High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/46343/2025allowed

Lakhan v. State Of Haryana

2025-09-16Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

$%&7$5+*+%!) $%&7$5+*+%!) $%&7$5+*+%!) $%&7$5+*+%!)"$4#$83$' "$4#$83$' "$4#$83$' "$4#$83$' .

#$ #$ #$ #$

! D6$#+#+%!$'

A$'*-* ( "# D6$*4%!7$!# ) ) ) ) '$*$!#) '$*$!#) '$*$!#) '$*$!#) ; 6"" ; 6"" ; 6"" ; 6""

'6* (B-8 '+!7 2.7@%5 #$&%'# $4$#+#+%!$'6 '6$$4 B-8 ''$= 2. CCCCC CCCCC CCCCC CCCCC

.60 < .60 < .60 < .60 < " " " " '$*$!#*$5%!74$#+#+%! *3$$!

!&+2$7-!7$'"$5#+%!:%&# $ $ '

#+(

, '+ "-'

! +# 0 0&%' * %'# 1"";< &%' ,'

!# %& & '$,-2 ' 3 +2 #% # $ 4$#+#+%!$' +! 5 *$ 3$ '+!

, %6:: 7 #$7 :6/6 .

'$,+*#$'$7&%'

'# $%&&$!5$*4-!+* 32$-!7$'"

"$5#+%!*

0 <0 < 90<%&# $ $ '8*5#. 9 90&%'* %'#1'8*5#;< !7"$ 5#+%!* /9. /./ . . .

/ %&# $!

!7+ !$!

2%7$. :/0&%'* %'

'#1;<. #%2+5$"# #+%!"$5#%'

.-'-,'

$,'

8$!%&# $ 22$, #+%!* , +!*## $4$#+#+%!$'+*# #%!

:6/6 .

3%-# )//4686.# $5%842 !#;*& # $'= *'$#-'!+!, %8$ $ &'%8# $42%# #&%'2-!5 = $! $= **-77$!2( (*-''%-!7$73( !>$$#. !#.

!04$#+# #+%!$' $'$+!<.+!#-."

!>-.B 4+2. !+* . !7B-* 26## $+'

+!*#+, #+%!. +!$* ? +88- &+'$7 8-2#+42$ $ ,-!* %#* # # $ 5%842 !#;* & # $'=+# 4+*#%2.5 -*+!, +8#%*-*# +!8- -2#+42$3-22$#+!>-'+$* !75%22 4*$ $ %! # $ *4%#6 4%! '$5$+@+!, +!&%'8 #+%! &'

'%8 4 **$'*3(. # $ 5%842 !#

+88$7+ #$2( '-* $7 #% # $ 42 5$ %& %55-''$!5$. = $'$ +* 5%-*+!* +!#-

2+# 7 2*% ''+@$76(# ##+8$.# $ 55-*$74$'*%!* 7 2'$ 7(&2$76 $ 5%842 !#.=+# # $ $24%&%# $'*.* +&#$7 +*+!>-'$7& # $'#%(-* 8 %*4+# 2. &'%8 = $'$ $ = * '$&$''$7 #% $7 !# %*4+# 2. -'-,'

86 %=$@$'.-4%! ''+@ 2 #$7 !# %*4+# 2.# $7%5#%'*7$52 '$7 +83'%-, # 7$ 76 $5%842 !#&-'# $' 22$,$7# #+!$* ?+88- 7%4$!$7&+'$ # $+!*# !5$%&# $ 3%@$!

8$7 55-*$74$'*%!*.+!52-7+!,

!04$#+#+%!$' $'$+!<.= +5 '$*-2#$7+! +*& # $';*7$ # 6$ 2*% 22$,$7# 22# $ 55-*$7 4$'*%!*. 2%!,=+# >$!7$'."

*#'+$$4 .$$4 ->> '.+* !#.-!!+ $@+. %!!+ !> . -# 8. '@$$! "%2 !+. !>-. % !. !7 %!- - !. 7 $!#$'$7 +!#% 5'+8+!

2 5%!*4+'

5( =+# %!$ !%# $' !7=$'$ 5%22$5#+@$2('$*4%!*+32$&%'# $8-'7$'%& +*& # $'6 6

'!$75%-!*$2&%'# $4$#+#+%!$' *+#$'

#$7# ## $4$#+#+%!$'+* +! 5-*#%7( *+!5$ 6/6 6 '!$7 5%-!*$2 * &-'# $' +#$'

#$7 # # # $ 4$#+#+%!$' *3$$!& 2*$2(+842+5 #$7+!#%# $+!E-$*#+%!6 '!$75%-!*$2

* +#$'

#$7 # **-8+!, ',-$!7%. # $ 4'%*$5-#+%! @$'*+%! +* # $! #% 3$ 5%''$5#.# $4'+8$'%2$ ##'+3-#$7#%# $4$#+#+%!$'+*# #%&5%!*4+'

5(6 '!$7 5%-!*$2 * &-'# $' ',-$7 # # # $'$ +* !% 8 #$'+ 2 +2 32$ %! '$5%'7

2%!,=+# 5 != +5 8 (3$'$5%'7$7# ## $4$#+#+%!$'= *4'$*$!# ## $ *4%#= $!# $8-'7$'+!E-$*#+%!#%%42 5$6 '!$75%-!*$2&%'# $4$#+#+%!$'

*&-'# $'+#$'

#$7# ## $F5%842 !#*+7$ *$G ,,$'

#$7# $@$'*+%!

7 +842+5 #$7

4$'*%!* 55-*$7. 3-# # $ 4%2+5$ * 5 %*$! #% &+2$ !%!2( , +!*#:4$'*%!*6 '!$75%-!*$2 *&-'# $' ',-$7# #4'+8$ 4'%*$5-#+%! =+#!$**. !

8$2(. H I "

!> ( 0F 5%842 !#F *%! %& # $ 7$5$ *$7< *#-'!$7 %*#+2$6 -*.'$,-2 +2+*4'

($7&%'6 6

#$5%-!*$2 *%44%*$7# $4'$*$!#4$#+#+%!3( ',-+!, # ## $ 22$, #+%!*'

+*$7 , +!*## $4$#+#+%!$' '$*$'+%-*+!!

#-'$ !7# -*

# $4$#+#+%!$'7%$*!%#7$*$'@$# $5%!5$**+%!%&# $'$,-2 +26 5%-!*$2*$$*#%42 5$%!'$5%'7# $5-*#%7(5$'#+&+5 #$7 #$7 6/96

.+!# $ %-'##%7 (.= +5 +*# $!%!'$5%'76

@$ $ '75%-!*$2&%'# $'+@ 24 '#+$* @$,%!$# '%-, # $ +2 32$'$5%'7*%&# $5 6 $ 4$#+#+%!$' = ''$*#$7 %! 6/6 = $'$+!

&#$' +!@$*#+, #+%!= *5 ''+$7%-# !75 != *4'$*$!#$7%! 96/ 6%# 2 4'%*$5-#+%!=+#!$**$* @$3$$!5+#$7.3-#%!2(/ @$3$$!$G 8+!$7#+22 #$6#+*!%#+!7+*4-#$# ## $5%!52-*+%!%&# $#'+ 2=+22# $2%!,#+8$6 $ '+@ 25%!#$!#+%!*'

+*$7 # 'J+!52-7+!,# $=$+, # ,$F@$'

5+#('$E-+'$7#%3$

## 5 $7#%# $#$*#+8%!(%&# $ %*#+2$=+#!$**J,+@$'+*$#%7$3 # 32$+**-$*. = +5 * 223$'

#+%5+!

#$7-4%!7-'+!,# $5%-'*$%&#'+ 26 +*%-'#7%$*!%# 7$$8+# 44'%4'+ #$#%7$2@$7$$4+!#%# $*$'+@ 25%!#$!#+%!*. ## +**# ,$.2$*# +# 8 ( 4'$>-7+5$ # $ #'+ 26 %# +!, # !,+32$ * 3$$! 3'%-, # &%'= '7 #% +!7+5 #$# $2+$2+ %%7%&# $4$#+#+%!$' 3*5%!7+!,&'%8# $4'%5$**%&>-*#+5$ %'+!#$'&$'+!,=+# # $4'%*$5-#+%!$@+7$!5$6 6 6 ## +*>-!5#-'$.+#=%-273$ 44%*+#$#%'$&$' $'$+! >-7,8$!#%& # $ %!;32$ "-4'$8$ %-'# +! @$7 -2 8 3+ "

+ @*6 "# #$ %& @$7 -2 8 3+ "

+ @*6 "# #$ %&

* #'

!%# $'*. 0<0'+8+!

2<9

* #'

!%# $'*. 0<0'+8+!

2<9

* #'

!%# $'*. 0<0'+8+!

2<9

* #'

!%# $'*. 0<0'+8+!

2<9.= +5 '$ 7*# -*) K :6 '+8+!

2* '$ !%# 3%'! %-# 3-# 8 7$6 $ -8 ! 4%#$!#+ 2 +! $@$'(%!$ +* ,%%7 !7 *%. !$@$' ='+#$ %&& !( 5'+8+!

2 * 3$(%!7 '$7$84#+%!6 +* -8 !+*#&-!7 8$!# 2+*%&#$!8+**$7= $!7$ 2+!,=+# 7$2+!E-$!#*.>-@$!+2$ 7-2#6!7$$7.$@$'(* +!# 4 *# !7$@$'( *+!!$' &-#-'$6 H $! 5'+8$ +* 5%88+##$7. @ '+$#( %& & 5#%'* +* '$*4%!*+32$&%'8 +!,# $%&&$!7$'5%88+## $5'+8$6 %*$& 5#%'*8 ( 3$*%5+ 2 !7$5%!%8+5.8 (3$.# $ '$*-2#%&@ 2-$$'%*+%!%'4 '$!# 2 !$,2$5#J 8 ( 3$. 3$5 -*$ %& # $ *#'$** %& 5+'5-8*# !5$*. %' # $ !+&$*# #+%! %& #$84# #+%!* +! 8+2+$- %& &&2-$!5$ 5%!#'

*#$7 =+# +!7+,$!5$%'%# $'4'+@ #+%!*6 96 & # $ "# #$ %' !( 4'%*$5-#+!, ,$!5( +!52-7+!, # $ 5%-'# 5%!5$'!$7 *!%= $'$=+# 2#%4'%@+7$%'4'%#$5## $&-!7 8$!# 2'+, # %& 55-*$7#% @$ *4$$7(#'+ 2 *$!* '+!$7-!7$''#+52$ %&# $ %!*#+#-#+%! # $! # $ "# #$ %' !( %# $' 4'%*$5-#+!, ,$!5( * %-27 !%# %44%*$# $42$ &%'3 +2%!# $,'%-!7# ## $5'+8$5%88+##$7+**$'+%-*6

'#+52$ %& # $ %!*#+#-#+%! 442+$* +''$*4$5#+@$ %& # $ !

#-'$ %& # $ 5'+8$6

/6 H$8 ( *#$!#% 77# ## $4$#+#+%!$'+**#+22 55-*$7J!%# 5%!@+5#6 $ %@$' '5 +!, 4%*#-2 #$ %& 5'+8+!

2 >-'+*4'-7$!5$ #

55-*$7 +* 4'$*-8$7 #% 3$ +!!%5$!# -!#+2 4'%@$! ,-+2#( 5 !!%# 3$ 3'-* $7 *+7$2+, #2(. %=*%$@$'*#'+!,$!## $4$!

22 =8 (3$6

H$ '$5%!@+!5$7# ## $8 !!$'+!= +5 # $4'%*$5-#+!, ,$!5(

*=$22 *# $%-'# @$4'%5$$7$7.# $'+, #%&# $ 55-*$7#% @$ *4$$7(#'+ 25%-273$* +7#% @$3$$!+!&'+!,$7# $'$3(@+%2 #+!,'#+52$

%&# $%!*#+#-#+%!6L 6 !7-3+# 32(. # $ 4'$*$!# 4$#+#+%! +* # $ *$5%!7 ##$84# 3( # $ 4$#+#+%!$'#%*$5-'$'$,-2 +26 $2 *#3 +242$ 4'$&$''$73(# $4$#+#+%!$' = *7+*8+**$7 *=+# 7'

=!%!/ 6%=$@$'.$$4+!,+!@+$=&-'# $' +!5 '5$'

#+%! %& # $ 4$#+#+%!$' &%' 4$'+%7 %& 8%'$ # ! /9 8%!# * !7 !% *-3*# !#+ 24'%,'$**+!#'+ 2.# +*%-'#+*+!52+!$7#% &&+'8 #+@$2(5%!*+7$'# $ +!*# !#42$ &%'3 +264'%&+# 32$'$&$'$!5$.+!# +*'$, '7.5 !3$8 7$#% >-7,8$!# %& # +* %-'# 4 **$7 +! "

#+#2$7 * &+E B &+E B &+E B &+E B @$'*-*"# !%# $'

@$'*-*"# !%# $'

@$'*-*"# !%# $'J'$2$@ !#= $'$%&'$ 7* *-!7$') K /6 * ! $4+2%,-$ #% # $ 3%@$ 7+*5-**+%!. # $ &%22%=+!, 4'+!5+42$*$8$',$) "$5%!7F*-55$**+@$ '$,-2 +2 4$#+#+%!0*< &+2$7 +* +!# 32$+!2 =M $!5$*-5 4$#+#+%!%-, #!%##%3$'$>$5#$7 *%2$2(%!# $,'%-!7%&8 +!# 3+2+#(# $'$%&6 6 "-5 *$5%!7F*-55$**+@$ '$,-2 +2 4$#+#+%!0*< +* +!# 32$ = $# $' '2+$' 4$#+#+%! = 7+*8+**$7

=+# 7'

=!F7+*8+**$7 *!%#4'$**$7F7+*8+**$7&%'!%!4'%*$5-#+%! %'$ '2+$'4$#+#+%!= *7+*8+**$7%!8$'+#*6 %' # $ *$5%!7F*-55$**+@$ '$,-2 ' 3 +2 4$#+#+%!0*< #% *-55$$7. # $ 4$#+#+%!$'F 442+5 !# * 22 3$ $**$!#+ 22(F4$'#+!$!#2( '$E-+'$7#%* %=*-3*# !#+ 25 !,$+!5+'5-8*# !5$* !7* %=+!, %& 8$'$*-4$'&+5+ 2%'%*#$!*+32$5 !,$=%-27!%#*-&&+5$6 $ 8$# 4 %'+5 $G4'$**+%! %& *$$+!, *$5%!7F*-55$**+@$ 3 +2 42$ 0*< %-, #!%#3$ 3*#'

5#$7+!#%2+#$'

2+#$'

#+%!*%&4$#+#+%!0*<=+# %-# *-3*# !#+ 2.$&&$5#+@$ !75%!*$E-$!#+ 25 !,$+!5+'5-8*# !5$*6 A %$G -*#+@$,-+7$2+!$*5 !4%**+32(3$2 +77%=! *#% = #=%-275%!*#+#-#$*-3*# !#+ 25 !,$+!5+'5-8*# !5$* *$@$'( *$ * +#* %=! -!+E-$ & 5#*F5+'5-8*# !5$6 +!, *-5

##$84#+*!%# +!,3-# !-#%4+ !$!7$ @%-'6',%.# +*+**-$+* 3$*#2$&##%# $>-7+5+ 2=+*7%8 !77+*5'$#+%!%&# $%-'#7$ 2+!, =+# *-5 *$5%!7F*-55$**+@$'$,-2 +24$#+#+%!0*<6 A !5 *$ %-'#5 %%*$*#%,'

!#*$5%!7F*-55$**+@$'$,-2 +24$#+#+%!0*<.5%,$!# !72-5+7'$ *%!* '$4$'#+!$!#2('$E-+'$7#%

3$ '$5%'7$7 &%' ,'

!#+!, *-5 42$ 7$*4+#$ *-5 42$ 3$+!, *$5%!7F*-55$**+@$4$#+#+%!0*<6!%# $'=%'7*.# $5 -*$&%' %-'#

@+!, *-55$**&-22( 5%-!#$!

!5$7F$!#$'# +!$7 *-5 *$5%!7F*-55$**+@$ 4$#+#+%!0*< %-, # #% 3$ '$ 7+2( !7 52$ '2( 7$5+4 $'

32$&'%8# $* +7%'7$'4 **$76L 66 *4$'5-*#%7(5$'#+&+5 #$7 #$7 6/96

&+2$73(2$ 5%-!*$2. # $ 4$#+#+%!$' 2'$ 7( *-&&$'$7 +!5 '5$'

#+%! &%' 4$'+%7 %& / ($ './8%!# * !7 :7 (*6-'# $'. *4$'# $* +75-*#%7(5$'#+&+5 #$# $ 4$#+#+%!$'+**# #$7#%3$+!@%2@$7+!%# $'0*<6%=$@$'.# +*& 5#-85 !!%# 3$ ,'%-!7*-&&+5+$!#3(+#*$2&.#%7$52+!$# $5%!5$**+%!%&'$,-2 +2#%# $ 4$#+#+%!$'+!# $+!E-$*#+%!= $! 5 *$+*8 7$%-#&%','

!#%&'$,-2 +2E- # $+!E-$*#+%!3('

#+%5+!

#+!,-4%!# $& 5#*F5+'5-8*# !5$*%& # $* +76$2+ !5$+!# +*'$, '75 !3$42 5$7-4%!# $>-7,8$!#%&# $ %!;32$"-4'$8$%-'#+! -2 % 768+' 7+@6"# #$%&66 -2 % 768+' 7+@6"# #$%&66 -2 % 768+' 7+@6"# #$%&66 -2 % 768+' 7+@6"# #$%&66

!%# $'. 0 < 0'+8+!

2< :

!%# $'. 0 < 0'+8+!

2< :

!%# $'. 0 < 0'+8+!

2< :

!%# $'. 0 < 0'+8+!

2< :J +@+*+%! $!5 >-7,8$!# %& # $ %!;32$ 25-## +, %-'#+!5 *$%& "'+7 ' *@6"# #$. 99:0 < "'+7 ' *@6"# #$. 99:0 < "'+7 ' *@6"# #$. 99:0 < "'+7 ' *@6"# #$. 99:0 < 0'+8+!

0'+8+!

M>-7,8$!#*%&# +*%-'#+!%6::

#+#2$7 +2$* "+!, @6"#

+2$* "+!, @6"#

+2$* "+!, @6"# .7$5+7$7%! 96 6 !7 2'

>@6"# 2'

>@6"# %& %& %& %& . 99:0<0'+8+!

2< 9 6

. 99:0<0'+8+!

2< 9 6

. 99:0<0'+8+!

2< 9 6

. 99:0<0'+8+!

2< 9 6 "-&&+5$#%* (.&-'# $'7$#$!#+%!%&# $4$#+#+%!$' !-!7$'#'+ 2+* !%#= ''

!#$7+!# $& 5#* !75+'5-8*# !5$*%&# $5

! @+$= %& 3%@$. # $ 4'$*$!# 4$#+#+%! +* 22%=$76 $#+#+%!$' +* %'7$'$7#%3$'$2$ *$7%!'$,-2 +2%! +*&-'!+* +!,3 +2F*-'$#(3%!7*#%# $ #+*& 5#+%!%&# $ 765%!5$'!$7F-#( ,+*#'

#$6%=$@$'.+! 77+#+%! #%5%!7+#+%!*# #8 (3$+84%*$73(# $5%!5$'!$7F-#( ,+*#'

#$.# $ 4$#+#+%!$'* 22'$8 +!3%-!73(# $&%22%=+!,5%!7+#+%!*) 0+< $4$#+#+%!$'* 22!%#8+*-*$# $2+3$'#(,'

!#$76 0++< $4$#+#+%!$'* 22!%## 84$'=+# !($@+7$!5$.%'

2 %'7%5-8$!# '(.7-'+!,# $#'+ 26 0+++< $4$#+#+%!$'* 22!%# 3*$!# +8*$2&%! !(7 #$ 3$&%'$ # $#'+ 26

0+@< $4$#+#+%!$'* 22!%#5%88+# !(%&&$!5$= +2$ %! +26 0@< $ 4$#+#+%!$' * 22 7$4%*+# +* 4 **4%'#. +& !(. =+# # $ #'+ 2%-'#6 0@+< $ 4$#+#+%!$' * 22 ,+@$ +* 5$224 %!$ !-83$' #% # $ !@$*#+, #+!,&&+5$'F"%&5%!5$'!$7%2+5$"# #+%! 22 !%# 5 !,$ +* 5$224 %!$ !-83$' =+# %-# 4'+%' 4$'8+**+%!%&# $#'+ 2%-'#F22 ,+*#'

#$6 0@++< $4$#+#+%!$'* 22!%#+! !(8 !!$'#'(#%7$2 (# $#'+ 26 :6 ! 5 *$ %& 3'$ 5 %& !( %& # $ &%'$* +7 5%!7+#+%!* !7 # %*$ = +5 8 ( 3$ +84%*$7 3( 5%!5$'!$7 F-#( ,+*#'

* 7+'$5#$7 $'$+!

3%@$%'-4%!* %=+!, !(%# $'*-&&+5+$!#5 -*$.# $"# #$F5%842 !# 223$ #2+3$'#(#%8%@$5 !5$22 #+%!%&3 +2%&# $4$#+#+%!$'6 96 '7$'$7 55%'7+!,2(6 /6 %# +!,* +7 $'$+!

3%@$* 223$5%!*#'-$7 !$G4'$**+%!%& %4+!+%!%!# $8$'+#*%&# $5 "+!5$ # $ 8 +! 5 *$ * 3$$! 7$5+7$7. 4$!7+!, 8+*5$22 !$%-*

442+5 #+%!.+& !(.* 22 2*%*# !7*7+*4%*$7%&&6 0"

" < "$4#$83$' "$4#$83$' "$4#$83$' "$4#$83$' .

@+' H $# $'*4$ +!,F'$ *%!$7)

$*F% H $# $''$4%'# 32$)

$*F%