Pernod Ricard India Pvt Ltd v. M/S Showhouse

   

         

!"#$#%&'&()


#*($&%!*$($&!+","$ --#..!("

/#*'0'

'1210'# #'-($#("

)  3,   4 ,  *#'#(")5 *1&"0$6$+%!"#6*!--#..!(" 
 71#"1#*"1##-*"#*'.%!.(#2'-!-#*8!9:#!..2#$" '##"1#;0$<8#("=  :#*##**#$""1##-*"#**("  71#"1#*"1#;0$<8#("'10.$:#*#-*"#$&("1#$&<#'"= 55 55 , 

, --#..!("5$##($!("5%8-!(9  &'  !<<*&#+#$  :9  *$#*  $!"#$
>


?   ((#@0*#55
 6-!''#$:9"1#.#!*(#$ $$&"&(!.&'"*&%" 0$<#6  0*0<*!86  +&$#  21&%1   *$#*  $!"#$  A
?  ((#@0*#55
 6 -!''#$:9.#!*(#$ &+&.0$<# 0(&*&+&'&( 6 0*0<*!862!''#"!'&$#6 +&$#21&%1-.!&("&.#$:9-.!&("&5*#'-($#("2!'*#;#%"#$ "  %8#'  0"  "1!"  -.!&("&5*#'-($#("  1!$  &.#$  !  '0&"  * *#%+#*9'
?6?6B  56 %.!&8&(<"1!"&"2!'*#($#*&(<'#*+&%#'" !--#..!("5$##($!("5%8-!(9"&'%.!&8#$"1!"&("1#9#!*

6"1#*#2!' %1!(<#  &(  "1#  8!(!<#8#("    !--#..!("5$##($!("5%8-!(9   +#( "1#*#!"#*6  -.!&("&5*#'-($#("

 2!'

 *#($#*&(<  '#*+&%#'

 " !--#..!("5$##($!("5%8-!(9 "&'0*"1#* %.!&8#$"1!" %#*"!&(&(+&%#' 2#*#("1(0*#$:9!--#..!("5$##($!("5%8-!(9!($"1!"'8#&("#*#'" 0-"9#!*
A1!'(":##(-!&$1#%&+&.'0&"2!'&.#$( 
A 1#.#!*(#$ &+&.0$<# 0(&*&+&'&( 6 0*0<*!86+&$#*$#* $!"#$ A
? ((#@0*#55
 6*#%*$#$"1#&($&(<'"1!"!'-#*&(+&%#6

55 "1#-!98#("&'%.!&8#$*#<!*$&(<&(+&%#$!"#$ 

 ""1#'!8# "&8#6  &"  1#.$  "1!"  !(  58!&.  $!"#$  >
A   $#'   ("   !80("  " !%C(2.#$<8#("$#:"!($2&..("#@"#($"1#.&8&"!"&(0*"1#*6&"2!' 1#.$"1!"0..!($&(!.-!98#("2!'!%%#-"#$:9-.!&("&5*#'-($#("!($ "1!"  "1*0<1  58!&.  $!"#$   >
A6  (.9  %#*"!&(  !80("  2!' !%C(2.#$<#$!'0(-!&$:&..'!'-#*"1#&*%!.%0.!"&('1##""2!'0*"1#* 1#.$"1!"!%C(2.#$<8#("2!'("8!$#$0*&(<"1#-#*&$.&8&"!"&( "#*   1#!*&(<   "1#   .#!*(#$   %0('#.   * !--#..!("5$##($!("5%8-!(96!8"1#+&#2"1!"*$#*$!"#$ A
?

((#@0*#55
 6  -!''#$  :9  "1#  .#!*(#$  &+&.  0$<#  0(&*  &+&'&( 6

0*0<*!86<#':#9($"1#'%-# *$#*?0.#

 &+&.*%#$0*#

$#6
 ''08&(<"1!"'8#!80("&'%.!&8#$":#"&8#:!**#$6 12#+#*6-.!&("&5*#'-($#("!.' %.!&8'&("#*#'"0-"9#!*
A21&%1 *8&"'!%#&'(""&8#:!**#$0*"1#*61#%.!&8' 58!&.$!"#$>
A !'!%C(2.#$<8#("(-0*'0!(%#""1!" 58!&.6'8#-!98#("'2#*#!.' 8!$# 1#*#*#6 &($&(<' *#<!*$&(<0..  !($&(!. -!98#(" :#&(< !%%#-"#$ :9-.!&("&5*#'-($#("6%0.$(":#*#%*$#$&(!(!--.&%!"&( &.#$0($#* *$#*?0.#

  6
 1#-#*0'!.-.#!$&(<'-!*"&#'

'12'"1!"&"*#D0&*#'"1#.#!$&(<#+&$#(%#1#*#!"#*6"1# 0*"%!( $#%&$#!'"21#"1#*"1##("&*#%.!&8&'"&8#:!**#$!($21!"&'"1###%" 58!&.  $!"#$  >
A  !($  12  80%1  !80("  -.!&("&5*#'-($#("  &' #("&".#$"6&(+&#2&($&(<'=''0%16*$#*$!"#$ A
? ((#@0*#5 5
 6-!''#$:9"1#.#!*(#$ &+&.0$<# 0(&*&+&'&( 6 0*0<*!862!'

*&<1".9'#"!'&$#:9.#!*(#$$$&"&(!.&'"*&%"0$<#6 0*0<*!86+&$#*$#* $!"#$
>


? ((#@0*#55
 !($"*&!. 0*"2!'*&<1".9$&*#%"#$" $#%&$#"1#%!'#!*#'1:9%($0%"&(<0...#$<#"*&!.&(!%%*$!(%#2&"1

55 .!21#*#&'(&..#<!.&"9*&(&*8&"9&("1#*$#*6-!''#$:9"1#.2#* !--#..!"# 0*"1#*#*#6&('"!("!--#!.&'$&'8&''#$

,   



';C' 71#"1#*'-#!C&(< *#!'(#$ ) #' 71#"1#*#-*"!:.# )