High Court of Punjab and HaryanaXOBJC/37/2014disposed of

New India Assurance Co Ltd v. Ravinder Kaur & ORS

2016-03-29Mr. Justice S.P. Bangarh15 pages

"#$%&'

$ %%((

)# "

*$+, #-"#.#

!" #!$%

0#-/#1% 2,2 # 0#+*02,2 #.%%(( $%-"#2,2 # 0# .! ##2,2 # 3#

41# &&&&&&&&&&& #!$%'

%%(

(4&. "#$%&!

.!.

.# 4# 6 #6

# 7 8 ! "# 5. # ., 6 4

,(, 9 2 !.

.*.

,%* 6." #"(& ( .

(

2( !

(4&# .# 2 .

!2 .!.

..(#0# ( $ 5# 4"(2. 6#.2!#.# + 2 83 "#.# !# + 2 2 3 # % 9 .# :# %4 #.5# 4"(;2!.

.$.# 5."

6 . !# 9

2..%# %%(. 4

(2 !.

.# .

5. 2 < #$. $%"6!#2#.*.

,%* 6.

! 6 #$. 6#.*# 20.( 2.

$#&(24"

9 %$ 9 =. . #. . #

6 *# 3/. )20.( 2!.

.,#

$#..( .>

6,.

(?$((6(& % #$.

-"$4# .!<2# ,4&# .# :.# #4# ## . # ,#;.

.$#&( ((6(&2.#! 4 6# , .

6. %2 # .6( 6$#4&.# ,#2(1 #* 6. "( . 2. 2(6!

$#&(2# ., 4#66 #(6

4&.#2"!.

.. . % ! ( ( $.. @4#.#2(!

#* 6.2!

((!

$ %#,.

(

! %( .( .. !

&# ( . $! # 6+ 2 2 3%#$. 4"

$2!.!

( $A%& + 2 2! #6

#/( * 2/.

20.( 2 #.$$

.4("#* 3 ./ *$.!2."6..!# .. . %2 .# #2 %# 2

..! 4&# "& , ( 7 % (2/. )20.( $$ (&.# #2.!,#2.$" % . "#(( # :+ 92 3;2. 4# ## . !# $% 92 2 2 3:+ 9## ;! ( $4"

." $(&. 2"#,# "

. + .# 2 .# ,#:# 4 #. 5# 4"(;2

!# $2& 6. 4" 6.

! !.! # , 6# .(&6( 6(&2!

." ((!

#"( .#..2 ! ..( $! .

6.(&A66#. .# ,#! ( 4(%&&$% .,.

(! "(& "# !

..%# %%((:# 4 #.5# 4"(;.. .

$ ( 2 # ,#(1 #* 6.2! ##& 6,( # , 6( 9 + .# 2.#6

#!# .#2

( !# $.

..."((& (.,.

( 4* 6.

:+ 4 #.5# 4"(# %.# ;24 #. 2. 4* 6..6 ,

, .

..!"(4# %

4( #&

3!#%

. $# 2.!# . .(

. <%(!

..,.

( B" + %.# 2 . 4* 6.2

( %#!#

6%#( $ #&41 #6# 6$ 4 ( & . .! .#!# .

6,.

(2#! #6

# .

$ . ! # !.! #6

#!# .( !#6 2!

.$%((< <!(6 . 4&. # %2 "#.# 6..!

#&%#& 5.%# %%((2 . "#$%&:# 4 # . 5# 4"(;2 (

( %# !# $ !

. . "

"( %#( $ #&41 2 (" ,( & .( .# ,#2 $%#%# #6

# #

#, .#$ .%( & 5. .( !#( 2.( 6. .4

.. 6#4$&

5.$.# :%# # %9;! %# 6 4&.5# 4"( 8 # #$

" .B" # 4" 6( 6. # ,# .@

6,.

(@2.$" $% 4!#. ,( & .( .# ,#2.(#5# 4"(2.4

, (2.( # % 46( 6 # , 6.#!

.!.

. . $!

. .

" $% 2."( $ !

#$.

$A#"# 5. #"# !# .&# 9 :CA/ 9; 2!

..#"# ., 64

$ &# #2 &# 4 #. %#.#"# #.

$&# 9 2."( $ ! 2 32!.# #.&# 2 ! .! 4+ 37!,#2 ! ( $.."( $ ! 2 2 3%#$.2!# !.

."$ CA / / 24

#$ . C

2 . 6#.2 !# ( , 2 !.

. %# %&$ $4&!& (($ #%(!#.+ 2 2 32.. 4%"#. 4&. .

4#.#(!

#* 6.2 *# 2 . 6#.5. "$ !#.(4 "

%# $ . 2 %&$ (($ "(.,4$ .#4&. (

$.#%#%#&2#4&.!# .%(2 .4#.# C,.4<" ! 4.(1 (& !

4#.# ! "#.#.(. "(4#$ !..#.%

.# !#$(&4&. #$.

! $2 # 2!..#. !#%

!# 4"

#4&!& .

72 . "( $ . ! < 4 + 32 %#.

( #"#

( 5.4, $2.(#5# 4"( D .

"$24&!& (

""#%# % $2#(& 6"%.1"6$

.*"%#$"# # %(!( ! ")*+ , , %:

;*5/':=4; 8*5."

2 D 2. "$2 ."( $ 2 (" 6.

"( $. $ .

.2 ( 4&!& ""#%# % $2! <4+ 282 3 .$"2" #! %%( !# .%# (( , 6 A% 2.., 64.(4# %

4( #.

$ ( 2.

$.#5.#4&2 "$ 2 928 83! ## ,4&.5# 4"(2 ."(% $ # 9.# = ..6 ., 64%#,4

&# %#.

4 #.##.

$## 6#

2$"( %( # ! %%(

%# . # . 1"6$ # # - , % ( %!

) ) !, %' :

; *

2.#4&4# 6 6. ($% "#.. (

$:4."## ""#;2 + 83

5!# (

"#(A% 2+ 9 3"#.

. !#!#+ 2 3! !# !# (

# "$2 5."

2.($% !#4&.5# 4"(2!

+ 2 83 . # "$2 # % ! .( ( + 22 832!.# # %9.# 2 .$.# 2 ! .( (+ 2 2 3# E D%#"$2 #$.

( 6 .( ((. #( F .$% $"2 ! ( !#.%# %( "$24&.(#5# 4"(

6 #6"$ 4 # .

"#2 (# " ( # . %%(( "#$%& "4$ .(

""#%# % $

.,4!#.( $# # %92 .!

$.## % ,(& *.

,%* 6.2#%&4(

, ! . ..

" 6# $% #(

""# %# % $. 4# ##(#6#. .*"%#$"#2 !.#. !

A (#&2 %#$147 "#.#

"4$ ..$.# 2 %# # %92! (

"4 B"(& $%( # %4 #.(#0# ( $

5# 4"(2. 6#.24 6.$.# 24","((& .!

%#6 G2.(#5# 4"( #%%# $

$% .A ( 46 ,# %9. #$ 6$"2 + 2 83# ( $2" .( $% 2 83

'#" ( #.( $#

41#2..#.2

"4$ .2 $# 2$% #(

""#%# %

$. 46 , %#.1"6$ .*"%#$"#

"$ %

& "' ( ($ ) * + $". 2. 4

&# 629 D

( %#, $! 4.

( $2("(.(

""#%# % $H!.# 2(& D. 44&.5# 4"( *. "#.# "4$ . "#(A% (&+ 92 3.,46#2

!.# ."(4+ 92 32 , ! . # 1"6$ '

# "$. ( 4!#(&.A 2 32!.#

."(4+ (26 #$ . # 1"6$ *. "#.# "4$

.,."6..$.# 2 *$-$( .-"## 92

%%((##

41#4 #.

"#2. #$

6. 4!#.# #.(

.# 2 &"66

# 6.#6"$ (#" (.B" $% 2.

.#6#6( 6 "

4(< 2 ."6.2 %

((&(#" ( #.%%((. #6".

"2.!,#2%#"

( .6#" %%(

(4&. %%(($%& .!

..!# .5# 4"(2,

" 2 !

.#6#.6( 6 # .# 2 # , 6.>

6 ,.

(?2. 4.((672

#&(!

#$.!#.4 #.5# 4"(2*$. +"< +$2%%# /=9#.

, 2

& "%%# .# 2.

. 9 24"

9%$2!..! 6 6

#$. 6#.0.( 2.

$#&(2. !..$#&(

# .

$! # , 6 (! %.(

.#.#

$# . .( . # 2 !. . >

6 ,.

(? 4# 6 #6

# 7 8 24 6# , %2# .(&6( 6(&2 $ #$.

-"$4#.!<.

.$#&( # .

$ "( . 2. ! #66(6

4&.# . % .#!# 2. .( !# "%%#4&

%# !.( $4&!

. %# . $%"6 !#2 . $ *$ . ! "#4"2 .# ,# .>

6,.

(?2(1 #* 6.2."6..

!# $2 % .!

&72. 5# 4"(<,# #2.4

. # $&2

( . .."$4# .>

6,.

(?.$ (1 # * 6.24. "$ .+#6

#2%.,#

6 , . ( 5.

! "#.#.4

. ..!

2*$.2 4#<! &$# .

A$ "#.#2.% $#$#%#., 6##4#. *.

,%* 6.. # "( 1"# "

$#,.

( 9 2.

"6( 62! ,"# . ( $6 # .# 2 .# ,#(1 #* 6.

, ! .4,2

# 6.# %# ,# ,

% .!

4A#4". $& .&!

2 !

.. .## 66 ,4&.5# 4"(2 #

6#!

6 "42."6..%%(($%&. # ##+"( 8 .+"( .++6"( 2 82%# 6" 4A#

# 2 !.$ (64# ,.# #$2!..& !

.#4"(.#4&# 2.. ! # , 6##(& (! %.(#&#

$#...(

# 2!..>

6,.

(?# ,# .(&2$.

$ #$ .

9 ! $ 6 .

" . $% !# 4& . 5# 4"(

7, 6

#.#6"$ #

4&(#" ( #. %# 2 ( .!# .(#5# 4"(2 $&% 2.#

41 #, 4((!.A.. "#(A% !##

.(!#

2 . <%( .&# ".

+ 92 3 !"( 4 . $" %&4(2 %# ( (!2 (" 6 . 1"6$

"%#;5. $

# 6(& !# * $ (#(&2 . $% !# !# (

# "$# #

41#2

( .+ '2 %# .# . $1"6$

( !..#. # .$.# . ! B"(&$% #4&.(#5# 4"(, ! .

. .. ( 4!# "$ ' 2,."6."#

%#. ."(.,4!# ( "$ #.(

.# 2.!,#2 .4 %%(2,., 6

(&#

41 2. "$ ' (#&!#

# B"$% 7!,#2 .$" (" .$% (

""# %# % $2 !"(4 "41!.. 4.( "#.#.2 %#6#%. 8

#6# . (#" ( #.%%((.!

%92-$( .-"$# 2., 64%#6 , 4 #.(#5# 4"( ".2$%

%&4(.#2. #6"$ ( .$". & .# 4 #.5# 4"(2

(" 6.%# %%((5.B" %%# $ .$% (&4414&.( $ .( 2 , ! .

.!..#.($" $%

% %# "(#( $#

%%# &%# "(#$# $6 .( $ 3.#(6( . # 2

#(&4! ".%# #. !. & #( 4(%&. #$% $" .%# 2.#

41#2 .!

! 2 . #

&41 ".%%# $2 2(#" ( # .#

41## 2. #6"..$.# 2 %9.# 2. 46 ,B"$% #.(

.# 72!

..( $ 4 #.5# 4"( #

6&41 ,.

62.%&$ $% . $.# 2!.! ( # %4 #.5# 4"(2.

"#$%&.

( 4(%&. #$% 2!..# %# #..#241 ".%%# $

8 $ 6.

" 6# $% #.(

""# %# % $2..@4(*"%#$"#2 ,! $ -!, $ + ) * . # ##.$# (#6#.2.6#"..1"6$

.#( #1"6$ "' ( ($ ) * + 72."6.6#!

..(#" ( #. #

41#.9 D2 D2 .( %#, $

."(.,4 # 4&.5# 4"(2("(.(

""# %# % $2 ".$"

!4 64&.

"#.(

$ 2("(.(

""#%# % $ 92 ".$":."6. ("(;2

##4<%

4"# .( $ ((.

..@4(

*"%#$"#:4&.(#6#.; 7!,#2. (("($" .((4%

4&. %%(( "#$%&!

..(#5# 4"(2!.

.!"(.., . "$%

( F4<2 ##& $A $"$ # .#"%5..$"!("(2!"(##&

# E D%#"$2#" #$. .

( 6 .( 2 ((. %

. ( F4< .1"6$ .*"%#$"#.( ,"((& ,"# .

"#$%&3,.

(!# 2.

..(

""#%# %

$#4% ".( < 2.%%(( "#$%& !"(4# ".$"%

..#.2

..@4(*"%#$ "#.( ,"# ( $ ".( < 2. !"(4

4"# #

41## %9 B"($" 2!

"#.## #.

"#2 . $$# !# .5# 4"(

".2.$% !4 6!##

9.# 2!"(4 ((!

.# # #6# .

$ .( $#4&. 2

6#!

6 .5# 4"(2.4

$A#"#

(4&. 2..

$! 3%# "$ 72 . . 6#" %%(2 ! < 4 # . 5# 4"(2..

"( $! 2 2 3%#$.24%2 !

."&

#$%# .#6# B"(&2.

6 .5# 4"( .#6#

"%.(. $ . $ .

<4+ 3%#"$7!,#2 , ! !.. 4

.# 4,2!

.#6#.

"6# 6 ""#%# % $2. "((

$2$ "

""#%# % $4&. 5# 4"(2.,4("( 5."

2%%(& 6 # ". # "$ 32 !# .%# (( , 6A% 2."((

$2# 9.# 2!#< "4+ 29 35. $"2$"( %( #

4%%( #$ .# 1"6$ :

"%#;# 6(&

%%( 2 ! %%( 4&. 5# 4"(5."

2.((

% $# 9 .# 2 $ "

. (

""# %# % $2 $ + 2 2 3 72.(

4&.5# 4"(24& D . $ 4&!& (

""#%# % $2

!2 $ "

".(

""#%# % $2

. # "$

+ 2 2 37, 6("(.4,2.$"!!#4&.

1"6$2:#%2$ "

""#%# % $;

((!

;

"( $

+ 2 2 3

;

# "$# % .# 2 !

+ 2 2 3

;

.# %9.#

+ 9 2 3

5!# "#(A% ( #

+ 92 3 IIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIII 5(

92 3

8 5."

2. # "$

2 2 883(

..$"

+ 83!#4&.5# 4"(

2 % . ..

"#. !#+ 2 3 $## !# (

# "$+ 2 3$#!#

"#(A% 5.# #.(!#$%

!4&.

"#2

4, "

(&4"

""#%# % $. 4

# 4&.

"#2.4,$% 2!.# .5# 4"(. D.( $ (#&#%$& $

#( # C, 2 .%%(( "#$%&

.( ( #,#.

# #$# 9.

624"

.(# " ( ## 3#

41#. "4$ ..$"(#&

4"# ".2###,#&2!..

" %&$

$% #(

""#%# % $

((% 64 #. *"%#$"#2

%%#%# 2 $&% "# 2

,"((&.%A "#.( . ".$%

%&4(2..%%((!"(4 ( #,#& .

# + 2 2 8832 "41 "#((&2 !.,#

.(4&. #'# .

$ 6!("( 6.(

""#%# % $ !.

.# 9!"(4 (2% 6"%."$

. .@4( *"%#$ "# .

" 6# ".

$% ".( < 2!.#. !

A (#& #6"(#144"! 2 .

24"

$ ("(

4 6$ #$ !.. 4.( @ 2#!

"%#;2

$". 29 D ."( $

4 6.

$2#$ .(

""#%# % $#

9.# * .(

"( $24 "%."( $ . : 3;2. (#&4("(2(&.#$ 6(

!# ""#%# % $2 9 D .$" "( $2

4 ! ("( 9 D + 3

+ 92 3 #$ .2 # " !# .%# (( , 6A%

4$2

"$ + 28 3 5."

2 . "( (

""# %# % $ 9$ + 28 36 2$"( %( #

4 %%( . "$2.#4&4# 6 6.((

""#%# %

$. # 4+ 28 3* (

""#%# %

$.A D @( $.,(#&4 !#% $% # 92.%%((

#B"

(&.

#4!.$"("(4&!&

69 D D."( $ '

""#%# % $4& D. $

+ 32 #" #!# .%# (( , 6A% . 4&%%(& 6$"( %( # .# #2!#< "+ 2

883 5."

#4!.$"+ 28 3!("(2 $ + 2 82

3 5.# #2.

.$"!.

!4%

4&. %%((2!

..5# 4"(2(6!

. D # .#"%2#" #$.

( 6 .( . ".%

5.5# 4"(!"(

$$ (&.# #2 (#& # %#6#%. 82%

. # $"

( F4<2##& 6$A $"$ # J%

..@4(*"%#$"#.

" # 2. $"!"(# 6(&4

4"# 2!

.. # #""% 2 .#

9 B"($" 2#4# ".%%((2 . $&4 B"(&2 .

%%( . #

41 .#2 #

% 4,2!

.##

. #!$%/ ! ,$