← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/178/2018dismissed

M/S Max Valves And Regulators Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And ANR.

2023-02-17Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra8 pages



     

 !"# $"    

    



   







   

    



   





 $

&'(' )"#!! * + ,*-!-  + ,*-!-*-   !"

 #$ % $ 

 #"

& '$()$  *** *-  .!  & "%##  

"



#

' "  & +,- .-  & + 

 .-$ '

   "

 %##  ,./ .-       & &" $  0 "  1    2&" 34"

&+/ , / - ./56

 &

%



 " 



50#

"

"    &%$ ..71 2 &%34'



 

&%$8691 20&%34:"



"

# %"

 



% "

10 

4 # "%  1(4#"

;"

< "

0#

)%

$/' # " 

" 

" : 

"





"

  "

"

 $:

 $#" =  '

"  "# %    

  %##"" "

"



"%:'#" 

 ..85.$

"

>

   "

 #  &  5  "

 "#          )&;  ?

-$, $6 $/-5&

  # &5 ' #" "# '" % "

%% $" %%  

:  

# 9..5 %"



: % '<

"

%"

'

$ #+5

'

' #<"

%"

  6174

 &% 0&%' " 

&

"

"%  8.7 .7

% "#

'"

  "%<"

 "% "    "

' #

 ""  # 7/$ 7$.

5 '% &

5

"

 "





8.7 .7  

  "

  "%  

 @"

  A%"  B &" 0##""

1 41 2@A&01434'

   9./ ./ #"

%

"

 " " %  

#

'

 $

"

"

%



"

" '

 >" 

  61 4

 &%"

"""



%

"

%"

% 



&

 % "



%

" 

"

   &  +5  

 

 ' 

 %   "

%%

,8

    &

..71   2

$  ..734   %%"

$"

 # "  "

  "#"

 7

"

5

"

 & %

"



"#

 ,./ .-

 / &

 

'"

  >     '   

     % 1"4



%

%"%# 

% $

 ""

''

" "



+5 '



 

 ""   00 '" 

,8 &%E 1""4



%

%"%# 

%

+ " ""

 

#  $'

"

"





 "

#

  "F



1"""4



%

%"%# 

%

"

#

" "



'" 

 "

+"% +5 $'

 

'"  "



%



+ 6 : 

#"

%



5 

"#

 

"



" 

'"

  "

 '&

 ""

'

" 

%

 "" 

,8

..7 

%# '"  # &+5 "

"" %"

%

'

 'G

 ""

' '

%#

 "

#    "

  "  '    

     %  '  

 

 

#

 "F  



G

" "'

%%  

  '

"#  



<

% 

 "



" "



$



>"

  

:'$

$

%

%"

'



# "

  D"

#

$ "'#"





&" " #

$

%



 % 

"   "

%" 

 1 )/ 1

)02!-%  $ ) $ .719.4 &

/$'

"

'

"



:'

0"

H

"0



   "



" 



  %""



,81414

..7

9 

%



$



$

'"%"

# %

'

&

%%  

5 

# 

 ..9 .,

(  A%" &"  0##""

  1     2(A&034  "

"     '

 ' 

  



' " %%"



,8

..7:' '



#

 8.7 .7

   "%%   !

=#

 "

  "%      '  

  

  

  % %#

&

"

"%   8.7 .7 % "

  

"   %" '

 

    "  

"% 

" %

%% "

 

&

%

 " #

&

"

'"



%

  '



"



"

+ "

 ' "

 

&

$"' 

" 



 ,



%



"





"





%

"

#&

 "

"%  8.7 .7 # 

   6174     &  %    '

   0&  %    

 

  7/$ 7$.

5         

 

5

 '  "



"#"

 #" # & 0& '"

 %" '

"

"%  "

    





     

  #       ' 

   "

   "   $  

"

 @A&014

    !

    %

"



"

 

'

"





"

 "   "

   "

 

&

@A&014  !

%





#+5 " 

'

$'" 

>

 %" #

'

  "

 

$

#

#" 

"

 " " %  

#

'



 - :"



# %

$

"

#

''"   & +5 "

"""



%

&

<

  %

 %         ..9 .,$     !

 =#$ %%  

# 



 &+5

 "

 



%

% %

"

"% 





#  !

=#$%% 

"

 

"

"% "



%

;% $ ' 

"

"

"% 

'" ;

 

 1

 54""%

 !

=#  

"

"%  /. .7$.6.

 .7 ..

 .7&

 '  8.7 .7:

% %"%# $

%

  

%

#

"





"&

 <

%



#  !

=# 

 "

" " ,./ .-'

"



""   

 ..9 .,'"

 < &

 !

% "

 "

" "

"

'

%

" " '  !"

=#' ,./ .-" 



%" &

#





" !

=#% "

 #  #"

"

"" % % " "% $'





     

 &"   "

 

     

 

   ..9 .,'%

#  !

=#

"%  #

"#"

 '

 "

&

"

"



% #

% '



 % "&

%

 1 )/ 1

)0+(% 14

 ""

"



 "



%" % $

'

"



'

"



% $#

#

%  %

 '

'

 



 #" 

%#

' # 



#

"

%

""

$

#"

,81414

..7 &

$



%" %  



"

 % " % %"%# 

% %%"

$""





# %% "











&+5 

""

%% '

$

%

 "

 

     "

 

  $ 

 

"

#

"  %

0

$""

 " >  ' "

 

%%"

$"

# ""

$

 "#"  5 6 5*- 6      "#!! # !

 <"

 

I +

 

I +