Naresh Kumar v. State Of Haryana And Others


  

 
  
 
   

  !"#$!%&'&"()*++



 



    





  )
 ,-. + / ./ ..

 - ****



   !"#



 /($!!0 "1$2&34 + $%&

"'(") * #+  !#',,-+ .(    #   (     
 / )    ) 0...$!&$1&. # ,,2342,5,56.76...  ,3 ,5,, $!9  %&:  %;

%  %;

,   . #  ,,2342,5,56.76...5% 5< ,5,,$!9  ,& 0...$!&  $1&  . #  ,,2342,5,56.76...  %% 5< ,5,8 $!9 

8&=))"#8;) ( >='!# ,5%-(''* ) =!9+ +"' !' %3-<,5%<$!9  4& #) # '(8% ,5,8$!9  -&"+> 8?8 ,5,,=>='+

   $,&

=;5@'# '6='   (  '    )  =*# )  ( ABA   . #  ,3 ,5,,  5% 5< ,5,,  %% 5< ,5,8 $!9  %  8  #"'&  ) 8@ "     '  # 88    ( >='

- 2 - $C/ '   #)D '' #&!# %443 $ (>!# %443&  $8&

.  #       )  # (# "  8@  ;@ "      '  # 8;   )   ( >=' !#  ,5%-   

  "##'')' ='  ( =#  ='          "'#8;8;

,,5%-!# ''# '#  # 8-  (> !#  %443  #  7"     ")  =  "    (   5% 5% %44-' ),5,, #"( =' ) '      ''  #  #)  ='  ''="'#88 E>!#%443 #8;

, E>!#,5%-'  # (F'G  )=' . # $;&

'# ') ) # $3&

' =    #   ,,2342,5,56.76...  ,3 ,5,,     #  %% 5< ,5,8 " (# 8@ H' "  ="=' ''' #'') (   5% 5% %44- %?

5;

,5%< 0...  #'"## (#  #  6

- 3 -

    



         

   !" #$% & '%% ( ')$  * (++, -' *. $$ %+
$)&, $%$.
-) )*%%&+#*+ '%$% /& ,%*+% %&++ *
$%,, ( ')$ #$%&%0,0
$
%$,$
%$+#*+)'+. ( & '''
#. ( ,%*+. % 0+*+ & 0
$
.
$*1
&$#,/&&
#%(,%*+% ,$(, (   (  % $ '%%*+  (++ -' & '% *. %0$ 0$ *. 1
&$# & '%  * (++, -' *. %0$ %&++ *
, (/, (  ', -' & %-*%2-$
-)$.%/&(%&+++'%  !*" & & ')$+ '%%  (++, -' *. %+
$ )&,   $ ) *%% & ,%*+, )'+.

% /&  /&$&$)+3$(
$%,$%&++*
$%,,( ')$  & ,2- $-)* ( ,%*+, )'+.% ( & '''
#.(,%*+. $ 0+*+ /&$ &$)+3$&3$(
$%,$).*1$,, (0 )% & $-)* ( 0
$
% $, & '%$% /& ,%*+%(++$#/&$&1$,,3$).

$ & 0$ ( $$ 0+*+. (
$,,% 0$ $ & 1$,, 3$ & %0$
$ * 1
&$#, % & '%
$ * (++, *.  '%$ /& &
#. ( ,%*+. ( '%%*+  (%$'%%*+(++-'&'%*.%0$& '% ). * (++, *.  '%$ & &$  '%$ /& ,%*+. $, & %0$ %&++ *
, (/, (  ', -' & %-*%2-$ 
-)$ .% /&(  %&+++'% 4 $-&

.#7"  "="  )  ,-  # (I'J/ =

- 4 -  #" ' "'')='( 8@ (#''="'#88 (>!# %443 (#   6  0. ''' 0$)$ %&++ ''$ $ 0. %*+%&)$%-
&'
$#(0
$
%$+%%&$& '
$('%$%
+%%('%$%/&,%*+.(/&
& $'
$
&%&++*%0,('%$%%-(($#()  !6"7+$,$%%+/0%$8!"7$#)')$8!"9
 ) ,%*+. 
*+ '+%. $ & '%% ,$(, ( 
&,%*+.: 

0,, & & ''' 0$)$ ). &0$# #,  & .' ( /;
, $ $ $. ,')$  %*+%&)$*.$(
$%-*<
%-
&
$,$%($. % ). * %'
(, $ %-
& $(
$ 1)' $. %*+%&)$()&'0%$%(&%%
$  $<&

# 8-  (> !#  %443 "  #   # "##'' =(=# =' (# 6 #  6 5=  &$$.
-)$.$.0
$
.-$,%
$ 55
$$ * (++, -' ,-  $$ 0+*+. (  %-*+ '%$/&,%*+.($.&%-((
$%$%-
& 0
$
.%&++*
,(/,$&%-

,$#
-)$ .$,(&%-

,$#
-)$.+%%-*+'%$ /& ,%*+. % $ 0+*+  ). (% * (++, *. $
&$#)$#&&
#%$,$+./&$&% $'%$/&,%*+.0+*+(&'%$&.& )'+.%&++(++-'&0
$
.*.''$)$('%$ &&$'%$/&,%*+.:

0,, & ( & $- ( 0
$
% $ $ %*+%&)$%%-
&&#0$
#.('%$
$$* )'+.,&0
$
%).*$
&$#,)$#&&

- 5 -
#% /& & ' ''0+ ( & ''' 0$)$ 4 $?&

.  ('' '   '(  (' '')   ""##= ='# ='#(  (   ' H  #

 = #   E/ 

=='# #)#"'='( 'H H # =9" 

="## (=''')(9H =# ."6"'='#"9H  "#=9#)#=''=( #)=' =' .=''' = "     = '' =       ( ='   " '' = # (    =/  #     (  '' '  .

  '' = =6'# ')='#(='''= #    )  " "##   #  ')='#  #)  =' "'='  "###=9#)(#)='  .

%443!#(# '''.G=')  #'    D '' #  C/ '   ' ( >='! ##)G =*#"=%443 !#   ) E>   #      # #

- 6 - )   E>F)(G E>    # = /  ( =#( #' # '

!#'%-$;& = ###

==#( #' E> ##' #')'## $%5&

! # = ) # 8,88  %443 !# 9'#    ) ='# =( /      "")  E>   #  # 9# # 8, # #'

 #    E> ''#='#))  ##( # =#='  " #889'#

 ''( # 

=" E>#"  #  ='')  $%%&

!##)'   (     ("  (  #9#" E>''  ''#) #" '')  #(= =(##   %< %5 ,5,8

%&+ /($!!0 "1$2&3 

1$2!

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No