High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/105/2018allowed

M/S M.C.S. Electronics, Sirsa v. The State Of Haryana And Others

2023-01-17Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra7 pages

Page - 1 - of 7

"!"#

$ !%"!

&' ()* )+) , -. /,. 011-- $ 2,.3 2. 1

$ "

!"!

&' ()* )+) , -. /,. 011-- $ 2,.3 2. 1

. ). 456 2./5/ .211-- '* ) )7, 6--8.//.3 9999

:2./ '.-* 24:67 2--1$ !%"!

& "

!"!

&62.77 ;: -8 . 5-5 <2 2 11- . .. / . < 6 =. .7 $ !%"!

& 2 11-/ :

#> 2 .3 $-: = / "!!# . 2 7 3. "!!"?"!!#/ 6 2

Page - 2 - of 7

.. !@ ! "!

=:. ?A* 1 <3 2 .3 = .<:

-/2 6.2/.4 6211-211-- 6 2.. "> !% "!!& '

=:. ?"* 1 <3 2 77 . '*?:7?

5 6:2.3/,.' B .* . 2 . 2 2 11-- 8 .6. :

.2.3 .-,-=8221.7 ,-= -:

.2.3 $-:=/"!!#/8--:

. 2 .- ,- = / @%> 7 :

"& 2 .3 .- ,- = / @# . 2 7 3. "!!"?"!!# 8.7<32 6:2.3/,./5.. @ !# "!! '

=:. ?

* 2../ 2 5 - :2.3/ ./ 5 .. "> !% "!!& '

=:. ?"* .4 2 :<7 7 <3 2 11-- 2..2< .7<32.<:

-5.. !@ ! "!

=:.?A* /21. 11- C.

- . 2 11-- 2 .6: 2 7 .23."!!"?"!!#8.7<32 6:2.35.. @ !# "!! '

=:. ?

* 2 1:3 = ( = 77 ./ 82- =. 6 2 18. 2 5 - :2.3 :

. 2 .3 $-: = :7 18. :

. 2 .3 @# : ..5 /822<3 4:. 1. , '

* 2 1- ,5 6 -:/ -3 . 1. 6 8. 5 <3 83 , '"*/ 822 8. 1 6277 7 2.3 $-:=/"!!# 2 / . 1 6 2 7 .. @ !# "!! '

=:.?

*/ 1. 68.1 6:

.2.3 .- ,-=/ @# 2 /2.5 -18.:- <=. <3 2 .1 ?:2. :

'"* 2 .3 $-:

Page - 3 - of 7

=/"!!# 2 1- 6 ,5 6-:.1.: :

? D > '

*2.3 @#'"! @#* 2.<3.1- '"*82 6 32 6 :<? '

*/? '* 311- /11-/.5 .2.1. 67. 1... 3 :2.3 :

. 2 / 1 6 2 77 7 2 / 2--/ . :2 77 7 / < . .. 1<32..:2.3828:-25 2 4:. . :2 11- / 11-/ .5 . 2. 6:

.22< . 2 822 :2 11- / 11-/ .5 . 2. 1. 6 8 7 . 1... E C.

-.211-- 2...24:67 1<32:.

$ #! "!

' # !% "!

@* 24:67 /2:.8 . 6 21.5 , > '

* > '"*2.3 $-:= /"!!# 1. / & @/8<.5:

? .72<5-6-1 /7.6 :2--/2:<?

*, > 2$2:< 51.5 2 ,2--<.< = .21:.1 8222 < 2.:

. 8.1 6 277 7 $

'"*'* $ / 2 1 6 11- / 11-/ .5 2.1. 67.1... 3:2.3:

., 8:- . ...1-2..:2.3828:- 254:. . :211- :

.2$ 21. .5 5 3. 1.5 :

. , . .5 2-- = 62 3. . 5 :- :.2./ $ 8:- 2 -: .27 2.8./ . -F.7 3.1.. 7 6 . $ /2-7 :

.2,8:-<11-<- 85./-8 < 61.:.--8/7 . 81.5 -8:

.$ .- 6-7 2--11-321 61. 6 :

. 2, .1:17 3."!!"?!#8--

Page - 4 - of 7

& 5. 6 2 :- 7.= 2 1. / 2 7 6 ;: 8. :

.2, 2../. 7 2 $ 822 7 . 8 !

!A "!!#/ 2 1. 1..< :

% 2. <7 11-<- 2 7 1. 6 1. , %'#* 2 $ / 2 1.. -F 624:67 7 2.3..72 -2 3.82227 .-82., %'A*2 $1.52.3..<4:67 7 .72- 2 3. 822 2 7 .- 2 $ 7 .

A "!!# 2:/2-7 1.2.3.8<71:.7 2 . -- 7 3. 1.. A "!!# 2 1. ;: -3/2-7 1..27 21. # # "!!>82.271:6 7 ..8.1 "> # "!!@ - 6 . 2 =1.3 -7 G2:/ 2 .<:

- .62-3 2- 2 ..< 6<..<3-7 --8211--<32 2.-5 6..<32.<:

-.2: ? D> H25.:--3 .27. . 6 > '"*'*2$/ 82 62.1-2,/ --1. 6 -: 611- .5 1 6:

.2, 277 7 2$8.<1<32 ..1 6 :2.3 :

. 2 $ 2 / 2 1. 6 ;: :

.2 , 8. 1 6 82 2 $ 7 . 2..:

.2$/-7 1.1..<:

% 2 $ <7 11-<- 2 7 6 2 8 -8 $ .6. 6 -7 < 6 1.:.- -8 - 2.8 <7 11-<- 2 1. 6 1 6:

.2, 258/8.:11.<32 ! "# $ % # # "# $

&# "# $ . 6 %'A* 2 $ / -7 1. . -F 6<4:67 7 2.3. 2$7 . A "!!# 2..2-7 1.23. <71:.72.--7 3.1.. A "!!# 2 ;: -3 2 -7 1. . 2 2 # # "!!> 85./ 2 71:6 7 .. --28.1<32 6 :2.3 "> # "!!@ - 6.2=1.3-7 2: :--35. 5:.2<32 ' (#)* (#':1.* H2 271:6 ..2 6:2.3. 2 <3 -7 / 71:6 .. 2 . 11-- :2.3 :7--36

Page - 5 - of 7

2 71:6 7 .. . 5 .7 2 <. :1 38.1 -<32 I<- 62:. 27.6. = <2- 2 2.6. <- 7-3/ 28.1 / I<-62:.<3 .7..23 -32.5.3= ...- .5 :<:2 327 1. 6

2 2. 2 / 2 71:6 7 .. 8. - 1 :. 621 38.1 . 22 :2.<-825.2.27-5<.5 271:6 .. 227 .11--1. 62 < 3<32 I<-62:. 27:-/2..< -F+1 2:

<21 328.1 <- 1 6 2 71:6 7 .. 2 < 3 3 6 21 6 -7 ../-7 1..1 6 27 .. 1..6= 7.-3: 1 3 2 . 8. 1 2 71:6 7 .. 8. 1 - 6 . 2 =1.3 7 1. -.3 : . <2-252.. .72<.-7 71--3:

1<- E

@ 5. 6 2 4:67 .- :1 <3 2 -.

- . 2 11-- ?.5 :/73 < 2 ( + ,

-. ':1.*/ 8 2- 2 , '"* 2 $ 65 3 ..1521.5 22.=1.-3.<3 .3 71- ,:< '"*, > 2$ 71-. . 1 6 1. 6 1. 6 11- / 11-/ .5 . 2. 62:2. ::

.2$ <1 <32:2. : 8:.2...2 =1.-3. <3 .3 7 / ..15:62<65 /2 .1-2,.;:.<=7 82.. , A 2 :

4< .--:/ &@&822 71-2 2< 3 ..3 =1.-3.71--3/ 3.62/1.5-6/-<-3. <-6 :

.2--88-- :<65.

.2--8 /

.':1.*/2 ::

., A! 2,.. 7 3..:7.5 7 8.2-- 6 21-J <321 .822- 6:6 , A!2:662 ..2--<.5.2=1.31. 53..722.. C. :

-.2,:<7 227.2< .7<J<321=:. .2: 822.21.1.5:

.282:.-7. -: .5 -1. 6.. 2. .=7 62.-5 :.31.5 2-8 21 /82-<32:.2 -:. 21.2-.:.

..1 /2

Page - 6 - of 7

6:2.3731.2<24:67 82 5 3..2=1.3:21.8228:-7 1. 6 8 -:221. 625< -:8221 6 2.. 7.-3 1. 6..5 2/2 :- 1 < 6 . / 2 7

< 3 5 6 2 -.

-.211-- ?.5 :."

-.211-- 22.4:67 2< --8<32.3 =.<:

-/2 6.2 0

& 1 ,"A%+"!!&?!@' !# !& "!

* <311-3 62.27/211-8--8 J1 6 58 2 . 7 6 . 2 .3 $ / 2 1..7J 67 .23."!!"?"!!#2< 71-82 2.3..727 .. /2 .. 8 1 <3 2 1. 2. 3./ 8 --6- 5 21. /27 ...23."!!"?"!!# 2 < 1 @ !# "!! '

=:. ?

* 1. 2 <5 4:67 /1.2.3.8:-=1. 23."!!> 85./ 2.. -8<3 21.-7 1..72 /2.5 -:2.3/82-=. 618.:

.2.3 @#/2: ..5 627 .. 2: 62 /2:2.:

.2.3 $ 2 4:. .5 2 ../ 7 68.1 682 2...5 81+:

/ .3 $ 2 7 ./ 2 :2. :- :2 /24:. ::2 2 < 5 2 5 6 -: :

'"* 2 .3 $-: =/"!!#

Page - 7 - of 7

/<311-3 62.2.4:67 2 2 1. / 2 71:6 .. . 2- < 82: 4:. , 2 7 .. 8 1 :

. 2 .3 1. 6:-< .7 6 .2.3 $/2< 21. 1. .7 2/ 1. 2 4:67 1

.':1.*/21. 6.27 3."!!"?"!!# 2 < 71- 82 1. 2. 3. 85./ 2 ..-2< 1 @ !# "!!'

=:.?

* 58 2 <5 : / 2 1. 11- $ !%"!

& "

!"!

&.--8 271:6 ..!@ ! "!

"> !% "!!&'

=:.?A ?"*. '

* '), *

"!"# 41

+ "#