ "* ( 5+ & (  &,/ ("( ("* /**,!* (<*, :. *%',/*,(  ;% ,( *-*, +45!+# ("*  ;% ;*++ !,-5,!5,4,/%&5!5*,((+%5.("*!%*("*' %*!&(5,   *<""&/" .#( . &:+5!# ,5'(% E %'*!55!++./*'%*/("(,>(;5/-5(%C ,/

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

 :(5,*/ 4*((5,4("* *%5/-*"5!+*( ,%* */1(* ,#

  /(*/ >9 &,/*  *!(5,% D$#D9# */ ;5(" %*!(5, D   ;% *45%(* */ ( +5!* ((5,  ("

"5,5#*+"5 "* ''*++,(# *%',/*,(  ,/ =5<% ,%+ ;* * <,;, ( *!" ("*   ( 5% ("* !%*  ("* ' %*!&(5, ("( ("* ' %*!&( 5C +,4 ;5(" =5<% ,%+ "/ 4,* ( *+"5 ( 7**( *%',/*,( , >$  "&%#  ("* -* %5, *! /*/ 5, ("*  *%5/  "% /&+. :**, ' -*/ ("( ("* ' %*!&( 5C +,4 ;5(" =5<% ,%+ "/ /*7,/*/ 7,*. ,/ , "5% *&%+# ("*. 7/*  !,!!(*/ %( . ,/ +/4*/  +%*   45,%( "57 , $ "&%# ("* ''*++,( 5, !,,5-,!* ;5(" =5<% ,%+ "/ 7/* *-* . '%%5:+** (%(4*( 5/("* +/4*/45,%(("*7,/ ("* *%(:+5%"7*,(   !5:+* '".%5!+ *+(5,% :. *%',/*,( ;5("("*''*++,(''* %(:*+%*,/!,!!

(*/,* "* -* %5,  ("* ''*++,( ("( ("* 7:5+* ,%9>D??D9,/>D>?D>;* *&%*/:."* (' -* ("(%"*,/ *%',/*,(;* *5,(&!";5("*!"("*  ;*-* #("5%-* %5,;%/5%! /*/:.("*( 5+& (#:*!&%* 5("%!7*, *! /("(7:5+*>D>?D>'* (5,%( /5(5 ,%+ /&4"(*   =5<% ,%+# ;"* *%# ("*  7:5+* 9>D??D9 :*+,4*/  ( ,* ,  (' 5,4"  (" ("*%* '* %,%  * !!&%*/ 5,   /(*/ >9 *45%(* */:. *%',/*,(45,%(("*7("%+%!7* 5,*-5/*,!*("( ,  (' 5,4",/=5<%,%+"/!

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

 !"#$ 3