← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6312/2018dismissed

Ramphal v. Satyawan

2020-02-06Mr. Justice Anupinder Singh Grewal3 pages



      

     

 

 !"!  # $           !" # $

 $ %"  !%&  '%(')  )'* +,-.'&/- &0'1122'%& ! 

 $ %"&# "

   0 '1122'%& +/%+'%& 0'! .0'22%3+ &0 4"+3)%&! '%+ &0 +. ! -/ &0 .-" &! 52-6* 60 57 &0 !"(& 1 / + 57 &0 !1-%+%&

12'(%&(//!8(%31-!!!!(-%-/&02'%+(%+(!1"&*0'!5%+. +'%+&0 '11'2&0 '3'(%!&0'!5%+(!)(!!+

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

' +

  0 !1-%+%& 12'(%&(//(!!&'&+&-0',5%'22-&&+ )' 2'! 12-& !;"' 7' +!57&09 ')'%.0'7'&-%<==:(%& )!-/(&! !.0)/- '22-&)%&-/2'%+&-2'%+2!!1 !-%!$ " !0*60-6'!&0 > ' 1'%.0*0'!&%+ +0(!'//(+',(&'!>$  '%+0'!!"11- &+&0 .'!-/&0 !1-%+%& 12'(%&(//&0'&'22-&)%&0'+(%++5%)'+57&0 9 ')'%.0'7'&-%<==:*60(206'!&0'%.0'&&0'&&()'%+&0 !1-%+%& 12'(%&(//0'+ '(!+5-"%+' 76'22' -"%+&012-&'%+0'+,% (%!&'22+'3'&0'1122'%& +/%+'%&0'+%. -'.0+"1-%&012-&-/&0 !1-%+%& 12'(%&(//&-&0>&%&-/:!;"' 7' +!$

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

* +)' .'&(-% 1- & '! > : '%+ &0 !(& 12'% '! > < 0 '1122'%&

+/%+'%&+(+%-&.0'22%3&0+)' .'&(-% 1- &'&'%7&()1 (- &-&0 !"5)(!!(-%-/0(!'112(.'&(-%5/- &0'1122'&.-" &(%&0(! 3' +(%&0 7'   % &0 ,%& -/ &0 '1122'%& +/%+'%& 5(%3 '33 (,+ 57 &0 +)' .'&(-% 1- &*60(.00'+5%1 1' +'/& 3(,(%3+"%-&(.&-0()(%



&07' *(&6'!(%.")5%&"1-%0()&-.0'22%3&0!')1 -)1&27'%+ %-&'/& &0!"(&/(2+57&0 !1-%+%& 12'(%&(//0'+5%+. + %!-/' '!&0!"5)(!!(-%-/&02' %+.-"%!2/- &0'1122'%&

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

-%&%&(-%-/&02' %+.-"%!2/- &0'1122'%& +/%+'%& &0'&&0'1122'%& +/%+'%&0'+ '(!+.-%!& ".&(-%-, &02'%+(%+(!1"& -, :+.'+!'3-.'%'2!-%-&5'..1&+/- &0 '!-%&0'&%-,(+%. 0'!5%5 -"30&-% .- +6(&0 3' +&-&0.-%!& ".&(-%.' (+-"&57&0 '1122'%& +/%+'%& -%!;"%&27*+-%-&/(%+'%7) (&(%&0(!'11'260(.0!&'%+! +(!)(!!

 $ %"

          '(#')#)')'#  6' %4(& $0&0 !1'8(%3 '!-%+  #!- $0&0  1- &'52  #!-