← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCEA/6/2022allowed

Commissioner Of Central Excise, Delhi-Iv v. A.K. Singh, Director, M/S Pelican Tobacco Co Ltd

2023-12-018 pages



                 



          



 

     



 

  ! "! "  ####$%%   

&  $#'# (

)* +  "#,#####-

  .            



 

    ####$%%   

&  -#'# (

)* +  "#,#####-

  

 

 !" "#

$ % 

 " "# & '(& " )")")*(    '(&)" )(   +

/ ) #& " 

  (&

 ) #

0 $  # 1

 #  22222 ")")+

,+-+./+0" #

 %%  





.3#45#.45$

$6% "7&   

   $%%  $ 



 

% 7)* +  "#,#

&%7

7%

% &

   89 

 $69:  

.:#4#.45 $

 $4 

 

 

   4#4:#.46$

$#

2- .#   &  

 %   ( ;&   

& 

/ <=

,# $ 

% 

.3#45#.45$

$3



 

        7 %

%  (   

 

 

(

 :#48#.48 $

 $8

"7 

 (  %

%

%  &"> 

%  "7)* +  "#,# 

  "7 ? @" ?(& 

.A#45#.48$

$ : 

 "7 ? @" &%

 & 

)* + ,   0

% 



  

.8#46#.48$

$9BC 8# $ %

&    %%

"0 & (       

 *  & 84#4:#.44$

$   & &%

 )* +  "#,# 

( 

   

    

 

((     &

 &  "

 (

 #  

   "

 .#4:#.445&



 

& 7 

 .8#45#.4 $

 $.  &  &

 %    %

7&

   $"&% 7

  

 # 

  %

%   &

  &

/ <D--   

%    

 ( &

%      $   

   $ 6::   0"   #   

 



7   

   &7   - #.:8959.*E- #5.435*F$- #334.9:* F 1 - #.3485:4* F  $ - #.4::* F # - #:399.5*F?# - #4A9A5*

)* +

3- " # ,# + 1#83E   A ! " &

 $ 

 $6::G   

 



7   

   &7  - #6.58358:* E - #3.A9A843* F 1 - #6564.89*F$- #3953.54*F# - #54.A3:* F?# - #64885*

)* +  "# ,#+1#83E A! "&

 $ 

 $6::G   

 



7   

   &7  - #9839:.9* E - #853885.66* F 1 - #99..5A4* F $ - #:.55:.:8* F $ - #A.5:59* F #  - #448968* F ? # - #.:8484*

 )*  +  " # ,# + 1#83E   A ! " &

   $  

 $6::G  



7

"



  &7

 )*  +  " # ,# + 1#83E  A! "&

 $ 

 $6::G   &    - #4544444* 

7  "7 )*  +  " # ,# ! "    &7 "7 &

(  %% %  "  &7 "



&7 

;&

"



  #   %

7   - #A84694963* -&%

 7 



1

, ! 7 &  ! &

1

7 

7# # ;&

 & &7



 )*  +  " # ,# + 1#83E   A ! " &

   $   

   $ 6::# ?

   

        $ 



& &7

 &

 %"7 % 7

 847 



%  D

&

7 "

;&.9H & &7 





&

7   %  847 



%  

# !&



7&

-&  .9 

 -& .44. 

;&

"

%

7  "

% &

 $ $#

4-   %

7   - #44444444* -&%

 

7     $& '&   ( 

 )*  + "#,#! "&

-& .A 

 -& .44.#   %

7   - #44444444* -&%

 

7     -> '&   ( 

 )*  + "#,#! "&

-& .A 

 -& .44.#C :#

 7 $#'# (  -#'# (

 

  7 

%7

%%    7%% (1#.3.*.4.3:.39 .3A.33 .56*.#

:#48#.4:$

$8

  &     % 7  %  94H   &7 %



"





%

 

.8#45#.4   (7 & %

#

 

 

& % 

  0   % 



7



7 94H

& 

 0 ( 

  - #4544444* 

7 #  % 7 %%     &  "7  ( $A9.48  &(  

) #$#'# (  E

"70 ( &   



     9 7   % %%  @  &"   

- #A

 &"

  9 7  "7 

 

 .A#45#.48    %%  &"

 

 #D & &

 & "

  &

  &  

 &

 (

 & %   

;&

"

"

% @  7

 

  &    .A#45#.48 %  

    

5- .8#46#.48$

$9# 

 

$ A9.48   &%  

       4#4#.48$

$A  &

%  & # 9#  % 7 

 ,+.5.6:.5.69.4: "

$% &



;&

"

"7 8#.#.49

& - #:

.#45#.49 $

$3#$   %&      

   

&  # 

%%

7

        

 



   .8#46#.48 $

 $9

 

$% & # "

% -





%      # A#

%%  7 

%%

$  

;&

   "





 0 (     ( &   %  

"

% 

 &"

#

%   %   

 (    %%  

#    7 %%    "

 

 "7

  "& "7   $#'# ( 

7 4#45#.45.3#45#.45$

$5 $6# 3# 

.:#4#.45$

$4    &   7  0

% 

%%  &  &

 

    "

(%% 1 #.3: .39 .4

 7 %%   "

   

 

  "

6- :#48#.48

"7 %% &

"7  %7

 

 % 7  "

  % #

& 

  (  



  ((

 ( 

%

 # 5# $  "  

   %%   &  $% & "7 

%  ,+ 

 

  %

   % 7      "

"

  %

 

%   %%   "

#   &"

;&

%% 

 



"7  

 .:#4#.45 $

 $4  

 "

& 

# 

  

  

& 7 "7%    (   7  &

  -

&*&   

 "

  (  (    %%   

 ( %%  & "

 

&    

   

 &% -

#- & 7 4#4:#.46$

$   

  

 

>    

 %%  



7  & %  7

 

(  

 ?( & #'

% (

 

.3#45#.45

 "

 

(  ">   

&  

 

 # 6# & 

 " ;&

  &"

    %%  

 

  %%

    

7 "

    "7 

 

 %

  7 

"& 

 &  4#4#.48$

$A

7-

"7  7 - #A 

   "

#  $   " $% & 

&

- #:

  7"

 &">    %  #   &  

# 

&    (    7"



 %7  7

%



( ("

 &  $% &  % 7 &(  #      &  &   

  %%  >&   "7 %%

  7 

  

% 

   

  0

#= 

  

% 

   &  # 4# - & 7

 

 %     ;&     &  "

  &  -

  

 >&   &  & 

  

% 

,+   .#45#.49#   %%     "

  (  "7  

     7  .45   7  4#45#.45  %%

7 "

 &



&  

7     "

 

 "7  #  



%%  ("

 "7 $% &   7 %%

       %%

7 

 

"

%7 ( 

0   

 "7  &   &  

(7"

( &(

"7 # # - & 7 

 %%   

 

#  =    % 7 &%

   7

% 

8- &

%& 9#48#.4.8"&

 %& %% 3#43#.4.8



 0

&%

7   %&  # 1")")*(2     " "#     1(  2          =

 % 0 (*

 

/ I =

- " / I