Bati Devi v. Haryana State Pollution Control Board And Others
!"#$%$ &'
!"#$$
() *+,($ - ,- ,, (+ ****
! "# $
$%& ! "# $
-."
/(!0 1'23 $ '()
*$
$ # $ +
& !",,- #$
#.
+$# " #+ $ ## /$ &$"
#$
"$ & & $ #$
$ ""
# 123 (4-5 (4-6 #,2 #$ " ',)
7 "
# $
01$$+& 1
28 2- (446#$$ #$#$
8( (446 $01$ #0$"#"'!
() +$"$$ #0$+2( (4-6 0/
$/
$# "##" $+0$"#"" & $ #0$ 023 (4-5'!
3)+$"$$01 $
2:
(445'!
-) '8)
. #$ 01 $ $ "
0 $
#$ #0$2( (4-6+1
1
"$ $
"
$ 01 $
# # 1 $ $#
"##" +$"$$ & $# 0# $
- 2 - +$ 0$"#"" &$ #0$ 023 (4-5 *$ + 1 $ "0
0 1$ +$ $
+ "$ & 2( (4-6# 123 (4-5 '6)
7 "
#$"
$$ $ "
$"
" #$% 1
" "
0 9" " #"" +$ #$% '3)
;
" # 1
+
(2 ,2(4 $ $
$ #$,- (( ,2,2$ &$ <$%$ "
0$# #
;
( 8 '-)
. $ 0 $ " $ +
"
# 0$
0 $ ##" $
+ 01$
#$ #0$ *$
01$
# 0$ $ &$ $ 70 .
"$& %&
;
= %=4-= 7!=(8:: (5 (44- 0 = # 1 0 "$ &11 "%&
& # "
!"#" & 0$ "$%1 "$ 11"%&
# $
2( (4-6'!
9>8)+$"$+ 0$ 11
'!
96) '5)
7 "
# $
#$ 01 $ !& ?0$1 ; ? =4-=4-,6 (5 (44-'!
>8)+ $
01$
# $ #0$# 1
$ "
&
*$ #$ # $
$ $ &$ # & ;>;&$ "@0& "
,6 2, (445 $$# "
- 3 - ##" @0& & #$&$ $ A ' #!"
9!
9>3) *$ &
@0 ;
358,, (445'!
9>-)
#0$"#"# + $
$1+# + $
> 0 70 "$&
%&
*$"
#"#"+ !""
##"
;
?=4:=6-63 (44:# "
':)
.#$01$ " $ "0
"
" ##" + 1 23 (4-5 " #
(4-6 +$"$$0 10$ &$ !""
+ ' ) $ + 1 # ?
/ (:
,2,2+$"$+ 0$$ "
##" !""
##" '!
>5) +$ $ 0 0 $ $ "
"
=" & 0 $ "
#1
+10$ &$ !""
+ ' ) $ B $ $$ "
##" $
+& #$
$$ $ &$"$& # !""
##"+$ $ #"
1 $ #"
*$$ #0$+ 0 2( (4-6 #$01$
1
# % @ @ %.010$
+$ $$"$ #0$2( (4-6'!
9>:) 7
$
# "
(4 2- ,2(:/ &# $"$ & # #0$# 1 (4-6 23 (4-50$/+" + #$#" $$
2( (4-6"
"
- 4 - "1 & 0 $ %1 "$ "$ " @ #" 0 $ " " ##" %&
$ 1 1 $ # 0$ 0 $ &
@0 "
0"" $
$$ 1 # $0
A $" & $"#" $ "#"$0 1 $
1 $< &$ #$#$
1 $ &$ '4)
7 "
#$ # 1$ /+"
" & & =&=1 & $ " 0
$ &
@0+/ # 1$" 0$ #
$ $!
"& '$$) # 1$
> $"
#
+
# $ #(4-6 (4-->(4-: ;
!=C=,2,2=563 5 ,2,2 !=C=,2,2=:42 (2 2- ,2,2 '!
9(2(( " ) '(2)
@$ &$5 8 ;
8 $ # $>.. # $ <0 @ " 1>. ' "0 $ )$$$"
#0$1$1 # # $ # % " $01 0"
" $# "
# $ & "
+$ + # 1 $ # $ % " $
"
010
$ #+ # "$ & #0$+0 !"$ $$# +""0 "0
2( (4-6 #23 (4-5
- 5 - '(()
& $ "
# $ # & & $ &$$"
$ #$"
+$$"
"$ & & &$
""
"+$+ .#$+ <#0
# $
0 $$
+ 2( (4-6
23 (4-5 $
"
$ &$+ " 0 & "
$ "1 & 0 %1 "$ " @ #" 0 $ "
"##" %&
'(,)
$
$ # $ + +$$
#0$"#"0$ &
@0$ + &$ 0$
023 (4-5 +
"
"1 0 $ "#" 0 $ %1 "$ # $ "
" & $ "# 0 $ " " ##" %&
+$"$
1" # "#" + & # " # $ #"
#
'(8)
!0" 10& $ #0$0# $
+$ "$
& .
!$ ""
#0" !(2 (4(2 + $ # 0$ # $ "
" 0" !
/+$ $0" +/ $ +"+$$ # 0$ $
0 "" ! (425 *$# $ % #1 $ #0$!(- (425 " $$$ 1 $ 0
!(- (4-, *$
- 6 -
+ "$ & 0 $ 0"
&$ *$ &$ $ $ $ # $ % 1 "
1 1 0# $ $ &
+ "
$ & & $ " "
1 1 +$ $1 & #! 8((
" $ +
&
0 $ + &"& $"
0 & $ $
+ *$!9 "
#1$ 0$&$ # .+ 0 0$ 1 +$"$
" "
/ " 1 0 1 "
+$ $
<" *$
"
" 10 # 1 #$ " $ " $ # 10& # 1 $ " 0# "
*$ 0" ""
& $ ""
"
0
0# !(2 (4-3 0 /+$"$+
$ 1
"
+$$ <" +1 &$ #0$ $ " "
" & $ $ + 0 (425 *$ + $<" #$0" +$ & & 1$" #$ '(6)
!""
& $ +
+ ,3 ,2(4 '!
>4) /$ $ "
# $
> "$ & & $ # 0$ # $
# 1 23 (4-5 (4-6 &$ +
> +00 " #$ # $ & & / "
# + & " #+$
<#"
0$
>
- 7 - +$ $ (, ,2(: & # $ #" # 1 @0 + +$ ## & $
+ '(3)
""
& 2:
(( ,2,8
4-."
/(!0 1'25
0 1
1. Whether speaking/reasoned?
Yes/No
2. Whether reportable?
Yes/No