← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3523/2023dismissed

Neelam v. Dharamvir

2024-05-28Mrs. Justice Sukhvinder Kaur9 pages



            



  !"

#$%&'%()*)&+,    

  !" --- !  ./! 

 01

0 

2%*%+$

#$"!% &!  ''''

3456)+7%20#328  ) %!" *& "*+,   &&)  %!% & " )%!""*+*! -!

*!.

 ".

 !&   &&."  "  / &&%!& %  "

& " &!"% !! &&% """" 0  $  "& +" " !!&  $  "! ""! * " ) !  ) !&   &&"+*!""!* %%".  %!1   &!& 2 % !  ) "&"&!  )$% * )!& )  "!+ !(   &&&  +" !

  &&  2!  ! !!&  "$ &$"

!+  +$ -!

%!!

%!%  !   ! ! !!&  "$ "%&! ! !!&  "+!*"  &!

  )"       !.  2! ! !!& ""% *" !!&  &



 ) %%""  ""!).  ! "&! &  -

 34"2. & 5*! $+

" (   && "*  ) " %"% !"+!&     " "&"$.

! 

*"!&  $ ) &! % "

!!" 4 *&   * "  ) &! *)  )$ "

&  "%!& "%  "&".      " + "*) ) && !& !+!&   && "  !. )%"%! ( "+)!!"

 !.  "&"" . & %! !!  !. 

! ( "&"" . &.  )& "

% + !  .    &&" +. "!  )!  ! ..

!+ "" ! "&"" . &    &! & "

!!" " &4 *)"   &&)! "!   0" & +!&  &&5

*". "!&!&!  % !&"&!*  " +6"   &&!!))  "&!%  ) !4 *)" *!

! )!$.

   &&" 

*"!% " 71 #. !& ) /!

 "6" ! +% & "%!+!& 2*" !& "

!."*+   &&$ %!6!.$!    " !%6$   " "*&"*+ " !&.!& %  !

 ""$! &!

"&"" !  &!

!&         &&     * "        & +  *"     !  .!

!%% !$ "&"" . & "6 !(   ! 8!&!*  )!"&!)  ) +&!%  )! 

 &!

"&"   &&. " %!!!& "&"" . &$" "&". "!  )!  !$ 8% " "

 & %"!!6")!&& "

% + !   !"!!*   ) !&   &&! !

! 8!&%! )&!  !&%  )!)  !+4

*)" """" 0   & %  !

"!%  " !

%!!&& "+"*+ "&"" . &"!

%! " !. "!   && 9 :!! %$!","&"""& ".    *+  6 )    +  !*2% !  )" )    *  +; !;2 " %%4.)" "" " "" 1  !) ) %! " ! %   !<,9  , < 4.!)" &! " "" "*% *"*+)  "= !   % !!&   &&"  %! " ! "*% "*+   &&  %!& *) $(   !&)  !!& "" 1  !"  ! !&.!""% !"

.  %!!&   &&4.!)"   &&)!  "!!>*  ) !   0" %! " !.

  ?"*+   &&!!

  )8 4. )" .& "

% + ! !&   &&.  "&"" "&"" . &. "!  ) !  !!   &&"   && " "   "  ( "&"...*!

*! ""

9 .

 .  8% "  &!   *  %! " !  *+       &&  "

  !.!% !"! * !&  """" )$ ""* " )!  ) !&   &&    &&!& " % !! . & "

*+ "&"$.

"+ ) !& . "

 " "    0 @!     " )  !&        &!!. )   "  . &"A  

  

   

 

 



      

 

        ! " 

  

   



#!

!    $  ! 



!   % &      '

% ( 

  

 '$  ! ! !     %    '

 '$ !

   !

% ) *  B &!$  "  %  "% C  !&  &&."  "*+  -!

$ " ")  "  "%  ""  0 9 0  (     &"  *+   ,  &&*&! @ -!

."  "$ " ")""%"" B 7%$ ) %!"

 *& "*+ ,  && < D"%!

&! ,  && %!"" 

  -!

 & "!%  &%   &&.  )

" %"% !"+!& "&"" . &" & " !

* &"&! % % %( "= " *)  .+"! &!

"!% " +"  + .+! & "+"*+ "&".    &&7  ) "          !&  "  =     !&  !  %     %! " !.! "  %"! $D*"$ . !& )""" !%6. 7 %!""  

!!*% "*+ -!

*!. "&" "!

!

%!&!+!+ %! " !!&$ $ ,!   &&7  * "  "!.!

"   " )%! " !!&6 %.

 6 !&  !+.! 6 %  + 7  * "   &&. " & * &   . !.!&  !+"!+&!  !$ "

8% "#!.!&!+ &! !&  $ )!!"&  7 

)"   *.!)+ " . & "*+   && % " 5/"   !

!"  !!& 8%  !!& ""*+ 4 !!& %! !$  %" % ! 2 ")!&7!5* -!

    

 

            -  !!&<0 $"% ""!B<0"   

       -  !9!& 0$"% ""!   0   4  ""%!

&! " )!

0 !

%!"  &% !"  "   &&.!.!&! %!&"(.!"".8% "*+   &&$! &!

 !&    &!&!

%!&" """""  9 "".% )"*+   &&*+&  ) "

! ""&! 8%.8% "*+   && &!

*  "&"    """"" 0  $ .

  "% )   ( " " 

 "% """" 0  *  )  ! " & "  !!) !E8 *   *)"   ""  .  8% "  "     "

  & %  "  & "  *+   "&""!%! " !. "!    !&&!&  "/  6*+   &&!*%!+!%

!   ! " )"  . " "

 & % "! !  "$ )" & ".+" ! *+ "&"  !).    . &  /!         %!" %!+  "

%! !% ! 4%!& "

 & % " 6!.") !&  !&% !* )&&%"*+ *  %!&& "$ .!

"*!*  !

!&  !&  "% ! +*%     .  +  "  !  %  !   "!  !  )      !     !!& "

 & %  4 *)" !.!!%% !$ "&""  . & "6 ! (   ! 8!&!*  )! "&!6 )  +&!%  )! &!

"&".



B

 ) .!* "! !

 " "

 & %"*+ 6 ) ")!&& "

% + !*.  /   ! %!&   &&  . .!.

!.!. !& " &&%*.""" +,) "!% 

!!$ &% !!*6!!& "" "* % *"*+)  "=  "  % !!&   &&"  "*8% "  %!&.! ).  % " )  )D*"(  ."*&! (  ", * ) $".)!) ".   "". >)  )    "8 "$! ! #F  *8 " =9$.

! ""!" ! 0  $   &&)!""!0C,8% ")" ) !&9C6!&" &!

"&""  """

"*+"*+ " % !!& &   %!&   &&  & )"+ )  ""!% $ . "!!   &&" "&"$" . " "

 )" !  &!!&   %!&  ) . 7 " +."*+ &   "

= )  !.

"   ) %!!" ) ! +7 " " &!")" ) %  )!&%! " !!&6   "%&! "&"  "!&8%  !!& """" 0  $ .& +%!% !

".! " "

 & %!&+!". !  !!"% " )!!"!*"

C 9

=! D*"$.

!.!!&  ) . !& &! """ !"!"!    ( (  "$.

! ") " "" "!*8 " =B "  & ")" ))  !!& ""*+&!!. ) "

!%"

  . E8 .& " % "5/"         "  ! 5  .

    ""  ""  0    . )"*+   &&5! ( .  "*& "

*+   &&2! +.  "&"!& %$.        !B  !&      "  .       

 

"&"  %.*!& " % &! * %! " ! !

"""" 0  4!<!& " . .

."

+ )"*+   &&$ . !"

"&"!   &&  % "&" 8% !&" !

) """ &!

!&"&"!9 "&"  %&! *%! " !" !&$ $ ,

"*% "*+"&"!   &&  %&! "&""  !!& """ "* ) +% !"!$ 

* ) +!*"*+ -!

*!.$ $

 &

  " "       &! "  .          ""  ""

0  ."

+8% "*+  &!

"&"

  &!%! " !!&$ $ ," %! " !. % "*+ &! "&" 0 "   !+   !& 

<  )$     "  6    E  -$    !$     -!"  !$ & )!")!"!!).  !  !  !

!

&! !$ %* &"  %!

" !+*  % "*+   &&&! %! " !.

.% "

*+ &! "&"$!! !

% "*" %!"*+   && ".

 %!

"  % "*! "  =!  $D*"$ !"!")" ) )!& %! " ! .

 " $ $ ,.) !   &&*+ "&"  %"+*&! 8%  !!& "" B !&$ %.% "*+"%!

&!  %!%"$  !&! * )*"! "  )  *&% "* )! %*  %  &%"% % %!& % C @! !%!""*!$ ) %!"

&  "!! +1  !!&.  *   !!&. < ""  "* )*&!&      " )   % !$  &  +$  !  "  " !"  !& %%!" )+  01

0"

 , +

=  6 ),!"

G,!

=  !* G,!