← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4720/2017dismissed

Ritu Saigal v. Rakesh Saigal

2022-03-04Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mr. Justice Ashok Kumar Verma20 pages

         



!

"#$#%&'(' # ) * #+ , ''''-- ,, %

.$'

 / $0 * #+ , '''' $-%!

%

 & 123

*'

*3   123

'

*3 *4 4  .3  

   

   

   

   







  

  

 # ) 05#6 '

 7 8 

 

 !

  8 

 

!

"



 # $% & 

    ( 



 (

 )* *+ )*%,  -





"!

&     

 %+/%0/

/"0

1     %233 

!

 



(4 %% *) %225

6

    '!



   !

  8

    (!

  

" )9 *, %22,

!  (!

    

"

 %+ *, %222

1 

  " 

!



   ( #

  

 

 

  .3* 7

 (







'!

    

-" ! )**%  )**:

'

  

 7 8.%:+ ;

&  < 8=-  .)

 /  (0   (

  

 

 %+ *3 )*%:

     



    

1

 ! 



  

; +* *: )*%:





"

#  

  

   ( (!     (" %**

  



 

 

!

  !

 

( 



; *% *3 )*%:

  (



  (  









'

 

"



! .

    *, *3 )*%:

&  



=     

 ; 







( (



(("

 .

  (" 



> 

  

..

& ? "

 &

    ( !

 



    

  (  (

(  (

(

!







   !

  7 8 



(

   ( #

 

  1





)**5 )*%*

 

!



$ -



!

@-

 (  &

 @



(B

     C

    



  

   )*%).%+

" 

(

!



)*%+.%:

 

( D  /1  (0   A!

)*%:

    



(  .3* 7

 (





  "

   



$



(

 7 8.%:+ ;

&  <  8=-  .66

 /  (0

 (

 

 #(    =&

  7 D.+5%

D.),2 !

1 

 ! .35



    

 !

'!

 1  





 



  

 

! 6 



  " &



; +* *: )*%:    



(  ( 

 

"

&     (" %**



 

&



 ( 

 .

4

   8=-

!  .66



 "  *, *3 )*%:

  

1  

  " &

   ((

.  



1



 (  )5 %% )*%+    8=-  .66







 



 -(  



  

( %* *: )*%3.

@% >  



 

( E )



 

>%

   

  "    

(  



 



1   







   

/>+0 ?

(

      &

 ; ?!

    



 



 

9

" !

 (

! "    " 

  

 ( 

!

" 

>   

"    !

 

 " "



.  

/<# %0

  /<# )0

'

  

 &   +* *: )*%:

1 



  />+0

 

"

 & (

 

 (









; ?!  &





 

#  

  

   ( (! 

 &

" ( "  (



 



"

 





!

  =





 #  !

   

!

1     !

  & ?

" 

!

 

  



  (

" # ( 



" !

  

1

 *% *3 )*%:    (



(



 











 



6 & 

   ( ( *, *3 )*%:

7 # (  

/>)0



(!

( 7 '  =(

1



!



 !  )*%+

)*%:

?

" (



 

 ( ?

" ( !

 

1

 

& #(!

 ?

   !

 

 



(

1

     / 0 ?

 1

(  

   4 8



 "!

G





 !

"!

'!

 ( !

  ( 

   / 0 G

 

&  

  &    

 

 1

&   /."

0

? " !

 

  



&

- !  

 



 

>+ 

"

. 

"

   (

 ( ( (

  

!





  (

  (

" @ 

!

B

1

 



 (!



 



'



   ?!

(  

1  





"

 

 ( (

(

1

 

+* *: )*%:

 -

 "



.# (

 ? (  

/<# %0

  /<# )0

6 (  /<# +0

.

  !

( 

   



.# (

!

( !

/<# % <# +0

  !

 !

( /<# % <# +0



( (   

.# (

 "      

 (

    (

 

 # (    

"  

(("



 '



(  

   

 +* *: )*%:

&    -



6 .# ( 

(     

/>)0 # (

  

!

?!

(



( 

 

   



-

  (   

 

   

 !" # $ % &  '() *# $ % 

! +,

* -./

((

 * +(

 // 



.# (



   

 

8

     %9 %% )*%5 /  7 +)2

-

 0 53.

D/:0

6 <  %9,)

<# :

 ! <# % + 1 -

 

 ( /<# % <# +0  

   

  -



  (  * "* (  !

1*

 *2

!

 *



* #   +3%

!4+5 

/*!12*  * 12*  *2

!

 *



 *6 75 + 70*, 5 +8 *2

!

 *

 

- 9

1 +   9

+*1 + 3%8 *2

!

 *

8-/ # 9#   0

#   -/ *2

!

  *

 

 8   !



! ( 

  " 



"(

 ( ..



" 

( !

<# % <# +

    (



 

 

  ?

!

& ?

 



  # (  /<# +0

'

 

   



H   !

( / 0

! 

" ? (



 

1

  "!

   (



(4  -



 "  " 

:

(  !



1 

  

( !

=  

 

 

 

   %9 %% )*%5 /  7 +)2

-

 0 53.D/:0

6 <  %9,)

   

/<# %0   /<# )0

# (  /<# +0

(" 1  ( 

 %9 88  



 :"  (



  



 

 & 



( (

  !

1

    (  %!4

  / %%+ ( %)  6

1*!  6

1*!

 0! +-)

+#

1 )+  6*1 )+- %%+8#+"( !

* +- 5%8-2 4+   22 +9 --;-.;- +    +  5)  1*!   !     !

  '   !    



 !  

     (  &

   !

 " " & 

  



 



 %+

1     %233 =  

   

 

 

   ( 

  1*+ 

83%%6 /#

2+

 ,  0 

: 

  , .0 



  #

12*  1*+ *+,< # +8-  

-

  %29:

6 <  %9,)  



("!

 

6 !

 (( " 

("

 (! 

53D

6 <  %9,)

-

   %:

-

  %29:

# ( 

  ( 

53D

<  %9,) 1    

  

-

     53.D

6 <  %9,) %9 %% )*%5 /<# :0



 %2 *) )*%5 /<# >%$0

  

<# %   <# )

# (  <# +

; ): %* )*%5

.# (  

.# (  

 # (  /<# +0



/<# %0



8  

# (  /<# % +0

!

?   53D

6 < 

   %9 %% )*%5

.# ( )% %) )*%5



( !

/<# %0

   .# (



(

 )% %) )*%5 /<# >%$0  (

!

"

<# %   <# )

 (!

    <# )

>  # (  <# +  ( 

(

(  





( 

  "   



   (

!

 <# +

 



 ( <# +

1

 



<# %   <# )

# (  <# +







 .# ( 

)% %) )*%5 <   53D

6 < 

  .# (   %9 %% )*%5  



 

<# %   <# )

# (  <# + 

 

!

 -



& 



  

;  

( 

  1

 5

  1*+  

83%%6/ 6 

 # ( %:

-

  %29:

 53D

%))

6 <  %9,)

%:

-

  %29:



.

@ -

 !



!

 ( ( (  !  

 

 !





    

(" 6 <  %9,) /%

%9,)0 . -

 !



!

 ( ( (  !  

 

 !





    

(" 6 <  %9,) B

" 

   -

 

 

("!





 " 

 

"   

-

 

!

 

  ( ( ( 

    !

!

 



(" 6 <  %9,)

  

" ( 

.

@ %:

-

  %29:



 !



!

  ( ( ( 

  









   @ 

    

(" 6 <  %9,)B

    &   

 

("!

 

   "  

 6 

     ( ( (       

   







   

 

  53D



%9,) !



 !

?

  6 



  

 

  ( 

 & ((!

 

 "(  -

 #

 

 5::

51 '

=  -> 

  

( !

5)

< 

("

 ( 



53D



%9,) '

 & 

( !

 "  "  "!



 # (

 # ( -

   

C ((  %))



%9,)



 

%:

-

 

 (  %))

<    -

 %:





  !

 



 %))



%9,)    .

.  ((  " 

 B

6 ." (

(

  

5::

51'



  -  

  

( !

5)

< 

("

 ( 



53D

< 

6

7 )* )) )+

):  "

.

@)* 6

9$ # +96 * +   * */2  !+

?/8

.

I D



  

 

 

>  

(4 

    



  .%3*

  @%3*  5+  !





(   @

 (  

 ( 

 !

!

 ( 

 B  "  !



(









!

( " 6  (       

  !

(

  '

1



"

),5 1  &

($ (  

 

"



. ( !

 



  !

 

 !

    &

   & 

  6

( 

?(

53.D



 

("!

   

  !

 

<  (!  5+

6 !

      ".

 /:0

53.D

   "   !

  

(   (  (    (!  5+

53 B )) '    

   "

  

 !

5+

<    !

 

 "    



!    

6

   ( & 



53 

("!

   5+

 

 

 !

!

 J

!

  53

53D ' # (

("!

 !

   

     / 0  !

    6 ? 

    

!

 !

 

(  ?( 53D

  ' 

8 8     

(    (

53D " 

(

& (



  !

    (" )+



(!



!

  (

53D 

8 <#".: 9 2 %* %) %+ %3 )*

)) '  

( '

   

 9       

(



  ):



  





 ( !

 &

  " 

8 

(

 

8 

" " 

( !

 4   <

((



( !

 1

    !  



 

 '    

(

   (

 ( 

(

8





 

    '

8 

(  !

?(

53D

< 

  6     

      !

 

 32 53

53D

< 

 

 

( !

5)

< 

(" 

 ( 

 53D

<  B >

" "  (



9$ # +96 *+  * */2  !+



 5:@ 4

 *2  1

 (

(  @ 4

 *2  



!



1 

 (

@ 4

 *2 5; /;

  6  



   53D

   %9 %% )*%5



 7 /<# %0   /<# )0

# (  /<# +0

& 

8 .# ( 

  

!







 

/<# %0   /<# )0

# (  /<# +0

1    

!

' 

 



"  !

& 



  7 %

 !

( 

 

!

 &

? 



 

/>)0



(!

( 7 '  =( 1



!

 

 !  )*%+

)*%:

?

" (



 



( ?

" ( !

 

1

 

& #(!

 ?

   !

 

 



(



?

   4 8



 "!

G





 !

"!



   

/>)0

"4

( 4 & 

"





( !



 ( 

# 

   



 

 



( 

(

 : ) A  !( )+ * +: ) ( )+-.. 

"     & 

 

 

( 4

& 



( !



  

!

  "?



 

&  



( !





    " 

!  

 &

    (   "  (  

   !(

(

    (

(( 

.

%+/%0/   C!

  .

C!

!

( !    .

 !  

   "( (  6

?



 .

 (  "(  

!

 " % 0*, %  ../ 

/0 # C!

 " #

(  ( "  .

6

!    

(

       /0



 !

  

  

 (

 



 .

'  "  !   !

!   

 "% 0*,

%  ../  /0  

 ( 4

!

  !



  .

!

 !

!

  !

 

(  (

 

 "% 0*,

%  ../ 

/0 <   !



 .

7 !

!

!

 

!

   ( "  !

 "!

  ( 

 +   +  88++B(+%

/- 

 8 /0 

!

%+/%0/

1     " !





    !

 (





 &  "

!



 /0 > !

  !

( !

  K 

!





    " 

!  

 &

    (   "  (  

   !( !     - %%   !+  //?  -  %%  +  / /   - % 2  *(!

% --  /0  !

  " 

  !



 



( 

 

0  3

6

%%+/   /#0 L

( !

 

(

 

 !

  "     

(

 !

  4 

+1* / %%+      />+0  







(

 

 (  



 

  



 +* *: )*%:

6 .# (   ?!

 (

"

 



( 

 (

1  !



+* *: )*%:

!



 (







 

 "    

 ( 

   (

 :

   

  



(

(!

 

 "  



   +* *: )*%:

  />+0

   &  

6  



 



( )) %) )*)%

   

( /8=-

!  .66

 /  (0



!



!

!

 3* 





(



 

 +.:

(

 !

&  

1 









 8&



&





(

& !(

 9****$.

 (

(   ):

1    

  *2 *9 )*%9

!       

 

 )) *) )*))

 " (   !

  

!

   

1

! "!

)) ! 

 

 & !(

 9* 



 



 (

 

!

1 



 

  -



 !

 !



 

<# %   <# )

# (  <# +



   

/>)0 #. 

 

   />+0  !

  

!

   !  !

 *, *3 )*%:

( !   

!

 %% *) %225

6



 "  

1    (

 )* *+ )*%, 

-



 

1  & 

"   9****$.

 (

(   ):

1     %233    3* 

( 

(!

 ( 

 /

!0  

 

3 '('

*4 4  .3  #;< %$0#

3 =0

$-

/#%+>5

$% !& $> =0

-5

?, & $>