Gurmej Singh And Another v. State Of Punjab And Others



   
 



!

 " 
! 

!#$% (%)*+*&, 

- -  ./0%1 2*,34 #,&$4%/ ------ %$*$*&,%/+ 5%/+.+ 2$#$% .,1#6 &$4%/+

------

%+7&,(%,$+

   8 9  -

2
  2 

/%+%,$  /- 5*1#:

#,#;

(<&)#$%

7%$*$*&,%/+-

/- #<,%%$ 2*,34;

2%,*&/ ! .,1#6-

/- -2- =4&>4#/;

(<&)#$%

- /- 5*/%, 24#/0#;

/- "#+4 2/*<#+$#<#;

(<&)#$%+

- &,% - /- 0*$

4#,1*;

2%,*&/ (<&)#$% ?*$4

/- 24#+4#,> 24%>4#/ 24#/0#;

(<&)#$%

-

&,% - - -  2  ;

-

9

- %$*$*&,%/+ 4#<% '*@%( *,+$#,$ )*<*@ ?/*$ 7%$*$*&, .,(%/ /$*)@%+ 
&,+$*$.$*&, ,(*#;

*,$%/ #@*#;

+%%>*,3 ?/*$ ,#$./% 0#,(#0.+ (*/%)$*,3 /%+7&,(%,$+ 

/%0&<% *@@%3#@;

.,@#?'.@ .,#.$4&/*A%( %,)/&#)40%,$ /%+7&,(%,$+ ;

,#0%@:;

#,#3*,3
&00*$$%% 24/* ./.

#,#> !#/6#/ /.+$ #,#3*,3
&00*$$%%

#(4# #(4#< #,(*/;

/%+7%)$*<%@:;

?*$4 )&,,*<#,)% ;

,#0%@:

 
/%+$



%+*(%,$+ %@'#/% 2&)*%$:

?#:

/#*+*,3 )&,+$/.)$*&, 24/* ./.

#,#> !#/6#/ ?%@@

#(4# #(4#< #,(*/-

-

'./$4%/ 7/#:%/ *++.*,3 #77/&7/*#$% &/(%/+ %,+./*,3 7#++#3%+$4&/&.34'#/%;

?4*)4 @%#(+ )&00%/)*#@ +*$%0#/>%$ #/% ,&$ 6@&)>%( ?#:

6#//*)#(*,3 $4%*/ (/.0+;

/#*+*,3 6&.,(#/:

?#@@ &/ /#*+*,3 #,:

&$4%/ $:7% +$/.)$./%;

*,+$#@@*,3 3#$%+;

4&#/(*,3;

6&#/(+ %$)- - /*%'@:;

)&@&,:

,#0% +$:@%  
/%+$ #$ <*@@#3% 4#3&0#1/#;

%4+*@ =4#/#/;

!*+$/*)$ 22 #3#/;

&4#@*;

?#+ (%<%@&7%( + .7$# .*@(%/+ /&0&$%/+ /*<#$% 9*0*$%(-

+$#$%( *,+&@<%,):

7/&)%%(*,3+ #/% #@/%#(:

*,*$*#$%( #3#*,+$  

,$%/*0

%+&@.$*&, /&'%++*&,#@ #@/%#(:

+$#,(+ #77&*,$%(- - %$*$*&,%/+ +$#$% #(<%/$*+%0%,$/%7/%+%,$#$*&, + .7$# .*@(%/+ /&0&$%/+ /*<#$% 9*0*$%(/%+7&,(%,$ 4%/%*,;

7%$*$*&,%/+ 4#( *,<%+$%( $4%*/ 4#/( %#/,%( 0&,%:

7./)4#+%( )%/$#*, )&00%/)*#@ 7/&7%/$*%+ ?*$4*, +#*( )&@&,:;

<*(% (*''%/%,$ +#@% (%%(+

,,%B./%  ,,%B./% C-

+$#$%( '/&,$ )&00%/)*#@ +*$%+;

$4%/% 7#/>*,3 #/%# &7%, +7#)% #,&$4%/ #/%# C '%%$ >%7$ /&#( *,3/%++ &.$3/%++ 3%,%/#@ 7.6@*)-

'./$4%/ +$#$%( $4%/% 3/%%,

6%@$ ?*$4*, )&@&,:-

- #77%#/+ /%+*(%,$ ?%@'#/% +&)*%$:

.,(%/ ,#0%  
/%+$

%+*(%,$+ %@'#/% 2&)*%$:

4%/%*, )&,+$*$.$%( +#*( )&@&,:-

)#+% 7%$*$*&,%/+ 7%/ 6/&)4./% ?%@@ +#,)$*&,%( +*$% 7@#, #'&/%+#*( )&@&,:;

,&

C

+*$% %#/0#/>%( )&,+$/.)$*&, &/ #,(*/-

+$#$%( ;

)&,,*<#,)% ?*$4 2&)*%$:

&$4%/ *,4#6*$#,$+ +&)*%$:;

/#*+%( #/%# #6&.$ C '%%$

#77/&B*0#$%@: #,&$4%/ #/%# %B$%,$

'%%$ %,)/&#)4%( .7&, /#*+*,3 7*@@#/+ 6&.,(#/:

?#@@ #/%# /&#(;

3/%%, 6%@$ 7#/>*,3 #/%# '#@@*,3 '/&,$ )&00%/)*#@ +*$%+;

?4*)4 $4%:

#/% ,&$ %,$*$@%( $&-

4% 74&$&3/#74+ #,(*/ 4#<% #$$#)4%( #@&,3?*$4 $4*+ 7%$*$*&, ,,%B./% 
&@@:

,,%B./% - './$4%/ +$#$%( %<%, #,(*/ )&,+$/.)$%( #, #/%# C  '%%$ './$4%/ %,)/&#)4*,3 .7&, #, #/%# C '%%$ #/%# 3/%%, 6%@$ #(1&*,*,3 )&00%/)*#@ +*$%+-

%$*$*&,%/+ +$#$% #))&.,$ )&,+$/.)$*&, #'&/%+#*( #,(*/ ./.(?#/#;

3/%#$ *,)&,<%,*%,)% )#.+%( 7.6@*) #$ @#/3% ?%@@ +4&7>%%7%/+ *,)@.(*,3 7%$*$*&,%/+;

/%+7&,(%,$+ )&,,*<#,)% ?*$4 %#)4 &$4%/ ?*$4 4%@7 +&0% &$4%/ 7%/+&,+ $/*%( 6@&)> 7#++#3%+$4&/&.34'#/% @%#(*,3 )&00%/)*#@ +*$%+-

#<%//%( /%+7&,(%,$+ 

#/% (.$:

6&.,( /%0&<% *@@%3#@ .,#.$4&/*A%( )&,+$/.)$*&, )&,,*<#,)% ?*$4 ;

,&$*)%( 4%/%*,#6&<%-

C- , #'&/%0%,$*&,%( )*/).0+$#,)%+;

7%$*$*&,%/+ 4#<% '*@%( *,+$#,$ )*<*@ ?/*$ 7%$*$*&, 6%'&/% $4*+
&./$;

+%%>*,3 /%@*%'

+;

,&$*)%( 4%/%*,#6&<%-

- , 7/%+%,$ )#+%;

/%7@:

6%4#@'

'*@%(;

?4%/%*, )%/$#*, 7/%@*0*,#/:

&61%)$*&,+ 4#<% $#>%, 7%$*$*&,%/+ 4#<% ,&$ )&0% ?*$4 )@%#, 4#,(+-

+.60*$$%(

 

)&,+$/.)$*&, 2#4*6 ?#+ +$#/$%( 0&,$4 7/*@;

 C #'$%/ 7#++*,3 /%+&@.$*&, (#$%( - - C /%+&@<*,3 )&,+$/.)$ <#)#,$ @#,(-

, 7#/# 

<

<** 7/%@*0*,#/:

&61%)$*&,;

'&@@&?*,3 +$#,( $#>%, 
  

             



     

            !     

    

"

 ! # !!          $

  

   !              !    !      $

 

            %       



  

  !   !   &'"

!       

!

         ! !

!        !        !      &'(

- + /%3#/(+ )&,+$/.)$*&, #,(*/ )&,)%/,%(;

*$ 0%,$*&,%( 7#/#

** #,(*/ )&,+$/.)$%( #@&,3 3/%%, #/%#;

?4*)4 (*+$*,)$ '/&0 )&,+$/.)$*&, <#)#,$ 7*%)% @#,(;

&?,%( 6.*@(%/-

-

./$4%/;

/%3#/(+ 7@#)*,3 (/.0+6#//*)#(%+6&.,(#/:;

*$ +$#$%( +#0% )#//*%( &.$ 2&)*%$:



7./7&+% 7/&$%)$*,3 /%+*(%,$+ 2&)*%$:

'/&0 .,?#,$%( <%4*)@%+-

2$*@@ './$4%/ 7#/#C;

'&@@&?*,3 +$#,( $#>%, 
)*               !                 

!  !   !

    !!

   &' 

   

!  !(

-C '$%/ '*@*,3 /%7@:

6%4#@'

;

#, #((*$*&,#@ #''*(#<*$ '*@%( &,% 24/* &4*,(%/ #@ 2*,34;

?4%/%*, *$ +$#$%( 2#4*6 )&,+$/.)$%( @#,( &?,%( &,% /+- %%@#0 %3#0 ?*'% 0/#, =4#,;

?4& './$4%/ %B%).$%( 3*'$ (%%( '#<&./ 24/* ./.

/#,$4 2#4*6

* - C-  $4%/%#'$%/;

#, #77@*)#$*&, /%3.@#/*A#$*&, 6.*@(*,3 7@#, +.60*$$%( 6%'&/% )&07%$%,$ #.$4&/*$:-

-

, &$4%/ 4#,(;

#))&/(*,3 /%7@:

'*@%( ;

#'&/%+#*( #,(*/ ?#+ 3&$ )&,+$/.)$%( :%#/   (&).0%,$+;

*'

#,:;

/%3#/(+ &?,%/+4*7 @#:

&.$ 7@#, #,(*/;

7&++%++*&, - +$#$%( /%)%*<%( ,&$*)% .,(%/ 2%)$*&,  /%#( ?*$4 2%)$*&,  .,1#6 .,*)*7#@ )$;

;

/%0&<#@ #,(*/ +#*( ,&$*)% #@/%#(:

)4#@@%,3%( '*@*,3 #, #77%#@;

?4*)4 7%,(*,3 #(1.(*)#$*&,-

- %#/(-

- , 7/%+%,$ )#+%;

7%$*$*&,%/+ 4#<% #77/&#)4%( $4*+
&./$ ?#:

'*@*,3 $4*+ ?/*$ 7%$*$*&, +$#$*,3 )&,,*<#,)% ?*$4 4#<% /#*+%(



.,#.$4&/*A%( )&,+$/.)$*&, #,(*/ #, #/%#;

?4*)4 '#@@+ #/%# 3/%%, 6%@$ &$4%/ #/%#+ ?*$4*, )&@&,:;

?4*)4 ?%/% ,&$ %#/0#/>%( )&,+$/.)$*&, #,:

+.)4 /%@*3*&.+ +$/.)$./%+-

-

7%/.+#@ /%7@:

'*@%( 6%4#@'

?&.@( @%#<% ,& 0#,,%/ (&.6$ )&,+$/.)$*&, #,(*/ ?%@@ /#*+%( ?*$4&.$ $4%/% 6%*,3 #,:

+#,)$*&,%( 6.*@(*,3 7@#,@#:&.$ 7@#,-

,&$ +4&?, 6%'&/% /#*+*,3 )&,+$/.)$*&, #,:

+.)4 /%@*3*&.+ +$/.)$./%;

#,:

#77/&<#@ '/&0 )&07%$%,$ #.$4&/*$:

?#+ +&.34$ &/ #,:

+.)4 7/&<*+*&, @#:&.$ 7@#, )&@&,:-

@$4&.34;

$#>%, +$#,( +.6+%D.%,$ '*@*,3 *,+$#,$ )*<*@ ?/*$ 7%$*$*&,;

*$ ?#+ (*+)&<%/%( $4%0 #/%# ?4%/%&, )&,+$/.)$%(;

?#+ &?,%( %%@#0 %3.0;

?4& './$4%/ 3*'$%( *$ ,#0% 24/* ./.

/#,$4 2#4*6

*;

'#)$ /%0#*,+ 6.*@(*,3+ 4#<% )&,+$/.)$%( ?*$4&.$ $4%*/ 6%*,3 #,:

#77/&<%( +*$% 7@#,6.*@(*,3 7@#, #,(&/ /%D.*+*$% 7%/0*++*&,+ $4%/%&';

%+7%)*#@@:

?4%, $4*/( 7#/$:

/*34$+ #@/%#(:

+$&&( )/%#$%( )&@&,:

D.%+$*&, *,*$*#@@:

$4%/% ?#+ ,& 7@#, +#*( +$/.)$./%+ +*$%+ D.%+$*&,- - &,86@% 2.7/%0%
&./$
 

               

  !"#  $%& &6+%/<%( .,(%/ 
+, 

    %     

-  !           

    

 *, .

 !   !# /    

 



   !

   !

 !  ) 0  )11*

 !

  !      !  

    

!  -                   

 !



  

 



   ! ! !      - 4*+
&./$
 '('#) !)

    

* $  +# *,& &6+%/<%( .,(%/  E)+   !!

 

   !  

 **3 " 4

! !  !   !!



!-    /     -    /  !        !!

  !    "

  



  5       

                



  !      !!

  



    $   !    !!

    .

   !   )*#6

  /   !-    7%# / 85 ,     9/  :&*);!+33+   !

 !

  !      !       

!  -               !        /  1<+33+ !     => ?, 

    %     

-  !           

    

 , .

 !   !# /    

     !

   



!     !            4 0  )11*2

 !

     !           !    

  

    

  !    -        

   

 !

 

  

 



  !  ! !     ,        

  

?

)@4 

   !!

 

 



   !

-   ! !  !



  !  

 **3 " ( - =%%7*,3 <*%?

#'&/%0%,$*&,%( '#)$+ )*/).0+$#,)%+;

+*,)% #,(*/ ?%@@ 4#<% )&,+$/.)$%( ?*$4&.$ $4%/% 6%*,3 #,:

+#,)$*&,%( +*$% 7@#,@#:&.$ 7@#, #,(&/ &$4%/ #77/&<#@++#,)$*&,+;

*$ 6% 4%@( )&,+$/.)$*&, #'&/%+#*( +$/.)$./%+

#,(*/ ./.(?#/# #/% .,#.$4&/*A%( #/% @*#6@% 6% /%0&<%(-

))&/(*,3@:;

 (%%0 *$ #77/&7/*#$% 7#++*++.% '&@@&?*,3 &/(%/(*/%)$*&,+

* /%+7&,(%,$+ #@&,3?*$4 $4%*/ &''*)% 6%#/%/+ #/% #''&/(%( 7%/*&( +*B ?%%>+ '/&0 $&(#:;

/%0&<% 4&@:

+)/*7$./%+6&&>+*(&@+ '/&0 +#*( +$/.)$./%+ #'$%/ (.% &6+%/<#,)% #@@ /%@*3*&.+ )%/%0&,*%+ /%0&<% #6&<%+#*( .,#.$4&/*A%( )&,+$/.)$*&,+ ?&.@( 6% #77/%)*#$%( *'

#'&/%+#*( )&//%)$*<% 0%#+./%+ #/% $#>%, /%+7&,(%,$+ $4/&.34 $4%*/ &''*)% 6%#/%/+ $4%*/ &?,-



** )#+%;

/%+7&,(%,$+ $4/&.34 $4%*/ &''*)% 6%#/%/+ '#*@ $#>% /%)&./+% )&//%)$*<% 0%#+./%+ +$#$%( 7#/#

* #6&<%;

$4%, $4%/% +4#@@ 6% (*/%)$*&, /%+7&,(%,$+ *$+ &''*)% 6%#/%/+ /%0&<% 4&@:

+)/*7$./%+6&&>+*(&@+ #'$%/ (.% &6+%/<#,)% #@@ /%@*3*&.+ )%/%0&,*%+ /%0&<% #'&/%+#*( .,#.$4&/*A%( +$/.)$./%+ ?*$4*, 7%/*&( '&./ ?%%>+ $4%/%#'$%/-

)&07@*#,)% #''*(#<*$ /%3#/( 6% +.60*$$%( 2.6 !*<*+*&,#@ #3*+$/#$%;

=4#/#/ #'$%/ %B7*/:

$%, ?%%>+ '/&0 $&(#:-

)&7:

)&07@*#,)% #''*(#<*$ 6% +.60*$$%( 6%'&/%

%3*+$/:

$4*+
&./$

*** %<%,$ '#*@./% /%+7&,(%,$+ $4/&.34 $4%*/ &''*)% 6%#/%/+;

)&07@:

?*$4 (*/%)$*&,+ )&,$#*,%( 7#/#

** #6&<%;

$4%, 2.6 !*<*+*&,#@ #3*+$/#$%;

=4#/#/ +4#@@ *,*$*#$% #@@ 7&++*6@% +$%7+ /%0&<#@ 4&@:

+)/*7$./%+6&&>+*(&@+ '/&0 #'&/%+#*( +$/.)$./%+ #'$%/ (.% &6+%/<#,)% #@@ /%@*3*&.+ )%/%0&,*%+ './$4%/ $#>% +$%7+;

?*$4 4%@7 7&@*)%;

/%0&<% +.)4 .,#.$4&/*A%( )&,+$/.)$*&,+ %B7*/:

7%/*&( 0%,$*&,%( 7#/#+

*

** #6&<%-

)@%#/ %,$*/% %B7%,+%+ /%0&<#@ .,#.$4&/*A%( )&,+$/.)$*&,+ +4#@@ 6% /%)&<%/%( '/&0 /%+7&,(%,$+ #,(&/ *$+ &''*)% 6%#/%/+

*< './$4%/;

)#+% '#*@./% /%+7&,(%,$+ *$+ &''*)% 6%#/%/+ )&07@:

?*$4 (*/%)$*&,+ )&,$#*,%( 7#/#

** #6&<%F %<%,$.#@*$:;

2.6 !*<*+*&,#@ #3*+$/#$%;

=4#/#/ #7#/$ '/&0 *,*$*#$*,3 +$%7+ './$4%/#,)%

 

(*/%)$*&, )&,$#*,%( 7#/#

*** #6&<%F +4#@@

+.60*$ +$#$.+ /%7&/$ /%3#/( 6%'&/%

%3*+$/:

$4*+
&./$;

(.@:

*,(*)#$*,3 @*+$(%$#*@+ &''*)% 6%#/%/+ /%+7&,(%,$+

< .7&, /%)%*7$ +.)4 +$#$.+ /%7&/$;

%3*+$/:

$4*+
&./$ +4#@@ 7.$ .7 0#$$%/ 6%'&/%
&./$ $#>*,3 .7 )&,$%07$ )&./$ 7/&)%%(*,3+ #3#*,+$ /%+7&,(%,$+ *$+ &''*)% 6%#/%/+-

 - 4% *,+$#,$ ?/*$ 7%$*$*&, +$#,(+ (*+7&+%( #'&/%+$#$%( $%/0+- - %,(*,3 #77@*)#$*&,

+;

*'

#,:;

+4#@@ +$#,( )@&+%(-

 2  

!

- - 

+1>+ 4%$4%/ +7%#>*,3/%#+&,%(

 "%+



& 4%$4%/ /%7&/$#6@%  "%+ 

&