High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/28214/2017allowed

P.G.S.D. High School Hissar Th Its Secretary v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2021-10-04Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan15 pages

!""#$ %"%&!"%%'" (%)%" *!!%(#

% +%& %'"%

,- %

% ,.$*/ %"-%

% "%*!!%(#$** $ %'

% "%"0/$*/ %"%-1 )&-"%&!"/%!

%3 !""#$ %"%&!"%%'

(%)%"*!!%(#"#"(%-! %- %' "%&!" %%'$ -%4 5& %' 5&$ "!%"$ %%$ %' 5&$ %'$")&#$%5& %$ % "/6"&%$%/!%&(%"&%%%%% 7&"!%%

*8&%-9'%- 1 3%%$%'5&$ %'$")&#/(""

%% : -9'-%3"#%4!" %/%-1 3"/6"&%"9(## %% -9'%-1 ;%5&

%$ %%.!"--##9'%-1 !" %4%% : &"%-1 %!

%4 %- 1 3 "/ 6"&% %/ ("

44#!("##"#9

$"-"%-1 3"/6"&%(--"()%%!&#%99'" -%3"#;

:<-%"%4" 4-#'4$"(%4-%9%-%'%$ ("" &# 9 8 % &" &%"% -% " 4- &"%'&%%&#4'%4<"%/%- 1 (%!/%9' %'*"# &%'%/*$ :

,&#%4&%"*"'%: <"-%,&# %'*"# &%'%/,&#$:$ -% --"-%4-%9%-%('%$ --9'%%%&4'%--"%( 4-# -% -%9$ " --! &"%' 4' %4 &" -%$ " (%) & - ( %'%#%""4-#'"4-#"-% %#'

(/%$ (%)&"4-#'( &%'$""%/&#9-("$-- 9'%%%&4"%($"%/%"4"%4% - % 8 " -% -%9< "(/% " # -%

; -%9 #&! " 8 &# 8 "% '%< " 9&(%)&%-1 3"/6"&%( %'$"-%3"#%4"%//%% :

=#!!!%/$%-1 3"/6"&%% &%#-&"4%(%%%"%! %$ >&%#?%9&#3&43@9&%&%$ %$(""/(% A :

::; "# " %4 %/ %- 1 ( .& " ( # % ' %# ?" %% ( (%%!#'

?"%-1 3"/6"&%#1 BB ::;9%"&%%7&"!(%A :

::;- 9'%! %$>&%#?%9&#3&43@9&%&%$ %$ (""4&-%"%!"(%-(4/ .&!4;

,-1 "##!"%%9'

#!@*1 B $(""4&-%"%! :

"&%("#-%4!-%C%-1 3"/6"&% ("%("--#!%"4#9%'/##%/%4'

?"&!"&%"%&#$"%-%/#!' %-%%-!"%%-9'"4!4 %4!"%/"4-#'&%!"-%9-%$## %- 1 # --# 9% %- 1 ; 3 % 5& %$ % !!$"-%3 "##%-#'9%%-1 ;<7&%'"4%( %&-&'%5& %$("/"%-%

A B-'*8&%$#&"&#9) /&%%-1 ?"%-1 3"/6"&%# --# 9% %- 1 3 %%$ %' 5&$ %'$ ")&#$ (" %4 " 4% %- 1 ;

%!"4"4%)-!/("%&# ,- 1 ;4"--#%-1 /%%

,-1 #--#9%%-1 ,- 1 3%%$%'5&$ %'$")&#" %% - 9' %- 1 ; % " %-1 %/("###9/%%

?"%%&%"##!"-%(%- 1"(%-(!/"%-$(" -&--%"%&!"&#

,-1 ;"/#.(%4$ ("%%-1 4&-("-%(%4 > ".(%4#9"#%-1 ;$" 4-&!%%#!#/# 4#%#'"(% 4%-#'#%-1 $""%""4-&! %%-9'%-1 &%%4'##!#'% %4'"%%"4

>"/"%#%&#%"-%9!! "%&!""%%

* -%&# " --4 %% %- 1 -#%%*8&%!"("-%%4 4 " %%$ " -% ( %4

B -%9%-%'%$("" &# 98%&" &%"%-%"4-&"%'&%"%&#4'%4

?"%/%-1 (%-("/%% : $-'(""9!*8&% ?"-%/-%" %%##(

=#!!!%/9'"%%$%-1 "% &%# -&$ ("" ( .& 9' %! %$ >&%#?%9&#3&43@9&%&%$ %/%% A :

::;$"%4%/%-1 ("#9 .& %% ( 9%/ " %- 1 3 (%)4 ( #'%# ?"%%("##!9'

%-1 "&%9'('#!1 BB::;$ (""(;

9'-)!(##%%% > "/#(%-$"4!4"#")&--# "%-1 3"/6"&%(--"()% -%9%'%/%%;

:"-%9 &#989'&%"%-%'%$(""( :B##'-%9-%(8/%% : 9& (%) "/ 6"&% "()% ( %'"%49"%/(%%4 %("%4"--4 %/ (%-("&%!"-%-%99%4-# -%9-% >"('$"(%)4"%!""-

A 9&"(##-%9$(""%/%4 ?" 6" "%! "4% &"&#%8-&#9 9%/"(##%%%"@9&%&%(%)4( --(-%9(""%/(%-(" * %%"--4#%&%-1 (4 9%/!"%4"%4"--4#%$ (#%"-%9-%-%(%-%'% "4&#98%&"&%"%-%"&"%' &%"%&#4'%4 >-%1 ".&!4$( 9%/"-%("%4-%9%-%('% %%%&4$"%/&#9-("$"(%) &(&%'

>"('$-%%&#"%/" (%)4&#9-("("-%"%'% &%"%"@9&%&%"%%!"(%)& "(%)%( %'&%!"-%-%9 ?" #&! -% " .&!4 % /%' 4-% % %' %%%%-%&&%

!"# $"# % &!% % '

(

$) #

"* + ,!) #!% -%. +

,+,% / ! ) #%

$ 011 *&3+ ,%

%# % & #% #

% # 0 #! % !% #

"* + ,! % ! . 425 %

% "

! . + ,! ) # %

# 0 #! 1

% 3

% ! ?" (%)4 3 %- 1 " "##! " .&!4"!#6"9%/6"9'('#! @* ?"%%- :

"(&%

! !% % % % 6 % %%

>&"##$('""@9&%&%"&% "4"#&"%/"(%)4(% -("&%!"-%"-%9$"%(' "#!'-%4#7&%'

*%-1 3"/6"&% "("%("@*$"!#9!&-%-

1 "(%!!#&"4 ,"%"--%4 "##!!"!%4B"5/* &%"%4%"!-%%.&%4 " " 4% ( 9% % 5& %$ %3%-1 ;$7&%'"4%(!& %4-&'%5& %$("/"%-%%-%" "!%(""%%-9'" !"&%A B ?" --##9'"(%)4(49'%5& %$ % / %%

(/%$ %%$ %'

5&$ %'$ ")&# 3 %- 1 / %%

-'*8&%#&&%

D$ ! 6 7 8 !9

9" :;.69 #.

!9 < .. * !1 %&

% # #% % % 1 %& :;.69 #.

!9 $.:;.6 9 # .

! 9 % 8 #

?"%%"#"-%3"#!!%/ ?" 4-&! %% - 9' %%$ %'

: 5&$ %'$")&#&%%4/%&%4"(! ""9-("&&--#49'4--%# " &# - (%! %-% #($ !%! " .&!4-9'"&%%#%(%-&9/

%%$%'5&$ %'$")&#-%" &4- " %/ " # " 9 %4 -&"4 % 4 4& %! ; " ,&#$ ("%(%"%%/"-%(%- ("&%!"-%-%9%"%"(%)& 9! %' %4 ,&# %' * "#

&%' %/ ,&#$ : -! (" %/ 4-#'("&"#!7&%'&%!"-%-%9 9#!##'/##' &""4-#'%%"% "&"4-#'9!%'4 "!4&%%7&%!"#!7&%' ?"("# --%" %%$%'5&$ %'$")&#( 4%%%& ?"%%-9'"4.&# %&'&9# >"9)-4""4-#' )%&%"-%4#%4'&% %'*"#

&%'%/*$:

%8"&!.&#%4'(" "&#"/9//% ?"--##9'"4-#'(%9&; '% " %4 %% "!"#' 9# ! ("& !/! ' .&%!%#%%-!"%% ?" -%""%-#"-% %'+#&%'

5&,&#$" /%4")/%"- (-%$ #$ "()%$ $ %4 (%)! "#$"%%#(%)!"-"/94/

/%4"# ?"-%C"#4%"# -%/& ?"&%-1 "#4/%" -$("""9)/%9' %' /%4 @%&#%"-%"%%%.&!4 -9'/6""&%

("%#!("

--##$("(--#&$% -%9%-%('%$"&!"#%"%-%9( 89''%$"(/%$"%%/(%%4& &%'(%)$("#"%/"--## (%%49%4-#484&4-%"%'% -%/9' %'*"# &%'%/,&#$:

$ %!""%&--##"#"--%49

"%%%"%.&!49'/6" "&%"%!%# !

" " #" $ %% & % 1 ".&!49!7&%#/%-%&&%

! % $#

444 #% %

# 2

. - 90 .

+. . ,0! + 0, % ! % #> :

#2 44

# % # < #

$ $ % % & % #% $ %

> :

# # # : '

# !"#

# %

% 9! ! % %

# #

%% % & %

= # ! % % & # & %

% %

#8 !

& % % !"#

% & $ ! % % . - 0'

% # #% #

% & %

""%"$#%&#%"%-1 "#-#%#&-/%&.&!4 =%9!'( ) * " " *

+ & ,+ ("% #! (" ("% -% ( (%)!!&#'-"%( &%'(%)$"-%((%)!""#-% %4%%"%/&%9&"4!4""#" &!"'&%"%%%4"%4%%%%#' "%!"&!!"&%!!%&4$"%(%& 4-#!"(%)!%-1 ;$&""%( %-(""%/"!%&"(%)%& (##!#'&%'::

: "&%"%-%%/-$$

; ' .

&/0$(""(("%4!!44"# "%4"%/%-3"%%"%"" %%#'#"&#-9&"%%#%8-% (""--#%"- % >(9%/" 9%%4!"%%/$"4!!44(%7&% "#%!&#%-%47&%'9'##(!"-%&%/! &%,&#":

,&#($"%% %4("#9-/#-%/"* ",&#(&(""%%-9'"5 "%%%'5&!"%4%% "&%"%-#%#&-1

+ 2 $

324 $ 0,50 &--%" "7&%'"4%(%7&%9"#9% -!("%/-% (/%$".&!4%%%9'#%&#% %- 1 --# " -% & % %&4 " 8 ("" &" 9%/"94

1("7&%(""%/(#% !%!%%9'"@9&%&%%49'!# E&!"&%$&"!"/!#'@*# 9'"(%)4"9("%(9'"4$("(%)4 (%!!#&"! ,"%#%&)

?"4%"/!99'"&%4-.&%$ 9%-"4%/&"%/%%" 9' " &% 4- .&% *#"&!" #% &#%%-1 ""%!##'"-% -%9%-1 (%'%$(""(8 9'('-!-%%$"%%%4!%/&" %-("&-!-%-%-%&% %/!'"%! "&-"4$!!"%-#'$&!7&%'!"4 "!"9&"%-%$"%%-!("%/ %-1 9& (/%$#%&#--%!%"-%" !%##'""(%)4"4#"%"&%# -&$(""(.&&-9'"@9&%&%$ %"/! .&%"4%/#.&!4$-'(""9! *8&%;

>"/%'.&!4("#!&1 $"% %%4"/6"&%"%84"% " ( -- / #% ; :$ ##' " ( -%9$(""-%(8 ?"%%%#% :B : 58 C58 C;$%-/#'$-%/ /9'"4!4"("-%9-%(%)4 (8&-

?"%%$"%4%/ "/!)-#/%% : ("-%-%9 "%('4!4"#!'7&%'%! " ?" %% - 9' " 4!4 -! ("

B %/(%)4!4 ?"%%$7&%'"4% (%7&%9& ?"4-&!%%-9'%- 1 3%%$%'5&$ %'$")&#! "%% : -9'"4!4-!("" %/%-1 9&-"##9#9

?"%%%#'-%#( ?"%4%- 1 ((%!#'%%9'%-1 ?"4"%9' 9'('-"-%(%-

?"-##(%!#'

6%.

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#