High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/927/2018dismissed

Ranjan Sood v. Om Parkash

2018-07-03Mr. Justice Satpal20 pages

#$ %%%&& '( )*(+, %%%&$

"#$%& '

( )*+,-& ,".&

,"/0 ,.0) *(

(-, "$- (,&& (,,."$- (,(&$%-( /// 1 ( 0, $ $ , $ , (1 ( $ && 1 , # $1) ,2 (344,(3 , ,&

,3$($ 0,&

$ ()$( # ($(1, $ $ (( ,) , & 3, " ( 5"

2,$1(,"4,,41$,-31 $ (3 +3 , $ $ 6

$ ,$ -( 1$ 4(, &&(7)

8%" , (1 ) ( 3, $ ,( )&( $ )"4,,4(1$3 (3 +4 3 ,$ $9,$ 3&( $,,1()$$

$ , $$$ ),41&,-3,$$-(3 , &

,$ $ 6

3$($ (1$" 3($$

$ -$ )1 ( , $ & 3, () , $

$&(( &4()$ 0, ,&

4,,,(14($

3, "*(+,((+"( 52,$1(,$,, ,3( 1,3 (),$3, $(,)$

:8.42(+( ; <$4 $14, $ 3( (+( $&1$ 0,.,4$,)3 ,2,$1(, $)( = 5 ! ( ( ; , 3 & 1 )

8%&( ( ) 5"

8%$ , 2,$1(,$)(0,3, ,> 7 0,)(+- ,( , ) 1 , 4 $ 3 &&(7) !5"

8% 94$, (

,- ,3,4 &&(7) !

8%94&$$,,&

4 ,& ;44-(4,?1,1 1; $1?1,3 $($(4(?1, 94&$$,,$ $4 ( 1,3 () 3, 6" * (+" ,( (+" ( 5" 2,$1(, 0, $ $411$) $1$3 9, (

,@ )( ,&

($1,)( 1,3 ,&

4$$-( ,((;,(3 ) 4,,$ $,@ )(+

8% (),$ $ , (

50,43( ($4,&($

8% 43(&$$ 0,) 4(&$ ,) $1, ) " ,$ $,$+43+1$)& &&( (), @ )(0,1 ( ,&

4(3$,&&(, @ )(+

8% (),$ $,(&(

(),",+7($4,,4-( 7(3(

($4(& 34,(44+0, 1,,4( (&$3 ,&

",4-(",$ $$$,$,)3+, 3+1$$ ) 0,&

<,( (+ &)&(- (-0,&

+) (),$ $ 9

", &

+ 5"

8% 9 4 (&$ 4, ( 9 -)3(8)3(

",$ $1,&

1)3+ $ )43+1$,A "3+1$)&&&($ (4 3+1$&1 0,&

+ ! "

8% (), $ $ ! !

"4,,,4(& 14,$ )

8%B, "

8%()$$ ",$ $4($, &

,,) "

8%4( ($

,) & 34 $3$ 3$ ;4)$&,() 4(1))(" ,$ $)4,3+)&&&( 58% $$ 6

$ ($&

1,4.,,$ ) 4(($3 ,$ $,1, 6

3 =5&)"4, ,&

43 ,,&",$ $14,7&( ),(0, -( 3 &,&

0, + "

8%,

(),&+$ (3 7$,(4+,3,0,$4 $,-34$3 ,3,4( ,$#3,0, 1, ,&

()$,*..73 ,&

$$(- ,)(?-,& *(

"$$,&,&

& $$4,,$ $ 94 () ,&( ,, ) ,&

4(($$0,&

4+C-() ;&"( 6"2,$1(,4,(,4)$ 7)$ 9$

+1 1,$ $&($1 $(

2(*2 4($13,,&

$,$ $0, 4(3,(($ $($33

&) 6

0,&

1 $$ = 6

1 & , $ $ (( & ;4-(",$ $$$(& ,$0,&

1-4( )&$$ 6 6

;*"(

"2,$1(,; )&$$ !

*"2,$1(,,* 3B$4 ))&4,C-(( !

(,(&$$,,$ $-4,$& $$,4,$) $,3+1$&&($,(&&( 11 ( ,&

$, ( (111() $$

&(1 3,D ,( 1() $$

$ $ )& (&($3(1($1,$1-(

&, & 3,3 ,&

,$ $ 6

$ +4$11(& 5 "

8%3 ,&

,1$ 1 ,3,94&$$,,&

$$( ,1() (,$,(-$ ) 1$ 13,($$, ,$-(,& 3,,$ $; 4,, &4 (3 +3 ,$ $"4,+$,)$ $ ,)# ( 6

3 !

&)"4,, ((3($3 , 6!$$ !

(($$

)$&($1 $(

2(*2"$,E ,&

) 6

F& , $ $ & &&( $ $ 4( )14, ()94&$$,,&

1($

, &(&( ,$ $ ($( =

+,-$ 1()$$

+,4&$,&

() ,) 1()0,(1)( 3,4 ,$$-(3 ,&

,$ $ 941($,&

4 $31-%

),)&,()1 ()$$ ) (A ($)&,0,3) 6+,43&$ ,) 7 $(1( $ ) ,?

2,$1(, 941($,,&

3+ (), 3(1",4 $33(

$ 6+,$ 3 ,() ,&

< (A ",$ $&$ ) ! "

8%,( 1, ,A 4,,4((A ($3$&$,?

"2,$1(, 0,) 4 3$# $,3$(, &

,) 1($$ (

$$,);4-(",&

$)&, ())$-$4(1$$

, ))&, ()47$$!

5 941($, &&((((1$,&

4,$-(,&, &

,3,,$ $$,$ $4&( & (, , +,3,,),&

$)&, ()"

,,$$-(&, $-& ,3,,$ $

6 ((-1) 5 "

8%4($&( ,1$ 1 ,3,,,$ $&

& ,3, (,$1-(&,&

$1$ )& 4,,&94

(,(, ,$ $,-,( (, &

(A $ , $ $ & ) )( ) (A ($ 3

$&$4,?

(0,$ $&$

8%,( 1,* ($(

$$=

,) ?

"F02,$1(,94 &$$,,$ $44 ($ $41&( (),&( , ($4($ 4,,3$(3 $ $ )&1, ()3 ,&

", $3)&$0, $ $ &$ , ) =

1$ , , &

0, $ $,($ &$ )

+, =+,-1 3 5 +, 0,$ $4$ ($ $41 &( (),&( ,(94 3)$,, () , $ $34$ $& &( () ,1()$$

3$($ (- "$( ((-(

6+,314,() &$14,(3&$ 9($(&(-,"&

7)$,) *B% ; 7)$*B% (,+@ )("4,&(-$,)$(&(?7*B% "*B%!(,@ )(4,( 1,,&,)(4 ,$ (3$&"*B%=,@ )(,"*B%5C ($ 1,,(4;&$(($& ,)((+*%

"& )84(1?7*"& ,)&3 ,&

; ?7 *%8 " & ,( )& 3 &

; ?7*." &

)&3 ,&

*?7*2"& )&3 &

C-((?7*"& ,)&3 ,&

*(1($1 (3 &?7*?"(&( ((1($1)$7) ,&

?7*B% 8 0,$ $,,(,$7)$,) B% "$&

$B% "4,$ $,1 (,1()?7% $ ,4(1$$

?7% ;&$(($$ )& 1()$$

?7% "& 4(1$$

7$1,)?7% "& 4(1$$ 6

(1($1,$1 -( -&$(-15 "

8%?7%!"& ( 3+(1($1& )

8%?

3 * ($(?7 %= E$ 0( 2 ( $ , , $ $ B% , (% 7)$)$,3,,4,1()$$

$&$$,44(,(-$&$4, &,4$,44,(3(,(%%40,2 ($,, 44, , &( 3 4,(4

31,&( 0,2 (

(,($,,1()?7 % $ $#$)$,-&$"

8%() ,,$3( 1,(($ -$ & ) ,$) ,&

(,$,3( 1, -$,4,,,$, & & ,$) 0,0(2 ($,,$ $, (%7),$$)$,,4(1 "

8% "

8%1 4,,&,4

(

,)4 "

8% 5"

8%; $)$,,4$1 ,(3 ($$,,- ,( &(&( ,)0,2 ($,,,$ $,$ $ ,4,,,$, & & ,3$(

8% 1($1,$ )?7%! &(4,,,$ $ )$,&,3,$$-(,) 6

$,&

,$(-$5 "

8%- (,1$ 1,,& E$0(2 ($,,4,4(1&+,$3 7)$(-(", ,$)$ A ((,$ (($34, &

$$ $3 ,)) ,1$,$1-(

&"(1($14,,4$1$$&($1 $(

2(*24($"4,,3,,&

$,$ $$ &+4((($" ,$$ )$ &&(,-(

, (3&,$3+3 ,$ $0,-( ,&

(1($1,A (($+1-(,& (3 3 , $ $4 &&($3 ,*B%!(,@ )($*B%5C ($ 1,G (,(",-( ,&

,,$,,$+ () ,$ $$

()4&$-4 , ,,&

,$&(-$(($(&?7*%$,$ $$)$,1 ( ,$4(1 ?7*%$,1 ( ,$ $ 6) - 944(,(H, 5%

8% =

I 0,$ $437&,1 (,$ )*

< -(4

(,( &&($3 ,$) ,$ $,,,$1- ! "

8%,&

)4,((,"

,( 1,,A $) 4( ($,)0,E$2 (,$,$$&&(& 3,, &

4 $ ( ( ! "

8% , $ $ 4, 3 $( 6"

8%4$ 9 ,) 4$ ,4 $ $$# 1,) $ 0,)( ,,$ $)$ & )

8%,?

((1($,3, (, 1$ (3$& ,&

4,$3

$&(-,&((&

,$1-( & ,3, , $ $ 0,2 (

(,($,B% $)$,,1()?7 % 41$3 ,) $,?

"4,($-$( 4(1 (4 (,)14, ,$ )4( (1($((>$4,, 4(7 $&4,((8, 2))(4(-3 0,E$0(2 (,(3 $$,, 1,,$ ) ?7% $% $,1 ( ,&

$,$,"

$3$ (1$$ 3($$ )3 4(,, $ )4(1- ( (,3$3 ,&

$, $4, ,&( ,)1()0, 2 ( $$,,$ $,$ $&(-3,,$ 7

,$ )$,($$41$, & & ,3$(;,$ $&(-?7%!-$ ,$1-(&

& ,3,3 ,&

,(,$ 3&(-$,,$ $,$+ (3& ,3,$, &

4$ ((( ,) ($1 ", , &

4$($,

,,4,$$& , &(&( 0, $ $ 4 $($,$-(- & , &() , &

4, 4 ), 0, 1() $$

",4(1$$

7$1,)$,$ ) & (&(1,$-(&

& ,3,,$ $

4($($ $-$0, () ,$ $4

$)$ 0,($4(&&2 (

()$, $1 ($ 4(2 ($1-$$( ($ 31,$ )1, ,1 (,$ ),$3$$3 ,&

3 ,,$ &$$,,1 (,$33$3+&&(",2 ($ ,,$ )?7% &1$ )$1,() $$34,&( ?7%9 ,&

,4,- 1$4&0,1()$$ 4,(,)& &&(& (,$

4, ) , (,3+$ , $ )?7 ,((,(1 (,3+ ,&

0, ( &4,(1($,$ )$ 3 (($, ,$ ),31$3+3 ,&

)& ) ,(4,(4$ (,)1,(&,3+ , $ )3+ 0,)&&&(4,,,$ )&(&($

4,(,$ 1() (&($ 3 ,(),- )$,-3& (,$, (

)( $ )?7 1$4&3 ,($, )& &&( , 3 & (,$ 3 , & (,( ,) 9 ,$ 3 7&$4, ,& (,(& (,$,)&&&(4,,)& &&( (?7 ,43& (,$3 ,-$()*(+, E+,0(2 (,&&2 ($,, 1,4 )$3 ,$ $,

+,4&$() 3 ,( (& & ) ,) , 94$, ,1, )&(33 ( &( & , (1 ) & (

1()4, +1(& E+,0(2 (,&&2 ($,,(,-3 (4,(1($3((41) 3 ,&

(), $ $,&(4($14,,,(")& ), $ )1$3 ,&

4(-34,,$ $ 94 $$,,$ )?7 "?7 $?7!,$3&(&($ ,&&(4,,4(($ 1$"4(-34,,$ $ $ ,$$( ,( ,&(94$,?7 &$$ )$B ,$,(%7),41$3 ,),&() ?

4,(,2))("( $ 0,$((1.

(1 ,$ )41$ ()) &(4,4($,&(?-,) , &,3 $$0,(),( ,$ ),4((A ($ 3((1$3 ,( 0,4(&&2 (,$,$$$(, ,-1,$$-(&

& , &(&( 6

, &

4 $,))$1)&4,(1($ (3 & ,$3,0,&

($# (,$ 4,,&(-$3 *B (,+@ )(?"C2;% 62,$1(,4, )$%1 7)$,&

$,E4&(-$ ?7*B 8 *B ,-3(%7)$3 ,$ $$& &&( *B!,

(,(((3($,$,

$-?7*B!8 0,2 (

(,(+ , ,,&

,$ $ () )&1,$ $ ( 1# (,)4,+1 (3

&4,,,$ $4-$ ;-1 &$ )( 1 , $ $ , E$ E4( &&2 (,$,, $3 ,&

,$3$($ $, () $3 ,$ $,$3$)$",$ $ 4(A ($ 4&(&&" (1,# $1), $,,( (1,# $1), ().

,,$ $ &&,)4)&4&$$ ,@(;1,2 ( , ,6 ".

+0& * 7*( 6"

+0& * 489 ,:,% 2$@(+;1,2 ('&%%"

7*( ')",""6"

;"+( 4 . (,E$E4(&&2 (,$ $,$)-$ && $(($(= ($1$$-$&(-, ,,$4,$(4"

()

,3(,()$94(1 $,, 1,,$ $,$3( 1,,

, , 3 (,0(2 (3 ,$$&(-, 3 ))1,3+(($0,-$4$3)( (, $ ,0,E$E4(&&2 (,4-($)$, &&94,$,4&&( ,1 && )+ (,1$ &,,($$)($ ,) E+ 1+4$1(&(&(1$-1( $ (&($

$$-$,&&10,&(-3 $ & (1&,&&(-(",(4&$1,4( )(, (%),(1($$,",1 &&, $ $ $34$1--$ ,1&

(-, "E($ (,&&,($,

41 % 0,($4(&& (,-1,$,4&& 1, ,-3 $$,1&&4)& 1, ,-$$$,&&)(0, $1 ,($ 4(&&2 ()( ,(, % 3 0,&

),-3 (3 $&$ 6

(& $(6 ,& " 6!

$,-3 $4,7),,( , 4 $

( 7 ), , $&" 4 )3 $)$ ,&

4& ,&(&( " )&( ( $( 4, )1 & $ & 1$-() ( 4)3,(,0( 2 ((,($4(&& (,& $4, , )3 $2 ( 4,,4(& ($3 ,$ $3 (3,, ( - 0,($4(&&,1- 4 $1;"

,# $1) 3$,$(-3 ()$$ ( $ )3( # $1) &&( , (,,.E($ (,&

%(&$, ($, ($ 3);(1 $,,E($E4(&& 2 ( ($($,)( ,&&$$)$,)0,

1&&31)&4 $$1( $ )$3 ,2 ((-(",1( $1 3, $($3 ,($4(&& (,$($ 3(-($ 3 -., ,@(;1,2 (0 %<,%==% $.)% >&

:*( ;)++"< $+0 ;( ?@ "

5829 ;& (?(( 3 4,,43( 1, , ,2 ( 1($1,(1 ), ,-13 $3 $7), $&4)3() 6 ,& " ($2 $, (,&

4$&$

&($1 $(

2(*24($13, ,&

$$ $0,&($14($(&&$

4, $(+()$ ())& ( 40, 4 $ 4,7),,(

;($# $1) ;<3 &()2 (&0 , ?% ".

+0& ' +( 0) , &:, ".

+0& *"

$,, $4,7), $(&&1, &($1 $(

2(*2, $(6 ,& 4 $34,)$$-()2 ( 4& 3 ;

(,((1 $, ,2 (), ,$-()2 (

& 3 $$(($1 ,A ( (3 $ ;($$ ;<3 &()2 ( (( ++& **A &

<"( ?+.( ".

+0&

7*( ., ,"

".&B1

859 3$,,2 (4 ) $,( (,(41- , ( ,&() 3 $3$A $# ()

($( ,2$ 2-*($ (

1($1,(1 ),,E4(&&2 (,1- %4 $1"E($ $$, , ($3 ( , 4( && ( 4( (A ($ 3 $$$ 0, $ $ ,$ $, $1 ,($( ( " $5

; $,,$ ,-3$($$$$$0, 1,&( %4 $1,3(($$3 ,2 (,$$ $,-$ $$ &&($,# $1)3 ( 3 $,(4,; ($ &( % <:

7( (( , -&*&

'.) ,1 5829 3 ;

(,( 3)$,- ,& )3 $$-()2 ( ,3$$$3 ,2 (34",2 ( , $ $$$()$,)( ;$ $$, $1 (($$3 , (34 $$, (3$-$; 3)$,,&&3$)$ ;-1,($E$2 (,&(9) ,-4,, &&$(-3$)$ , ( ($ 3 ( " E$ 2 ( , (&$,(1, (1 $,,&&2 ( ($($,&& )( 0, A )3 1&& 4 $$1( $)$3 ,2 ((-(",1( $41 3,$($3 ,($4(&& (,$ ($ 3(-($3 -.,0 %<,%==% $.)% >&

:*( ;)++"< $+0 ;( ?@ "

5829 ;& (?(( 3 &(4,,1 &&4)31)&$( $ (%) 0, $1)(4 $,-3$($ " "1

&&41 )&1&&4)&, $1 )((($$3 ,2 (3$($ 0,A )3 $2 ( $3$4, 79 &&( ,(1 ),, $3$($

$(6 ,& "E$2 (,(&$,$ $, (,&

4$&$ 6

&($1 $(

2(*24($13,,&

$$ $ 4,, 4( $(&&$

4, $( + ()$ () )& ( 40, ,-13 $4,7),,(

$3$($ $(6 ,&

0,3&$9

&($1,$((3$ $( =52(*2,

,&( 4,,$3$&$0,&($1$$$(3 ,;1, 2 ( 2() (- 0,( ( , ( &$$)14 $94,7,;<3 &() 2 (,$,, ", 1, $4,7), $&"3

$))$ ($(&&1 ,&($1 $( =52(*23 ,;1,2 (1-13( (&" $3($

$(6 ,& 0,(-3(-( $(

" #

$% % &'

" (

) *

)

, % ) % % ( - + . + ) !

) - + . +

, % !

" # / 0,# $1)3($,)(&(&$3 ,E$ 2 (,(&$9$ $4,,)& +$

&($1)1((1 (3$&37 $$ 9&($1 $( =52(*2",&( 4(1

$&$ 3(($&# 6 ,& B,( &($1 8

2(*2( ( ( (+&1&$(( &(-,)) 1>3

0,(((# 7 $,)&,&($10, ,3,$,, &( ,-13 $3 $7), $& 6

3( $3 $(6 ,& 9, 3($ (&4,,$-()2 ( & 3 0, ,($2 (,&&,, E4(&&2 (,1- %4 $1 ,# $1) 3$)(&9,3,$3 ;<3 &() 2 ( ( %

<: #* &( , ,( ,3 3 )&4,,&(- ($(= !

2-*($ (2$$,

$1 ,4(&&2 (3($",,# $1) 3,$3-$94,$,4,(,&& (,$($,

(-$(($$$ $,) $ $ ) $ $1( &&($3 (,-, 1,,&

($(),-3 ()$3 ,&&2 (,( 3 )&4,,&(- ($(= !

2-*($ (2$$, # $1) )(-$3 ,3 & $() 0,(-3(-,(1($( $(

1 & " 2 + . +

)

3 6 )

% )

+ +

)

1 & " 2 +.+

$ 6 3

) %

% ) )

) +

1 & " 2 + . + 3 )

)

) ) 3 %

3 " 6

)

6 ) # ) + . + / 9,&(",4(&& (,$($,-$ (($$ &&($ 4,(B,

()1, $1

,0(2 (,1-$$( &&( 0, "# $1)3 $,1( $4 0,( () ,($( ,2 ((#1, && ,$ $ ($1$$-$ (1($, (( $1 (($$3 , ( 34E($ (,&&,333,,4 , $1(&(-((1,(($ 0, ",&&$)$;4-(,7 ,$( 3+&3 (!

$ 9$($,3 (7 1,$( ,&

,& $-() ( ,( &

8 9 1

B,,(&+18$ J B,,(&(3 J8