High Court of Punjab and HaryanaTA/491/2018disposed of

Suman v. Sat Narain

2018-09-27Mr. Justice Satpal3 pages

!"#"$%&%'() *+, ' "!%!%'"- .& * ! - %'

"&/'#"'!

-"&"'!(0

- .,1%!*%'213#.$ !" -!1"/"!%!%'"-

-4 5/ !*1 -, 3#.$ !" -!1"-"&/'#"'! 1"/"!%!%'"-06%"1 &%7"#!1"/-"&"'!/"!%!%'+'#"-*"$!%' !1"#"%.%7 -$"#+-"-!- '&"-$ &"+'#"-*"$!%'8

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

00 ! //" -&!1 !" -7%"- /"!%!%'+'#"-*"$!%'80!1" %'#+ --% 2"$!6 &%7"#6"."-3 !!1"%-&!,!%'3!1"/"!%!%'"- , #" &! !","'!9+!'!1"&"$'#,!%'&1"-"+&"#!2%."&! !","'!- ''0/ <,"'! 7%,'<39"$ +&"61%$1!1"& %#/"!%!%'6 &#%&,%&&"# 1"-" !"-!1"-"&/'#"'!%7"# /"!%!%'+'#"-*"$!%'8!1"%'#+

--% 2"$!361%$16 &#%&,%&&"#-''0/-&"$+!%' '#''0/ <,"'! , %'!"' '$".%#"-#"-# !"#:) !%&&! !"#!1 !9!1!1"" -7%"-/"!%!%'&6"-"%7"# != %!1 7 9+!'6!1"8-#/"!%!%'1 &9""'%7"#9<!1"-"&/'#"'! !1%6 '%1" -"&/'#"'!%&'!-"&%#%'2 !1%6 '% '#!1"/"!%!%'%&%7"#!1"-"'7< 6%!1 .%"6!1 - &&!1"/"!%!%'"- 1"/"!%!%'"-1 & 7&%7"#!6 /"!%!%'&3'"+'#"-*"$!%':!1"#"-%,%' 7 -$"#+-" '# '!1"-+'#"-*"$!%'!1"%'#+ --% 2"$!361%$1 -"/"'#%'2 !

= %!1 71"/"!%!%'"-1 &'%'#"/"'#"'!," '& '#%&6177<#"/"'#"'! +/'1"-/ -"'!&!%&."-<#%%$+7!-!1"/"!%!%'"-! !!"'#!1"+-! /-$""#%'2& !1%6 '%361%$1%& ! #%&! '$" 9+!8:= &-, = %!1 7 4" -'"# $+'&"7 - !1" -"&/'#"'!3 ' !1" !1"- 1 '#3 $'!"'#&!1 !!1"$'#+$!!1"/"!%!%'"-%&'!2#*1"1 #-"$"%."# ' ,+'! &3:3A0%'/+-&+ '$"!1"$,/-,%&"61"-"+/' /"!%!%'+'#"-*"$!%'80!1"%'#+ --% 2"$!6 &%7"# '#!1"

/"!%!%'"-2!1"-&! !","'!-"$-#"# !!1"%-&!,!%'6"."-3!1" /"!%!%'"--"+&"#!-"$-#1"-&! !","'! !!1"&"$'#,!%' '# 7&#%# '! -"!+-' !1" & %# ,+'! ! !1" -"&/'#"'! " &! !"& !1 ! ' '" $$ &%'3 $,/7 %'!6 &7#2"#9<!1"/"!%!%'"- 2 %'&!!1"-"&/'#"'! ! = 7 < !3%&!-%$!= %!1 761"-"!1"-"&/'#"'! '#1%& ,%7<,",9"-&6"-"

$ 77"#!!1"/7%$"&! !%'!%& 77"2"#!1 !"."'%'!1"/7%$"&! !%'%' !1"/-"&"'$"" #'&! 97"*1 ,&1"-*%'2139-!1"-!1"/"!%!%'"- && +7!"# '# 9+&"#!1"-"&/'#"'!61"-"+/' 7"'#"- +'#"-*"$!%' )A:- 6 &/-"/ -"#" $$-#%'27<$'!"'#&!1 !!1"$ &", < 9"!- '&"--"#!%&!-%$!%'#361%$1%& ,%#6 <9"!6""'= %!1 7! 1%6 '%31 .%'2"B+ 7#%&! '$"?= & '&%#"-%'2 !1" $!& '# $%-$+,&! '$"& !1" $ &"3 !1" $'!"'!%'7" -'"#$+'&"7-!1"-"&/'#"'!%& $$"/!"# $$-#%'27<3!1"!- '&"- //7%$ !%' %&#%&/&"#6%!1 #%-"$!%' !1 ! !1" /"!%!%' +'#"- *"$!%' 8 % %9 !1" %'#+

--% 2" $!3:: !%!7"# & ;* ! - %' .& *+, ';3 %7"# 9< !1" -"&/'#"'!361%$1%&/"'#%'2%'!1"+-!7" -'"#%&!-%$!+#2"0 ,%7< +-!31%6 '%%&6%!1#- 6'-,!1"& %#+-! '#!- '&"--"#!%'# 1"%&!-%$!+#2"3%'#, < &&%2'%!! +-!$,/"!"'!5+-%&#%$!%' -%'#"-*%'21*%#1+ ) +#2" #%'"&1 C1"!1"-&/" @%'2A-" &'"# "& C1"!1"- "/-! 97"( "&A