High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6331/2018dismissed

Madan Pal v. Balbir Singh Since Deceased Through His Lrs

2019-08-20Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary17 pages

!" #$% &

%

% '(%()** +,-,'.

+/ 0$1 # 1 11

! "#$$% &'%() %! "#$*+ &'%() ,

! "#$*+ &'%() -

. ! "#$$% &'%() &. ! "#$*+ &'%() ///// 1 11. # 0 "#$$% &'%( #$*+ &'%(

,

&*%&&'%& 2 3 !4 )

56

'+%'&'%( 1

4 3

56

2 2 "%% &''#2 "%$7 &'%'! &&%%&''78&*'7&'%')

$%'%&''9

,

1 2 "%$7 &'%' .

6

1 1

,

'9'$&''7

12 "%% &''# .

.

1 1

,

'*'%&''7

,

1 :

.2 "%$7 &'%'! 1 )

'9'$&''7

1

7$ 5 +

# +'

'''8.

, 9 ''

'''8.

1 , , 1:

1 , $ ''

'''8.

%7'$&''7

%7%%&''7 , $ ''

'''8.

'9'*&''7

%7%%&''7 1 61

;

&(%'&''7 1

1

0

0 1<10

. , 1

%7%%&''7 1

, 0

, %%%%&''7

%(%%&''7

4

=

, %%%%&''7%(%%&''7 ,

,

1

"

0 ,

, 3 .

%%%%&''7 %#%%&''7%(%%&''7

,6

6 &#%'&''7

1 ,

1 2 *(& &''7

6

,

, , &%%%&''7

1 &%%%&''7

,

, 1 &&%%&''7

.

. 2 "%% &''# ,

1

# 7'

'''8.

'*'%&''7

, # ''

'''8.

, 1 >.%&.

>.%$.:

&'%&&''7 :

. 1 1

- , &'%&&''7 3 .

0

- . ,

1

. 2 " %$7 &'%'

,1

6 1

1

# 7'

'''8.

'*'%&''7

, # ''

'''8. , 1

;

&'%&&''7

'9'$&''7 :

5, 4

, ?1

!>.+), @

'9'$&''7 1

6 6 1

. 5,4 , ,

.

=

,, 8 6

6, &$

>.+. , ?1

=A

'9'*&''7

, @ %''',0 1 6 1 = 1 , , 6

&.$

1

,

'9'$&''7

'9'$&''7

,

'9'*&''7 ,

,

.

, ?1

5,4:

1

.4, 1 :

,

1 . 2 " %% &''#

'*'%&''7,

, 1:

1

4

, .

&'%&&''7 :

, ,

,6

.

,0 , 1 <,

, 2 2 "%$7 &'%'.

% >

'9'$&''7

,

1 , , 1

%(B

,, CD

& >

, CD4 $ >

CD4 * >

1 CD4 7 >

1

1

CD4 # <,

, 2 2 "%% &''#. % >

'*'%&''7

,

1 , , 1

%(B

,, CD & >

, CD4 $ >

CD4 * >

1 CD4 7 >

1

1

CD4 #

,8 2

.

'*'%&''7

'9'$&''7 1

1 .

, 1

, 1

1 2 "%$7 &'%'

1 1

,

'9'$&''7 1 2 "%% &''# ,

'*'%&''7E

, 1

,

,

2 E;

1

2 2 "%$7 &'%'

1

1 , 2 "%% &''# 1, 4 3

56

,

'+%'&'%( 2 %2 "%% &''# 1

'*'%&''7

1

1 0

,

= 1

, :

1

,

, ,

:

1 , , 1

,

1

,

.

. " #$$% &'%(

1 2

1

1:

.

'9'$&''7

6

, ,

= '9'$&''7

'9'*&''7

= 1, $ ''

'''8.

, D

,

'*'%&''7

=

'9'$&''7

.

, , ,

%'6

:

2

1

.

1

1

, 1 , ?1.>.+

4 5, '9'$&''7

'9'*&''7-

=:

1

1

:

>.%.: 2 " 1

:

,

'9'$&''7 1 , ,

10

1

:

1

2

2 = 1 . ,

. "#$*+ &'%(

1

'*'%&''7

1 1

4 3

56

1

,

10

1

1 .

1 .

. 31&''#

&'%&&''7 E;>.%%8&

.

:

=

, ,- -@ 2 45 ,7'

8 $ :

*

'5(6 *;*7 2 1 <5;*6* -5

'5(685

*5

'5(6 3*;*7

:

'*'%&''7 ,

1 1

,

'9'$&''7 0

'9'$&''7

,

,

. :

1

1

.

2

2 = 1

.

.

.

, 1

.

,

'*'%&''7,

= 11

:

.

, 1

.E;

'9'$&''7

,

'9'*&''7 , $ ''

'''8.

1

0

1

'9'$&''7

%'6 1 ,

. ;, >.%'.A23

,,

:

,

1,

1 ,

, 1 ,, ! ) , :

6

,

, ,

, 1 1

, .

;, , ,

'9'$&''7 6 1,

:

'*'%&''7 ,

1

'*'%&''71

, 1

:

,

1

1 >.%*., 5,

, ,

'*'%&''7

1:

,

,

4>.%..

;,

45, ,

'*'%&''70

1

,

'*'%&''7 :

,

1 ,

1

, ,

1 1

'*'%&''7:

1

,

2 2

"%$7 &'%' 1 :

= .

'9'$&''7 ;,

>.

*.4 : 2

>.% F

, ?1

;, >.+ .,

>.7 . ;, A 23 - < E;

>.%'

1

8 ,,

'9'$&''7 ,

'9'*&''7 0

1

1

5, E , 1 9 ''

'''8.

1

,,

, :

'9'*&''7 1 ,,6 1

, $ ''

'''8. , >.+. , ?1

'9'$&''7 E;.% 1 ;

0

'9'*&''7 E;.7 1

>.%.: 2

EG.%

1,2

1 ,

" $+99

'9'$&''7

,, 1

,1 >.%.: 2

,

>.%1

, 6

0

>.+. , ?1

1 , =

1 1

'9'$&''7 '9'*&''7 =

>.%'.A 2 3 - <

E;

1.

;, 1

"53

- < E;

1

8 , ,

, -

1, 1, 1 4

1.

;,

1 , :

.4>.%

,

'9'$&''7'9'*&''7

6

,,6 8 1, =

.

;,

,

'9'$&''7 -

, , , 4>.%

1

,,

E;.%E;.7 4>.%. ,

, ; ,

&%%'&''#

1

,

, 2 1 1

:

,

,

.

, E;.%E;.7

,

. 1

, E;

, 1

:

,

&(%'&''7

1

.

1 @? @0

,

1

,

,

, 0

, ,,

1 &&%%&''7 ,

, 5

,

: 1, , 1

.

,

,

.

1

0

1

:

,, !E;.%7)

*'# *&'

*#9 *#( *9% 7'# %&'.:2 1 ,,

*&':2

%''%&''9 E;.%#0 ,

1

1

.

1 0

'*'%&''7 ,

1 , :

,

, >.%&. ,>.%$.

, 6 0 0 4

56

@ , 1 ,

1 ,, ! ) , .>.%&

>.%*., 5,

, ,

'*'%&''7

,

,

E;>%*8 :

,1

,

'*'%&''7 .

45,

,1 0

11

,

'*'%&''7 < ,

,

6 1

" 1,

1

&'%&&''70

6

,

'*'%&''7 ,

1 =

14 1

1

1 1

,

45 6,7'

0) (,=6 1 <5;*6* -50) (,=6 .

,

1 , ,

1 1

.

,

1

,

'9'$&''7

1

1,

E=1

,

1 1

'*'%&''7 D

,

1 ,

1

, ,

1

1

'*'%&''7

, 1 ,, 1

. 2

1,

.

1 .

" =

" ,

,

,

1

>1 11?

,-,'. #,-( <5

>

68 A 8" >

8"