← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaSAO/82/2018dismissed

M/S Tulip Service Station (Bharat Petroleum Dealers) v. Usha Bhardwaj & Others

2018-09-11Mr. Justice Satpal6 pages





         

  !!"#$#%&!' !()!*+

,$-.#'!*/#"!  #% ''!..% 0!*$-$

$11*234%2 1!*$  !$'%2!% $   &5 67

   

*!$!% &

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

2!!%2% !124#%!2 1!$!*/#"!#% 1!(% 1-:-$ +@@A%% #%# #.$.*8 $>>,5'!*(% 1!2#!2%>>2-*#%: 1!"-*$! 1#$!('.8(!% !3$$1  )8-%?%3%'!*$%$31!%1!3$:#%:



2!'$#  1!"$1 1!2!!%2% 6$$!*/#"!$  #%%2% 1!*'! *. '-('+%(!.84 #238." !2 2!.+#$ *#"  .3.+31#"148 1*(  3$  $$"# !5"-(5 %:!*    1  #(!  1!  3$  "**8#%:  % (-%    $++,5+    31#"1  $@++,5  3$  *(  ,$  4

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

*!3$%C-!$ #% %83#..-.2!-. *%!:.#:!%"!% 1!'*  1!2!!%2%  %  *2!*    '*/!  1!#*  "$!+  1!  '.#% #$  !D(#%!2  $1 1*234+3#23 1!2!"$!2$ E+31 !%2!*!21!*#2/# *!# !* #%: 1!"% !% $ 1!'.#%   1!2!!%2% $!D(#%!2B#$1*! 1*($E 1!.!*%!2*#.-* 1!.2 1 % 1!)$#$ 1!!/#2!%"!+# "-.2% )!"%".-2!2 1  1!*!3$%8%!:.#:!%"!% 1!'*  1! 2!!%2% $ 3$1!.2 1  1!2!"$!2"-.21/!"..!2 1!'.#"!* ""('%8#%:1#( 2!'$#  1!"$1+)-  1!$(!1$% )!!%2%!!

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

3$*!C-#*!2 )!'$$!21!*#.-* 12% 2%!$  -* 1!*+%.8 1!$!*/#"!$  #% ,$-.#'!*/#"!  #%12 )!!%#('.!2!2$2!!%2% #% 1!$-# 1!3*# !%$  !(!% 12)!!% #.!2)8( 0!!*( #+'*'*#! * 1! -(''.!2#%: 1 #%%"#.

%2(*?! #%:#*$ 1! -('3!*!)!#%:.?!2 !*)8%!B#$1*!

1*(-%2!*'*#/ !"% *" 1!.!*%!2''!.. !-* !.  1  1! *#.-* + # $3%( #%+-:1  1/!**8!2,#('.!2!2 1!1*

! *.!-(  ('%8  7 2*  $1*  F 7G  %2  B#$1*!  1*(  $ 2!!%2% $*!!" #/!2!"#$#% 1!"$!$ 1!2!.!*$1#' 1!'! *. '-('12)!!%.. !2)8 7%.8# "-.22#$".$!  1!-*  1!

!*($%2"%2# #%$ 1  1!2!.!*3$*!C-#*! "('.83# 1#%*!$'!"  $!"-*# 8 )!(#% #%!2  1!'! *.'-('1!2!"#$#% 1!$-# #% 1! )$!%"! 73$% 4-$ ##!2$ 1!*#.-* 3$*!(#$$% 1! *!$#2"-% $+ 1!4-2:(!% %22!"*!! 1!*#.-* 3$$! $#2!

%2 1!"$!3$*!(# !2  1!*#.-*  #*$ 2!"#2! 1!''.#" #% 1!  '.#% #    $-!  $  6#%2#:!%  '!*$%6+     #('.!2  B#$1*!  1*(+ 0!!*( #%2 7$2!!%2% $%2 1!%2!"#2! 1!( !*$'!*.3 7!*%!2 "-%$!.* 1!''!..%  1$"% !%2!2 1  1! 72 73!*''!.. !-* 1$#.!2 % #"! 1  1!*#.-* 1$.*!28 2!"#2!2 1  1!'.#% #3$% "/!*!2-%2!* 1!2!#%# #%6#%2#:!% '!*$%6 -* 1!*+B#$1*!1*(%2 7"-.2 )!$ )!"%$#2!*!2$ '*'!*'* #!$%2 1!*#.-* 4-2:(!% "-.2% )!$! $#2!% 1! :*-%2 1!#*%%5#('.!2(!% !*:-!2 1 %"! 1!1*  ! *.!-( *'* #%7 212:#/!% 1!*! #.- .!   1!2!.!*,'*'*#! *$+ 1!8 3!*! #%2!'%2!% .8*-%# %2 1! 712%*.!#% 1 *!:*2 1!*!$#2"% !

% #%$ 1!72-%$!.* 1!''!..% 2 % #%%838%-..#8 1!*!$%#%: 1!7273!*''!.. !-* 31#"1 "%% )!-. 2  $'!* 1!'*/#$#%$ *2!*<<<  1!''.#" #% *'!*(#$$#% $-!$%#%2#:!% '!*$%3$*!C-#*!2 )!2!"#2!2#*$ %2#% 1!!/!% # $)!#%:*!-$!2+ #(!*'8(!% "-* !!3$ )! :*% !21#$'*"!2-*!1$% )!!%..3!2 -* 1!*# 3$% 2#$'- !2 1  1!-%* -% !#%"#2!% 12""-**!231#.! 1!2!"$!23$"**8#%: "$1*2!'$# #%: 1!$(!#% 1!)%?1!#$$-! )!2!"#2!23$ 1! %!:.#:!%"! 1!*!$'%2!% 2!"#2! 1!#$$-!# 3$%!"$$*8 ?%3  1! !*($%2"%2# #%$+#%8+ 1 2!.!*3$*!C-#*!2 "('.8 3# 1#%*!$'!" $!"-*# 8 )!(#% #%!2  1!'! *.'-('1#$"-.2 %.8)!2#$".$!2)8 1!

 71!*#.-* 2#2% "%$#2!* 1#$$'!"  ..%2"-*$*#.82#$'$!2 1!



%6).!-'*!(!-* #%   



    

   

!"## $% 1$!D'.#%!2#%2! #. 1  1!2- 84-2:!#$ 2#$"!*% 1! *- 1 %2 1  1!*!2!C- !'*/#$#%$#% 1!2!#/#. *"!2-*!31#"1"% )!-$!2* 1 !%2 3$)$!*/!2&         

$                         



       !"

##$  #% &#'          ( (   )*            + , ( ) *        -

&

.

 .

   +  /        (  0        12 32 

         (  (            

                     !"

141)44% &12*      

5     

 (

  11        

   

                                             ( +     ( (     

     16*.        * 

     

  +        ( 7

            ((        (  (   (            (     8        

 9* ()            

 :(       

:

   (                      13;  <       

 (

 =                 

       <     1$*=(     

   +  +   (   !"

$4>  1>% ?1>'&  

   ( + -5



"   % 

   ? ( <(                  

  5 1>@   A   

B    !"CB $1% ?'*   D (E      

             <       DE      ( 

 5 14        *    0  *      

 <                       ,   (

8  ?   

   ( + 5 *     

  

   F  (           ( 1G@  

   !"CB$6% ?'*5  (     (          

      ((

 '5 6H;            

     .

   (          



    << <<< << << 61?'

('5"  ?  5%        .

    * * ( 

       I * *           

     (!

?    F 

        ( (    

  (       5 1!''!.. !-* *2!*%.8"#.#  !$ 1#$)4!" #/!1!*!#$ %#%#*(# 8#% 1!#('-:%!2*2!* #$(#$$!2 !' !()!*+      :#%  E1! 1!*'!?#%:, !$%!2 !$ E1! 1!* !'* ).!

!$,