The Managing Director, Punjab State Co-Operative Supply And Marketing Federation Ltd And Another v. The Additional Chief Secretary Cum Financial Commissioner Cooperation, Punjab And Others
!" # $%& '' !$%$(%) # $%& '' '
* +, - +.%./0%/
0! )1$!2 (%3.4 51.1 $$6 !.10"
5(6678 .%# +.!9 10%/ # !.10$% :1#'
.%# .%$1- !
'''
1010$% !
; '
- ##010$%.7 -0 < 5 )! 1.!8)(=0%.%)0.7 $==0 0$% !2 $$6 !.10$%2 (%3.4 .%# $1- !
'''
6$%# %1 '
* +, - +.%./0%/
0! )1$!2 (%3.4 51.1 $$6 !.10"
5(6678 .%# +.!9 10%/ # !.10$% :1#'
.%# .%$1- !
'''
1010$% !
; '
- ##010$%.7 -0 < 5 )! 1.!8)(=0%.%)0.7 $==0 0$% !2 $$6 !.10$%2 (%3.4 .%# $1- !
'''
6$%# %1 +& > : +'
5 5
!"
#$%
& '
(
)**
+ , #$% -& .' 1 2
3
4444444 5
2 '
# 5
** 0 6 ( * *
7 86 & 0( & 0
* +9 "
: &) 6 ;
) $ , #$ 7 !% 3 # 6 6* **6) * 3 < " #+ 7
% 3
:
?
=*( ( #$$$ 3
6 & *( 6 & ) ) 3 * 1 $ <!<" 9
> ;
( 7 )
86 ( ) 6 ) ;
( ) )
*(
3
)
( < + 7 #% *6 ) * ( 6
* 0 ( * * 1 !
!! <$9
3 # )) . )) 3
* 3 = . 12?@. 6
) , # # 7 % !
;
*( 3
*
* #!%
*( &) ?
* *% * #$$ A1 #$$ B% 1)
< " #+ 7
% 3
* 1) %
5 3
* 3 #
+$
A #$+#B% 6 **6 ) $ , #$ 7 !% 5 , C * %
) 0 * ) ( 0 @7*
+$ #$+# 3 "
#"
6 $ # #"
* % @7*
;
**( ** *
+$
( 6 ( *( 7
: #$$ )) ? 7*( 1)
A1 /0B% *( * ( 6 )*(
+$ *( 0 : ) * ) @7* ) (
$ # #" ) 0
0* *6 **(
#!% #$$ )**( * 1 ** * 0) 0( *) ( * /
+ : 3
6 & * ( 0*( 6( *7 : ( ) & )*) ) 0 *0*( *( ) (
* 6 & 6 * ) *0*( 3
?
** 0*6 3 # 3
) *( )*) & 6
*) 3 6
*9** 6 0) 6 6 * ;
: & 6 3
6 6 ) 5 * * ( 6 **( 6 * & 1 3
&
* 6 0 ) 7
# * 3
0) ( ) ?
** 3
* ) 0 ) * & 6 * (
0 *
"
* * 3
3 # 0 *
+$ #"
5
) 7*( * 6
' 1) 0( )
0* : 3 "
#" * ) @7* * % 6 *( 0 * 6
) /
C * * ( * / ) 8B0*
6
7 ) * * * 6
1)
' )0* 7 < C * 3
7
;
( * (
0*( ) 6 ) ) &
* 6 *;
6 $
* * 6 5 12?@.
& ) ) ? : ?:% * 6 * : 12?@.
* * ?: * 3
3 #
* ) :;
( D 6 0 0*( *( 6 . ) 12?@. 1 5* D 5 . ) 5* D 0*
) * & ) * )6 6** )) *( $ **( 0* 6
$ #, 3
7 = ) *(
C)
3
+ ,% 6 ( * ( #$$$
1
# #+ 7
9#% 6 *
*
# , #< 7
9 % 3 # 5 *(
# , #< 7
9 % *( )
++ #$
, #$ : * 12?@.
3
* *)
( &
5;
:
55 # :
* * 6 0* ## 5
*( &) ? #$$ 7 6 %
<!
** 0*) 6 * 1 /0 ) *) *( * #!% #$$ 6
1 ** 6 ** ( = . ?
* **( 1
**
* #!% #$$
! "# $%
@ #
& !" "# $
%&'
@ *% # D
+$ 6
' 1) 6 *
+< * ' 1)
(
+$
()& *+ &$ ' '( " ' %% # %( # #
)' # ( %# # %%
" # *+
&$ ' # '(
, #
, # # # &'
@ *% #
86 3 "
#" 6 $ # #" @7*
+$ * % @7*
;
**( ** *
+$
( 6 ( *( 7
5 @7*
+$ *(
-. *+ /0,
. # , &0 + !
. # & /0
# # 1# 2 , $
" # *- ( % " $# "
# # #.%$ # $ ( %$ $# "
#(/ / 3 ()
# # # # &'
@ *% #!
* * 6* ))) *)* 6 *
0)
6( * )
**(
* ) * * / 0 (
* *)( )) 7 = 8B0*
0 1 '
1''"
"
'"
" 2 32 &) )
- 0
2
4 $ # " ' ' ( % % #% % " '" %# "'%
" '5 '5
" '"
% % # "# #
#( " $"
" 4 # # & 0
# &0 5 # &'
@ *% #, ?
) = 8B0*
6( 7"' (('
& 5
"'
8 # % 9' 2 &) ) = 6* 0 **6 6(&0 # 7 8 98 !:6- &
*+ 80 # #
##
&5
7#
&5 8 8 : 5 8 7# # #
& % ' # "
6# ! '
( # " # " '
" :
66& +;$< #
# ! 7 * : ' ## $ # %% " # ( # " "
(
%% ##
" " " $( " "
( # " #" #
'#( :'
*% #+ : 6 0 * #!% #$$ *
0) ) 6 ** ( = . ** * 1 /0 6 **
5 *)* *() 7 A* 0)B
;
**(
* 0*( 1 5 *)* * #"
+$ 5
*( * 7) *)* 7 *
+$ 6 (
0* 6 7* *) ) * #!% #$$ #"
?
?
** = 1
'' 6%% 1 0$ 22 $ 7
+$ #$+# #"
) **6 ;=& #
*+ /0!, ! () "# !, !
>>;? .
" #
& /0 # ! (= "# ! >>@? & / '( $ #
$ % %%
" "( $# "
'' "
$ %( # #
0%"( % 6%%
6"( " "( "
'' "
(
$ " # *- !" 6# " # 22 ;( 6# '( %%
%$ " # *+ !" 6# " #
;( 6# "#
<" %%
% ( #
#( ( 0%"( .
%$ #( $ ' "#
$ ' ( % ( "( " 6# %#
" 6# "
' " / 0 # #!& 0 #. #
+ & / 0 #.# !, #
! () "# ! >>;? # # ! (= "# ! >>@?
& ,
# .
#
&'
@ *% #< 5 ?
** = 7 ) / ) )**( *
+$
0* 1) . ( 1) ( **
(
* ( * 0
+< : 6 ** ( = . 1 7 * /
* #!% #$$ 6 7*( * * 0) * ) ;
0*( 1 ** ?
** = * * *( 1 7 * / #$ * 6 * * * * / ) 8B0*
B %
* 5 7 * 6 ( * #!%
#$$ 6 7*( *( ( 7 * / :5 : 6 )) **6 ) $ , #$ 7 !% 3 # 0( D 0 1 = .
* #!% #$$ 1
*( 0) ;
*( 1
+$
0* # 86 3
** *0( * < " #+ 7
% 3 *) *)* (
6 *6 ** )
** *% ( ** ( * * 5
" ## ,
&)9 E93
0*
E93