← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaVATAP/45/2018dismissed

Excise And Taxation Commissioner, Haryana v. M/S Krishna Auto Industries

2018-05-07Mr. Justice Ajay Kumar Mittal,Mr. Justice Tejinder Singh Dhindsa5 pages

VATAP No. 45 of 2018 (O&M) 1 Gurbax Singh 2018.05.22 12:51 

      

!"#$#%&'&()* +%&'# !($ !+!"&( ,,&''&(#-. !-/!(! "0-120 #31"/ +%&'# !($!+!"&(,,&''&(#- 4 . !(%0516! 7733#66!(" ' 8' 9-&'0(! 1" ($1'"-&#' 6"  : ($1'"-&!6 '"!"# !-;!6! &'"-&%" !(%0516!!($!("0#- 7 #'3($#("'  ) <=  49  =.    4   <=  4 44  

      

    >!/91,!-&""!6.

 

! ! "# $% !$&'( )

**!    ! *  

     !  + 

  !*      *  + , *! "# $%'( ) '



   !   

 !

* -&     "

 !!!  , * '((- .  / "*0  !!

!() (1 '( 2, -

!+   ,+ ./+ 30

# $% '( )* +  4  .

0/5 

!! , 

* & .'0.!0.0     "

 !!!  , *

VATAP No. 45 of 2018 (O&M) 2 '((- !6&1 "

!!! ,6 '((-7 .+0 5   ! +   ! 

*   

 

!+* +*!  !

 %( *!! !

* & .'0.!0.0     "

 !!!  , * '((-7 .*0 5  * ! **  *   *   ! * $.&0 "

!!! ,*'((-



*  +7 -    * 

   !*   *    !   !

+*!

 !

89 :!!+

 * !   *

 :!!!"* !;

  , * 1%& .;

 *0       !  ,

 ** !6');< # 2'= (% '(( ($ (2 '( (

! "     !  !    ,   (1-''(8  !

! (2 '((% +     !   , !    

>

        !!     +    *+!    4            '((1 ( ! ! !

! '1 ('

'( - * !  !! !

!!;

*

1($(18

 !+! ! 

+?@,*

! , ;

.

0!  !    +!  !*!*  + ! *&'.'0.!0.0"* "!!!

!('

'( $ , '

! !

# !   !   !

 ! *!

 + 

VATAP No. 45 of 2018 (O&M) 3 "!!!

!() (1 '( 2, -+ ! 

 !!

!'% (2 '( $

  

              !    " #  $)  '( ' !  !     '((1 ( !  *  

!!!* :  

    * A. 0 !  *   

  !!      !!  , ! + * * !  !!* 

    

!   ! !  

 * ! 

 

!++*! !

 %(  *!!   !! * !+ , ; !

 ! !B!*  * 

+

  $ 5

 ! !*

 % !

! !

 !+ !,

 ** !6') ; 

 ,6 12% ./630  (% '(( ($ (2 '( ( !"  !  !    ,   (1-''(8   (2 '((%  "! ! !

! '1 ('

'( - ,   @,* !  ,  C*D*

  !*!!   *      

 '((1 (*   !! !

!1($(18 !  ;

 *  

 ! +     ! !

! '1 ('

'( -   B*! +  ? @,* !  ,  ;

 .

0 

!+ ++   !!

!('

'( $ !

!

!+  + ! !

 

!!+ *> 

VATAP No. 45 of 2018 (O&M) 4

!* **!

*  !  !! +; 

    "#. : +* * *!!++    +

!+ +!+%( * !  !;

*  '(()

(1 !!+* " !;

  '((1

   *   

!!     

 !+  +  + !+

!

 ,+!!*

:  ;! !+; 

    

            

 ! *!! +   !  /#     + ! +   +  !+%( * ,!  !;

*  '(() (1 !!+ *  '((1 ;4*  

+

!!   !+  +   !+  + !  

   , + !!* 

:  ,;! !+A+; *  ,:!

E !"    !.'( $0$)$) .F0  6    

  !

: !!+ +    '((1 (   !    +  * !

!!+ +   '(() (1  ! ;

* !  *   

!!       !* **!

* *!  !!  *   ,  :! 

 E ! .

0

   +

  

VATAP No. 45 of 2018 (O&M) 5    !*! 

 +   )

'( 2 3 & E !*

 + +

!* 

 *!* !*!!+     * +  ;    +  4      ;4 

 !

*   *! ! 

 !! !



>!/91,!-&""!6  %"&(20&#1'"&%# !/*.  #>&($#-4&(200&($0'!  ?2'<  1$2# 5 >8 ! #'  5  + #'