← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/26788/2022allowed

M/S Bansal Agro Mills v. State Of Punjab And Others

2022-12-08Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur18 pages

  

     

 !"!#$!%&'

(   

  

     

   !  )   

     

   ! # (*    $ " %

&     

   ! '

* 

(      

   ! )

+ *+%

&     

   ! ,

, 

(   

  

   ! -

$

%

       

   !  ))  . !

/$        

   ! 0 (,  $"%

     

   !   )*   !

 $       

   ! 12!34256+789:%178%4!77:4*9!  3 "  ;<   " 

1=5,-  1   ;

< >   *

 >

;<  5

*

;<  " ?

@

1=5 ,-0,;,);,);,'; ,#;,;,-00 ,#   A $;<   " 

1=5,0)  $ A



 ;

< >   8



 $ ;<  $ 

;< 

#    "  ;$;

 

 -   :

 A



 

  > "



<<

  >  "

  4><;    .  

< &;  



A A1=5,#    

 



     

& >&   >  "

 

     A"

   , >  & A    "&A

   <     "&&  " 

   A "A

 # %  ;     " A

1=5,#  

 

 

 A



""&

AA 

     "   (1%   A  ""   A    "& A

"

 

1

A



& *  # ?

 1 #@

&      

 4><;(%!5,



';'0;',-;',; '-;%1 

-;;;#?@  <  1 "  A   

  

       ; +

 "

  





   

" A CCA     .



<

  

  

;>

  <   " A  "

  ;  ""   " A > A



  (%!

 &"

"



A   ; >



00> <  " A ""  

'  



A 1AA  "&: " A &

  "&      >

  :  ; < "

  ;  >   &   



 A 1AA   " A

 AA  A     "&#

 "

&    

  "

A



(%!5,:    



A 1AA >   &>& ""   

A"     &    

    ;

 "

; ""   &< ; 

 "

&1 & 

  

 &       " A

  A    &  

 &  A    



      ; >    

 A

   (%!



 

  A     " A   %  "

     "

& ""   &;" A  

 A >   "

 & ' :  ;   #; 

 * A 8

; ""     *

!

 *  * <!

 >   &      AA &;   



        "

 

     1    A    "& 

 A       

 * A 8

;  ; 

 >

 " A   

 #: "  <     " A  ""   1   # 

 "& 

     ""   &   ;  A    &  D

     " A

A



   (%!2 ';   

>

)    " A   

   );

 "

  >

""  

 1 "&       " A 4><;>  

  



&  " A

 "&;< ,"

& 1; A   " A    "&& 

   "A

     " A     

  <

  ;" A "" 

1  >& > "  ) 1   ;+

1



 &*

  >

;<  5

*

;<  > " ; <      A  $; <  ""

    " >      

""

"   A &

     >.   A

 "&; "

    A  <

  

 >     "

 

;

<  <  "

" 



  1

 %

  &        < %

       " A& 

  ""

   "  A A

"&         "&

 

   (%! 5  ,



 ;   ;+

;>

"

  

" ;    

A CCA ; >

    

   >    

A A

"

& & 

;

  ; " A  

A



    (%!  %

       ; "



  <  "     <





< "



<. 





  " 

   

 &A

  1

,  "<

& %

 

   > > >     " &     (%!

 B  >     A  > D

>   "



"&>  : 

>    "     

     (%! >   >   &   ""    &; >  & "

       ;  

 

"

 "

>    "  "

  

     1     "<

 &   :          "" 

 "

& ""   &   ;  A 

 & , %

   

' 

       *

+ 

* A8

 <        

 (%! 5   ,     " < AA 

>     "

  A



  (%!;  ;    . 

 A > :    " "   >



; ><; <    , A    "  <

    

    "" 

  %

        ""    &  & .



     A   

    (%!> 

 "" "  &<

  :  ""    &    (%! 

 

   > "   A

A CCA  "&  

AA

"

  

 & & 

 & A

  (%! A 

A A

 "

  A.  A 







<



"

&  >: "  



< A



 (%!

B E  & 

  

-   A  &  



 A   



    

; 1

"  

; >

 &   ""    &   

 &  (       "  1

 '' ?

@     A  >  > A A ; & A; &A

>.

 "  > "    .

< &   & 

&   A   A

;   

      

        "

 . 

 " ;



 

  :  ;  "

& 1  ,

 >  

 -  ;  $ A

 

 ;   

 1



 &8



 $ ;< ;""

   

"

&

  > "

A



;   "  

   D 

    A&    "" >

   A

 < &

 "

 1%

   A

 1#  

   "



  



  %

 

 

"

  

>  "    ;    

 > >

     "   "  A A

 "&  4   1

 - ?<

@  ?<

@< A &  A  

   ;  "

"





 A CCA ;>   



   1

 - ?<

@      A & AA      > " 

AA   



 A

    &  

 "<

&?

@;

A       A %

  "  





"



      ""    &  

 < >;

 

  

  ""

 "  AA

"&       "&%

   >     *

+ 

* A8

(%!5,

 

 ;   ;+

; 

"" 

    "A > . 

 A    ;

     1   < >        ""    &  % <  

    "  <      "

    0 : "

&



& 

1

      > "  

A



; A& 

""

<  " >

 & < ;

A



;

"

 > ">



,    1

   %

 

 >  D

  &     A  

A   

  & "

"  >   < A&    <    4   1     ">



,  1

 %



"""  ;    

 &;>   

>  

A&

"< &>?

.%/.-#0"/.&&%1"2#0!"3"2.2!  (  

(4 ./.#."/2#. 2.2! .#%   .5 " 3" /.05/ 1"1 /.0 /.67..&%2/!#" 80$!8.6(

,@:    

A&   ""<  "

."

< >     * #

       "&

  "

 A; >

> &

A "A

 



 ;

1 

  < >     < &B



0 D

  >

  ;

1 

    

&    &       , "

& 1; > D

 >

  :   

"

 D  (%!5 ,   

 

     





     

"      .

 %

 

 (%!; >

& A 

        ""



     "   A    "

 

        > 

&  ""   & 

   <

   1 #  

B     "" <

>;A > 

>   "



 "& >       "    "

   A

; ><;< ,"

&1;  A  <

  :  

  

   

 "" 

 

 "

  (%!     

; > "    "    ; >

>.   "&

   "&    ; >

 > 

 

    < A   :  >

 >          <& 

 

>     

        >   :  1

A 

 

& #  <

  &  >



 

 & A 

 A    "&;>  A >

     <  

  <  A & AA 

  



  A     "& 1!: "

&     > > 

"

 A

  "

&: 





 

 .

  

 (  

  

A   <

     

              !!;       A

 <



 D

 >   

 >   

  :        >  >   ""



   " >  

  "

 

: < ""    

A

"



3 9'

    

       

                         !"             "           "          # 

      "     "

         

    "           



                          $  (""  ""

   

  ; >  <    >  <

   1 #  :  A F  G  

1

?

@>  1

?@

> 

F+

"

G1

#"

F!

 GA >

 & < 

>   "A >  

  A   

 >  &   A



'; )   ,     "

&  1

 # ?

@ "

    

 &  

 &" ;>   ;

  <       A    

     & 

 %

   &   &

 >





; "

1

#?

@ ?@1

'

A  F1   A 

 

G>  1

,   F  A   &G  1

 - 

A  F7<      G   :  <

  "

 

> &  3 %&'( )#  *           "         

 



 +          '

  "   

( "  

+ 



           

 ,-    "   '( 

+        

  "    ' ().# *   

   

 

                         

        "    

 

 

  

           

         

              

   

+        

,- /'( '0(      

   "  '     

"

 

       1    ( 

  

        '        1    (          

   



  2 '(' (                   3 "     4  

   "#,       #-         

         

 '

(      

        4      1       #-         5++ 1     #-    / 

        1   

  #-       "                 "    #,  5++ 1   

    "   #-  1   #,

#-   "    "   #,         6 '"(     '(   7

 +   '(+ '(+ 8 '(+#  +. +.+         "  '(          "         

 " 4  

 



  

      



   

            

   

 #,'

   (   '(7

 +   '(+ '(+8 '(

      4         1       '"(         +  +      

         

  99  

+    

   :

"    

+   

   :    

         

#  

  ,- 

+     1    #  +,-  3 "          

          "   '(        "   

  

  "                    

       -   -+, ;+-  -+    - 

   "        

 <7-     

,-    

  "      

      1               + $ # :     A

     

 >     "       %  A    

   F  G

 1

?

@; A ;>      <  A

A



 "&  

"A

 

AA

&  "

  "<

& ;>     

>   &  "



(1  "<

&?

@;            : 



       

     "  

   A    "&     A  <1!

 "<

&   " (1%;



 



A <   

 

>     "



 



   

  &    ;  &       " 

   

1

?

@ 1# ' (    & 



 ""

      1

 - ?<

@   ?<

@  A

<    

' "  

   2 

  1

-;

 ;

      A A  

  "<

 

 

 

 A      &      "&



"

&; " #   #   $  

 

 <    A"   "<



A

1#





&



     &<   1

-?<

@  ?<

@;   "  

      ; >

 > 

&    

""

 A AA

 "&   A "A

     



 1

-?<

@ ?<

@>   

   A &AA ?

@   > " ?

@

?

@AA ?

@   



    A        &  

 "<

&?

@;

A 

       A      A    

    ;   "

 "

 

A 

   A CCA %

   A

(%!5,> 

;   "

A

  

 >    "   A & AA   A  A



   ;   

;"  

>   

>  >.  A

"&%  "

  1 ;   "   <        

 1

  ?

@; >   &

   

1

-?<

@/?<

@  

>

 <     <;

   1 #

 

    A" 

     >

;     &

" & ""   &;

 A  

   ; "

  



A 

<<

)

   ; 

     

   A CCA   

   <& 



        &"





(1  .

 &  "A (1%  ; "



"A (1% <



"



 "  

&



A"

  



 A  ;

A"

> 

  

      "    

 1

 - ?<

@ 1#  

 1

-?<

@>    

A      >     & >  

     < &?

@  

 <&"

>  A ; A&

 A >   "

    A    

 (%!  

  "



A

;   .   A" 

;  

 "

 

   " &  &     "



: 

  < &

A  &  

 

    

 "

  <& 

  A  &  "

  &; <  

 

 

 (%!;  A&

 A >   "

  A  



:  ;

1 >     1

-?<

@

"

   

 "      1

-?<

@

>     "   

    A & AA  <        

    "

 "



&  "<

&?

@;   &  &  ""   &" & 



>  

  &A 

, ) : 



 ""

     & &

1

,?D@     

A

"

A  

A

B A  

A ; A.   AA & 1 

 

;    

>  A  

  &    &; A

   &  "

  &; >

 

    

A  

A  %

>

 "

< >   ;>    A "

&.  A 

 < A      &         "&   , :   A 

  &

A

  



"

"

>  " %  "

   ; 

 

"

 "

>         &   "

 &  ; "

 <

"

 



 

"

   >;:

 &    A >    "      "

                  

 

   &   "<

A A

 "

  :  ;

   " A  

        ; A 

    (%! 

  " ?

@  "



     "&  :  

   (%!        





      A CCA     

; >

  "



   &1

A



& :  

" "

;<   &< >  1

A 



& 

 "<

& ;  ;  A  

 

      

  

"

 >    A  

- "

  &; A    "& 

 > &



 A; >   <    &   " *

+       A  "&  

 &; "



 <&

521;>

>   

  > :  A< >> . & ""   &;>  



  "

  



 A  1AA  

   AA  A

 

 >  A   "

 &

;

 > >      ""   & 

   &   -      A  

&   

 1

    "  "

&1

>  

;  ""    &  &

 

 

  (%!5 ,; >

    

 &     

 

"";  A : 

  

<   1  "

        A      

  <  > 

;

  

"" 

  A& . 

  " > &   

"

(%!5 ,%  "

  1 ;"

&1 ,



     A

 

 < >    

  

<  %  "

  1 ;  .  "



  >.   A

 "&

  <   

 "

; >  <   

"<

&   A"&

>   "<

"



&  "

  "<

&  

   %

       A

  

 >    

 "



;

 

    "

 &; >    

  ; >

   

   "  4><;

 A

<  

1

""

 " ;

 &A  

 

;

 

>  1

A



&2     A

"&  " ;  

 "<

  "

>

 A . " > 

<. & "



 <    0 1

B &;   A"

 

 

      > "

  >  :        >   "   

 >     >.   A

 "&   "   A  

 & A>  "



 

 -

 !:!;<!#

4   . H =   ".

  I 5 =  "  I 5