← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/772/2017dismissed

Subhash And ANR. v. State Of Haryana

2017-07-28Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan13 pages



    !

  

"##$%% &    

 

 

  

!

   

 

  

 '& ( )' * ')  * 

 

  

+, ""

*% -./ 

 



  



!     "

 

$%&''&$%   

   

   (   " 

)

  

'*&+'&$*  



   "   ,

 %%' '&$%-  ,

 ./* '&$%- 











*0.

 *%$1 

 # 

$'&2 1  



  

2

 (

3  #

    

  









*0. *%$ 1

 # 

$'&21

 

2

(

3#

 





 # 



 #

  $&&&52  

' 1

!     "

6

(

3



 #



 

  # 

#

      

"     # #



  #,

8 -  (

3#







#  #

  

# # 

9! #

  

 :   #

 

     

+

 

 

(

3  





  , (

-  &/&0'&&%   4   



   

   3   +/'*  

$/&''&&0 









#3 4 

    

 $/+/ 

&%&''&&0 

)  (

 ,)- #

4   6

 # 

7 9!  )

    $;..

4 , -  



#



 





 *

 6

  <1   $$%  

 &/&0'&&%  # 



   









*'& *0% *0. *%$ $'&21 / = 





$%+ 



#











*0.

 # 

$'&2 1 

*%$  

 # 

$'&2 1 



0





 



7 $+#  

#>2 (  ?$ 3 ?'

1

 ?+ (  ?* : 3 ?/  @

?0 )  ?% "3  ?.

1  ?;

 ?$& A#  ?$$ !3  ?$'



 ?$+

 







+$+

   



    

#

7

#

 >2 "  

(?$ A ! 

(?'

A

)?

(?+ 

#

>2 !



7

B7(0 !  (  ( !

B7(% !

 

(  ( !

B7(.

!

 

) 3C  % =  





 

  ?$ ' ( 

 3 )

  4   '&

?$( 



      

$/2'&     

  3  

     '&2''     

  4

#  





  

  ,?$+-#

 



6 



   $;.. 4  # ?* / $&,(  : 3 -







,) 32D-#

# #



)  

4    #

 

  )

#  



#   

#



6

 

4  ##



 

( 

    ?$+

 4  B7?$+5! .

 6

)

 

#



 # !3  #    

$;.. 



 

 < '&&0  

  

  

  



    )  (

 ,)-  #

< '&&0 #

  

 



E)

   

,9!- 

 



 6 

"   # 

  #





)

E

 #



#

#

6    ++3  $'

 



#



= 

  

 

 )

 ; !



 4   

)   (

   ,)- 

 

   6

 #



 #

  $;..

, 4 - 

#

 6

 

)  6

9!

$&



 







#





 

 

 

#    $&&&52 



 

$$ 1

!     "

 



 









  # #

# 



B7(+  #

 '&&0 

#3, #(

-  

 



4   #

 $;.. 

 

 





 $' 4

#







 ?'3 

 .%   

7 &;&*'&$& #  

#    7



'&2''    

        

 

   1 

2

7   # #

  4 

    



3



#3 #

 



2 7   #  

#

 

#  # 

 



 

  ?/ $ * $& 



#3 #



 )

# 

 # # 

 

# 







 

!3  $+ :

 

B7(+  #

   '/&%'&&0  # (?+A

)

    

  ?

 #   

  

   



2 7  

#

#





 



 6 

F





  6

 

  

 $0%#



  #

 #

 ) :

G

3  

H  (



) 3





# ,(?+- # 

7



 



 

9    #  



6 #

 



 

<  

   (?+ 

  



 

  

 

B7(+ # 

 6

 #

)

#

 $*

 

 

 

 

)

    4 $;..  

2

7 

 

 



6 #

 

(?+ 







 #  



#3 #

#

 

 

, '&&0-



  

 

 

4  ?$+

 

 

 

 

6  

 )

#



#  # 

 



= 

  





  

 

  $;..

# 6 







, - &%&''&&0 $/

 6

  #





#



"     #



   



 





  

E)

"   # 

, 

 

- 

"    











 # ?$&# #



 



 #

  





  



 

)  (

 ,)-    



$0

 

      



 

7  #

  



#  )

 # #

 .&

#

)  (

 ,)- 

9!  #



)

8   "    





$%

 6

+



#







 



 

  #

(

3 



 # #

#





9!

  

 #





 6

 9! 

 

  

(

3# 6

  



     

"     

#

6  

 

 



 









 *0. *%$ 

 # 

$'&2 11 #









 

  $'&2  1  8

8 

   

   



 $. 1

 

 ) !



  



#



#

 

,9!-



 

 

 

#

)

 





 

&0&*'&$% ,#  #

- 



 









 #

  



 



 $; ( 

    





  



   . +4*"

"# 

 '&$&;'-    ,  -  +/'



 



# #

#



  '& ) !



 6

 



 

#  #

 



 4 

  

 



, - 5 +67".#54*"

"#86#93"6*39#5% "#

"

,%$# '&$&,'-,  -;% 

 



 6

4  #

  

<1 



 

    '$ @









   



#

#

   '/&%'&&0 

#3 # #



) 3

 4  

$;..

 

 # 

 4  







#

  

 6



   '' 



   



 

  



# 1 



  

 



= 

 

#

   '/&%'&&0

) 3

 4   #

#

B7(+ 

  



#

    $;.. 4 , - #

 

1 





# 

 







 

  (?+A

# #    

) 3

  # 

7



 



#     

   

    



 



#       

   

   

  

   

7   



#

 

(

  

)   



  #



 

#3 (

  

  



#3

 

 





'+ 



   

#

  

#   

E)

# 

#    4    

 



  .%

,?'- ?$& 

#

)   #



 #

 







  

   

 

            

  #









 #



E)

 

 B 

3

 

 ,# 





- 

 

4 $;.. 

 

  





)  (

 ,)- 

  # # #







#3

 

4      #

#







#

)  (

 ,)- 

#





(

4   

 , 

 # '&&0-   





  

  

 







 

"    #

 

(



 



4    '* !















 

 



 

#  

  

      #      #  

   

 

 

 6

#  

 

 

   





 



  





  

  #  

 #  

  

0 







1



  



 

, - '/



 ) !

 



, - 



 









A  

   





















  F









 

# 



E)

     $;.. 

# 

 

 #



  " '&&0 #



 1 

 

( 9   #

7 #  # 

6









  



1 







# 



 '0

 6



    





 

    

3,6 /  :

')  *!

   $?

 3

I '?



ID