← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5967/2024allowed

Nirmla Devi @ Nirmala And ANR v. Rajesh And ORS.

2025-01-07Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl16 pages

   



      

 !"#$%&#'()($*+ , ,    

         

   

  

  

     

     !   " 

  

 #     # $   %      

 &&'   %   (

    "   "

#)*+&*&, -

. /)0  12 

   3 3

%  

  #)  &*&,   *4*5&*&, 6    

 "    7#*4&*&, -

. /'0  12  %  3 " -3 0

 



 8  7+   #

&   6  #4# %%  %  )+,  &*#)  1

 

   

   "   

 &  

         1             "  

  6



# 6   "



#7##&*#)        

  

/

9 6   6      :    " 

   " +# 9  #  

   "  !  $   

 3

 (  1     6  1  ; &**'&**'

6  1   1 .     

 

   

  " 6     " 

&,# 7##&&*#& 6   ;     (    1    6    6 6  12                

6 6   2  &*#&  1  

     1

" 12        "  

 (    1         /

 2  &*#) 

       4 2 

 < 

7##&&*#&

  .  2 1 <  ;     2 2   

   7 (  1  

#,4+ #&*+&*#) 6        6  

                 .      (    1        

  " 6    1  .    "  

&&#*&*#)   "      

  

 ! 

-      

   

   6    

"        "  <  (  1       "   

    " .  

        

6   " 6    

  2  &*#& 

   % 

7#*4&*&,  

 

 8  7+   # 

& %%    1  "   

          "   2    , (  1  

   3 "

#)*+&*&,      6   

  12   % 

 6  

   

  = 2 12  "   "

  

      "

   ; &**'&**'

6   1  "  2 

6 " .      

6   1  "  2   "    

 6   1  "  2  "    " 

7##&&*#& (    1   1       %     "

      

 "

     /  ; 

 

  

 2 

 1   2   1    

   

 

             "

  6   

" "  55 

5+     19 (  1       



  2 

 1       

 



   /        "

 1   

1 2 1 "         4  

       "  

#          

 1        (   %    "

      /

 ; &**'&**' 6  

7##&&*#&

      "

      (    1       .    

&&#*&*#) 12  

 6   

  

#,4+

2 .

1   (   % 

  

  

.

   " 6 %/&&)#)/%((/&*&,    .      .      

 5 (  1   "  #5##&*#' -

. /&0 6    12

   6     ) 9   

     2 

 6      "     

&&#*&*#) 6 . 

#  6      1     ! 

   1   

&&#*&*#)         1     "      (    "     .     

  "  &+*5&*#) -

. /70 6     

  

#'*+&*#) -

. /#0 6 .  1 6      

    "      #5##&*#' (  "       " 6  

 .  

&,*+&*#) -

. /50    !   



6    

&&#*&*#) . 

 

   

  6    6  





"   "  #5##&*#' .  12   

6  1   12     

 (  1   "

     6 6 

    1  

       1  "      1    ' $ %      

       

     19 ) #)#*&*&,  % 6      6 / 

   

 



       !  "# #$ "##$  %   

 &      '( ("

"#("  %&)%*  %  &    &  % %  %&)%   %      & +% &*  

 %    *

  %&               % *

  % %&     %     &          , * ,%    -% &%  %&)% %  ,%         ,%  * ,   

. 



 "/ (( "#"0

1 & ,   %  

&*          %    

(/ (# "#"02 + &)##&*&,  

     

#  2       "         8 #&#&&*&,  6    #+#&&*&, 2  6 "  12      

#  "         (  1 12  

   

#          2   12     

        

 "2    1      #*

         "2     

 

 

 >6

     1     

 ##

    "  

       

  "    19  %           12  (

  % #)*+&*&,   " 

    1              #& (   

   

     6      6    

  " +# 9  #    1   "  ; &**'&**'   . 

   6    (    

   

#/    "

   

  6           



"  

 ! -

#0   

  

    6   

6 "  (  6    

 & 

7 ?

            6 9   ; &**'&**'

6   

 " 

&,# 7##&&*#&

 2

  1   

  1     ( 6     6

      1              6   6    .         

  " +# 9  #  

   "   1     



# 

, 

 

#,4+ #&*+&*#)   

       6     

 # 

,  "

 " 1    #7

 " 6  

 

 

 8  7+   # 

& %%    " 

    "    2 $  %

7#*4&*&, 

  6  1  

  

 

   

7##&&*#& 



  6     

#/   6    9 6 "   

     "        "  " "   

  6   6 6   2  &*#+ 

      , 2 

 

   "    " 

 ( 6   1 

 

.

      

6  



 #,4+ #&*+&*#) 

  

   " 6       

 "  

&&#*&*#)   !   "

    1 6       

#,4+ 



     9 6 "     1  

 

    

 6    <1       #, $   

  1 6 12  (   % #)*+&*&,    2 1  "   "

    ; &**'&**'      "

    

7##&&*#& $  #)*+&*&,   " 

    1      6 "  / 0 $ 

7##&&*#& 6  ;

&**'&**'     

 

 

   6     2    " 

  $ 

 

 ! 1   "  !  -          

. /&  

" " 5+     19 6    

. /&0 (

   12  

  "

       

4/

9 6   9    

6      

  

    "

  

        ; &*'&**'  2 &4*4&*#) 



6         4 2      .      " 

1 

 "  <    " 

  .  2 1 <  "            0 $       #7##&*#)  6 2     "    " 

7##&&*#&  1  "

 

  (        6     

    " 

       2       " "  

6    6     12     

*)*&&*#+ 

   6  "

#)*+&*&, 6 

  "  1      "   

 7##&&*#& 0 $  "  

  6         1    

#   6   

#/           -,, /  " 

  "  ;

&**'&**'6 .   , , .

   6   , , ./

. /7 6  1   

  1 "

# 

  2 6      

 2  1  

   "  "      

 

  "      2      

 !

   6  1

 "   

 "      

2      "      #5##&*#' $ 

   2 6  1 <  

#,4+ #&*+&*#) 6

   6     

6 "   

 

    $    

. /7      1 6/ 

!" !# "$ "% & "!

' ("

$%!$)) # $ *

"*

!" !# "$ "% "

$)

 +*+  $& !#  # $& ,$ ' & ,$  & *$ "

 , & &%         % 

  * 1      %%    %   %     & +% , %      * &     & %  *  3 "4 "#(/

(

6  7%

6 . 3 6 % 7%  7   

'

6 8 3 -)./0&# $& ,$ '2 , , ./ 

#,4+ 6 . 

6  

<  6          .    1  "  "    , , ./

. /# 6         1

  

# 6 6    

  " 6                 " &         2   6       

  " ) 9  6       

1     /  $     -

. /#0 6  1

2 "

        1 6/  6! (  7% 0& 

$   1 $ + 23  -

+ 23 %     

 9:   ; 1   3 <  &* *

    % (

1 ,    

  

 4  # $& ,$ ' $ !4"$ " ,!&&&& !" !#  +") !# !

$ # $  "$ " &!" !# $ 5$  $& )"

!#

6$ & + # )!" %!

,$ &) " 4 !7-   !891 %  ! 8:  ++ ! 87.;. ;/9 ") ;9.8.;

-/8 ") ;8.; 8/89 ") ;;.8 9/7 !

+ $ & $ "* < "+& 9 $+ (!

")$ & !# 4 % $  =    %  !  3  . <   %  

 *   <&   * "#(" ('

1  *           !; . "05/  (5 (( "#($ , ( % 7%    %     ;  "

7     3  )%   

 1       

 /"#####6 >%  * , ?  %    *    ;  "######6 >% ,* ?   *  +      '# #5 "#(/      "4 #/ "#(/       , +  (@ #4 "#(/ 1  *   & + ,  +  "@ #@ "#(/  ,     

A  (@ #4 "#(/  , B 9*    * 

  ($ #4 "#(/            !     *              %    * >?

 4 ## 

    @ ## 

,     

  %&   &   &%      

'

1 , ,   %      %

1 %  * & ;   %

3 6 $ + 6 

6 0& 6

+2

        6 6 

    

     12   

   

#       

#             6     2 <   , , ./

. /4   

. 

 

   6     6 9   

    

  

 !   " 



 

 1    

#,4+   6     2 6      6  9 "   "      1 6     

      .     



     

6   6  6

-  <  6        

6  "



 

1   

  

 "   "  

 6    6       #4 @  1         

6  6      2 

2  .  ; &**'&**'     

 

9 6   "

  

      " 

7##&&*#&    ; 



       4 2      

 < 

 " 

       6  

#&*+&*#) 6   6  "

    1  "    

      

 6  2 6   2 6     6   

6  

       #'*+&*#) -

. /#0 

  

 -

.  /4 

/50 (   2                #7##&*#)  " "    #,4+6 1  2   #5 ( 2 "    1         4 2     " 

1   "  1       " 

      6   

   "  "  



 8  7+   # 

& %%    " 

    "  "

 

  %  "2   





    / "         

 

 8  7+   # 

& %% $ (

  %        "  "        / 

# 6     "  ; 

12  

    6     "  

1 "   "  

8 7+   # 

& %% 1   " 

  6   1 9      6   6   "    "  

661 <   "  ; #' $ 1     (   %     "

    ;      "

    

 6   " 

 1   

   (

           "

    

 "

 1  (    1   %     

  2  

      "   "

 $            

   "   "

    

    $ 1      (   %   1 2

  "       "      >

6 " A.   6  "

     @   

6   1  "  " 

  1

2     " 6   6     ! 1   "

 !  6   " 6    2  

      

9 2    ; -

 

" " 55     190  6       " 

- 

" " 5+     190    6   "

          9   2 1  6      

   1

12  (   % (           

 

        

  "

#)*+&*&, "

   1    #) (      "   12     6 1 "

12     B 

B 1        1 6     %           1                    % 1     1 <    

 

   2     6      

" "  

 1 .  12          2     2 6     2  <   6         

" "  " "    ( 6 1                       

#)#*&*&,     

 1  "  #+  

         6    

# 2 1         6    

 

        

  " +# 9  #  

   

      2 &9   

 &* !  " 

 6  1   

   "

#)*+&*&,    

     

    2 6

                

  & 9  -  2  0 1     "  

    6 1  <    1    % " "     1 <    

6  "



9 "    6      

" " 6  

 

   1 <      6   

" "



   .  6       % &# (      1          2      "           "     " 

 8  7+   # 

& %%

6

 1    .             

6 6

12   % 



2 

66  /0 1

2  !*3!45 6 , 3 7% ;   9 "? 

C ? ;   1 C ?