High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/6491/2018dismissed

Des Raj v. Babu Ram

2019-02-07Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan12 pages

!" !

!#$% !%&'(')*+

!%(#, #-.#/

!"#$% &$' (( % ) (( "(*$+ !"#$% &$' # $) ($" ,,,,

!- .

(( % $' /& "&$( % $%$"' ""

" "01230443 56)0 (( % $ $7" ( +"&$ """ "01230443

(8 "$( %$%$" 56)0$&' 8' "+/ 9 %$"/+' $6 5:

' # ' " " %$6 &$ ' ( " (6 " ' 8 $%$" '

(( "

'6"

8 " %" "

0024;20<( "/+"""

%6"

! 6 # (( $:;4 $&0:0;;203!/+7'

%''' && 8"'& "

%$"" 6"

8 "

%" "0:00;203( "/+ # 6"

#.! 6 8 #

$=0>$&;00;;20=$&'( &&) ($"'"&" ' (( "( && ' ($"'

'$& % % +&$%$ " $$&' "68 "

6") ' 6 &$"% $$& "%$#+$&($ $7 & "

/+ ' ( &&? ($"

' "&" ) (( ' ' ( &&) ($" $7$&''$6 ?($(+ "

(6! '$7 '

( 9)@!7'

%''' "(6%' "&$8'"&" ) (( # " ""$03:=" "01230443!7'

%' " 8 9" 5:&

&6'% 8"' 86 $! %%$"

+!7 $ % $" & #$6$&' ( &&) ($" & %$8 $ ($ $! ' ( &&) ($" "8$ '" ' %$ 6%" ($ $ $& ' 6 ($(+ "! ' &!

%$ 6%"7$ '$( !$$$8$' $6"&$$!$$$8$'& &$$!9 %'!# " '!$ !/ '$$8 "% %87 $ "

''$6 $ "7% %%$% $&$' '$( %%$"

$'( &&) ($"!' "7 6 " '/6 " "' ( && $6 "$6 % %?'$ ( ' '$( 6"' 8 " + $&

7' $!' $ " $'% % + %$% $$=>==< ""

$$'

!'( &&7 ' # '

" +% " " $% " "'

& $% "'( ($ " " + % " '$7 '( %$& "%$/'($(+ "

(6& &6' #"' '7 &$&'( &&% #" (($ 8 ' 8 "%'+ ;22>!'7 &$&'( && $ &"$ ' 6!'( &&7$ $ ''

& 8 +'$6 '!''$6 7 $%9"/6'$&6 "$#

' 6 ($(+'( &&7 $ ( + '$6 5$&' '$( $ %' + !'8 "'

$7 '

(

0 " ' 8

$&' %' + "' '+ ;22<!7''"&" ) (( % 8 !'A6 "' ( &&$

#''$6 ?($(+ "

(6$'

8&$ 58$' '' "$ 9( $8 % ' # '"&" !'( && #'

($ $$&' "'$6 ?($(+ % " $"

%"'

8' "7''7 9'

8$# % ' 8!'7$6"' #$# % ' "

'$6 '+ ;202!( &&"% ""$$6' "'$6 " '$( $ &$ %$8'' 9"'"&" $# % '(8 "

(6/6'&6 "$# % '8 7 ($"$'($ % $/6!

'"&" 7 ' # &6%$#'($ %!'($ %"

"$ 9 + % $

8' &!'"&" $/$9' '6 $&' '$( "&6' "%$ 6% $$&7 7 '$6'(8

$$&' ( &&'6 !'( && $6 ' &' ! %'"&"

($ $$&'"

(6"($(+ "'( && ' # $# !'

"$ / %9($ $$&' 8'( &&&6' $6 ' & &$ :!222?)(8$'$ %%$6$& 7&200;;202-7'' "&" &6 "$# % ' ". =200;20=-7'

%' '" $&&

$&' 6 . "&6'! ' %6 B $$& 8$6 "%$#+$& ($ $ $ $6 ' %$8( $&$8'"&" $'6$&

:2!222?)&$% 6 $ $'( &&/+/ 9 ' '6 $&' '$( "8 9 % %$ 6% $ 7 '$6'

$ ($$ %!'"&" (( "/&$'$6/$7 " & "'

7 8

%' % 6 $&$%6 ) "

!% 6 $& % $!8 /

+% "/+'"&" ' 7$ ( '

#/+'( && $ ''( !'$7#!7'' "

%$6 7 %$&$"7 ''A6 $ ' 8$&' /+'

' $7'''%$% ( 7 /$6 '$%$"/+'"&" !

'' "$%6 $+&

6/% 6 7 #"$ ($ "$6' ' $ $7 " "! ' ' 8 ( $ ($(+$&'"&" "' $'" %( % $7 ' (%$'/$6" '$7 ' ( $ "' ' $ '$( '($(+ '$7 ' ( 6 ($(+ $ '%$88% $' '( &&' $%$%7 ''($(+ 7'

%'' / '$7 ' ( '"&" ' % 8"'

8 & $7 ($ $$&' 6 ($(+ %04<:'"&" "' '' " $"2;8 $&# % "/ ' $=<:?:?3?0-2);.$' ( &&/6' "2;8 " $' "7'

%'' / '$7/+' ( && ' ( $+# % "7 $"7 '$6 +%$ 6% $ ' &6'/ "' ! %'# % "7 $"$'( &&!' A6 $$& +% %8 ' " ""$ $ !

%'7 %6 + "/+'"&" '

8 '+ 044:$ '%$ 6% $8 " 04<: "' 8 5 %$' ($ "

'"&" ( + '% % +%' $&' 8 " ($' &$ "& % "/+'"&" '

( "

A6 $7 9"/+'

$6) &'%$ 6% $7 5 % 04<:7'+% % 87 " &02+ 044:C$'

A6+ $!' "%$6 &$' (( )"&" "$ $' # + 7 '"&" ' &6' "' '( &&8 +/ "

$'#6 6'$ &$"8 % $$&'($(+ $"$'

87'

%'8 +

($%"

'( $7'$7$6"/&$6" ($ $$& '

($(+$7#!

' $/ " +7'' %6 +7'$ 7 ($ $$&'($(+ "7'

%'($(+ %6 +7 $"!/+

1 /

$%$" + ( &6' "' $% "!#$

" +% " "('$/ %"$$ $' "($(+

%$ " '( "

$&'( !' $6& 8"

&$$7 6 ) D0 E'''( && "&$($ $$'/ $& $7 '

($&'$6 ! ( +"&$C ; E'''( && "&$ ( +"&$C

= E'''( &' $ "% 6 $& % $$ & '( 6 C > E''' 6 $8 / '( &$8C : E'''( &&' $%$8$'%$67 '% ' " C 1 E'''( && $(("/+'

$7 % "%$"6% &$8&

'( 6 C 3 E''' 6 $&'( && /+$" $C < E''' 6 $($(+# 6"C 4 E'''( && $$7$&''$6 "

(6C 02

&F &&! $"$($#'

% !5 8 "'

8 & E0! "

&6'5 8 "E);8 G 68 !9! %' + !'8 !E= 9 " !H$$" (%$!E> 8 I # 6!E: 6/' '

' "!E1*6G

'!E3 %''8

'!E<6 !%'

% "E48

' " &" "$%68 !'( &&) ($" ' %$ "'

# "% && ' ($#" $ %$" #$ " + % " 50!

"$ 85;!#$ " +% "$&'

&5=!"$ 85>!

""$03:=!" "012304435:!"$ 851! ( 53! "$ 8 5<! %+ " #$6%' 54! / $& %+ " 502!%$( $& 8&$8 &$'+ ;22>)2: ";22;)2=500

"50; (% #+!%$(+$& (($ 8$&'

&50=!% ( $& %' + 50>$501!('$/ 503$5;2 "

5=3!% % +/ 5;0$5=>!%$(+$&'( ($$&' & 8 # 5=: "$

( 5=1 '% $&'( &&' "+/"

%6 " /$# " 6(($$&' 8!'' "+/$6 '$%$"' &$ ""$%68 E'

/ 5 8 " 7 ! ' ( && " $' 7 ' # 6(($"'

($ $&# 7 '$6/$7' $ %"' '( &&7 %$ )5 8 "

" /+'%$6 &$'"&" $'($ "

8 $$& '($(+ A6 $ "#5%6 $$&' ""$&'# % ($ " ( ($"6%"$%$"53 "&6' "

'"$%68 ($"6%"/+'

8 # "% 6%' % % +/ ! "' % " " ( 5=1%$7#!$( $&'"&" !' $+$ %$ $' '($(+ "

(6 $' 8($(+7'

%' / "/+' ( &&$7'

%'7 $"/+'"&" ' $6' $&"$ % $ 40J4;$&"

# "%%!0<3;-&$/# +'%.&$'(6($ ' &'8 $& %$ %$$& $ +$'"

($ $$&($(+!' #/"6%"$ '&$8$& "$%68 '8 7'

%' A6 "/+ 7!$# "% 7$6"/A6 " &$($$&$&'8 $& 6%'%$ %! $$' "

($ $$&($(+$$& 6%'8 !5%('"$%68 &&8 $& 6%'%$ %$ $$'"

($ $$&($(+$ +8 A6 "/+ 7$/"6%"$'&$8$& "$%68' #/"$ %%$" %7 '

% $40$&'%!'! ( % $4;$&'%!$# "%$& +$

8 $ 8 ' / "8 " /7 ' ( $ 6%'

68$' ( # &$'(6($ $&%$ "

% !

# + ! ""

$!$ 6/ % &$8! 8 ' $6' 9$ %' '"&" '

%$ ) 5 8 $' "8 "' ( ! ""!/ "$'"$%68 ($"6%"$%$"7'

%'7$6" 8$6$/ "8

$$'( $&' "&" '6 !$ 68 $/' &$&'"&" % $7 ') 7 + $7 "$7 6%'"$%68 +# "% E)>! ! 8 I # 6!7'$% 8"' ''

7$9" 6 ' 6 $8 %'+ 0443$;22;!' ($#"' '( && "'

& 8 +88/ 7 "

(6"($(+ $"6+($#"'"

8 $ 8 $"/+'( && &&' &6'5 8 "E);8 G 6!9! $6% !'8 !7'$' /$6 '$%$"' 8

$&'+ 044<)44 "( %"$%$"'%$(+$&

5=< "' &6' "($ "' '% ( ($"6%"/+'

8 7 ' (%$( &&) /6

8 $$& 6 8% $& 6 ' 6 $8 ' $/$ %" '6"

8$&' $6' " %$6 &$ ' "&" %$ )5 8 " '

7 '

' (8

$ &$ ' %$ 6% $ $& ' ($(+ A6 $!

'$7#!'' "' '% $%$886($' 7 '"6+$& '%$%"9 "&6'' !# ' 8$& 8! $6 '

8 (( " " + $/8 " '$&& % "#'

6#+

8 "/+'"( 8 $7#!' $6' "

% ""'# $$&'"&" "

'+ A6 $ ' # $# %+$/6'# "%$& '

'"&" ' $5 8 " +%$%"7 '

5 8 "'

8 &$+ E0 %$6"' #5 8 " +7 &$8' %' + 6(($$&'

% ' '($(+ A6 $ '

($ $' ( &&' $5 8 "E)= 9 " ! (%$H$$"J # 6((+!

'8 7'$' "($ " "

' 6 %$& $ " & #$6$&' ( &&$' "" $&''$6 ?($(+ A6 $' $( %"$ %$"%$(+$&' $ " 5=47 $%$ )5 8 " '

/6' $6' $"' $'

%$6"/5 %"/+'"&" &$8'

8' &6'"($ " ' 8$&%$ )5 8 $' ' 8$&(( $$& $ "!'($$& "

$7 '

($&''$6

A6 $ 6 "$/%$ "" "$($(# & % $$+/+#

' "" A6 $!' $% " (( " '( &&' &6'5 8 " 6/' ' ' "! 9 $& $6% !'8 E:!7'$' ($#"' 8

&$' + 04<<)<4 "' % $ % + "' 87 "$( $ + /+'

8 " ' 6!'8 "'# $( $:3 "

'$7 '

($&'( &&) /6 8 "( %"$%$"%$(+$&' 8 5E:?0$7#!$# "%' "/"/+'"&" $/6' # $$&'

H6'!'( &&' 5 8 " %'8

'! $ E3!

7'$% 8 ' '' 8 "%$ 6% $ '/' $&'( &&6($' ($(+ "

(6'( &&' $5 8 "6 !'%'

% E<!7'$' ($#"'# 6 $($ 5E<?' "' '#

"' ($ "(( " # 6 $($

' $ $&

'! &$8 ' $&& % $&

6( "! ! 6 8' $/5 8 "/+'( && E4!

7'$' /$6 '$%$" "8 "$ %5E4?$($#' $ $&('$ ' 8$&( &&$'($(+ "

(6$$+' !

'( &&' ""%$(+$&86 $$0=10;?'8 ) 5>2 " %$(+ $& 5>0 7'

%' # ' %$ "

'$7 '

($&'( &&) /6 8#' "" A6 $# ' ' 8' "/5%6"/+'"&" 7' %'

"8 " $ &( "6 %$ " $ "'"

8 $ $&' 6 ($(+ $ " 8 $"' $ ''/$6" ' $6' &6'$ %"&$8'(6 $&' ( 5E1?' $/ '

6 $&"&" "7'

%'' $ " "/+'

8 '% $&'"&" ' '' $" $8$'($(+$ '( &&/6$($#' 8! ''' 5 8 " +7 $'

' ( %" $ %$" + "$%68 ' $6 ' &$6" ' '

%$ $ # 67'

%' $&%" (% & % + '&$8'7 8$&$87'$$&'# "%&' ($ $$&'($(+ "

(6!$'

' //$6 '$%$"$($#' # "5%(' '' "' ('$%$% $7 '

8/6' &$'( $"

"6 7'

%'! %%$"

$ ' ( &&! ' 7 ($ $ $& ' "?($(+ "

(6 '

%%$$#!5E:?0! !' ""

& 6

' "&" '

8 & ' " #" ' ($ $ $& ' ($(+ & #$6$&'( &&'6 !'

%$ $' ' # %$) $7 $&'$ ($(+$&238 $$($ $%$6"' #/

#$'( &&!& & &$' $' '% $8 9 (

'% $&' ""7'

%' " "8 "/+'

8 (( ' ' "&" ) (( ' " $/G% $ "

' "8

+ $& '

"$%68 9% % +/ !('$/ " $% "%/6'

%$8(+ $ $'$7 6%'$/G% $%$6"/ "&'( && 7 $ ($ $$&'($(+ A6 $&$87''%$6"' #

"'% % +/ !('$/ " $% "%7'

%' "

"6+($#"/+' (% #7 &$8'%$%""( 8C' "&" ' $ 9 + "' ' "$%68 ' 6$&&$ + $' 8' #/& / % "' / %$&' !'

$/G% $7$6"$ / /

% ' "&" 7 (8

# ($ $# ' 6 ($(+!'8$8'7 9"$# % '(8 ! 6%'(8

%%' $/%$ ""$' #% " 7$6" $/ ($$ ' % $:;$&'"

8 %!0<<;"& % 7' $& 88$# /($(+ " "& " % $02:$&' &$&$(+ %!0<<;'$/ 6(8$6 "%

$""

!"#!

$ %%!&

' " 7 '' 6 "' "

%6 "'"

% $$& &$8 %% '"' $8+ %$ %/6#

& '"8 "($(+/+%

' & #$6$&' E' ! % $+8 9 % $ 7&67 '$67'

%' 7$6"/6 7&6/6"$ $ & + & #$6$&' % ' (%$' "($(+'6 ! %$

'! $ 7 &"/+

# (8

$$ % $ ( $$$%%6(+'(8 '$6 +%$ " $ 8$6$! 6%'+($& % #$ A6 "$/"6%" 7 $$/

'"&" ' $/ /$($#'$7 ' (6($' " "

(6 /+ ($"6% + "$%68 $ + # "% 7' ' ( &&' / /$($#' 8/+/

$%$"' "" "

' ( " $'$'"$%68 '$7 '

($ $ 6/ A6$ ' ' /"

%6 " /$#'6 ! % &+/'"' '( && 7 " &$ ($ $ $& ' ($(+ "

(6 ' ' ($#"

$7 '

( "

' 6 ($(+ " %' % $(8

# /+'

8$'"&" $$%%6(+'(8 % $5 $;20;;20;

7''( &&" "'

8$# % '(8 !' $6'

%$%+% %6 "' &$8;20;;20;$;20;;20='$6 '!

'( && "8 "7 ' '$6"/ :!222?)(8$'/6' ' /% %6 "I =!222?)(8$'$+7'

%'!/+$ !% /'"$/5% #$ "&6'!'( &&'

'+/'"

"$ ' 8 &$8'" $&&

$&' 6

" #+$&($ $$&' 6 ($(+

#/ %9$'( &&

%'( && % ' '

'6 %78$#"/+ '"&" "7 '$6'

$!% %$ 6% $78 " "

'"&" ' 8 /+& "$ / '' ' '$7$&' ($(+ A6 $!' $6' %$%+'"'( && "

&$'%$8( $ 8$6 $ ;2!222?) $$ %%$6$& 6&& $ $&($(+"6 '(8 7 6 "/+'"&" !7'

%'%$6"' # /# ''

' "/6'

$67$6"$ $ $' &$' $ ' ' $%$ ) (( ?%$ )$/G% $ '6"

8 " %7 %' "/+'"&" /+ &

# (( $:;4$&0:0;;203/6'"""

%6"

6!# "'

8" "0024;20<!' 6('"'& "

%$""

/+' $6 "' "

"' (( # 7$&'"

%6 $ 8 " /$#!'

$6 $$&' # 7' $ $$" $6"%$6"/ "/+' (( )"&" 7

&% ' 8(6 " 6"

8 " % " $ 6/

A6 $$& 7! '$( $$&'

$6! #$#" '

(( ' ( ! "%$6 &$' (( )"&" ' $$ / /$ + $6" 8 $& % $>0$&'6G /$6 %!

040<$"8$ /&$'

$6' ' 8(6 ""%

$ %$ + $ 7$ $8%6 $8$6 ' # '&$%$& 7' $$/ /$ '$7' /$''$6 /$7' #& "$"8 +8

6$& 7$%6 $8$6 ' # '&$%$& 7 ' 6!'

(( !/ "#$ "$& +8 ! "

" $7#!'( 7 / ' $7%$ - .

* 232;;204 G 23%$3%4(5%#6')784%#()%9:"%(8 23%$3%44%54$#-;%:

"%(8