Sawai Singh v. Jai Bhagwan

 
 
 








 !"#!$%& 
 
  




  '

 ()
*

 

!

" #$
"%
#

"



%

&

'"
 
(
 

  )
"
  


 "
 
*
+,%
,"+$
"
 

"
    
 #$


-%./%.//0
1
2%./%///0
  
3 

2%//%.//
0

 4
+ 


,

 

2/ /5 2/&2%
"
+

%
 

"
  


+$
"
 %
"
+

6
7

 # %
 

"


" %
"
+ 

+$
" 
 ) 

"
 

'"
  %
 

 

#$
, "
"
#3
" 
+,

3 


2%./%///0
3
" 3

2/ /5 2/&2% ) )
," "
 
8

 
 

#



)

$
 
9
2-:



3

 )
 
 

"


 
 %
 

 
"3+
37




"3

7









"
   
#+
;
 # 

)
 

&.

/2 2/&<% 
 

$
"
3 
"



" 3

 
 
)

-

=


 %
 

 
 
"

, 

3 
 $ )
+, )
 $
3


2%./%///0
3
"
  


2/ /5 2/&2
 
8 

 $
 
 

#

"

$3 

 $
 
"

'"
 

"
"
 7 )
# )

"

; 
3 )"
"#
+ 
"




3
 
 #
"3

 
 %
," "

 +

)

" 3


 

+ $
3 $
 
 $
 
  

'"
 
"

"
"
)#

 
$
 "
)
 
) #
+$
"


$
 $ )
"
#3

"   %
"
 

"
 

"
  

+ 

 



$

"



"
 

<

 
"
 
,

#  %
"
 
 
*
3 "
, )



&

""
 
8
 
 

# 
  

2/ /5 2/&2
 
+,

2%./%///0 >
=




 &

#
,""
  

  
 #$


-%./%.//0
1
2%./%///0
  
3

2%//%.//0
  4
 ), "

 
3
)

"
 >
=

""
"
 

3 +

"
 
3> = 



-

""
"
 

 3
+>
=  <

 

?




#

8 

 
 %
 

 2
 +  
"


 

  $

   
"
 
+,

2%./%///0
3
" 3

2/ /5 2/&2% ) )
," "
 
8

 
1@8 &04
 
  1@8 &04
 
 
)

$
 
9
2-:



3

" +,
3

"
 
"

 )
 
 

"


 
 %
 

 
"3+
37 "3

7







"
   
"  

#+
; # 

)
 

&.

/2 2/&< 1@8
54%
 
 

$
"
3 

3 %
"


 " 3

 
 
)




 

"

# %
 83 
 # 
 )"%
 ,  )
 
6 ) 
@8
1 &4%
,"   
"

" ,  )
 

"
 

 
1@8 &04
 
 
1@8 &04
 
, "
"
3 


 
" ,  )

"


3
!

7 "

A# #
1 54
#
"
)
 
@8
5
 
 
 
@8 -%

 )
"
"
"

"
 
")"
) 

=
"
 $% 
 


 $
#  %
"

 )

 % " 


"
 
,

)




C 
,
*%

 

#  
 
" 




 &

2

#

"
  %
" )
 +,
3 $
3
"
  
 
$
8
 
  
 
)

$
"
 
"
 
"
 
"




 

$
"
3 

3

'"
 
 
*

,
"


 5
 
-
)


"
 
" )
"
"
  
#
"3%
"# )

)




*

; $%
 "
 

#$

#

"


.

6  

 
+$
 
,


# 
D)3



/& /.

2/25



+$
   
  
)%
   3 )
"



"
 

' 
*%
 )

  )


 )
 


C 




"
 0 
)
"
+"
" *
+,
#7
"
3 
#3

"
 
"  
1@8 &04
 
 
1@8 &04

;  

 



'"
 
#
+,
 $
3 $
3
"
  
 # 8
 
1@8 &04
 
 
1@8 &04

#

 
"$


+

)

" 3

'

"
   %
 




"
+"
"
3


 
+$
 $
3)  , 



"
+


+$
"
  

"

)% ")"
3 
"
+"
"
3
,


"


" # )%
," "

; 
+$
# )
3 

"
 3
C 




+3 
"
"
 $
3 

"
  

   

$ 

#
"

8 

"
 
"
  &/


C 




"
 
"
+3 
"
3 


"
" ,  )
8

 

 )"

#
" 8 

 
 

"

, 


"
8 
  
 

6"%
"
, 




+
7 



+ 
 "

, 

,$ 7

#

"
$%
,"
 ))

" 3

&&

C 



"
)
"


"
  

 "
 %
"
  
3 )"
"#
3  
"


" 
 
 #
"3

3
;   %
,"


"

 



+,
3 $
3
"


C 



)
"

) #

8

#
  

"

3 


"
 ,  )
@8
+$
"
*
+,

# 
8 
,
  
3   #

&2















8
 
+$
"
 




"
 
"   
 

#
"

  
 $

 
"
3 

;  


 

#
"


3
, "
" 3
+$
 )
 $
+

3 




"
 %
," "
"

 
"

3
,"3 "
"
7
"
3 $

 + "
"
# +  $

"
 "
, "
" 3


"
# 
$

&5








'"
 




"
 
"
+3 
"
"   
 3

"#
 
"#$
3 

"
 %
," "



 $
3 
"
  

+


3 $




 3 %
"
  
,
; 

#
"

3 $


)
 

,#%
 
*
+,
 

 
"
3 
 3 $

"  

"





"
+3 
"
*
+,
 
 



"
"
  
"
 

#
)
 
@8 5
+$
83

)


"
'"
  3 
 

5



+ #
#
 "


"#
+
 


'"
 



+3 
"
  

) 
 +
#  

#

8 

 
 


")
"
 
, "
 +  $

$3 

3 $

)




"



"
*
+,

+ $%
# 
 
+

  

  

"
+

&- 
"#
"
 




"
 
"#
 "
%


"
# ,
"
"


 
3 

"

+3

3
+$
"
 




"


 
+,

 

"

#  

"
  
1 24
 , "
3 

" ,  )
 
 ) 
8
 # 
 )"

1 &4
 
"


@8 &0
#

3



+
" 
"
8
 

2/ /5 &2
1@8 &04



 
1@8 &04
, "

7 ,)
 
 

)%


+,

2%./%///
3
"
  
 
 
)

$
 92-:



3

"
+,
3 %
 
"
)
 $
"
3 

3

'"
  
) $
 
"
3
, $

#
 
3
  

"
 %
,"



"3+
"3

7






'"
  
 
"
 
" 3 
+)"
"
 
  
 

"3

"

,
,  )
 
 
8


; 3 

 $
"


, 
 
 

" 3


"



"
"


"
3
+ )

63
"

3 

"
  %


3

"


,
# +


,"
 
 
,
8

'"
 
  
 
"
  3 
 

"
  
 
"

, 

% " ,  )
 
 )
 
8
1  &4
+$
+ )
 $
3



"

#

 $
 3 

+ #
"3


++ ) 



+
" 
#

=
"
 $%
"
 
" 
 
"

" ,  

"
 
 %
"
"

"

  
,
"

"

7 , %
"
3 )"
"#
+ 
"



 
"3%
 
 #
"3

3


) # %
" 
,
; 

#
)

+$
 )
)

 #  )
# 
C,

"
," #
7
"

 
3 
#
"
3
+$ 
 +
+
 7

 3  ")



 
 %
 
,"

7

 ) 
#  %
 

+"

3

"
, 

+8


"

"

%
"



 
" 


)


 


"





# 
C *
+,
"#
 )"$

"
#



+ #
"
 +
#  

"
 # '"
 




"
 
"
 
"   
"


 
 


 
+$
" 3) 
, 

%
"%

"

+
 


'"    

+


"
)

"
  $%
 1 24
) $
8 
"
 3 %

," "
3

,
8
 
"
"

)

+
"

#

"
3

 $%
"

; 3 
 
"
,
"


 
"
+
 
3
"
 )03) 
, 

+ ,-.&-/0- ,# 1+  
   





 

 

   

      

   

    



  

   
   !  

  !

 

  


! 



   !   ! 



  



  "#
'"
 

"
  
#
 
;    

  


3 

 $
 

"
7
 + 
 
#
")"
   
; 3 

,
% "



  

 
1@8 &04
 
  1@8 &04

 
 %


37
"3
+
6"3%

 
 
  
"
+
+

#
"
8 

"  
 


'"
"

)



",
"
+"
" *
+,
"#
3



3


"
#  

"

  
"%
"

 3 

 
&&.14

'" ) +


3
%
&..&
"
 
 

 

 
 

 $

#

'"
"

)

 
 + "
"


)



 
" 
+
#



  
+#%
 
 

3

, 

+8

+
" #

"

C,

"
,"

$
3

,$ 3
"
, 

+8%
, "
 $
8   %

# 
 
+
,
)


" 3
 
,"#

+$
" 3
3$
+
7

, )
)


" 3

"
 
 %
 


) #  

",
"

+  $



"
, 

+8


 #
"


 


"





 
 

 
#



 
)


"
 

 3
"
,"#
"
+


+$
"
  




3#4,13"5#!6 *
#73"5#!   "4!5-"!

#

2 %

,
"
"

"
 3 
 
 
&&.

" ) +


3
%
&..&

+
 

"



 3

"
 %

83  

"
, 


# "#


'"


, "
"
+ # 

3

" $
 


#7#!#58 !,!#5"1"#,9" ,.++# :!-"0:)
;

* #!"

:#+:#1#5 ,.++# :!-"0:)
% +
3



"

"



#  
"
"
 
  
"
 
 


 #











6"%



)

+$
"
 




"
 
( 
"

"

 
  
" 
#
"
"
,

 $

37
"
$3 


2%./%///
8
"


#

3
1 24
'"
   
 +

"


"
  
"
$
8 
"


3
, "
" 3




; $%
"

 $

 
3 $


 ) $
 
"
"
"

205




 
+

  #
$
)
 
"
) #
"
3 


F "


3 
"
7
"
3 $
3
" 3
 
)#




3 
"
3 
 " )


6"%
,"

  
"
#
"
8 

 
 
 %
"  3 
# +
 
&&.14

"
) +


3

%
&..&
+3
# +

" 3
 
 
"
 

+ "
 
 3  %
"
 3
  

; 




#
"

 $

37
"
$3

 3 
# ,
,
8

+$
"

*


 

, ,.0:6 #+::# #!,.0:#.9

:!

< & 

 !,5,.#1 

&*

#






'"
  
  $
 
"
"


"
+


3 $


'"
  


#  

+
"
3%

 3
  
, 
; 


 $
  
 3 $


"
 
#
"
)
 
@8 5

+$
83

3
!

7 "
A#
#%
"
  $
 
"
"
"


"
) 

 
 
 
"
 
 
    "


"
 
#
,"
"

"
 

&<


" 

7
)"%
37 
) 

3
   


+ )
"



"
 
*
+,
, "

" 3

# $ &?

6
"


3   %



 $
) $
 # $%

"
  


%
," "

+ 

  

 
3 $
# 

 3
"



 
) 


 
3"


##3 

 $
+  
;  

,

&B

 $%

"

3 

"

 %
"+$%

&.

)
3  
   4%

 $%

 
 
 )$

  

 **&   #"!#;-!-

Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No