High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/1956/2023dismissed

Nachhattar Singh v. State Of Punjab And Others

2024-01-23Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary3 pages

!"#"$"

%""" "$"

&&'

()*+, -./0-012 3

45.66577589/2:6 ;<<-==527 >-8?@? 9757-1A@2B5C520176-8? ;D-?<120-27?

"EF G#HEIJ!

I #" K"!

I G#HE J!

I"E""

% LLL 8-?-27 +8396565=M0N1.57-MA1876-5<<-==5273 +?35N52O55@=MPM@2B5C3 LLL "E""

%K!J EQRSSTQ'U'V W18 76- 8-5?12? ?757-0 /2 76- 5<<=/.57/12M 76- ?5X- /? 5==1Y-0 520 0-=5O1A 05O?/28-A/=/2:76-5<<-5=/?6-8-CO.12012-03 EZ[\"]]^Z_ 3 `6- 5<<-==527 65? .1X- @< /2 5<<-5= 5:5/2?7 76- B@0:-X-27 520 180-8 057-0 3

<5??-0 CO 76- =-582-0 9/2:=- a@0:-M Y6-8-CO 6/? <85O-8 A18 C-/2: .12?/0-8-0 -=/:/C=- Y5? 217 5..-<7-0 A18 76- ?-=-.7/12 <81.-?? A18 P81@< bcM @2B5C /N/= 9-8N/.-? (de-.@7/N- 852.6,M 12 5..1@27 1A 6/? A/e-0 <5O :850- 1A D?3

fX5g/2:6/XA5==Y/76/2:81@<bc.57-:18O1A-X<=1O--?3 3 `6- =-582-0 9/2:=- a@0:- 650 0/?X/??-0 76- Y8/7 <-7/7/12 CO 8/:67=O 1C?-8N/2: 76-8-/2 7657 5? 76- 5<<-==527 Y5? 085Y/2: 76- <5O :850- 1A D?3

f 12 3 3

520 /2 7-8X? 1A 76- .=58/A/.57/12 180-8 057-0 3 3 M 76- ?@C?-h@-27 /2.8-5?- /2 6/? <5O :850- 71 D?3

f Y1@=0 217 8-?@=7 /2 5 .652:- /2 6/? ?757@? 520 76@?M 217 -27/7=- 6/X 71 <587/./<57- /2 76- ?-=-.7/12 <81.-?? A18 P81@<M 5? 6/? <1?7 ?7/== A-== /2 P81@<3 i7 Y5? 6-=0 CO 12cC=- 76- 9@<8-X-

! "#$ % % &' ()*+ , *- &%.

#/ 1 234

5 67 68 9:7;978:78<=79>68?78;@7:;97A

A B7=:C5 D<7 68 ?89< D7<<8? =C 68 :878? 3@:8 4?@8 68 D8<8 E785 7 7??7: 7;;?7F ?78?

AA G7< ;:8? =C 68 8DC 38987C5 HFA ; I7=5 8D7E8 ; 8<8:5 G696 < 7DD<8 =88;88?7?87?<6< JA K67 68 7=F8 E88? G < D8?@ =8;8 6< L=:8683D8E87?<;M8?; A A K67 68 L=:8 @6 G7< D:87<8? <<8 ?89< AK68D87F8D7;68?8<7<?8 JN88D@ F8G 68 7@E8< =8@ 7??8<<8? =867:; ; 68 D88<5 68 378 < ?898? ;:8 7 7;;?7F 8@7?@ E=8 ; 97?8< 9:?8? HD JO <8F98<5 7< D8 7C 28F< 2:8<5

5 G696 G:? @8 D<68? D 68 DD8 HD 38F98< 799 ; 987 =8@ :C @7?8 D7C 7< 86798?P ;8?7;868<7C7C28F<2:8<5

A K67 9ED:798 ; 68 7=F8 ?89< ; L=:8 @6 5 68 8D7E8 ; 8<8: 67? ;:8? 7 7;;?7F 68 =7<< ; ;E7 <DD:8? =C 8D7E8 ; Q798

AA 5G696<7:87?C89?7<8M82A

A K67 36A7>6G?8 3@6 R75 <8: ; 68 D88 67? <8 7 :88 ?78?

AA G688=C 68 D8? 67 68 97?8 ; D67E79<< 67< =88 E88? 68 78M8 77968?7<8M82A A K67 D 898D ; 68 7=F8 :885 8D7E8 ; 8<8: <@6 68 9:7;97 ;E 68 8D7E8 ; Q798 68 <<8< 7<8? =C 68 <8: ; 68 D88A 8D7E8 ; Q798 F?8 < :88 BAPP QP ?78? A A 67< <8 68 8F<8? :<5 G696 9:?8< 68 D<< ; 67E79< 7? :9> SM8< S?97A 9DC ; 6< :88 0?:C 7<:78?1 7:@ G6 68 :< < 89:<8? 688G67<8M82 AO

A < D8 8M8 2 5 7DD8?8? 688G65

D<< <96 7< <<<7 3= T<D89 R>6 38F>75 7; T<95 U><6D T<95 4 6@7D685 <<<7 7E87E75 7= T<D895 R V869:8 T<D895 67E79<5 :9> SM8< S?97 G:? 67F8 =8 D:798? @D WL 978@C567?=88;689:7;97C<9<?78? A A A

! "#$%! #& '( )*+,(( -./0,( ! &

%% & % 2% 3# # ! &# 3#

#&1& &#

# &4

%% "

5 #3

# #$ ! # ' 2 & 5 2 & 6#'1&

4 & &

&' #3

4 & & # "& " &

# & %% 4 "#$%!#&$! # $ "

! 3&4

% 2% #

2# ! 7&1 #!

! 2 & #$&4 # 2 &

#3 & 3 % #!4 &$ 4 # ' &! & 2

! &# '

$! '#$ #3 &

%% & $ # '

&!4 # &

& & &#3 8' 3

% " &# 2

& &

& 4 &

33& &

#& #3 4 "# "#$%! ' 2

%&! &#$ 9 &77

! 9 & 3#

! #"

% # &! 3$&

#1#&# %% &#

#!& 23# & #$& % # !$ &# & 3# # &' &#

! 33%$:#3&14&% 1#3&

%% & #&!

2% #&

#&! #$& & & '

$ !! $ &# & 5

'" !33& & & # #3 & % ! ; % <$! 4 " '

$% 3 & !$1 & #3&

& #&3 &

1&4 #! %! 1

! !

% &# 43 4 %%2!!

# !#3 = >?@AB=CDE?@F=======================================>DGDH=IEDBJED?KF= = DIA@HL=IE@MN=OBPA@IM= = OBJLM=

#5Q ' R&

5 Q

S8;QTU R&9 #& 2% S8;QTU