Dimple v. Naveen Kumar





   
 



 ! "!#$%$&' (

  

     

)'

*+)
),)+- 

  

 

  
!"

 

 

" 

 

  "

),)+-.

/012

#$% $

 !

&'  "(( )" *((*+ ,

   !

-. "/  



-011)*

* " +     
 #$

"#

 2

"

     %  /    "  "

  # % "  "

% 

$

% "" 

  

4"#

  $

$ 





!



4%

"



$   

 "

" 





# % 2

"

   "

56 7 " 

# % " 

"



4%    

  

 

8 

 



  " 

"(    "

"

#  # 



  !

-.

2

"

  3  #

  #  

 $  

4%

"

4"#

3  

 

% $#

 

# %#$  

4%   2

"

 "

 "#$ "

4"#

(  

 "%

, "



  

    "



9 " 

# %

%

 



 "% " 

 % "

   "

 #  %" 



, "

 :"





8 % !

&'

"( ( "

" ; 



"

  " 

3 

 

 %" ( 

  " 

 "( "



,



"     " "   

 "

#"

 



"

 



 



#<

"

 

 "

"  ,

 ""

 %"

#

"$    ,

"  

       $      "  %*

 

%" " #,

#$ "( %" 

  :"%

, #$ "(    %

;



% 

/ "(



"( 4
      

 !"# $% &' (  ) * 

+

 ! , -)

..

!/ 0(% -  *0($+++
+

.# . & *0&   $++$

 , " "10& 0$++$
2#"

1 * 34 *$++$ $ 2."# #*30   -0&0 $++,
+ 

$#+

5 6

)&7

3- 866  $++

 

,
+      (      01

($++

 
, !

  0&(   0&  7  0&(   &1  *   05 9&1:& $++#

,,,
$/% 34 * $+
. ,  2
"#
,   $+

 $ )2,!
!   $+
,2 0  
".


.4; 0&$+
+

 - $#"
" &  $+

 "  - 

$
  0  % -  7  0  0&  7  0     )'  *$+
$ #  - #! :"

#

 #$  -' ;

-314$&"!0-305-314$&"!030#60& $&76*

) + %" "

#

$% "

  4 =
 

     

   

            

 

     

         

 

   

  



   !

  "         # #  

       

  

     #  

"

$    #   #        

% #   #   

  #      #

  ##   %



 

%      

       

   

  

 

%

&   ##  

 

   

        %        



     

 

#          

 

      



 &       

$   #    #                #  '      #        # 

   "    

  

  #     "



       

      "   (

 #

 

 

     " 

  

03809&$949: ) + "  4 =$ &  

     

 

     

     

      



'

      

  "        

  

  "           



  #   $  

#   

      

                

"

     



   #    #   #   #               $  )          

# 

"  

        "  



 

 

   

 *

   

        

  

#   #



 #   

      



  

#  

   &      

  +     

             





 %   #  #     

  #      

           #      

       

#         $    ,             

  

- 



.(  :" #4  % % #$ *#!"

#

%#$ "( 

->6.&6->  : 0'1 &6-1)!"

 " ?!

"

+

: @0@&6-1 )2

   !

" " ?: $+%" "



%#  ";



% 

/ "

(



"( 



 "



$ %

" % % #$ % 

/ "(



"(

 "

$" "

4%



"  !

-.

2

"

   

#"  

% "

$ "

""



""



"

4"#

3  "



 % "

;  $ # # "   "

#  3

%   2

"

% 

  ;  ":"  , #

# % " % " % 

 

#

; 

 

" %

 "(   % "

% #;

 8

"  !

-.

2

"

    " 

%   ( 

" 

 



# % " "  

 "( 

% "

 #





" "#$ %  !

-.

#$ 

"#

 #

2

"

  



$ " 
 

2 2

"





    #4  " 
 

2    

 $

#

$

% "  

" "

     $ " :" 
 

2    

 " 

" 

"   

;



 $ 



% " %   " " "   

 #  

  @@&6-@ A " #4 #

 









 "% % " 

  .-1&6-@ /),)+-2 !"

  A" "! ,

B    CB A" "

#  CB