Esi Sandeep Kumar And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others
! "#$# %&'('
)*' '
$ ' # # % *+$, $- %. % +$, !
"
#
! $%"
"
&
' ()
/& 01 /' ) / )1 * + ,'- ./)0 + 1 1 2'/)0 + - 33 /'1/ / )12'+ 1, $ 0
)') 0 / 2 0 3 / 33 0
4 - 3 ) 0)0/ 0 3
2 ' 5 .
0' 6
7 -.
. "8"9" 2 3 ( 0 1 ' '0/ + , 0' :
, !
;
4 0 . ":2 0' ! 5
'04 05
-2-
!
'5 '. - 3''0 3' :2 0' 0 3 '$! <3'0 '/$%!8='03' > =
?@> 3' ' 5 0' :
, !
;
4 A 5 2 :2 0' " , 0 5 2''. .:2 0' 30 2 52 3' 8 : 0 ' . 3 2 . :2 0' 30 2 ' 3 ) - 3'5 .
.
0 5 2 ' ) 0' 3 0' 2
0 ' 3'
/' 0 ' 3 0
.7) . . 0 7) . 0 30 0 3 3'' 3'037) . . 0 5 ) . (1 '
""%"8 0' . 3' 3 00 ' 3' 7) ' 0 '
0 2 3' 0 5 '. '
""%"8
-3- (120 03'2*
! "#!$ %
$ "" & ! " #! " "'" " $ ( ""
"" " " ! " #!
-4- " ' ' ( "- ( " ( " $ ( "" ( ( ( !" #! $ . "( "$ / 0 1 )*2') *2 $3 9 4 ' '
/ )
)'
7 3. 0 ' 3.
+
3 B '. '03' ' % 5 3' 3' .) 3 '$!$ 2 '$! $!95 ' 03'2*
/!1 " $ 4 $ " - ( " " 5" $ 6 - ( (- "$ . ( $ /71 8 " "
-5- (
( ( " " " $ (
"
""
" " " " $ /91 , "
" " "5" ) # * 4 ,( $ ) # * " !9$: !9$; !9$< !9$= ( "
"$ 4 *"
"2 "
!9$!>/!1 ( "
"$ , "2 "
!9$!?/!1 ( " "$ 4 ) # *4
"$. (
$ @ ( 5 $ /A1 @ - " # ( ( 2 /A1)!: $
-6-
/!1 ) #
- ",!9$;$ (
$ # $. (
5 (
$. (
" / 1 :7B "
C "5 ( 4 . / 4.1 " D / 1 9?B D /1 >9B " ' " ' 5" " " " ( "
#$ /71. ( 4 . " " "- ( " >$7? ($ 4 "" ( 4 .
(
-7- " $.
( 4 . " $
" - ( 4 .$&( - ( "" " ( $ / 1 ) "" " !> ( (
" /1.
& >!D /1% >7D /1) >7D /1 >7D /16 " >9$ / 1. ( #$ ! "
# / 1 :7B ) " - "" ( 4 . 9? "? - ! E ( $ / 1 9?B ) " - #
$$ 9?B (9?A> " ? - ! E ( $ ( "" 9!
$ /1 >9B ) " -
-8- # >9B $$ " ' " ' 5" " " A> " - ! E ( $ /1 ( 5 " "2 ( "" ( 4 ./ 4.1 " 9?
" 5 A> D /1 5 ( "" ( 4 ./ 4.1 " " - D /1 :7B ( 9?B $ . 5 ( 9? 5 " ( 4 ./ 4.1 ( 9?
:7B9?B $ ( ( "" *"
( 5 $ ( *" '
-9-
$ $ %&
% 1 / 1.*2 " *" ( :7B 9?B >9B $ 4 *
( *"
" 2 " ( ( *"
" % $ . *
( "" * 2 " ' - "$ , (
4 . " " " 5 $ / 1. " $ . ( /1 4
%
!>F7 >!
.
. . >7 . *" . >9 2 /)$1 >9 2 / 41 >? (2 >< 2 /)1 >:
2 / 1 ><
-10- /1 /
1
'
>9
>7
>!
. ( 5 !>$
"!E " $ /1. % 5 ( " $ & " "9!* " ( ( ( $
( ! 7 9" ( !? !> >? "$ ,( " " $ 2 /* 1 %
" /* 1 %
, (( >! ) # !>
/!>%1 , ( ( >7 >: @
'
) , , 5 7 (
5 A ( >9 # *" >: ) @
2 '
), , 5 A >A # *" >? #
-11- (
5 : ( , 5 : (
5 < ( >? #
>?
/9%1 < (
5 !7 ( >:
" 6 " >? . G/9%1 , 5 !7 (
5 !: ( >; 8) >? 6/9%1 !: (
5 7>( >< % ) % G >? /9%1 , 5 7> ( !> * #
>? /A%1 /1@ % ( '"
(
"5
' , "
>? ,"
>7 . ' "
( ( E " ( $ (
#
() "# / 1,9?B
-12-
/!1 *"
/A1 $, ( !E ( 7 " ? -
5 7A 5" (( "(*2 @$ !7;'7>>< 77 " 7>>< ( # ( - ( (
# $ *
) "# / 1 ( 9B " ( *" (
" " " 2 - " 9!* " ( $ /1
" /!B1D /1 2 % ) 2 + * %'@ 2 G /!B1D /1 5" " " G/!B1
-13- / 1 6
" ( - " " 2 D " 9B " ( "
"" " $ +
/ 1,"
" # ( ' ( - ( D ( ( - ( # ( ( $ / 12" " ( #
:7B ( 9?B $
( " "" 9B & ) 2 ' * % ' @ 2 45" # $ /1 . ( $ ( "$
-14- /<1 . *"
"" *2 $.* 2 "" $ . * 2 H *"
' ,
- /!1 5 /, !9$</!1 ( " ( " $ ) ""
!9$?/71
" 2 I& ( ( - $. "
" I "" *"
" 2 "$3 $" ' ' $!$ / ) 3 '0 3 C00 0 .) . '0 0 D '0 2 0 2D '/ ' $! 0 3 ' 0 '0 0 :2 0' 2 3' 0' :2 0' C
0 5 0 !
;
4 A E ;A / 3' .!
-15- 0 2 !
;A / 3'3 2!
8" . 0 73 / D 0 ' "
@ D '. )0 & 0 0 3 0 ;2''!
;0 . '
'5 )
) 3'.. ) . '
'B (1 0
(
''0
'0 3' 3 :2 0' 0 . + - 0 3 3' '$! ' ) 2 ''
0 . 30 '$!9/ :2 0' 0 ' / 00 ' 0 3 . :
2'' -2 0. )
0 2 5 '2 2 0 7
.02 . 2 0 ''. 3 $$ 0< . ' $!$/ $! $!9 / 0 22 0 '2 ) 0 7 :2 0' /0' B 0 0' 5 0 0''0 )' )
0. 00' 05 2 3 5 30
0 ' ' 0 0 ' .:2 0' - 5 '03' '
-16- 3' 3 ') :
(1 0 0 ' 00 $ 7 2-3)0 ./
0 0 3 0 '' - 7 . ) 7 2 /
0 0 ' - ' ' 00 ' $! 7 3) / 7 3 0' /00/'' 3 ' 0' 3 20
0 3' + / )1, '(' 02'
-.6 * F6&
3'* F6&