Arjan Dev v. Devinder Pal Wadhawa And ORS
!""#$%$&'()(%!*+ ,- &".
"!$!$&", /",%(% ".$&0", 12 03 4 !3",% "%5&0"&!% !
"#$%& '()* & * + %
,"%"&!'
,67 %%$+0.# !"+ ,!3"5"!$!$&",
,,(&$&0 1+0.# !"
, $%3 8 $&+0.# !"+ ,,"%5&0"&!
, 9 &73 ,9 +0.# !"+ ,,"%5&0"&!% *
,7!! ,$4 1 +0.# !"
,6 5$163 && +0.# !"+ ,,"%5&0"&!:
, 3(13 ,) . +0.# !"+ ,,"%5&0"&!%; <<<<< * + %,' 2,$!!"&%! !"9"&!$1"0&8"3 1,"%5&0"&!% &0* !0 =$&(,!$%! >"&&,"#,0 3"5,"%"&!!, &%", 551$# !$&3 %8""&$1"0&8"3 1!3" 51 $&!$$& #$.$1%($!*0 !"0*?$1"0 !7 &),(,!$!1"0 % @,- & ". /",%(% ".$&0", 1 2 03 4 !3",%A #1 $9$&) !3"
114$&),"1$"'B @
!"" #$
% & '
( ) *
+
$
+ (
, -
(
$
( + ) ./ 0* +
(
+$
! 1 /
(
# +$) ./
23
3 , ! "!,1"(9,5, !$&C!0 : ;* 3 98 1 ",!$1$D",% &0 3"9$# 1 C!0 * * ;: $9 #3 1 (!(,$%!$#99(&$# !$& C!0 ; :
:;
$&0(%! & "!,1"(9 ,5, !$& C!0 : ;
:*?: C!0 :
* C!0 ?
* &0$ &#,=1$#%C!0 :; C!0 ?;
727!""1C!0 *?
,%7!4 ,"
*:
&)1," "$&",= &0 "!, 3"9$# 1C!0 ; *
,"5"&C 8, !,$"%C!0 ; * * ,8"&"
:
"&! 9"0$ , 5 ;
*:?*
4", $& &#",5C!0 :
??
&0$ C!0 ; ?
;
%3,$ 3"9$# 1% &0 ",!$1$D",% C!0 * ;
!! 9/ 1("7!""1%C!0 ? ?* / ,(&73$55$&)95 &=C!0 4
$
#
-
/
!
1
5
#
/
,
(
# ( +
+$
(
$
6
+$
# 7
+
$
$
$
(
6
#
/
! 1
# +
,
$
4".",+%($!4$!3,") ,0!$0"&!$# 1,"1$"3 %8""&$1"0& 8"3 10""&0 &!$&!3" ,"9"&!$&"0%($!8"$&) 51 $&!$5,$,$& !$9"+$"+#$.$1%($!0 !"0?3"0"%#,$5!$&!3"% 9"," 0% %(&0",'B @7($!,0"#1 , !$&!!3"""#!!3 !!3"51 $&!$$%4&", 51!:?+9" %(,$&)*7E ,0%+8" ,$&)>3 %, ; :B +%$!( !"0$&.$11 )"7(1! &5(,+"3%$1 $%!,$#!98 1 &0 1%!3"4&",!3"%3 ,"%1"!8=73">3 &02 03 4 %&7363(%3$ 9
.
3 , ! "!,1"(9,5, !$&C!0 ;* 3 98 1 ",!$1$D",% &0 3"9$# 1 C!0 * * ;: $9 #3 1 (!(,$%!$#99(&$# !$& C!0 ; :
:;
$&0(%! & "!,1"(9 ,5, !$& C!0 : ;
:*?: C!0 :
* C!0 ?
* &0$ &#,=1$#%C!0 :; C!0 ?;
727!""1C!0 *?
,%7!4 ,"
*:
&)1," "$&",= &0 "!, 3"9$# 1C!0 ; *
,"5"&C 8, !,$"%C!0 ; * * ,8"&"
:
"&! 9"0$ , 5 ;
*:?*
4", $& &#",5C!0 :
??
&0$ C!0 ; ?
;
%3,$ 3"9$# 1% &0 ",!$1$D",% C!0 * ;
!! 9/ 1("7!""1%C!0 ? ?* / ,(&73$55$&)95 &=C!0 7 .$&) &>F# &> !$ 1
%++FB 11 %3 ,"% ,"$& "9!F#B *?**;* &>+C""1 3 4 &+ !$ 1 &0 ,"%$0"&!$ 151!?+9" %(,$&)7E ,0%%$!( !"0 !
&% 3$ ) ,+95,."9"&!,(%!+7(& 9 0+7 &),(, &0 51! 9" %(,$&) B 9 ,1 % * 7E ,0% (! 1 &0 9" %(,$&)::> & 1%B9 ,1 %8" ,$&)>3 %, :FF*F :B + B + B + B + B +*F :B +*F *B + >3"4 !F>3 ! (&$*?F?:+*F%3 ," B* 9 ,1 % &01 &0 9" %(,$&)B?9 ,1 %(!1 &08" ,$&)>3 %, :FFF9$&
/
B? +>3"4 !F>3 ! (&$*:F;; %5",- 9 8 &0$,!3" =" ,:B;%$!( !"0 ! -$ !! & 8 ""57$&)3 ) , 3 !$&0 +8(&0"0 %(&0",'B %! '
*?""!5 %% )"B""! 2"%! '
*?""!5,5",!= ,"9(5!
,!3 '
?;""!5,5",!= %$86 (, 7(!3 '
?;""!5,5",!= ,"9(5!
&0 ,5",9 &"&!$&-(&#!$&,"%!, $&$&)0""&0 &!%+!3"$, !!,&"=% &!!!, &%",+ 1$"& !"$& &=4 = &0&!!#," !" &=#3 ,)" &!3" 8."% $05,5",!=A c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
23 '(45& +33 6 178 97 +33 :
!
97